How much is too much rent? (LONG...)

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2 3

Candy Girl
Candy girl- you are so sweet!

Member since 11/07

6349 total posts

Name:
erin

How much is too much rent? (LONG...)

I think i am just writing this to sort things out in my mind, but feedback would be nice too, so...

DH, DD and i live in a smallish rent stabalized apartment in prime Park Slope. the rent is 1470. We have already almost outgrown this apartment, but the location is so amazing, we love it so much and we do not want to move to another neighborhood. We are also in no position to buy.

The apartment is kind of old, has some nice details, but the layout is pretty bad. It;s a railroad, small bathroom, no washer or dryer in the building and limited closets.

DH's business associate told him about an apartment for rent across the street from where we live now. We went to check it out just for fun. Oh my God, it is gorgeous. Two huge bedrooms, two full baths, washer & dryer in the apartment, elevator straight to the apartment doors (only one apartment per floor), terrace, granite counters etc. in the kitchen, huge closets and storage space, our own thermostat, video intercom etc. The rent? 2700 per month. Needless to say, i want this apartment so badly.

For reasons that I won't get into right now because they are too long to explain, DH and I are unsure if we want to buy anything in the near or even distant future. We may be "city renters" for a long time--mostly due to the fact that we don't want to leave the city and can't (and may never be able to) afford to purchase anything in the neighborhoods we desire.

What would you do? Stay in the small 1470 apartment or go for the fancy 2700 apartment (may be able to rent for 2400)?

Just curious.

Posted 2/7/09 9:29 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
  |   Prudential Douglas Elliman Real Estate

MrsM-6-7-08
<3

Member since 8/06

4249 total posts

Name:
Nicole

Re: How much is too much rent? (LONG...)

If you plan on staying in the city for a long time, i'd take the more expensive apartment, why be uncomfortable, especially with a child, and having to go to the laundromat...that is a PIA

NYC real estate is so expensive
From what i have seen online a million dollars basically buys you a one bedroom one bath in nyc in a nice area.
I mean really who can afford that
A mortgage on that would be way more than the rent on the new place.

HTHChat Icon

eta: owning a home is not all its cracked up to be, and its not for everyone, just like college isn't for everyone.
I know alot of people that plan on renting indefinitely and there is nothing wrong with that.

Message edited 2009-02-07 21:39:47.767000.

Posted 2/7/09 9:34 PM
 

Jackie24
~We Did it~

Member since 7/06

6718 total posts

Name:
Jackie

Re: How much is too much rent? (LONG...)

I feel that if you love Park Slope and plan on staying there then why be uncomfortable and not truly love where you live. Can you afford the 2700 a month? If so I say go for it. Thats the going rent in NYC.

Posted 2/7/09 9:44 PM
 

Erica
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

11767 total posts

Name:

Re: How much is too much rent? (LONG...)

I don't think the rent sounds too bad...we paid $2600 for a 2br LES apartment (new apt, but crappy, "up and coming" Chat Icon neighborhood) 8 years ago.

Posted 2/7/09 10:33 PM
 

itsbabytime
LIF Adult

Member since 11/05

9644 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: How much is too much rent? (LONG...)

When we lived in the city we paid $3600 for a 690 sq ft apt - now we pay more than that to rent a house in a nice area - i think only you can answer that question!

Posted 2/7/09 11:27 PM
 

KGools
Happy

Member since 9/06

9532 total posts

Name:
Kim

Re: How much is too much rent? (LONG...)

If you can afford it and don't plan to buy anytime in the foreseeable future, why not go for it?

I wouldn't but that is because 1) we wouldn't be able to afford it, and 2) we plan to buy in the next few years and we hope that our mortgage when we do buy isn't that high.

Good luck!

Posted 2/7/09 11:34 PM
 

lovemy2boys
LIF Adult

Member since 10/07

3915 total posts

Name:

Re: How much is too much rent? (LONG...)

EEEKS!!! THat is very high for rent, If it were me, I think I would just stay put. It's more than 1000 dollars a month difference. it would be one thing if it were a mortgage, but I would try and keep my payment down as low as possible, good luck Chat Icon

Message edited 2009-02-07 23:57:10.513000.

Posted 2/7/09 11:56 PM
 

Candy Girl
Candy girl- you are so sweet!

Member since 11/07

6349 total posts

Name:
erin

Re: How much is too much rent? (LONG...)

Thanks for your responses! I didn't expect to get so many on a Saturday night! I can't stop thinking about this new apartment and I am still really torn.Chat Icon

Posted 2/8/09 12:28 AM
 

ave1024
I Took The Wrong Road

Member since 12/07

6153 total posts

Name:
That Led To The Wrong Tendencies

Re: How much is too much rent? (LONG...)

