I need suggestions.... please come in

Posted By Message

BellyBlessings
LIF Adolescent

Member since 8/08

574 total posts

Name:

I need suggestions.... please come in

So - I've beeln trying for a month or so now to get my DS (almost 17 months) off of the bottle and to drink milk from his straw cup.

I followed everyone's recommedations and put the milk in his cup and I give it to him with meals - instead of the water. This way - when he is thirsty - he will have to drink some gulps of milk.

THe thing is... I've been measuring how many ounces he consumes during meals (so I can still get him to his 18-20 oz a day mark) and he only drinks 1/2 oz - 1 oz. That is way too little IMO. If it was water he would drink the whole cup.

I give him some water after his meal because I feel like it's torture.

I know he likes milk - because he loves his baba... I just can't get him to drink it in any sort of cup!

Anyone else experience this? Anything you could share would be great - thanks!

Posted 2/22/12 1:23 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

sfp0701
Liam's Mommy!

Member since 1/07

9764 total posts

Name:
Tricia

Re: I need suggestions.... please come in

Honestly I would just take it away. Liam went through a few weeks where he didn't drink much milk but when he realized he wasn't getting the bottle back he started drinking again.

Posted 2/22/12 1:39 PM
 

NervousNell
Just another chapter in life..

Member since 11/09

54921 total posts

Name:
..being a mommy and being a wife!

Re: I need suggestions.... please come in

This is such a common thing and I always wonder why.
Why will they drink water and juice from a cup fine but not milk?
And why do they drink milk fine from a bottle?

EVERYONE I talk to says the same thing.
It's so bizzare

I'm of no help- I just let her have the bottle. I'm a sucker!

Posted 2/22/12 1:47 PM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: I need suggestions.... please come in

With my DD I just went cold turkey with the bottles and only gave her the sippy which did not go over well because she HATED cold milk. Her milk consumption went waaaaaay down but the ped said not to worry since at her age (at the time she was about 17 months) she was getting her nutrition from food more than anything else and milk was just a beverage at a meal as it is for us.

But to get her to use the sippy and drink the cold milk I put a little drop of Hershey syrup in her milk and it worked like a charm. After 3-4 days I ditched the chocolate and she was drinking cold PLAIN milk from a sippy and her milk consumption did go back up to a more reasonable amount.

Good luck! Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 2/22/12 1:56 PM
 

Jacksmommy
My love muffin!

Member since 1/07

5819 total posts

Name:
Liz

Re: I need suggestions.... please come in

I took the bottles away at 2 and he has never drank milk again. Despite me trying to force it. I have tried chocolate milk, strawberry milk etc! If I force it, he will drink a little bit but I literally have to sit there forcing it in his mouth. I just gave up and make sure he gets yogurt and cheese every day!

Posted 2/22/12 2:15 PM
 

bluekat16
My boys :-)

Member since 3/09

6659 total posts

Name:
Kathy

Re: I need suggestions.... please come in

So I just replied to the two other bottle threads but I let DS #1 have the bottle until 22 months...meaning this week...LOL.

I transitioned him with this cup:

External Image

BTW he won't drink milk from the straw cup...go figure.

Posted 2/22/12 2:35 PM
 

cheryl28
LIF Adult

Member since 2/10

4657 total posts

Name:

Re: I need suggestions.... please come in

have you tried different cups? Straw cups?

It took dd a few weeks o get used to it. She drank water no problem but milk she wanted the bottle. At first I would give her milk in a sippy with her meal, then when she was down and ready to get out of the high chair I put the milk back into the bottles (what ever was left in sippy) After a while she stopped needing/wanting the bottle. I let her have cups around the house.

Posted 2/22/12 2:51 PM
 

TreAnt427
-

Member since 8/06

8652 total posts

Name:
Tracy

Re: I need suggestions.... please come in

I started with these cups, the have a rubber spout like a bottle.

Message edited 2012-02-22 15:30:29.207000.

Posted 2/22/12 3:30 PM
 

CaMacho
Sisters :)

Member since 7/06

15112 total posts

Name:
Jess

Re: I need suggestions.... please come in

Posted by NervousNell

This is such a common thing and I always wonder why.
Why will they drink water and juice from a cup fine but not milk?
And why do they drink milk fine from a bottle?

EVERYONE I talk to says the same thing.
It's so bizzare

I'm of no help- I just let her have the bottle. I'm a sucker!



I know and I feel like i'm answering a ton of these posts lately too. I also started similar posts when DD was 1.5, 2, etc b/c nothing worked!

But same here, I just let her have it. The "baba" was her comfort at night for 5 minutes and we always brushed her teeth after. She just gave it up a few weeks ago at 2.5 years old when she FINALLY decided she liked chocolate milk in her straw cup.

