I just don't understand - Formula vs BM

Posted By Message

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

I just don't understand - Formula vs BM

Why is it such a competition? Why is every comment over analysed and taken personally?

I have never met a BF mom (so far) thinking that non BF moms were not good enough. That their babies are smarter, healthier, bigger, smaller.... BETTER than non BFd babies.

We all had our dose of lectures and comments.

The sense of guilt, pressure is on ALL moms.

Posted 5/29/08 11:24 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

MyChip-n-Dales
lifes many lil twisted curves

Member since 10/07

5158 total posts

Name:
aeriell

Re: I just don't understand - Formula vs BM

if u are referring to me...I didnt over analyze---I simply gave my opinion! and yes i have seen and heard comments made about moms who didnt BF. I never stated BF was easy cause its NOT! i tried and would prob try again to BF. YOU personaly made the comment about your son being bf and that BF babies are usually bigger... you dont think that someone whos dc is struggling with there weight an is not bf wasnt hurt by that comment.... think again. that post asked if your child tripled in weight... not was your child BF and tripled in weight..
you know what its not always the comment its when you whip out a bottle and mix that formula the looks dont help either.


dont turn this into a debate.. i stated my opinion that was it.. i made a few moms feel better letting them know they arent alone.

Message edited 2008-05-29 23:36:07.120000.

Posted 5/29/08 11:34 PM
 

partyof6
b nice like u want ur kidz 2

Member since 7/06

7752 total posts

Name:
jeannine

Re: I just don't understand - Formula vs BM

Posted by twinboys425

if u are referring to me...I didnt over analyze---I simply gave my opinion! and yes i have seen and heard comments made about moms who didnt BF. I never stated BF was easy cause its NOT! i tried and would prob try again to BF. YOU personaly made the comment about your son being bf and that BF babies are usually bigger... you dont think that someone whos dc is struggling with there weight an is not bf wasnt hurt by that comment.... think again. that post asked if your child tripled in weight... not was your child BF and tripled in weight..
you know what its not always the comment its when you whip out a bottle and mix that formula the looks dont help either.



not true necessarily.....
myboys are on Neocate---sad to say...we looked and its better made formula then anything the U.S sells...
so I sooooooooo don't feel guilty about making a bottle...
and again---i couldn't produce....
my boys at 14 months still drink every three hours!
Chat Icon Chat Icon
besides...bottomline is any kid---b/f or formula need Omegafatty acids...
thats one of the most important things

Posted 5/29/08 11:42 PM
 

BaroqueMama
Chase is one!

Member since 5/05

27530 total posts

Name:
me

Re: I just don't understand - Formula vs BM

I don't know why anyone cares how a mother feeds her childChat Icon I don't care how anyone else eats, why should they care how my daughter eats? That's how I see it. I feel no pressure from anyone to formula feed or breast feed. When it really comes down to it, women who breast feed, in my own experiences, are quite often ridiculed and judged for where they breast feed, how long they breast feed their child, how appropriately or inappropriately they're covered, etc. So, it's not just moms who formula feed who feel judged.
That being said, if we would all just be confident in our decisions as mothers, then it wouldn't matter so much what anyone else's judgements, suggestions or comments are.
We all want the same thing for our children, so we all do the best we know how with what we're equipped with.

Posted 5/29/08 11:46 PM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: I just don't understand - Formula vs BM

Posted by twinboys425

if u are referring to me...I didnt over analyze---I simply gave my opinion! and yes i have seen and heard comments made about moms who didnt BF. I never stated BF was easy cause its NOT! i tried and would prob try again to BF. YOU personaly made the comment about your son being bf and that BF babies are usually bigger... you dont think that someone whos dc is struggling with there weight an is not bf wasnt hurt by that comment.... think again. that post asked if your child tripled in weight... not was your child BF and tripled in weight..
you know what its not always the comment its when you whip out a bottle and mix that formula the looks dont help either.


dont turn this into a debate.. i stated my opinion that was it.. i made a few moms feel better letting them know they arent alone.



Well, I still think I am entitled to post my opinion too.

You posted several links to disprove what I said and I posted a link to support what I said. We were "even" in our opinions. But then you go on posting that BF moms give a hard time to non BFing moms. WTH????

