How do you discipline your 1 year old?

Posted By Message

Daisy32
Mommy

Member since 2/08

8081 total posts

Name:

How do you discipline your 1 year old?

I've been meaning to ask this question. What kind of discipline works for your 1 yr old? Luckily DS is pretty good but he's starting to act up a little (ie pulling hair, throwing food). I tell him NO very firmly but he ends up laughing at me...he thinks its the funniest thing. I always keep a straight face but he still laughs. I dont think time out will work yet (though I fully intend on incorporating that one day) because I really think he's too little to understand to sit still in one spot...and I dont want to put him in his crib as punishment b/c I dont want to to associate it as a "bad" place. So I'm kind of at a loss as to what works. What do you find works the best?

Posted 7/20/11 12:28 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

LoveyQ
Stalkers, get a life.

Member since 11/07

12820 total posts

Name:

Re: How do you discipline your 1 year old?

I don't really know what works best, but I do pretty much the same thing you do. DS is at the stage where he KNOWS what no means and certain things he shouldn't do, but he tests me. For example, he'll go behind the sofa and I tell him No. He will literally go over, wait until I look over at him, then lifts his leg and slowly steps to go behind the sofa. Sometimes it's all I can do to not smile or bust out laughing at him. I find that ignoring him is effective, but the thing is that I HAVE to look over at him to make sure he's not actually doing something bad or dangerous and he's just waiting for me to look over! Chat Icon lol

I tell him no, and explain why not to do something. Then I DISTRACT DISTRACT DISTRACT. That seems to work best right now.

Posted 7/20/11 12:34 PM
 

NervousNell
Just another chapter in life..

Member since 11/09

54921 total posts

Name:
..being a mommy and being a wife!

Re: How do you discipline your 1 year old?

I think it's really hard to discipline a 1 year old because they just don't get it yet, kwim?

I will tell her NO (like 400 times a day!), divert her, distract her etc.

But I really don't think she gets it yet...

Posted 7/20/11 12:35 PM
 

ko123
My loves!

Member since 10/07

3002 total posts

Name:
Kristin

Re: How do you discipline your 1 year old?

I'm in the same boat. I try the firm "No" as well. If she throws her food (which usually happens when she is full and just can't communicate that) I say "We don't throw our food, mealtime is over now." When she throws her toys (our biggest issue right now) I say, "We don't throw toys, we throw balls" and hand her a ball. (I think I sound ridiculous but I have been told this "redirecting" strategy works.) When she is doing something that could REALLY endanger herself or someone else, she gets a very firm "NO" (ie...going near outlets, stove, etc). Other than that I don't think she will understand real discipline at 13 months.

Posted 7/20/11 12:38 PM
 

GioiaMia
Let's Go Rangers!

Member since 1/07

14818 total posts

Name:

Re: How do you discipline your 1 year old?

At 11 months, I have to stop using NO because she shakes her finger back at me! Chat Icon

I have started just redirecting and if it doesnt work I will walk away and she cries and follows me.

I have slapped her hand for doing things like playing with an outlet or almost touching a hot stove. She JUST started crying when I do this (trust me, not b/c it hurts) she used to just slap her own hand after Chat Icon

I am in BIG trouble

Posted 7/20/11 12:42 PM
 

cheryl28
LIF Adult

Member since 2/10

4657 total posts

Name:

Re: How do you discipline your 1 year old?

I tell her "no" firmly. I also redirect her attention. I do a "timeout" by making her sit down ( for the 1 second she will) but she gets pretty upset by that so I think she knows it's bad, kwim?

I do my best to explain it to her, or make her do nice and tell her no hitting nice only, and making her rub my face or whatever she did. It's so hard but they will understand so enough.

For throwig the food I taught her all done by waving her hands, (kind of clapping( and she does that when she's all done and it has lessened the amount of food that goes on the floor. Or if shes not listening to that I will take her out and she's done eating.

Posted 7/20/11 12:45 PM
 

GioiaMia
Let's Go Rangers!

Member since 1/07

14818 total posts

Name:

Re: How do you discipline your 1 year old?

