I will never understand "Art"

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2]

rsquared
Sweet P is here!

Member since 4/11

2026 total posts

Name:
R

Re: I will never understand "Art"

Just curious, if this is not good art, what IS good art?



Posted 5/15/13 7:33 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

rsquared
Sweet P is here!

Member since 4/11

2026 total posts

Name:
R

Re: I will never understand "Art"

I will answer my own question. To me, "good" art, or art that I prefer, reflects or advances thought, either collective or personal. To me, "good" art also is reflective on art making, the history and theory of art, and thought within artistic or intellectual circles.

Minimalism was more about the feeling you feel when you are in front of these large works, the feeling in your body, the actually experience of viewing it. Most minimalist sculpture and painting is very large because it creates a certain spatial relationship between the viewer and the work.

Its not about how beautiful or realistic or technically difficult it was to make, its about a moment in time, a history.

Posted 5/15/13 7:46 PM
 

mrsboss
my little love

Member since 12/09

5054 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: I will never understand "Art"

Looks like a ping pong table

Posted 5/15/13 9:05 PM
 

BunnyWife
Insert Witty Comment Here

Member since 5/07

8274 total posts

Name:
BunnyWife

Re: I will never understand "Art"

I think it's gorgeous. The colors are amazing. I imagine it's very impressive in person.

Posted 5/15/13 9:32 PM
 

rsquared
Sweet P is here!

Member since 4/11

2026 total posts

Name:
R

Re: I will never understand "Art"

Posted by BunnyWife

I think it's gorgeous. The colors are amazing. I imagine it's very impressive in person.



I agree! And I love that its so big!

Posted 5/15/13 9:38 PM
 

meloyellow
LIF Adult

Member since 3/13

1843 total posts

Name:

Re: I will never understand "Art"

Posted by rsquared

Just curious, if this is not good art, what IS good art?






that's subjective.

"good art" to me evokes emotion & thought


a piece to me can seem cold and simple but to someone else the colors can be bold and exciting or dark, cool and calming.

Message edited 2013-05-15 21:53:58.253000.

Posted 5/15/13 9:52 PM
 

rsquared
Sweet P is here!

Member since 4/11

2026 total posts

Name:
R

Re: I will never understand "Art"

Posted by meloyellow

Posted by rsquared

Just curious, if this is not good art, what IS good art?






that's subjective.

"good art" to me evokes emotion & thought





I am aware it is subjective. That is why I asked. I was curious about everyone's criteria since so many decisively ruled this "not art." People obviously have some sort of definition of art they are operating with, just curious what that is.

I have a masters in Art History, so I have a very trained view of art, and I wonder what other people view as art. My husband and I talk about this all the time...he is a musician and he often argues that some music is "better" than others for technical reasons, and to me its more personal and I don't care if its technically good. And I am an art snob, and he thinks its more about preference. I think that some artists are better than others for specific reasons, but those reasons are from a trained perspective, kwim?

Posted 5/15/13 9:58 PM
 

LINewbie
Tigger the the Rescue!

Member since 8/08

5647 total posts

Name:
LB

I will never understand

Yeah, if I can do it, then I find it hard to call it "art". You really don't need talent to paint to rectangles. Just my opinion.

Posted 5/15/13 10:01 PM
 

meloyellow
LIF Adult

Member since 3/13

1843 total posts

Name:

Re: I will never understand "Art"

Posted by rsquared

Posted by meloyellow

Posted by rsquared

Just curious, if this is not good art, what IS good art?






that's subjective.

"good art" to me evokes emotion & thought





I am aware it is subjective. That is why I asked. I was curious about everyone's criteria since so many decisively ruled this "not art." People obviously have some sort of definition of art they are operating with, just curious what that is.

I have a masters in Art History, so I have a very trained view of art, and I wonder what other people view as art. My husband and I talk about this all the time...he is a musician and he often argues that some music is "better" than others for technical reasons, and to me its more personal and I don't care if its technically good. And I am an art snob, and he thinks its more about preference. I think that some artists are better than others for specific reasons, but those reasons are from a trained perspective, kwim?



I don't think I would ever call something "bad art" or "NOT art". Everything is art. It's just "something I don't care for". I like mexican folk art / surrealism like frida kahlo. pop surrealism like mark ryden, Amy Sol, Lori Earley, Audrey kawasaki, Jason rudolph pena, greyson castro. The taste that best represents me is more quirky and modern. Urban and edgy.

but I can also appreciate the older art of van gogh, Renoir, monet etc

Message edited 2013-05-15 22:17:42.463000.

Posted 5/15/13 10:15 PM
 

Domino
Always My Miracle

Member since 9/05

9924 total posts

Name:

Re: I will never understand "Art"

Yes, art is supposed to evoke an emotion...and conversation. It would appear that this painting has done bothChat Icon

DH is an artistChat Icon

Posted 5/15/13 10:16 PM
 

LovesMike
LIF Adult

Member since 8/10

978 total posts

Name:

Re: I will never understand "Art"

Posted by meloyellow

Posted by rsquared

Posted by meloyellow

Posted by rsquared

Just curious, if this is not good art, what IS good art?






that's subjective.

