How honest are you?!

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 2 [3]

Selden78
I lvoe the fall :)

Member since 6/06

3543 total posts

Name:

Re: How honest are you?!

No way you ares sooooo lucky



ont feeel bad at all

enjoy

Posted 12/30/06 3:56 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Candygrl776
LIF Adolescent

Member since 2/06

671 total posts

Name:

Re: How honest are you?!

Nah I wouldn't have said anything!
If it makes you feel any better, think about how many times people have been OVERcharged for things and didn't realize until they got home. I'm sure the cashier that overcharged a customer doesn't get the extra $$ in his or her paycheck! Enjoy your new boots!

Posted 12/30/06 4:11 PM
 

Goldi0218
My miracles!

Member since 12/05

23902 total posts

Name:
Leslie

Re: How honest are you?!

Im wondering if retailers take into account errors of this nature and just deal with it. I can imagine that they would seek retribution (or perhaps just fire)from one of their employees, if these actions were a common occurrence to easily identifiable cashiers. One mistake, during a very busy retail period, does not a criminal make.

I come from a retail family. Granted, our family business was one store, but when errors in calculation were made, whether by the clerks (who were family ONLY), salespeople or even the customers, my father chalked it up and said "Oh well." IMO mark-up is designed to cover errors as well as to generate profit. I always grew up knowing that regardless of the stink a customer makes with pricing, damaged goods or anything else, they are ALWAYS right. Sometimes retailers (of any size) have to cut their losses in order to maintain a good reputation and a decent customer base.

Message edited 2006-12-30 16:23:18.023000.

Posted 12/30/06 4:14 PM
 

debsey75
My two best friends!

Member since 11/06

5879 total posts

Name:
Debbie

Re: How honest are you?!

Posted by Beth1210

if someone gives me back too much change - I give it back

but if they ring something up wrong- I get excited

enjoy! you got a great deal and no one is going to get in trouble for that!



I agree with this as well. Dont feel bad.

Posted 12/30/06 4:24 PM
 

dpli
Daylight savings :)

Member since 5/05

13973 total posts

Name:
D

Re: How honest are you?!

I probably would have said something. To me it feels dishonest not to.

Posted 12/30/06 4:28 PM
 

Jen2999
Baby girls & beagles rock!

Member since 8/06

10356 total posts

Name:
Jen

Re: How honest are you?!

Posted by Maathy317

Posted by SweetestOfPeas

Posted by Maathy317

Posted by Jen2999

Posted by Maathy317

Posted by kbeana24

Its her mistake, not yours. You have NOTHING to feel bad about!!!!!!!!!!!



That is true, it is her mistake, not yours. However, she will have to pay for it. She will have it deducted from her salary and, runs the risk of losing her job. The store loses nothing. So while you may think you are "sticking it to the man", you are, in fact, sticking it to the sales clerk. Not saying anything, IMO, no matter what the circumstances, was, absolutely, the wrong thing to do.



See I worked in retail for MANY years and I have never ever had an experience were I had to pay out of my salary for a mistake so I find that hard to believe. I also find it hard to believe that it would even be caught being that there were 7 cashiers open all with huge lines. Yes, it COULD happen I guess, but I think what you are saying is a tad unrealistic.



I have to disagree with you. I, too, have worked in retail and I HAVE seen it done. If you did work in retail, then you know that each cashier signs on when he or she begins their shift and all trays are tallied at the end of the day. It is not all that difficult to spot that huge an error and to find out who was responsible. Even on the slim possibility that it wasn't caught, it is still theft, no matter how you justify it.

if they couldn't find the price, how will they even know how much to deduct out of her paycheck? assuming that would ever be done (which I highly doubt). Sorry, I completely disagree with you.



That is, certainly, you're right. These cash registers are hooked up to computer systems and you can go back and find a transaction from a certain period of time. The SKU number would tell you what was purchased and if the price that it was sold for doesn't match the SKU number, there is a problem. It may not happen right away, but, when inventory is done, there will be a discrepancy and it can be traced back. As I said before, I worked in retail and I was privy to this information Sooner or later an accounting must be taken and this will be discovered.



