I Need Help-Tantrums

Posted By Message

cjik
Welcome 2010!

Member since 2/06

8879 total posts

Name:

I Need Help-Tantrums

My son is almost 2, and his tantrums are getting out of control. He has a lot of them throughout the day, mostly over transitions--going out, coming back in, getting in the car, going downstairs, going upstairs, having lunch, changing his diaper. You name it--it's likely to cause a tantrum.

I can't say he does things that are bad and has a tantrum. He's upset because we need to go out, come back in, he can't watch more TV, etc. and this is his way of expressing it. I think he's also very strong willed and while he's generally a good kid, if he's not happy with something YOU WILL KNOW IT.

Time outs really don't work with him. He will not stay in one space and either winds up getting more upset if I try and force him to be in one spot, or he thinks it's all funny. I'm not even sure punishing him for expressing his feelings is the right way to handle it. Ignoring the tantrum and going about my business doesn't work lately either--the tantrum just escalates until he's close to hurting himself physically. Most distractions don't work either.The only thing that seems to break it up is putting on the TV, and I feel like he's watching way too much TV as a result.

I feel like I'm walking on eggshells all day long waiting to see what is going to set him off next. I do warn him before we start something new, "we're going upstairs to read your books after lunch," "we are going home after we leave this store," etc.

It was such a struggle getting him out of the house this week to buy stuff for his birthday party on Saturday--at times I felt like calling the whole thing off.

Any suggestions or advice on dealing with these transition tantrums? It's to the point where I feel like staying in the house with him all day, let him watch all the TV he wants, and change his diapers as rarely as possible. But I know this is a rotten solution, it's just miserable trying to get him to do anything lately.

Posted 12/3/09 1:20 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

cjik
Welcome 2010!

Member since 2/06

8879 total posts

Name:

Re: I Need Help-Tantrums

Bump--any suggestions at all? I'm really at my wits end. TIA!

Posted 12/3/09 1:54 PM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: I Need Help-Tantrums

you are the mother.

what you are saying essentially is that your child's tantrums are controlling you and not the other way around.

not sure how this will go over, but my friend used to throw the most horrendous tantrums.

her mom would run a cold bath and put her in it.

not artic tundra ice cold, but cold enough that it would make her stop.

not sure if this would be viewed as abuse now Chat Icon

in my house, we didn't throw tantrums. that would lead to a beating. so we didnt' do it.

but I will say that by letting him win, you are doing both of you a disservice.

I might also say to let him take it to the end...he's not going to hurt himself that badly...but maybe a bruised knee from kicking and screaming will snap him back into reality.

I am sure it must be nerve wracking for you.

Chat Icon

Posted 12/3/09 2:03 PM
 

cjik
Welcome 2010!

Member since 2/06

8879 total posts

Name:

Re: I Need Help-Tantrums

I know he's controlling me at this point. We actually did not go grocery shopping yesterday (despite the fact that there was almost no food in the house) because he threw such a fit right before we left. He is thin, but tall and strong, and I could not physically move him to the car. Nothing I said made him want to go to the car. Rewards don't work. Threat of punishment doesn't work. And the only solution offered time and time again are time outs, but I swear, these do not work with him, not now. He just gets crazier.

I did let him scream his head off today, and often this is what I'll do. I do my best to calmly go about my business and ignore him till he calms down. and it went on for nearly an hour. As usual, the TV stopped it, but I feel like this isn't the best solution. I only did that when he started flinging himself repeatedly at the wall, fell down, and started screaming even louder.

My parents were never physically violent but they got very upset and would scream at us. So we were afraid of them and didn't act up. I don't want to do this to my kid, but I just don't know what will work with him other than yelling also.

Posted 12/3/09 2:15 PM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: I Need Help-Tantrums

he is playing you.

you guys are in some kind of conditioned-response tantrum dance.

he knows eventually you will give in.

he's not hurting himself when he throws himself to the floor....but he knows he is scaring the dickens out of you.

and he knows eventually you will cave and tv watching will resume.

I don't think screaming at him would help you either at this point. but I do think putting him in his room and shutting the door for him to scream it out will teach him something.

you just need to be consistent. no more tv.

maybe you could put the radio on (to YOUR favorite station to drown him out.

show him you don't want to hear it. that his ridiculous behavior will not stand.

it sucks b/c we are so scared for them/sick of hearing them scream we don't realize after a while they learn to use it against us.

