Re: How do you discipline your 1 year old?
Posted 7/20/2011 1:56:17 PM by Daisy32
Posted by mommyIam
This is what works for us. I know it sounds like a lot of talking, but I swear DS understands everything perfectly. From what I've seen around babies his age, mom's don't give them enough credit for understanding what they do.
First acknowledge why they are doing it, are they frustrated? tired? teething? "I can see you are frustrated" "I know your teeth hurt" They usually act out when they need to express and can't express. Help them express their feelings. Its turns DS around like a switch.
Give another option to express their behavior We don't do xyz, but we can do abc or 123. "I will not let you hit me, but you can hit this pillow, or you can bang on the drum" Giving them an option gives them control over their environment, while keeping them within your rules.
Praise good behavior, but not just to their face, but to a 3rd person. Sometimes when its just us 2, I will tell him bunny "Bunny, did you know, Noah can bang the drum so good, he does such a good job!" This has a much stronger affect because it eliminates the embarrassment factor. DS responds to this so well, and particularly when I tell DH. He so wants to please his daddy.
They get embarrassed, they can feel shamed, they can feel guilty, and they can empathize. I have not done Time Outs.
I am "almost" against time outs. I don't think they work and I think they shame the child into behaving instead of giving them the tools to behave. While it may work for some, I feel it doesn't teach the values I want to teach.
I say "almost" because just don't have enough experience to know whats best forever, I just know this is working. DS is a dream and has been since I started talking to him and expecting that he'd understand at 8-9m.
We also practice listening, waiting, practice gentle behaviors, I make games of it. So when we are somewhere and an adult is talking to me, and DS just wants attention I can say "Noah, I know you need something, but you have to wait, I'm listening to Linda." And usually the Lindas of the world, always is stunned and says something a long the lines of "wow, he's so patient and well behaved" its like a gold star, he's so pleased with himself.
It doesn't work, I resort to the next stage. I stop whatever I'm doing, get to his eye level. Make it deathly serious that he listen to me. Ask him to please show me his eyes and look at me. I tell him, "I will not let him have the behavior he's having, but I will listen to him, and try to understand him" I may hold on to him, I may carry him and put him somewhere else. for example "hold my hand on the street, or I will put you in the stroller" "if you throw that toy, I will take it away"
Screaming... is very normal for us, especially when teeth are cutting. I act confused and say "I'm listening, but I don't understand screaming" I don't ignore, I pay attention to it, as if there is an encoded message but do nothing and act nothing but confused. It gets a different reaction every time, but at least the reaction isn't more screaming. I usually have to reiterate, "I'm really listening!" the best thing he does is calm down and try to verbally tell me in his way, or he'll try to point to it. But I don't ask him to point because I don't want to tell him what to do when he's frustrated, I want to give him the power of trying to figure it out for himself what he needs to do.
I learned a lot of what I know from Janet Lansbury, she wrote no books or sells anything, she just writes a parenting blog.
Here are some relevant articles:
Toddler Testing - 3 Steps to End the Nightmare
Free as a Dog - Parenting with Calm Control
Baby Discipline - Person to Person
Toddler Discipline without Shame
eta:
pulling hair grab his hand, when you pull my hair, it hurts me. I will not let you hurt me. Hold his hand for a second and say, you can play with the toy dog's hair, or you can rip this paper if you want.
throwing food
hold his hand, "I do not want you to throw food" I take away all the food, and put back 1. You can put the food on the table (its adjacent to the high chair) or you can put it in this cup. I don't put too much on his tray, and then just replace what he eats. He tells me all done, when he's done, and up when he's ready to get out. If your DC isn't talking yet, you can teach them a sign.
I can totally see this working on a 3 or 4 year old but my DS is only a year old. I honestly cannot see him comprehending a lot of this.
|