I worked in retail too. I was privvy to the same information, BUT the inventory NEVER ever matches up exatcly and the errors are usually very high up there in the thousands, if not millions if you are dealing with a large chain. Even still in the companies I worked, that type of advanced information was only looked at if there was a substantial amount of money missing or a employee was under suspect.I don't know what company you worked for, but all the the ones I worked for would never even think about searching back to find a 40 dollar error after inventory was done, usually months later. This is without even remembering that the SKU price for the item changes every week with sales and whatever else.

Im not justifying it, but I think you are blowing the situation way out of proportion.

Posted 12/30/06 5:07 PM
 

PotofLuck06
Our Baby Boy Is Here!!!

Member since 11/06

13241 total posts

Name:
Betsy

Re: How honest are you?!

When it comes to shopping deals, I don't fight the discounts (unless it's not enough), but n cases of record keeping with bills with banks, etc I'm honest if something didn't get transacted correctly. For instance, the day DH and I opened up our checking account together, they gave our account # to another person as well, so we had an extra $10k in our account that we couldn't account fo when we went home, so we called the bank and they froze both assets and we went down to the bank the following Monday to get it all straightened out.

Posted 12/30/06 5:16 PM
 

Jen2999
Baby girls & beagles rock!

Member since 8/06

10356 total posts

Name:
Jen

Re: How honest are you?!

Posted by PotofLuck06

When it comes to shopping deals, I don't fight the discounts (unless it's not enough), but n cases of record keeping with bills with banks, etc I'm honest if something didn't get transacted correctly. For instance, the day DH and I opened up our checking account together, they gave our account # to another person as well, so we had an extra $10k in our account that we couldn't account fo when we went home, so we called the bank and they froze both assets and we went down to the bank the following Monday to get it all straightened out.



OMG I definitely would have said something there!!!

Posted 12/30/06 5:19 PM
 

Maathy317
Grammie's Little Man

Member since 2/06

3235 total posts

Name:
D

Re: How honest are you?!

Posted by Jen2999

Posted by Maathy317

Posted by SweetestOfPeas

Posted by Maathy317

Posted by Jen2999

Posted by Maathy317

Posted by kbeana24

Its her mistake, not yours. You have NOTHING to feel bad about!!!!!!!!!!!



That is true, it is her mistake, not yours. However, she will have to pay for it. She will have it deducted from her salary and, runs the risk of losing her job. The store loses nothing. So while you may think you are "sticking it to the man", you are, in fact, sticking it to the sales clerk. Not saying anything, IMO, no matter what the circumstances, was, absolutely, the wrong thing to do.



See I worked in retail for MANY years and I have never ever had an experience were I had to pay out of my salary for a mistake so I find that hard to believe. I also find it hard to believe that it would even be caught being that there were 7 cashiers open all with huge lines. Yes, it COULD happen I guess, but I think what you are saying is a tad unrealistic.



I have to disagree with you. I, too, have worked in retail and I HAVE seen it done. If you did work in retail, then you know that each cashier signs on when he or she begins their shift and all trays are tallied at the end of the day. It is not all that difficult to spot that huge an error and to find out who was responsible. Even on the slim possibility that it wasn't caught, it is still theft, no matter how you justify it.

if they couldn't find the price, how will they even know how much to deduct out of her paycheck? assuming that would ever be done (which I highly doubt). Sorry, I completely disagree with you.



That is, certainly, you're right. These cash registers are hooked up to computer systems and you can go back and find a transaction from a certain period of time. The SKU number would tell you what was purchased and if the price that it was sold for doesn't match the SKU number, there is a problem. It may not happen right away, but, when inventory is done, there will be a discrepancy and it can be traced back. As I said before, I worked in retail and I was privy to this information Sooner or later an accounting must be taken and this will be discovered.



I worked in retail too. I was privvy to the same information, BUT the inventory NEVER ever matches up exatcly and the errors are usually very high up there in the thousands, if not millions if you are dealing with a large chain. Even still in the companies I worked, that type of advanced information was only looked at if there was a substantial amount of money missing or a employee was under suspect.I don't know what company you worked for, but all the the ones I worked for would never even think about searching back to find a 40 dollar error after inventory was done, usually months later. This is without even remembering that the SKU price for the item changes every week with sales and whatever else.

Im not justifying it, but I think you are blowing the situation way out of proportion.




The "situation" is about being honest. Everything else doesn't matter. If you can justify to yourself that you did the right thing, then what anyone else says is of no consequence. You have to live with yourself. I have said, and I will continue to say, that what you did was completely dishonest and if I stand alone, so be it.