Posted 12/3/09 2:20 PM
 

Diana1215
Living on a prayer!!!

Member since 10/05

29450 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: I Need Help-Tantrums

Oh I feel your pain!

First off, my son is very very hardheaded so when he blows up, it's out of control.

I am just now (he's 2.5) consistently doing time-outs.

I am obsessed with watching SuperNanny and have gotten some great tips.

Stay calm and in control of the situation. Get down to his level and explain to him why he has to do something "We need to change your diaper because it's wet. We need to go to the store to pick up grapes" etc.

You have to let him know that you are the boss, not him. Which to be honest, is very very hard. Somedays I walk around silently, scared to wake the beast. Some days I have the strength to fight him so I do.

With time outs, I do it until he stays in the corner and says he's sorry. It can be five times, or twenty five times, but I have learned not to give up until he says sorry and does his time. It has been working, and now when I give him a warning for his behavior and say "Do it again and you'll go in time out" - for the most part he stops doing the bad behavior.

I also find that kids like to know what they are doing ahead of time. THey don't like surprises. Ex: If Jack is taking a bath and I want to get him out, I will say "After X song you are going to get out of the bath and watch Yo Gabba Gabba" --

If all else fails there's nothing wrong with a little bribery!

Chat Icon Chat Icon

Message edited 2009-12-03 14:23:31.940000.

Posted 12/3/09 2:22 PM
 

cjik
Welcome 2010!

Member since 2/06

8879 total posts

Name:

Re: I Need Help-Tantrums

Diana--how did you ever get Jack to sit? This is where I feel the time outs are ineffective for DS--he will not sit or stand still which would be OK also, not even for a few seconds. I could use his high chair, but he has eating issues too, so I hate to add any negativity to that realm. I've tried boxing him in a corner, but he either fights like hell, and it all gets worse, or he giggles and thinks I'm playing some game with him, more often the latter. Same if I keep grabbing him and putting him back in a corner. So I feel like it's not a punishment when that happens.

Maybe it would be a good idea to put him in his room alone until he calms down though. That way, the sitting isn't an issue--he can do whatever he wants in there, but he also isn't getting my attention or seeing me cringe.

Guess it is becoming very clear to me what my own limits are as a parent, and what skills (or lack of skills) I picked up from my own parents.

Posted 12/3/09 2:49 PM
 

lbelle821
Arghhhhh

Member since 2/06

5285 total posts

Name:
Lisa

Re: I Need Help-Tantrums

i don't have time for a full blown response right now but if you don't mind, send me your e-mail address and I'll send you the tantrum behaviorial plan that our therapist wrote up for us. My son is extremely strong willed like yours with a speech delay so communication is also very difficult. We went through what seemed like months of tantrums and it is worlds better now. He still has them to an extent but usually the threat of a timeout is enough to cease the behavior.

Posted 12/3/09 3:07 PM
 

Diana1215
Living on a prayer!!!

Member since 10/05

29450 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: I Need Help-Tantrums

Posted by cjik

Diana--how did you ever get Jack to sit? This is where I feel the time outs are ineffective for DS--he will not sit or stand still which would be OK also, not even for a few seconds. I could use his high chair, but he has eating issues too, so I hate to add any negativity to that realm. I've tried boxing him in a corner, but he either fights like hell, and it all gets worse, or he giggles and thinks I'm playing some game with him, more often the latter. Same if I keep grabbing him and putting him back in a corner. So I feel like it's not a punishment when that happens.

Maybe it would be a good idea to put him in his room alone until he calms down though. That way, the sitting isn't an issue--he can do whatever he wants in there, but he also isn't getting my attention or seeing me cringe.

Guess it is becoming very clear to me what my own limits are as a parent, and what skills (or lack of skills) I picked up from my own parents.



he stands - won't sit, and when he walks out of the corner I keep putting him back until he finally realizes that I mean business!Chat Icon

Posted 12/3/09 3:39 PM
 

Diana1215
Living on a prayer!!!

Member since 10/05

29450 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: I Need Help-Tantrums

Posted by lbelle821

i don't have time for a full blown response right now but if you don't mind, send me your e-mail address and I'll send you the tantrum behaviorial plan that our therapist wrote up for us. My son is extremely strong willed like yours with a speech delay so communication is also very difficult. We went through what seemed like months of tantrums and it is worlds better now. He still has them to an extent but usually the threat of a timeout is enough to cease the behavior.