OH for throwing food - I give it back to her ONCE and then if she does it again I tell her NO MORE and put it in the little cup holder for her high chair tray - now she puts her food there when she is done Chat Icon

Posted 7/20/11 12:47 PM
 

Ian&EmmesMommy23
My family is complete!

Member since 11/08

12970 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: How do you discipline your 1 year old?

i do the no and then i threaten with time out. i've been doing this since about 1 year and it works.

I say if you do that one more time you go in time out. at the beginning he would do it again. so i have gates and a small chair. i set it up against a wall where these is no outlet or toys in reach. i sit him on the chair for 1 minute. (1 minute per year) before i put him in i explain why hes going in time out. when the minute is done and hes crying, we hug to calm him down and i tell him again why he was in time out and then we kiss.

now at almost 2 if i said, do you want time out? he'll say no and stop. but if he does need time out he'll walk in himself and sit down and says he's sorry when hes done. and we hug and kiss it out. Chat Icon

Posted 7/20/11 1:00 PM
 

mommyIam

Member since 7/09

9209 total posts

Name:
Shana

Re: How do you discipline your 1 year old?

This is what works for us. I know it sounds like a lot of talking, but I swear DS understands everything perfectly. From what I've seen around babies his age, mom's don't give them enough credit for understanding what they do.

First acknowledge why they are doing it, are they frustrated? tired? teething? "I can see you are frustrated" "I know your teeth hurt"
They usually act out when they need to express and can't express. Help them express their feelings. Its turns DS around like a switch.

Give another option to express their behavior
We don't do xyz, but we can do abc or 123.
"I will not let you hit me, but you can hit this pillow, or you can bang on the drum" Giving them an option gives them control over their environment, while keeping them within your rules.

Praise good behavior, but not just to their face, but to a 3rd person. Sometimes when its just us 2, I will tell him bunny "Bunny, did you know, Noah can bang the drum so good, he does such a good job!"
This has a much stronger affect because it eliminates the embarrassment factor. DS responds to this so well, and particularly when I tell DH. He so wants to please his daddy.

They get embarrassed, they can feel shamed, they can feel guilty, and they can empathize. I have not done Time Outs.

I am "almost" against time outs. I don't think they work and I think they shame the child into behaving instead of giving them the tools to behave. While it may work for some, I feel it doesn't teach the values I want to teach.

I say "almost" because just don't have enough experience to know whats best forever, I just know this is working. DS is a dream and has been since I started talking to him and expecting that he'd understand at 8-9m.


We also practice listening, waiting, practice gentle behaviors, I make games of it. So when we are somewhere and an adult is talking to me, and DS just wants attention I can say "Noah, I know you need something, but you have to wait, I'm listening to Linda." And usually the Lindas of the world, always is stunned and says something a long the lines of "wow, he's so patient and well behaved" its like a gold star, he's so pleased with himself.


It doesn't work, I resort to the next stage. I stop whatever I'm doing, get to his eye level. Make it deathly serious that he listen to me. Ask him to please show me his eyes and look at me. I tell him, "I will not let him have the behavior he's having, but I will listen to him, and try to understand him" I may hold on to him, I may carry him and put him somewhere else. for example "hold my hand on the street, or I will put you in the stroller" "if you throw that toy, I will take it away"

Screaming... is very normal for us, especially when teeth are cutting. I act confused and say "I'm listening, but I don't understand screaming" I don't ignore, I pay attention to it, as if there is an encoded message but do nothing and act nothing but confused. It gets a different reaction every time, but at least the reaction isn't more screaming.
I usually have to reiterate, "I'm really listening!" the best thing he does is calm down and try to verbally tell me in his way, or he'll try to point to it. But I don't ask him to point because I don't want to tell him what to do when he's frustrated, I want to give him the power of trying to figure it out for himself what he needs to do.

I learned a lot of what I know from Janet Lansbury, she wrote no books or sells anything, she just writes a parenting blog.

Here are some relevant articles:

Toddler Testing - 3 Steps to End the Nightmare

Free as a Dog - Parenting with Calm Control

Baby Discipline - Person to Person

Toddler Discipline without Shame


eta:

pulling hair
grab his hand, when you pull my hair, it hurts me. I will not let you hurt me. Hold his hand for a second and say, you can play with the toy dog's hair, or you can rip this paper if you want.

throwing food

hold his hand, "I do not want you to throw food" I take away all the food, and put back 1. You can put the food on the table (its adjacent to the high chair) or you can put it in this cup. I don't put too much on his tray, and then just replace what he eats. He tells me all done, when he's done, and up when he's ready to get out. If your DC isn't talking yet, you can teach them a sign.