There is no such thing as "too much rent" in Park Slope.

That's one of the most desireable neighborhoods in Brooklyn, if not THE most.

Message edited 2009-02-08 02:26:13.783000.

Posted 2/8/09 2:26 AM
 

rkoenke
my little piggys

Member since 3/08

4315 total posts

Name:
rachel

Re: How much is too much rent? (LONG...)

Could you sign a longer term lease for maybe $200.00 less?
Say five year lease for $2200.00 per month? they know that they won't be searching for another, reliable, tennant, guaranteed income for five years?

do people do things like this?

Posted 2/8/09 8:51 AM
 

MrsM-6-7-08
<3

Member since 8/06

4249 total posts

Name:
Nicole

Re: How much is too much rent? (LONG...)

I did a search on craigslist and the going rate for 2 bedrooms in prime park slope is anywhere from 2700-4000 a month

It sounds like an amazing find!

Posted 2/8/09 9:09 AM
 

Sherwood
LIF Adult

Member since 8/08

1643 total posts

Name:
s

Re: How much is too much rent? (LONG...)

I'd say thats really a personal decision, if you can afford it and feel that you really want to stay in this neighborhood long term, then go for it.

But personally, I dont think I'd ever spend $2700 a month on a long-term rental....I'd keep thinking about how much of that money I'd be able to save for a down-payment or putting towards mortgage- instead of paying rent.

Message edited 2009-02-08 09:11:09.953000.

Posted 2/8/09 9:09 AM
 

Candy Girl
Candy girl- you are so sweet!

Member since 11/07

6349 total posts

Name:
erin

Re: How much is too much rent? (LONG...)

Posted by sideshowbob

I'd say thats really a personal decision, if you can afford it and feel that you really want to stay in this neighborhood long term, then go for it.

But personally, I dont think I'd ever spend $2700 a month on a long-term rental....I'd keep thinking about how much of that money I'd be able to save for a down-payment or putting towards mortgage- instead of paying rent.



See, that's the thing, we have a nice sum of money in savings, but even if we put it down on a house/condo in a neighborhood that we would like to live in, we would still have a gigantic payment--IF we even got approved. Plus the property taxes, water, maintenance charges (for a condo), heat/oil and on and one. With apartment, it's 2700 plus our basic utilities and any extras that we wish to purchase. And then, we'd have no more money in savings!

It's so hard! Chat Icon

Posted 2/8/09 10:51 AM
 

SweetestOfPeas
J'taime Paris!

Member since 3/06

32345 total posts

Name:

Re: How much is too much rent? (LONG...)

Posted by Snickers
it's 2700 plus our basic utilities and any extras that we wish to purchase. And then, we'd have no more money in savings!

It's so hard! Chat Icon

I think your 2nd to last statement says it all.

Posted 2/8/09 11:01 AM
 

TheDivineMrsM
2 girls 4 me!

Member since 8/08

7878 total posts

Name:
Mama mama mama....

Re: How much is too much rent? (LONG...)

I don't know what to tell you... IMO I'd never wipe out my savings to pay rent. Esp if you can't replace the money afterwards. In this economy, I'd be really uncomfortable w/o a "cushion" of money in an emergancy fund.

Is there a place nearby that's >2700 in rent but with a better layout than what you have now? Can you negotiate the rent a bit?

Good luck!!

Message edited 2009-02-08 11:32:53.500000.

Posted 2/8/09 11:22 AM
 

Gertyrae
Peace out Homies!

Member since 5/05

20046 total posts

Name:
Gerty ®

Re: How much is too much rent? (LONG...)

Because of the neighborhood you are staying in, I would say go for the better apartment...BUT only if you can afford it. If it's going to use up all your savings, what are you going to do after that?
If it's something you will be able to afford, but maybe not add much to your savings...then I would still do it.

And I only say this because it is a beautiful neighborhood and you won't find too many apartments at that price.

Posted 2/8/09 11:29 AM
 

Tine73

Member since 3/06

22093 total posts

Name:
*********

Re: How much is too much rent? (LONG...)

If you could afford it and your jobs are stable, then I would go for it. Have you looked at any other places in the neighborhood or is this the first one? If its the first one, I would look at a few more just to see what is out there and how it compares.

Posted 2/8/09 11:58 AM
 

babymakes3
Almost there!

Member since 7/06

7376 total posts

Name:

Re: How much is too much rent? (LONG...)

