Honest opinions please

Posted By Message

spa118
LIF Adult

Member since 3/09

2157 total posts

Name:
Shari

Honest opinions please

Hi girls, I know this is going to be long, so I apologize in advance.

I don't know if I'm crazy or over protective or over reacting, but let me tell you this situation with FIL and I would love to hear what you think. Please don't qote, I'll probably remove it.

DH's parents divorced when he was 8 and had shared custody of him. They lived a couple of blocks from each other, and had an amicable relationship. His mom died when he was 18. Chat Icon

FIL loves DH and DH's brother so much. He is one of those people who is so cheap, but has a lot of $. He never spends $ on himself, but helped ALOT with our wedding, buying our home, and college fund for DD.

He's a little odd - single older man (almost 70), and he's been lonely. He has a girlfriend, but DH thinks he's just with her for company. He's also had a drinking problem. We believed he was a functioning alcoholic. He has an important job and does it, but he always carried a water bottle full of vodka in his briefcase.
He's become drunk and embarrassing at family functions.

Both DH and his brother talked to him numerous times in the past about his drinking, but nothing helps. Before DD was born, DH had a long talk with him about his drinking, and said that if he continues like he is, he will never be able to hold her, etc. He had offered to babysit, and DH told him that we didn't trust him to babysit.

There was one occasion when he came over after he had been drinking. It made me very uncomfortable. DH had a long talk with him, and FIL said that he didn't think he was drunk and that he had a couple of drinks hours earlier. DH told him that from now on, ABSOLUTELY NO DRINKING anywhere near DD. For the past 3 months, he has abided by this. We don't serve wine with dinner anymore when he's over, and he's been sober every time he's come over. I now let him hold and feed DD. She's 4 months old.

Now, there's a new thing..... and I find this odd. I wanted to give you the whole background, so now you can make an opinion on this.

About a month ago, after he fed her, I said "Ok, she needs to be changed now" and I took her from FIL. He offered to do it, and I said, "Thanks, that's OK, I'll do it". I didn't think anything of it at the time, but then later I thought it was odd that he wanted to change her diaper.
I let it go though.
Well, last night, was DH's birthday. FIL, BIL and SIL were over and I made dinner. After dinner, DH was feeding Maya. FIL wanted to burp her, even though she didn't need to be burped. I joking around said "Oh grandpa just wants to hold Maya" and he said "Of course I do" and he wasn't drinking and it was fine for him to hold her.
Then he said "I want to change her. I haven't got to do that yet." I didn't answer him, but grabbed DH and told him privately that I thought it was weird, and that we are going to change her alone and do the bedtime routine. He didn't think it was weird, but we did change her alone.

So... thank you for making it this far. I don't know why, but I do not want FIL changing her diaper. I think its odd that he wants to, and that may be why I don't want him to. DH thinks he just wants to help, to learn how to take care of her, but I just find it odd. That's a chore most men pass off, isn't it? He never had a daughter, he never changed a girl's diaper, and it just bothers me. What do you think? Do you find it odd?
It reminds me a little of the post a while back about someone wanting to nap with the baby. I don't think it is as strange, but yet it bothers me that he wants to change her, that he point out said "I want to changer her, I haven't done that yet."

Thanks again for making it this far. Honest opinions please. Chat Icon

Posted 4/29/10 10:30 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

beachgirl
LIF Adult

Member since 7/05

7967 total posts

Name:
sara

Re: Honest opinions please

To be honest I dont think its weird based on what you said. I think your DH is right and your FIL wants to be involved and maybe thinks changing diapers is something he should offer to do. Because you feel uncomfortable though I would just pass it off if he asks again.

Now if he were to persist on asking to change her I would find it weird and would say something.

Posted 4/29/10 10:33 AM
 

BethanyLynn
Love these munchkins

Member since 10/09

6295 total posts

Name:
Bethany

Re: Honest opinions please

I dont think its weird. Maybe hes trying to help out...if he persistently asks, like PP said, that would be weird. Glad to hear he is not drinking...I have gone through the same thing..so Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 4/29/10 10:36 AM
 

jerseypanda
Life is good.