Posted 2/22/12 3:34 PM
 

A3CM
Avatar Title

Member since 9/08

3762 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: I need suggestions.... please come in

cows milk is NOT necessary at ALL.

a LOT of children do NOT drink cows milk, and they are perfectly 100% HEALTHY.

does your DC eat cheese, yogurt? there is their milk intake.

my DC don't drink cows milk at all... once they got off the bottle at 12 months (and for DS 12 months and 2 weeks) he drank chocolate milk and then we switched him to rice milk.

DD hardly ever drinks cows milk (she may get it with her 1 yogurt a week) she is on rice milk as well... if its offered to her she may drink it, but its very rare that it is.

not sure why we as parents get so worked up when our DC don't drink cows milk.

but to each their own

ETA: no need to worry about your DCs intake, but if you are worried, just keep on giving the sippy or straw up and eventually they will take it

Message edited 2012-02-22 15:41:50.743000.

Posted 2/22/12 3:38 PM
 

allIwant
Love my crazy life!

Member since 1/10

9170 total posts

Name:

Re: I need suggestions.... please come in

Posted by sfp0701

Honestly I would just take it away. Liam went through a few weeks where he didn't drink much milk but when he realized he wasn't getting the bottle back he started drinking again.



I agree...It took a couple of days now they drink it down. Ped said they only really need 3 servings of dairy a day. So in the mean time you can fill in with yogurt and cheese as long as they are drinking water

Posted 2/22/12 3:44 PM
 

Kelly9904
Mommy to 2 amazing little boys

Member since 5/05

9306 total posts

Name:
Kelly

Re: I need suggestions.... please come in

Posted by AJandCJsMommy

cows milk is NOT necessary at ALL.

a LOT of children do NOT drink cows milk, and they are perfectly 100% HEALTHY.

does your DC eat cheese, yogurt? there is their milk intake.

my DC don't drink cows milk at all... once they got off the bottle at 12 months (and for DS 12 months and 2 weeks) he drank chocolate milk and then we switched him to rice milk.

DD hardly ever drinks cows milk (she may get it with her 1 yogurt a week) she is on rice milk as well... if its offered to her she may drink it, but its very rare that it is.

not sure why we as parents get so worked up when our DC don't drink cows milk.

but to each their own

ETA: no need to worry about your DCs intake, but if you are worried, just keep on giving the sippy or straw up and eventually they will take it



agreed! DS hardly ever drinks cows milk now! He will down an entire nesquick if I allow him though!Chat Icon

But especially right after we took the bottle away, we just relied on cheese, yogurt, yogurt drinks, some milk, chocolate, strawberry, etc. I also buy OJ with calcium to up his intake of that.

But honestly I dont worry about it. DS is a active happy healthy intelligent 4yo who has always been off the charts for height and weight etc.

Posted 2/22/12 4:00 PM
 

RegalBeagle
LIF Adult

Member since 2/07

1124 total posts

Name:

Re: I need suggestions.... please come in

Posted by BellyBlessings

So - I've beeln trying for a month or so now to get my DS (almost 17 months) off of the bottle and to drink milk from his straw cup.

I followed everyone's recommedations and put the milk in his cup and I give it to him with meals - instead of the water. This way - when he is thirsty - he will have to drink some gulps of milk.

THe thing is... I've been measuring how many ounces he consumes during meals (so I can still get him to his 18-20 oz a day mark) and he only drinks 1/2 oz - 1 oz. That is way too little IMO. If it was water he would drink the whole cup.

I give him some water after his meal because I feel like it's torture.

I know he likes milk - because he loves his baba... I just can't get him to drink it in any sort of cup!

Anyone else experience this? Anything you could share would be great - thanks!



I am having the same problem..my DD will drink water with it, but No milk. I gave up and went back to the bottle becasue she wasn't drinking anything.

Advice would be great!

Posted 2/22/12 7:11 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Another chirstening gift question - DH is Godfather, need suggestions. MrsJ 9/14/05 5 Pregnancy
can you help with gift suggestions for a 2 yo girl? oops123 8/25/05 7 Parenting
louie is teething (and teething!) - any other suggestions? pschica 7/9/05 5 Pets
Suggestions for a restaurant to eat OUTSIDE in Roosevelt Field area? Holly 7/6/05 11 Families Helping Families ™
Need suggestions on a child friendly place to meet my friend... 2003fallwedding 7/6/05 4 Parenting
Starting to plan my sisters Baby Shower... need some suggestions on places! julz33 6/6/05 36 Families Helping Families ™