You have to determine if the pros of the new apartment is worth the difference in price. The laundry would definitely sweeten the deal for me, but I'd still be hesitant paying $1k-$1,300 a month more for that. With that difference in price, you could drop your laundry off and pick it up washed and folded at the end of the day and still have plenty of money leftover.

Once you leave your current apartment, you will never find another one at the price in that neighborhood. I dream of having a 2 bedroom for low rent in a great neighborhood.

I don't know if you are planning on having more kids, but if you are, I'd keep that money in savings in case you want to buy a house or larger condo in the future.

Posted 2/8/09 12:22 PM
 

Candy Girl
Candy girl- you are so sweet!

Member since 11/07

6349 total posts

Name:
erin

Re: How much is too much rent? (LONG...)

Posted by SweetestOfPeas

Posted by Snickers
it's 2700 plus our basic utilities and any extras that we wish to purchase. And then, we'd have no more money in savings!

It's so hard! Chat Icon

I think your 2nd to last statement says it all.



Ooops, I meant to say that if we bought a condo or co-op or house we would have no more money in savings. If we take this place, our savings will stay in tact.

Posted 2/8/09 3:48 PM
 

philsdeezy
LIF Adolescent

Member since 12/06

643 total posts

Name:
Dee

Re: How much is too much rent? (LONG...)

Keep looking, for that kind of money you can rent a house.

Posted 2/8/09 4:03 PM
 

jgl
Love my little boys!!!

Member since 8/07

7060 total posts

Name:
g

Re: How much is too much rent? (LONG...)

honestly that is not much shy of a mortgage in nassau county. personally i couldnt see spending that much to rent. but that is me, im not a city girl.
But if youplan on staying there for a long time and dont see yourself buying then it may be worth it for you

Posted 2/8/09 4:22 PM
 

Candy Girl
Candy girl- you are so sweet!

Member since 11/07

6349 total posts

Name:
erin

Re: How much is too much rent? (LONG...)

Posted by jgl

honestly that is not much shy of a mortgage in nassau county. personally i couldnt see spending that much to rent. but that is me, im not a city girl.
But if youplan on staying there for a long time and dont see yourself buying then it may be worth it for you



but what about the property taxes, oil, landscaping, and other general landscaping. We would also have to have two cars then and our commutes would suck.

Posted 2/8/09 5:00 PM
 

ave1024
I Took The Wrong Road

Member since 12/07

6153 total posts

Name:
That Led To The Wrong Tendencies

Re: How much is too much rent? (LONG...)

Posted by jgl

honestly that is not much shy of a mortgage in nassau county. personally i couldnt see spending that much to rent.




Apples and oranges. You can't compare rentals in Park Slope to mortgages in Nassau County.

Posted 2/8/09 5:24 PM
 

PeasandCarrots
&hearts;

Member since 5/07

9579 total posts

Name:
L

Re: How much is too much rent? (LONG...)

If buying a house isn't in the near future or maybe not even in the future, you can afford the nicer apartment and keep your savings I really don't see why you wouldn't do it? You're looking at this like a renter "looking" to buy a house IMHO (I know you're not but follow me on this), and what you need to do is look at this as a renter maybe renting a new place. Why would you not rent it? What are your reasons for staying in your smaller apartment? What is it about this apartment that is stopping you from saying yes? If it were meI would do it! Esp with having a baby......they only get biggerChat Icon

Posted 2/8/09 6:31 PM
 

TheDivaBrideandTeddyFrog
Leah's here!

Member since 9/07

5404 total posts

Name:
Sabrina

Re: How much is too much rent? (LONG...)

I think if you can afford it, are still putting money away for the future (since you never know what you'll want to do a couple of years down the line) and can maybe talk down the price, I think it sounds amazing..with a new child, you want comfort but the thing I stress again is if you can afford it then you deserve to be happy..enjoy!

Posted 2/8/09 6:32 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2 3
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Repost from Home board. What is "Rent to buy"? KGools 5/10/07 2 Families Helping Families ™
Would you ever rent out a friend's house if they went overseas for a couple of years? Tine73 11/12/06 14 Home
How do you guys do it???? For those who rent and pay for full time day care! lipglossjunky73 10/2/06 12 Parenting
RENT on Broadway! *edited(will sell w/out ticketmaster charge of $13.50) Cookiegobbler 2/4/06 10 Families Helping Families ™
Repost from Home-I'm looking to move, does anyone know how much small houses or cottages rent for? LFitzy79 11/25/05 0 Families Helping Families ™
uh oh...we dont have a closing date yet and our apartment is in the paper to rent! raken40 7/30/05 2 Home