Message edited 2011-07-20 13:34:07.353000.

Posted 7/20/11 1:27 PM
 

Daisy32
Mommy

Member since 2/08

8081 total posts

Name:

Re: How do you discipline your 1 year old?

Posted by mommyIam

This is what works for us. I know it sounds like a lot of talking, but I swear DS understands everything perfectly. From what I've seen around babies his age, mom's don't give them enough credit for understanding what they do.

First acknowledge why they are doing it, are they frustrated? tired? teething? "I can see you are frustrated" "I know your teeth hurt"
They usually act out when they need to express and can't express. Help them express their feelings. Its turns DS around like a switch.

Give another option to express their behavior
We don't do xyz, but we can do abc or 123.
"I will not let you hit me, but you can hit this pillow, or you can bang on the drum" Giving them an option gives them control over their environment, while keeping them within your rules.

Praise good behavior, but not just to their face, but to a 3rd person. Sometimes when its just us 2, I will tell him bunny "Bunny, did you know, Noah can bang the drum so good, he does such a good job!"
This has a much stronger affect because it eliminates the embarrassment factor. DS responds to this so well, and particularly when I tell DH. He so wants to please his daddy.

They get embarrassed, they can feel shamed, they can feel guilty, and they can empathize. I have not done Time Outs.

I am "almost" against time outs. I don't think they work and I think they shame the child into behaving instead of giving them the tools to behave. While it may work for some, I feel it doesn't teach the values I want to teach.

I say "almost" because just don't have enough experience to know whats best forever, I just know this is working. DS is a dream and has been since I started talking to him and expecting that he'd understand at 8-9m.


We also practice listening, waiting, practice gentle behaviors, I make games of it. So when we are somewhere and an adult is talking to me, and DS just wants attention I can say "Noah, I know you need something, but you have to wait, I'm listening to Linda." And usually the Lindas of the world, always is stunned and says something a long the lines of "wow, he's so patient and well behaved" its like a gold star, he's so pleased with himself.


It doesn't work, I resort to the next stage. I stop whatever I'm doing, get to his eye level. Make it deathly serious that he listen to me. Ask him to please show me his eyes and look at me. I tell him, "I will not let him have the behavior he's having, but I will listen to him, and try to understand him" I may hold on to him, I may carry him and put him somewhere else. for example "hold my hand on the street, or I will put you in the stroller" "if you throw that toy, I will take it away"

Screaming... is very normal for us, especially when teeth are cutting. I act confused and say "I'm listening, but I don't understand screaming" I don't ignore, I pay attention to it, as if there is an encoded message but do nothing and act nothing but confused. It gets a different reaction every time, but at least the reaction isn't more screaming.
I usually have to reiterate, "I'm really listening!" the best thing he does is calm down and try to verbally tell me in his way, or he'll try to point to it. But I don't ask him to point because I don't want to tell him what to do when he's frustrated, I want to give him the power of trying to figure it out for himself what he needs to do.

I learned a lot of what I know from Janet Lansbury, she wrote no books or sells anything, she just writes a parenting blog.

Here are some relevant articles:

Toddler Testing - 3 Steps to End the Nightmare

Free as a Dog - Parenting with Calm Control

Baby Discipline - Person to Person

Toddler Discipline without Shame


eta:

pulling hair
grab his hand, when you pull my hair, it hurts me. I will not let you hurt me. Hold his hand for a second and say, you can play with the toy dog's hair, or you can rip this paper if you want.

throwing food

hold his hand, "I do not want you to throw food" I take away all the food, and put back 1. You can put the food on the table (its adjacent to the high chair) or you can put it in this cup. I don't put too much on his tray, and then just replace what he eats. He tells me all done, when he's done, and up when he's ready to get out. If your DC isn't talking yet, you can teach them a sign.






I can totally see this working on a 3 or 4 year old but my DS is only a year old. I honestly cannot see him comprehending a lot of this.