The comment I made had NOTHING to do with the "perfect" weight a child should be. It was only stating that BF babies gain more weight on average. But usually by 1 years old both BF and formula babies end up at the same weight.

I just don't understand the comparison. I NEVER said DS was better or healthier than your sons.

Actually the reason why I said that is because when DS was only 2 months old he was gaining twice as much weight as he was supposed to and we discussed with our ped. I started looking into why my son was gaining weight quickly and I found that it was common for BF babies to do so.

As far as the triple the birth weight, I just replied that DS would meet that statement. I was just responding the the OP.

AND YES, I had plenty of comments on how big my son was. So, you know, it does hurt both ways. Not just when you heard you child is smaller. Like I had to justify to people that I was not overfeeding my child.

Posted 5/30/08 12:18 AM
 

chelle
It's a Good Life

Member since 8/06

15404 total posts

Name:
Isn't it obvious?

Re: I just don't understand - Formula vs BM

Posted by prncss

I don't know why anyone cares how a mother feeds her childChat Icon I don't care how anyone else eats, why should they care how my daughter eats? That's how I see it. I feel no pressure from anyone to formula feed or breast feed. When it really comes down to it, women who breast feed, in my own experiences, are quite often ridiculed and judged for where they breast feed, how long they breast feed their child, how appropriately or inappropriately they're covered, etc. So, it's not just moms who formula feed who feel judged.
That being said, if we would all just be confident in our decisions as mothers, then it wouldn't matter so much what anyone else's judgements, suggestions or comments are.
We all want the same thing for our children, so we all do the best we know how with what we're equipped with.



I'm still BFing DD at 1 yr and I COMPLETELY agree with what you just said.

The only important thing is that you FEED your baby! Who cares how? When? Why? or with what!?

I could care less how anyone feeds their child. I have made my decisions for me and my child as I would hope another mother would do the same for her and her child.

Message edited 2008-05-30 07:32:48.087000.

Posted 5/30/08 7:31 AM
 

05mommy09
Family of 5!

Member since 5/05

15364 total posts

Name:
<3 Mommy <3

Re: I just don't understand - Formula vs BM

What about the formula feeding moms looking down upon BFing moms...???

It happens often... It happened to me.

I cant even begin to tell you how hard OTHER PEOPLE made BFing for me.

We had no support from majority of our family and friends. Better yet- I had family members blaming DS weight loss in the hospital on my choice to breast feed. I was even called selfish.

This debate goes on ALL the time. Facts have proven BM is better for baby, but that doesn't mean those that choose to BF are doing anything wrong OR that their child will be any less smarter, taller, fatter, skinnier etc...

Everyone is entitled to their opinion- and every mother is entitled to do what they feel is best for their child, without having to justify it!

Posted 5/30/08 7:35 AM
 

2PreciousBlessings
The Perfect Pair

Member since 5/06

19861 total posts

Name:
Best Wife & Mommy

Re: I just don't understand - Formula vs BM

I can't understand why people should care about how someone feeds their child. I can't understand the competition between BF and FF either.

For me, I started out BF and after 3 months my daughter just would not take my breast milk anymore and then I started giving her formula. I never one day feel guilty about what I feed my daughter. I am so happy and contented with whatever I did for my daughter. I never feel that I need to justify my choices.

I think the reason for the competition is sometimes people are either guilty about their choices or they are not happy and contented with their choices. That is why I feel sometimes people have to keep justifying why they make certain choices .

Message edited 2008-05-30 07:48:35.927000.

Posted 5/30/08 7:42 AM
 

RMA9728
LIF Adolescent

Member since 1/08

863 total posts

Name:

Re: I just don't understand - Formula vs BM

I think it is hard to be a mom to begin with so we all need all the support we can get. I think everyone wants to feel they are right in their decisions and some people do feel the need to state why what they are doing is best. I know for me I've felt that way as well. I've personally received comments from both ends. With my oldest dd I bf her for 5 months. When I switched to formula I was told I was doing a horrible thing for her......

then with my next two dc's I ebf for over 2 years each and then I was told I was disgusting for what I was doing, etc.

By the way I also co-slept with them and had the comments and flames on that one too. So for me it was a no win situation. Just ignore them all and go on happily with what you are doing.

Motherhood is the hardest job out there and I bow down to all of you!!! Forget about what people say just know that your doing the right thing for your child.Chat Icon Chat Icon

Message edited 2008-05-30 08:06:19.230000.