Lisa, can you send this to me pls!!!!Chat Icon

Posted 12/3/09 3:39 PM
 

DanaRenee
Fitness Junkie!

Member since 6/06

6470 total posts

Name:
Dana

Re: I Need Help-Tantrums

All I can really say is that I feel your pain! DS is 26months. I do have good phases and bad phases...like weeks or days at a time when he is a monster and then weeks or days at a time when he is an angel.

As for tantrums, when I know they are coming, I used to try to make sure that when he threw himself on the ground that I was ready to make sure his head was not going to slam on the floor. After many times of not getting there in time he learned to be careful.

I always just let him lay there and scream and cry for a tantrum.

The more he throws them the stricter I am.

Time out is 2 minutes. I must say we don't do time out that often b/c usually his tantrums don't last long but if I make him sit in the naughty chair, I will stand there and put him back in it over and over and over and over and over again until 2mins are up.

I think you will learn to tune out the tantrums also. You will get used to them and they wont stress you out as much. When DS is screaming now, I usually walk away or do something that will distract him (like play with his little sister which makes him jealous!)

You will learn your way. You will learn what works! Hang in there, they will get better but even if they dont for a while, you will learn to deal with them and they wont stress you out as much. Chat Icon

Posted 12/3/09 3:47 PM
 

CkGm
They get so big, so fast :(

Member since 5/05

13848 total posts

Name:
Christine

Re: I Need Help-Tantrums

I know this is probably wrong but the only thing that works with my DD is to put her in her crib and she is almost 3Chat Icon Strangely enough she still loves sleeping it and recognizes this punishment as a daytime event. I just threaten going in her crib before bed and suddenly the behavior stops. Or if it doesn't its timeout in the crib for 3 mintues.

I know, I have no idea what the heck I am going to do when she moves to her big girl bed next monthChat Icon

Posted 12/3/09 3:50 PM
 

dottiemchugh
<3

Member since 5/05

8261 total posts

Name:

Re: I Need Help-Tantrums

My son is very strong willed, so I feel your pain. If he doesn't want to do something, it becomes a nightmare.

I recently took a class at his school on promoting positive behavior. ALL negative behavior (screaming, hitting, throwing themselves on the floor) stems from a few different reasons. Bad mood, medical issues (like a low blood sugar or imbalance), attention seeking, or (and this is my son) not getting their way. It sounds like when your son can't have what he wants, it triggers the tantrum. My son is the same, except he is a little older and understands consequences, and does sit in time out if he if placed there.

They recommended ignoring it and not giving them what they want, whether its attention, or giving them control over what you are doing. I KNOW that is the hardest thing sometimes, but if a time out won't work, it's really the only thing you can do. It sounds like you have tried everything else.

If you give in once, by saying "OK, we won't go to the store, fine finish you tv show", they know that if they tantrum again, they will get their way. Even if they have to scream and carry on for 15 minutes, they think that they will get their way eventually. So my advice would be to seriously just ignore it as best you can, he will learn that tantruming will get him no where and hopefully it will become less and less. The first times will be h ell.

Hang in there...Chat Icon

Posted 12/3/09 4:13 PM
 

Janice
Sweet Jessie Quinn

Member since 5/05

27567 total posts

Name:
Janice

Re: I Need Help-Tantrums

Posted by cjik

My parents were never physically violent but they got very upset and would scream at us. So we were afraid of them and didn't act up. I don't want to do this to my kid, but I just don't know what will work with him other than yelling also.



IMHO, this is it in a nutshell.

I have this conversation all the time with DH.

I don't care if my kid feels like I am a mean lunatic. I know I am not.

My mother had 7, never saw a tantrum.
I babysat a boy for 2 years. This kid's life was one big tantrum. at home. He threw one with me. He was told he will not be going to park and was put in a corner with books while he watched my dh take my kid to the park.

He never threw another one. Yet, threw them at home all the time.

DH feels he does not want Josh to be intimidated by us. He wants a pure love. Well, I want to live a normal life, get out of the house without a ticking time bomb.

I don't believe in time out. I believe that if you are acting like an out of control beast, get to your room. We don't allow beasts to have fun with us.