Posted 7/20/11 1:56 PM
 

Ang-Rich
Beyond Compare

Member since 5/05

17988 total posts

Name:

Re: How do you discipline your 1 year old?

I do the same thing that I did with my first child at that age:

Redirect his attention

Minimize my reaction to his behavior - especially laughing but that's sometimes hard

Show him other ways to handle his feelings/reactions/actions


Above all...I try to be consistent


ETA: with the throwing food

My rule is: you throw it and you lose it. I take it all away...same with toys.



Message edited 2011-07-20 14:05:58.817000.

Posted 7/20/11 2:04 PM
 

mommyIam

Member since 7/09

9209 total posts

Name:
Shana

Re: How do you discipline your 1 year old?

Posted by ShaunsMommy

Posted by mommyIam

...




I can totally see this working on a 3 or 4 year old but my DS is only a year old. I honestly cannot see him comprehending a lot of this.



I KNOW! Trust me I KNOW! I thought this way. I felt like I was talking out of my butt, and it was almost as if one day, serveral days later, it clicked. AND can you believe I tried this stuff on an 8 month old? AND it was working even then!!!

He was pulling 1 year old tantrums on me. And it worked and I was stunned and shocked for weeks. At 16m I'm grateful that he was such a little crazy monster at 8m, because I learned so much for now.

I can only say, try it for a while, really, I have told other moms to try and they look at me like I have 5 heads. I keep getting the "he wont understand" line I don't care, it works this good, I have to put it out there and dare others to try it.

Or even better line "your just really lucky with a such a well behaved baby" Chat Icon No way, I worked for this!

Posted 7/20/11 2:10 PM
 

MaMaTeenie
Party of 5

Member since 4/08

6489 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: How do you discipline your 1 year old?

I started time-out around that age with both of my kids. Worked great with DS, I will let you know about DD Chat Icon They don't really get it right away, but imo its like sleep training, if you wait til age 2 to start it will be a heck of a lot harder than if you start early. Don't expect him to sit yet. Give him a warning. If he does it again put him in the spot. Same spot all the time (unless you are out). Tell him you need to sit in time out because you hit mommy, we don't hit" or something like that. Then go about your business. As he starts to get it you require that he stay in the spot. When he gets out of time out you say you were in time out because you hit mommy. Give him a hug and send him on his way. Don't reward him with too much attention or he may end up wanting to go in time out to get the reward kwim?

Posted 7/20/11 3:30 PM
 

MamaLeen
:)

Member since 10/09

4594 total posts

Name:
E

Re: How do you discipline your 1 year old?

I don't have much experience yet. What has worked so far is to say no. He 100% understands what no means and now he will sometimes stop if I just shake my head no. Another thing I do is warn him and then follow through. I am consistent and do the same thing each time.

For example his new thing is to take a sip from his sippy and let the water fall out of his mouth onto his shirt. Chat Icon He thinks it is hysterical. Anyway, I tell him no we don't do that with the sippy cup, if you do it again I will take it away. If he does it again, I take it away. He understands and he will stop the behavior. I will give it back to him in a couple of minutes and let him try again. If he continues to do it I will take it away for good.

He might not understand every word I am saying but he understands Mommy does not like when I do that and she takes away my cup. I agree with PP that is is similar to sleep training, I guess I am preparing for the years ahead. Chat Icon The scary thing is that this is the easy part and it is only going to get more intense. Chat Icon

Oh and I can't believe that your beautiful boy would ever misbehave! Chat Icon Chat Icon

ETS: another thing I have pushed for months now is to do "nice", which is petting or patting softly. So when he would bite me or hit me I would say no we do nice and then take his hand and make him pet me, lol. I also do this when he is around animals because I obviously don't want him to be rough. This is a key thing that helps in a ton of situations. Whenever he is rough I tell him to do nice and he (mostly) does. He actually pets me all of the time now. Chat Icon

Message edited 2011-07-20 15:45:56.310000.

Posted 7/20/11 3:41 PM
 

Daisy32
Mommy

Member since 2/08

8081 total posts

Name:

Re: How do you discipline your 1 year old?