Posted 5/30/08 8:04 AM
 

Diana1215
Living on a prayer!!!

Member since 10/05

29450 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: I just don't understand - Formula vs BM

I don't care how anyone feeds their child. I was not breastfeeding. Period. It's not for me. I don't feel guilty about my decision - at all. I have only had ONE person preach to me how breastfeeding was better - and that was before Jack was born (turns out her own daugther didn't end up breastfeeding her kid 6 months later)


I will admit this in regards to breastfeeding - Before LIF, I could never understand how people could BF their kids as they got much bigger - but - after being on here - I realized that they are doing what is best for THEIR child. As, I am doing what is best for mine. I get it now - and to each his own. Who are we to judge each other?

Posted 5/30/08 8:25 AM
 

mosh913
baby boy coming spring '11

Member since 5/05

3133 total posts

Name:

Re: I just don't understand - Formula vs BM

Posted by prncss

I don't know why anyone cares how a mother feeds her childChat Icon I don't care how anyone else eats, why should they care how my daughter eats? That's how I see it. I feel no pressure from anyone to formula feed or breast feed. When it really comes down to it, women who breast feed, in my own experiences, are quite often ridiculed and judged for where they breast feed, how long they breast feed their child, how appropriately or inappropriately they're covered, etc. So, it's not just moms who formula feed who feel judged.
That being said, if we would all just be confident in our decisions as mothers, then it wouldn't matter so much what anyone else's judgements, suggestions or comments are.
We all want the same thing for our children, so we all do the best we know how with what we're equipped with.



Very well said!!! Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 5/30/08 8:29 AM
 

jlp63
LIF Adolescent

Member since 2/08

871 total posts

Name:
Jenn

Re: I just don't understand - Formula vs BM

Posted by prncss

I don't know why anyone cares how a mother feeds her childChat Icon I don't care how anyone else eats, why should they care how my daughter eats? That's how I see it. I feel no pressure from anyone to formula feed or breast feed. When it really comes down to it, women who breast feed, in my own experiences, are quite often ridiculed and judged for where they breast feed, how long they breast feed their child, how appropriately or inappropriately they're covered, etc. So, it's not just moms who formula feed who feel judged.
That being said, if we would all just be confident in our decisions as mothers, then it wouldn't matter so much what anyone else's judgements, suggestions or comments are.
We all want the same thing for our children, so we all do the best we know how with what we're equipped with.



COMPLETELY AGREE! Chat Icon

Posted 5/30/08 10:00 AM
 

PrincessP
Big sister!!!!!!!!!!

Member since 12/05

17450 total posts

Name:

Re: I just don't understand - Formula vs BM

Posted by jlp63

Posted by prncss

I don't know why anyone cares how a mother feeds her childChat Icon I don't care how anyone else eats, why should they care how my daughter eats? That's how I see it. I feel no pressure from anyone to formula feed or breast feed. When it really comes down to it, women who breast feed, in my own experiences, are quite often ridiculed and judged for where they breast feed, how long they breast feed their child, how appropriately or inappropriately they're covered, etc. So, it's not just moms who formula feed who feel judged.
That being said, if we would all just be confident in our decisions as mothers, then it wouldn't matter so much what anyone else's judgements, suggestions or comments are.
We all want the same thing for our children, so we all do the best we know how with what we're equipped with.



COMPLETELY AGREE! Chat Icon



EXACTLY!!!!!!!!!!!!Chat Icon

Posted 5/30/08 10:04 AM
 

Stefanie
&hearts;

Member since 5/05

23599 total posts

Name:
Stefanie

Re: I just don't understand - Formula vs BM

It's such a personal thing...
People just love to give opinions.

Posted 5/30/08 10:05 AM
 

july0105
My three little miracles

Member since 4/06

2628 total posts

Name:
Alison

Re: I just don't understand - Formula vs BM

I think we do this to ourselves. I have felt guilty at times because BF just didn't work for us, but have realized that this is all ME. I was making myself feel guilty, no one else really was. I had to let it go and I remind myself everyday that this is a personal decision and I have weighed all of the pros and cons of my personal situation and came to an informed decision. If ever I feel judged about it, I do my best do remind myself to let it go.