I also believe in not having hungry/overtired kids. That is when I will turn into a beast...when I am tired, bored, hungry....this is only my experience. Every kid is different. I think if you are proactive and just don't tolerate behavior, it may go away.

good luck!

Posted 12/3/09 4:14 PM
 

Diana1215
Living on a prayer!!!

Member since 10/05

29450 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: I Need Help-Tantrums

Janice - what do you do if their room has more toys than TRU? Jack would love it if I sent him to his room Chat Icon

Posted 12/3/09 4:17 PM
 

Janice
Sweet Jessie Quinn

Member since 5/05

27567 total posts

Name:
Janice

Re: I Need Help-Tantrums

Posted by Diana1215

Janice - what do you do if their room has more toys than TRU? Jack would love it if I sent him to his room Chat Icon



send him to your room then. I am no expert at all. But I really believe that if you act as though everytime they tell you no you act as though they have just committed a murder...they will get the picture.

At this point, if Josh lied to Leo or something, I say that's not how you normally act, so you must be tired. Go upstairs and get to bed. come down when you feel better. That's the moment when I am giving him a chance to reset. Usually he makes it up 3 stairs, says he's not tired and will be nice.

Posted 12/3/09 4:21 PM
 

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: I Need Help-Tantrums

Posted by Diana1215

Janice - what do you do if their room has more toys than TRU? Jack would love it if I sent him to his room Chat Icon



D-I've started putting C3 in his room when he has a tantrum and shutting the door, and even though there are toys in there, he KNOWS he is in trouble because of the events that preceded it and he knows he is in trouble...

He still goes and plays there independently during the day too (we are on one level) so no real harm done, you know?

To the OP, it is SO hard having a toddler and they are SO irrational that sometimes you HAVE to give in for your own sanity...

I'd try time outs in his room, maybe and see if it helpsChat Icon

Posted 12/3/09 4:26 PM
 

lbelle821
Arghhhhh

Member since 2/06

5285 total posts

Name:
Lisa

Re: I Need Help-Tantrums

Posted by Diana1215

Posted by lbelle821

i don't have time for a full blown response right now but if you don't mind, send me your e-mail address and I'll send you the tantrum behaviorial plan that our therapist wrote up for us. My son is extremely strong willed like yours with a speech delay so communication is also very difficult. We went through what seemed like months of tantrums and it is worlds better now. He still has them to an extent but usually the threat of a timeout is enough to cease the behavior.



Lisa, can you send this to me pls!!!!Chat Icon



of course, send me your e-mail address

Posted 12/3/09 4:54 PM
 

pinkandblue
Our family is complete, maybe

Member since 9/05

32436 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: I Need Help-Tantrums

Posted by lbelle821

Posted by Diana1215

Posted by lbelle821

i don't have time for a full blown response right now but if you don't mind, send me your e-mail address and I'll send you the tantrum behaviorial plan that our therapist wrote up for us. My son is extremely strong willed like yours with a speech delay so communication is also very difficult. We went through what seemed like months of tantrums and it is worlds better now. He still has them to an extent but usually the threat of a timeout is enough to cease the behavior.



Lisa, can you send this to me pls!!!!Chat Icon



of course, send me your e-mail address



me too please, you have fm Chat Icon

Posted 12/3/09 5:01 PM
 

Bxgell2
Perfection

Member since 5/05

16438 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: I Need Help-Tantrums

What about taking things away? We are having MASSIVE problems with Alex lately, but she's 4, and too smart for her own good, which makes it difficult. The only thing that seems to make ANY dent at all, is to deny her those pleasures in her life - like, a few weeks ago, she started acting up, so I didn't let her go to a friend's bday party. Devastated her, but she got the hint that I meant business.

Two nights ago she lied to me - so I took the "princess" TV in her room up to the attic and told her it doesn't come back down for a week, and she isn't allowed to watch any TV in the meantime.

At the same time, I do have a reward chart - for every time she behaves well, or responds nicely to something I ask her to do, or when I say no and she doesn't freak out, she gets a star, and once she accumulates 20 stars, she can pick a treat for herself.

Posted 12/3/09 5:07 PM
 

mommy2devin
2 Boys, I need calgon!