Member since 1/07

9164 total posts

Name:
Amanda

Re: Honest opinions please

My opinion... based on the information presented, I don't think it is strange at all.

I think he is trying to be a part of everything with your DD. When he first asked to change her, he had fed her and you said she needed to be changed, so since he was holding her it seems only natural that he would offer to do it. I wouldn't think twice about it and think it's nice that he wants to help.

I will say that I think each person is different. My dad would not hesitate to hold, feed, play with, change a diaper for either of my kids (and I have a boy and a girl) I am no less comfortable with him doing things for my DS than I am for my DD. My FIL on the other hand is not as hands on. He doesn't get down on the floor and play with DS like my dad does. I would be surprised if he asked to change a diaper, but not because I was worried about anything... just because he has never asked in 2.5 years! Chat Icon

So to answer your question, I don't think it's strange at all. I think it would be strange if he never wanted to hold the baby or feed her and then suddenly all he wanted to do was change her. But he seems to be a willing participant in everything for her so to me it seems very normal.

Posted 4/29/10 10:40 AM
 

CrankyPants
I'm cranky

Member since 7/06

18178 total posts

Name:
Mama Cranky

Re: Honest opinions please

I don't think it's weird-my FIL changed DDs diaper when she was a newborn. He just wanted to be helpful.

Posted 4/29/10 10:44 AM
 

maybeamommy
Blessed beyond belief

Member since 10/07

17048 total posts

Name:

Re: Honest opinions please

I agree - as PPs said, with the information you gave, it doesn't really strike me as being weird.

BUT - if it makes you uncomfortable, that is what matters!

Posted 4/29/10 10:46 AM
 

TwoGirls4Me
Treasure what you have

Member since 5/05

1839 total posts

Name:
Marie

Re: Honest opinions please

Posted by beachgirl

To be honest I dont think its weird based on what you said. I think your DH is right and your FIL wants to be involved and maybe thinks changing diapers is something he should offer to do. Because you feel uncomfortable though I would just pass it off if he asks again.

Now if he were to persist on asking to change her I would find it weird and would say something.






I agree... I dont think its odd but if he were to keep hounding you about it then it would be weird.

I think its sweet... maybe he feels he missed out on having a daughter, or changing diapers, etc.

Babies are so amazing and bring such joy to peoples lives. She is probably filling that void in his life. For him to not drink when he knows he is going to be around her, especially if he truly is an alcoholic which it sounds like he is... he obviously adores her and wants to spend time with her.

I do agree that you can never be too careful though and can see why you think its weird.

Posted 4/29/10 10:48 AM
 

MAC222
LIF Adult

Member since 12/08

3860 total posts

Name:

Re: Honest opinions please

My sis-in-law LOVES to change diapers...weird, but she does..she always asks if he needs to be changed....

It sounds to me that FIL is trying to show you that he wants to be helpful regardless of the task at hand..even if it includes a diaper change...

But, keep in mind, that YOU are uncomfortable...and even if everyone on here tell you that they don't think it's strange, you still do, and none of us know him, etc...so go with your gut, and if you are still uncomfy with it, talk more with DH...

Posted 4/29/10 10:52 AM
 

spa118
LIF Adult

Member since 3/09

2157 total posts

Name:
Shari

Re: Honest opinions please

Thanks girls.
I really don't think he's a pedophile or anything like that, he does love Maya so much, and he wants to be a part of her life.
I also think he's jealous of my mom who gets to babysit.
BUT, for some intangible reason, it just bothered me that he asked about it 2x.
I think he might be upset that I'm not letting him do it, so now its turning into a thing that he might mention again.
Maybe next time I'll let him, but watch - do you think that would be OK?