Posted 5/30/08 10:21 AM
 

mommy2bella
Where does time go?

Member since 12/05

9747 total posts

Name:
Kelly

Re: I just don't understand - Formula vs BM

It just BOGGLES my mind how people (men AND women) can ask such a personal question to others. And sometimes they are not even close friends and family.

I STILL get asked if I breast fed Bella almost three years later and it's bananas.

Posted 5/30/08 10:24 AM
 

Stacey1403
Where it all began....

Member since 5/05

24065 total posts

Name:

Re: I just don't understand - Formula vs BM

Posted by prncss

I don't know why anyone cares how a mother feeds her childChat Icon I don't care how anyone else eats, why should they care how my daughter eats? That's how I see it. I feel no pressure from anyone to formula feed or breast feed. When it really comes down to it, women who breast feed, in my own experiences, are quite often ridiculed and judged for where they breast feed, how long they breast feed their child, how appropriately or inappropriately they're covered, etc. So, it's not just moms who formula feed who feel judged.
That being said, if we would all just be confident in our decisions as mothers, then it wouldn't matter so much what anyone else's judgements, suggestions or comments are.
We all want the same thing for our children, so we all do the best we know how with what we're equipped with.




Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Well said Rach!!

Posted 5/30/08 10:27 AM
 

LuvMy2Girls
@>---------

Member since 5/05

11165 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: I just don't understand - Formula vs BM

I did both, FF my 2nd and bf'd my 1st. i heard it both ways. I wasn't pressured to do either, it was my choice and my choice only.

I said Who cares, i'm going to feed my child what I want without second guessing myself or feelings of guilt. Give yourself permission to do what makes mommy and baby happy.

Posted 5/30/08 10:29 AM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: I just don't understand - Formula vs BM

I can answer that...

because everyone wants to feel comfortable with the choices they make and people make opposite choices.

So if you made the best choice for you child & I made an opposite best choice for my child, some people believe this =one of us is a bad parent.

Sad.

I didn't read through the posts on the other thread or post because I took it for what the first post stated. It was a vent. A mom venting over being judged. And that sucks no matter what your feeling on FF or BF.

Posted 5/30/08 10:34 AM
 

CrankyPants
I'm cranky

Member since 7/06

18178 total posts

Name:
Mama Cranky

Re: I just don't understand - Formula vs BM

Posted by nrthshgrl

I can answer that...

because everyone wants to feel comfortable with the choices they make and people make opposite choices.

So if you made the best choice for you child & I made an opposite best choice for my child, some people believe this =one of us is a bad parent.

Sad.




Hitting the nail on the head-well said.

Posted 5/30/08 10:36 AM
 

twiceasnice
LIF Adult

Member since 2/08

1126 total posts

Name:

Re: I just don't understand - Formula vs BM

Posted by nrthshgrl

So if you made the best choice for you child & I made an opposite best choice for my child, some people believe this =one of us is a bad parent.

Sad.



I agree with this but not to cause a debate I am clarifying the calcuation (even though nrthshgrl did it so well).

Choice A: BF
Choice B: FF

People who take Choice A don't vent about their decision but do vent about the process of BF and any negative feedback received.

People who take Choice B vent and seem to want to validate their decision to everyone else as well as dealing with negative opinions.

So FF and BF moms are venting all the time about feeling judged and dealing with negative comments.

But why do FF mom's feel like they have to validate themselves. If someone writes a comment that their baby is big and they are BF, to get offended is absurd! Then a FF mom who's baby is big can say the same thing and feel proud!

It doesn't matter BF or FF! I think FF mom's beat themselves up way too much over this and there is no reason for it.

Be thankful Formula Exists because life would be alot harder if it didn't!

Message edited 2008-05-30 11:10:39.300000.

Posted 5/30/08 11:10 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
captain charisma (Don) luvsbob4603 3/18/06 11 Families Helping Families ™
I don't understand it...(long vent) Stefanie 3/7/06 58 Families Helping Families ™
Where's Don?? Gertyrae 3/1/06 8 Families Helping Families ™
Don luvsbob4603 3/1/06 6 Families Helping Families ™
Comedic Actor Don Knotts Dies at 81 IrishTracy 2/25/06 9 Families Helping Families ™
Don Knotts passed away LisaW 2/25/06 14 Families Helping Families ™