Posted by IansMommy23

but if he does need time out he'll walk in himself and sit down and says he's sorry when hes done. and we hug and kiss it out. Chat Icon



ssssigh....I heart Ian Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 7/21/11 9:12 AM
 

Daisy32
Mommy

Member since 2/08

8081 total posts

Name:

Re: How do you discipline your 1 year old?

Posted by MamaLeen

Oh and I can't believe that your beautiful boy would ever misbehave! Chat Icon Chat Icon




Awwww thanks E!!! You're such a dollChat Icon Chat Icon

And thank you everyone else for all your suggestions...it was all very helpful Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Message edited 2011-07-21 09:14:18.230000.

Posted 7/21/11 9:13 AM
 

Ian&EmmesMommy23
My family is complete!

Member since 11/08

12970 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: How do you discipline your 1 year old?

Posted by ShaunsMommy

Posted by IansMommy23

but if he does need time out he'll walk in himself and sit down and says he's sorry when hes done. and we hug and kiss it out. Chat Icon



ssssigh....I heart Ian Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon



you wouldnt if you saw his temper tantrums. Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

actually...he's still pretty cute even when he's lying face first kicking his legs. he's got a cute butt Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Message edited 2011-07-21 09:22:22.313000.

Posted 7/21/11 9:22 AM
 

Daisy32
Mommy

Member since 2/08

8081 total posts

Name:

Re: How do you discipline your 1 year old?

Posted by IansMommy23

actually...he's still pretty cute even when he's lying face first kicking his legs. he's got a cute butt Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon



LMAO I just spit out my coffee!! LMAO!!!Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 7/21/11 9:38 AM
 

gck0708
She is love!

Member since 11/08

1863 total posts

Name:
Grace

Re: How do you discipline your 1 year old?

I logged in to write this EXACT original post. My daughter literally starts crying and comes for hugs when DH tells her "No" in his 'firm' voice. When I tell her no she laughs and keeps repeating the action i'm trying to get her to stop.

It's SOOO frustrating. I don't know what to do either.

The other thing she does is when I try to change her diaper - which she hates - she kicks and tries to hit. I tell her "no we do not hit/kick" and she either laughs or just keeps going. Honestly I don't know what to do with her. She's seriously independent, so I know that's not helping, but normally she is a sweet and well behaved girl.

Posted 7/22/11 9:20 AM
 

Daisy32
Mommy

Member since 2/08

8081 total posts

Name:

Re: How do you discipline your 1 year old?

Posted by gck0708

I logged in to write this EXACT original post. My daughter literally starts crying and comes for hugs when DH tells her "No" in his 'firm' voice. When I tell her no she laughs and keeps repeating the action i'm trying to get her to stop.

It's SOOO frustrating. I don't know what to do either.

The other thing she does is when I try to change her diaper - which she hates - she kicks and tries to hit. I tell her "no we do not hit/kick" and she either laughs or just keeps going. Honestly I don't know what to do with her. She's seriously independent, so I know that's not helping, but normally she is a sweet and well behaved girl.


Yes!!! I feel your pain. I just dont understand what the laughing is about Chat Icon I do the same thing as you with the stern NO...I tell him "NO!! We dont throw food!!" or I tell him "NO!! We dont pull Mommy's hair" but he thinks its the funniest thing Chat Icon I have to say though the last few days I've been continuing the stern "NO" and he's starting to NOT laugh.....yesterday he actually started to get upset...which to me is better than laughing Chat Icon I think that the others are right...repetition is key. Its just such a fine line because they are still babies so its hard to determine what they really understand.
Hey keep me updated if you find anything that you find to work really well Chat Icon

Posted 7/22/11 9:45 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Can anyone offer advice on how to discipline my "spirited" 2 year old? jenny 7/27/10 8 Parenting
Discipline for a one year old - is it possible? -Lisa- 8/1/07 11 Parenting
Discipline and 3.5 year old. itsbabytime 4/6/11 7 Parenting
Take me through your successful "discipline" routine/strategies for your 1 year old (past or present) Bri 8/11/10 12 Parenting
Crasher: Needs advice/Autistic 5 year old & discipline FreeButterfly 5/7/10 1 Children With Special Needs
Discipline for 1 year old mcl916 10/4/09 9 Parenting