"good art" to me evokes emotion & thought





I am aware it is subjective. That is why I asked. I was curious about everyone's criteria since so many decisively ruled this "not art." People obviously have some sort of definition of art they are operating with, just curious what that is.

I have a masters in Art History, so I have a very trained view of art, and I wonder what other people view as art. My husband and I talk about this all the time...he is a musician and he often argues that some music is "better" than others for technical reasons, and to me its more personal and I don't care if its technically good. And I am an art snob, and he thinks its more about preference. I think that some artists are better than others for specific reasons, but those reasons are from a trained perspective, kwim?



I don't think I would ever call something "bad art" or "NOT art". Everything is art. It's just "something I don't care for". I like mexican folk art / surrealism like frida kahlo. pop surrealism like mark ryden, Amy Sol, Lori Earley, Audrey kawasaki, Jason rudolph pena, greyson castro. The taste that best represents me is more quirky and modern. Urban and edgy.

but I can also appreciate the older art of van gogh, Renoir, monet etc



I also have a very loose interpretation of what art is. I love Renaissance and Baroque, these are my favorite periods, but for reasons of practicality I have my MA in Art History and concentrated in Modern and Contemporary. John Berger's "Ways of Seeing" is an interesting read, if anyone is interested in taking the conversation further.

If I had to pick my one, all-time favorite artist, it would be, Picasso. Big surpirse, right. He was just such an innovator and classically trained. It's not that he couldn't paint figuratively or representationally, he created and imagined new ways of seeing objects. Cubism, which he created along with Braque, was like nothing anyone at the time had ever seen before but is another period of objects that people like to poke fun at. I think he would have gotten a kick out of that. Chat Icon

Posted 5/16/13 10:43 AM
 

rsquared
Sweet P is here!

Member since 4/11

2026 total posts

Name:
R

Re: I will never understand "Art"

I love Ways of Seeing! It was the first book I was assigned in college. It rocked my freshman world. :D I studied Contemporary, but my focus was video and performance from the 70's and 80's. I like really weird, twisted, performance art, lol. My favorite artists are Marina Abramovic, Paul McCarthy, Miriam Shapiro, etc. I wrote my thesis on McCarthy. Since I am a performance person, its never really been about beauty or objects for me....

Nice to meet another art history buddy on here, LovesMike.

Message edited 2013-05-16 18:03:34.360000.

Posted 5/16/13 6:01 PM
 

HeathKernandez
Our Ron is an awesome Ron

Member since 4/07

9091 total posts

Name:
baby fish mouth

Re: I will never understand "Art"

Sometimes you need to look beyond the painting and who the painter is. Barnett Newman has a story behind him.

Other artists know this Chat Icon Chat Icon

I find the painting beautiful but the price tag is for the painter, not necessarily the piece.


Message edited 2013-05-16 18:55:03.590000.

Posted 5/16/13 6:39 PM
 

HeathKernandez
Our Ron is an awesome Ron

Member since 4/07

9091 total posts

Name:
baby fish mouth

Re: I will never understand "Art"

Posted by BriBri2u

This is why I don't take 'artists' seriously...I just can't lolol



It's ok. We don't take you seriously either... Chat Icon

Posted 5/16/13 6:42 PM
 

LSP2005
Bunny kisses are so cute!

Member since 5/05

19461 total posts

Name:
L

Re: I will never understand "Art"

Posted by rsquared

Posted by meloyellow

Posted by rsquared

Just curious, if this is not good art, what IS good art?






that's subjective.

"good art" to me evokes emotion & thought





I am aware it is subjective. That is why I asked. I was curious about everyone's criteria since so many decisively ruled this "not art." People obviously have some sort of definition of art they are operating with, just curious what that is.

I have a masters in Art History, so I have a very trained view of art, and I wonder what other people view as art. My husband and I talk about this all the time...he is a musician and he often argues that some music is "better" than others for technical reasons, and to me its more personal and I don't care if its technically good. And I am an art snob, and he thinks its more about preference. I think that some artists are better than others for specific reasons, but those reasons are from a trained perspective, kwim?



I understand what you are saying, I just don't care for this particular piece of art. I prefer bierstadt, calder, mondrian, rodan, seurat, monet, renoir, degas, and diego rivera.

To me, this is not ground breaking and it does not speak to me, I find no technical merit in it as the white stripe is not even (I know he did not have blue painters tape when he made this Chat Icon). It is just large. I do find technical merit in being able to stretch a canvas this big, but it does nothing for me.

Posted 5/16/13 7:19 PM
 
Pages: 1 [2]
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
What part of No Thank you do you not understand??? dooodles 12/30/06 3 Families Helping Families ™
What do you think about this piece of art? Eva Luna 12/7/06 34 Families Helping Families ™
Jessica!! Where art thou?? reggie 6/29/06 2 Families Helping Families ™
I hate to ask but you may all remember the art teacher from selden middle school who passed janet 6/28/06 1 Families Helping Families ™
We registered at BRU this weekend but what I don't understand... preciouslove 1/23/06 5 Pregnancy
I don't understand.... Sharp Objects May Be Allowed on Planes JennChris 11/30/05 7 Families Helping Families ™