Member since 10/07

1572 total posts

Name:
Shannon

Re: I Need Help-Tantrums

Posted by Diana1215

Posted by cjik

Diana--how did you ever get Jack to sit? This is where I feel the time outs are ineffective for DS--he will not sit or stand still which would be OK also, not even for a few seconds. I could use his high chair, but he has eating issues too, so I hate to add any negativity to that realm. I've tried boxing him in a corner, but he either fights like hell, and it all gets worse, or he giggles and thinks I'm playing some game with him, more often the latter. Same if I keep grabbing him and putting him back in a corner. So I feel like it's not a punishment when that happens.

Maybe it would be a good idea to put him in his room alone until he calms down though. That way, the sitting isn't an issue--he can do whatever he wants in there, but he also isn't getting my attention or seeing me cringe.

Guess it is becoming very clear to me what my own limits are as a parent, and what skills (or lack of skills) I picked up from my own parents.



he stands - won't sit, and when he walks out of the corner I keep putting him back until he finally realizes that I mean business!Chat Icon



Sorry, hijacking. Does Jack kick, scream and cry the whole time you are putting him back in the corner until he "gets" it?

Posted 12/3/09 5:27 PM
 

GoldenRod
10 years on LIF!

Member since 11/06

26792 total posts

Name:
Shawn

Re: I Need Help-Tantrums

DS was amazing at being stubborn. When we put him in timeout, he would voluntarily stay there for an hour or more, even after we did everything that all of the "experts" said to do. Take away prized possessions? He would voluntarily offer us ALL of his toys. He NEVER got what he was aiming to get. Now that he's 6, he still has tantrums, but nowhere near as bad, mainly because I can talk to him more, and he now has favorite things that he doesn't want to give up.... However, he admits that he's never gotten anything that he's cried and screamed for. The only thing he's ever gotten is punished. He understands the repercussions, he understands it makes us unhappy. He understands that if he behaves, he gets what he wants, and everyone is much happier.

It's like trying to convince an agoraphobic that the outdoors is wonderful.

It does eventually get better. You just need to be consistent, and hold your ground. When they eventually start to figure it out, the consistency will be there, and you won't have to transition.

Posted 12/3/09 8:43 PM
 

dpli
Daylight savings :)

Member since 5/05

13973 total posts

Name:
D

Re: I Need Help-Tantrums

Posted by KateDevine

D-I've started putting C3 in his room when he has a tantrum and shutting the door, and even though there are toys in there, he KNOWS he is in trouble because of the events that preceded it and he knows he is in trouble...




this is what I do too. He gets put in the playroom and the gate goes up. Even though almost all of his toys are in there, he knows he's in trouble. He doesn't like it since he usually has free run of the first floor of the house, and wants to be in the same room as me.

C- don't let him fool you. My DS isn't really talking yet either, but he understands EVERYTHING. They get it, believe me. I have even said out loud to DS "I am the boss, not you..." Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 12/3/09 9:11 PM
 

cjik
Welcome 2010!

Member since 2/06

8879 total posts

Name:

Re: I Need Help-Tantrums

Thanks again for all the messages! I am hoping today will be better. It does seem if one day is horrible, the next is better.

After I wrote yesterday there was another monster tantrum, and I did decide to put him in his room for that one. It worked well since I was ready to lose my cool at that point, and I know that doesn't help matters. He has toys in there, but he knew he did something wrong, and he just cried, didn't play with his toys as far as I could tell. And yes, he does understand most of what we say, he just can't communicate well yet.

I know time outs work for a lot of people, but with us, it became more of a game for him than any sort of repercussion because he had done something wrong.

Thanks again for your advice!

Posted 12/4/09 8:07 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Why is everything SO hard? The tantrums! dm24angel 3/16/09 16 Parenting
How do you handle temper tantrums of a 12 month old??? munchkinbugs 12/11/08 11 Parenting
Toddler Taming, Tantrums, Advice, What do you thinK? Its long, really long. yankinmanc 4/28/08 15 Parenting
aaaahhhhh between the wrestle mania at diaper changes and the temper tantrums if unable to roll over im exhausted......any advice PLEASE. babybugsmum 10/17/07 8 Parenting
Is it possible that my 9 month old is having temper tantrums ??????? babybugsmum 10/13/07 7 Parenting
BTDT moms .. temper tantrums .. what do you do? Ali1 6/26/07 13 Parenting