Posted 12/30/06 5:59 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: How honest are you?!

For the record, an employer CANNOT deduct cashier mistakes from a paycheck. That's a Department of Labor law.

Posted 12/30/06 6:04 PM
 

Jen2999
Baby girls & beagles rock!

Member since 8/06

10356 total posts

Name:
Jen

Re: How honest are you?!

Posted by Maathy317

Posted by Jen2999

Posted by Maathy317

Posted by SweetestOfPeas

Posted by Maathy317

Posted by Jen2999

Posted by Maathy317

Posted by kbeana24

Its her mistake, not yours. You have NOTHING to feel bad about!!!!!!!!!!!



That is true, it is her mistake, not yours. However, she will have to pay for it. She will have it deducted from her salary and, runs the risk of losing her job. The store loses nothing. So while you may think you are "sticking it to the man", you are, in fact, sticking it to the sales clerk. Not saying anything, IMO, no matter what the circumstances, was, absolutely, the wrong thing to do.



See I worked in retail for MANY years and I have never ever had an experience were I had to pay out of my salary for a mistake so I find that hard to believe. I also find it hard to believe that it would even be caught being that there were 7 cashiers open all with huge lines. Yes, it COULD happen I guess, but I think what you are saying is a tad unrealistic.



I have to disagree with you. I, too, have worked in retail and I HAVE seen it done. If you did work in retail, then you know that each cashier signs on when he or she begins their shift and all trays are tallied at the end of the day. It is not all that difficult to spot that huge an error and to find out who was responsible. Even on the slim possibility that it wasn't caught, it is still theft, no matter how you justify it.

if they couldn't find the price, how will they even know how much to deduct out of her paycheck? assuming that would ever be done (which I highly doubt). Sorry, I completely disagree with you.



That is, certainly, you're right. These cash registers are hooked up to computer systems and you can go back and find a transaction from a certain period of time. The SKU number would tell you what was purchased and if the price that it was sold for doesn't match the SKU number, there is a problem. It may not happen right away, but, when inventory is done, there will be a discrepancy and it can be traced back. As I said before, I worked in retail and I was privy to this information Sooner or later an accounting must be taken and this will be discovered.



I worked in retail too. I was privvy to the same information, BUT the inventory NEVER ever matches up exatcly and the errors are usually very high up there in the thousands, if not millions if you are dealing with a large chain. Even still in the companies I worked, that type of advanced information was only looked at if there was a substantial amount of money missing or a employee was under suspect.I don't know what company you worked for, but all the the ones I worked for would never even think about searching back to find a 40 dollar error after inventory was done, usually months later. This is without even remembering that the SKU price for the item changes every week with sales and whatever else.

Im not justifying it, but I think you are blowing the situation way out of proportion.




The "situation" is about being honest. Everything else doesn't matter. If you can justify to yourself that you did the right thing, then what anyone else says is of no consequence. You have to live with yourself. I have said, and I will continue to say, that what you did was completely dishonest and if I stand alone, so be it.



I am AGREEING with you that it was dishonest. I never said it was the RIGHT thing to do or that I was NOT being dishonest. But to go and say I am a thief and that the cashier is going to be punished by being fired or taking money from her is a little extreme and honestly if I were her I wouldn't want to work for such a cut throat company anyway.

I guess I better stop eating grapes on line at the supermarket tooChat Icon

Posted 12/30/06 6:35 PM
 

Maathy317
Grammie's Little Man

Member since 2/06

3235 total posts

Name:
D

Re: How honest are you?!

Posted by Jen2999

Posted by Maathy317

Posted by Jen2999

Posted by Maathy317

Posted by SweetestOfPeas

Posted by Maathy317

Posted by Jen2999

Posted by Maathy317

Posted by kbeana24

Its her mistake, not yours. You have NOTHING to feel bad about!!!!!!!!!!!



That is true, it is her mistake, not yours. However, she will have to pay for it. She will have it deducted from her salary and, runs the risk of losing her job. The store loses nothing. So while you may think you are "sticking it to the man", you are, in fact, sticking it to the sales clerk. Not saying anything, IMO, no matter what the circumstances, was, absolutely, the wrong thing to do.



See I worked in retail for MANY years and I have never ever had an experience were I had to pay out of my salary for a mistake so I find that hard to believe. I also find it hard to believe that it would even be caught being that there were 7 cashiers open all with huge lines. Yes, it COULD happen I guess, but I think what you are saying is a tad unrealistic.



I have to disagree with you. I, too, have worked in retail and I HAVE seen it done. If you did work in retail, then you know that each cashier signs on when he or she begins their shift and all trays are tallied at the end of the day. It is not all that difficult to spot that huge an error and to find out who was responsible. Even on the slim possibility that it wasn't caught, it is still theft, no matter how you justify it.

if they couldn't find the price, how will they even know how much to deduct out of her paycheck? assuming that would ever be done (which I highly doubt). Sorry, I completely disagree with you.



That is, certainly, you're right. These cash registers are hooked up to computer systems and you can go back and find a transaction from a certain period of time. The SKU number would tell you what was purchased and if the price that it was sold for doesn't match the SKU number, there is a problem. It may not happen right away, but, when inventory is done, there will be a discrepancy and it can be traced back. As I said before, I worked in retail and I was privy to this information Sooner or later an accounting must be taken and this will be discovered.



I worked in retail too. I was privvy to the same information, BUT the inventory NEVER ever matches up exatcly and the errors are usually very high up there in the thousands, if not millions if you are dealing with a large chain. Even still in the companies I worked, that type of advanced information was only looked at if there was a substantial amount of money missing or a employee was under suspect.I don't know what company you worked for, but all the the ones I worked for would never even think about searching back to find a 40 dollar error after inventory was done, usually months later. This is without even remembering that the SKU price for the item changes every week with sales and whatever else.

Im not justifying it, but I think you are blowing the situation way out of proportion.




The "situation" is about being honest. Everything else doesn't matter. If you can justify to yourself that you did the right thing, then what anyone else says is of no consequence. You have to live with yourself. I have said, and I will continue to say, that what you did was completely dishonest and if I stand alone, so be it.



I am AGREEING with you that it was dishonest. I never said it was the RIGHT thing to do or that I was NOT being dishonest. But to go and say I am a thief and that the cashier is going to be punished by being fired or taking money from her is a little extreme and honestly if I were her I wouldn't want to work for such a cut throat company anyway.

I guess I better stop eating grapes on line at the supermarket tooChat Icon



Maybe you should.

Posted 12/30/06 6:43 PM
 

saraH
happy birthday sweet kate!

Member since 5/05

16555 total posts

Name:
I know that God exsists, I held her in my arms...

Re: How honest are you?!

i don't think i would have said anything. and the odds of her losing her job over a slight error are low. and chances are, its not the first time thats happened.

i've worked retail as well and have never had money taken out of my check for a error on the register.

Message edited 2006-12-31 16:56:40.953000.

Posted 12/30/06 6:47 PM
 

lucyloo
nope

Member since 1/06

9758 total posts

Name:

Re: How honest are you?!

Posted by Jax430

Posted by neenie

if it were a mom and pop shop, i wouldve said something. I don't feel bad for the big chain stores.



Agreed!




Yup

Posted 12/30/06 10:27 PM
 

nyteacher13
Three Under Four!!! :-)

Member since 8/06

6405 total posts

Name:
~ THERESA ~

Re: How honest are you?!

Posted by -Laurie-

If Lost Prevention or a Manager looks over the transactions she will get fired most likely. Money is money be it change or giving an extra discount but on the other hand you telling on her could get her fired as well.

I would just figure out the EXTRA amount you saved and donate it to charity or give it in your weekly tithe at church. I figure it balances out that way!



You MUST be Italian with that guilt trip!!! You sound like my very Italian mother when she gives me incessent guilt trips... hehehehehe Chat Icon

Seriously though, I'm sure there will be consequences for that 70% discount!

Posted 12/31/06 1:42 AM
 
Pages: 1 2 [3]
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
. MABLE03 7/25/06 11 Parenting
do you like these names at all? be honest KAS 4/6/06 20 Pregnancy
OK, I need honest opinions. Am I wrong? (VERY long) Scotty-CassidysMom 1/8/06 9 Families Helping Families ™
Only respond if you will be honest with me! Vent about my SIL ** Warning this is LONG! AJsMommy122 8/12/05 11 Families Helping Families ™
aww this is a nice story - Honest man tracks down rightful owner of money -DonnaMarie- 3/16/06 8 Families Helping Families ™
Need honest opinions....Please read! ladybug78 3/14/06 14 Home