Posted 4/29/10 10:52 AM
 

nferrandi
too excited for words

Member since 10/05

18538 total posts

Name:
Nicole

Re: Honest opinions please

I honestly don't see an issue. Would you be weird about it if you had a son instead of a daughter? If not, then there's your answer.

Posted 4/29/10 10:59 AM
 

kerrycec03
Mom of 2 beautiful boys!!

Member since 6/06

13519 total posts

Name:
Kerry

Re: Honest opinions please

Posted by beachgirl

To be honest I dont think its weird based on what you said. I think your DH is right and your FIL wants to be involved and maybe thinks changing diapers is something he should offer to do. Because you feel uncomfortable though I would just pass it off if he asks again.

Now if he were to persist on asking to change her I would find it weird and would say something.





ditto. I don't find it weird at all and I think he just wants to help and be involved. It seems like he's being a great grandpa to the fulliest!

Posted 4/29/10 11:06 AM
 

1stimemom
Love my boys

Member since 2/08

8766 total posts

Name:
Mrs Dee

Re: Honest opinions please

I don't think it is weird. Next time, let him change her, but stay with him. I bet he is just trying to regain trust ans respect.Chat Icon

Posted 4/29/10 11:17 AM
 

DanandNette
Love my baby boy!

Member since 9/08

2830 total posts

Name:
Jennette

Re: Honest opinions please

It sounds like he wants to show you he can take care of her He fed her, can burp her, etc.

But .... I would say go with your gut, if it makes you uneasy, just keep insisting that you or your DH do it. Chat Icon Your feelings might change, but until then do what you're comfortable with.

Message edited 2010-04-29 11:25:14.773000.

Posted 4/29/10 11:23 AM
 

Janice
Sweet Jessie Quinn

Member since 5/05

27567 total posts

Name:
Janice

Re: Honest opinions please

odd man out here...i think it is weird.

but i am nutty with this thing.

i would change her diaper, come back to room and hand him changed baby without pjs on and ask him to put them on.

Posted 4/29/10 11:24 AM
 

Peainapod
Peanuts are here!

Member since 1/09

13591 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: Honest opinions please

my father never changed any of our diapers as kids, so i would be shocked if he ever changed DS's. he even joked that maybe he should try since he never did with us, but then was like "nahhh..., i'll leave that one alone."

i dont think its weird. i think you're just more uncomfortable with the fact that he has a drinking problem and may act inappopriately? I do see where you are coming from considering his history. I dont think its weird that a grandpa wants to change a diaper, but i can see why you would not be ok with it.

is there a way you can do it together with you watching and make him feel like he's a part of diaper changing routine?

Message edited 2010-04-29 11:32:42.290000.

Posted 4/29/10 11:31 AM
 

LoriH
There's no place like home

Member since 8/07

4110 total posts

Name:
Lori

Re: Honest opinions please

It doesn't sound odd from what you wrote but you were the one there when he said. If you aren't sure about it, maybe go with him. Joke that you want to be there for backup because she can have explosive diapers or something like that.

Posted 4/29/10 11:38 AM
 

mommyIam

Member since 7/09

9209 total posts

Name:
Shana

Re: Honest opinions please

I think with infants there is so little you can do with them, that sometimes diaper changes are a kind of play time. With DS (7 weeks) it starts with crying. When the diapers comes off he stops and gives me a look. Then when he's all clean and dry he smiles and coos.

We chat though the whole thing, and talk about which sesame street character is on the diaper. I show it to him, I think he looks at it. I wipe down his hands and feet, and tickle a little, nibble on toes, etc etc.

Anyway, its so rewarding, considering he's sleeping, eating, crying or fussing much of the day otherwise.

Like other people said, its about your comfort level, and if you can be there, as backup, that's not a bad idea for your piece of mind.

Message edited 2010-04-29 11:42:25.323000.

Posted 4/29/10 11:41 AM
 

eddiesmommy
best buds!

Member since 5/09

11524 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Honest opinions please

I dont think its strange at all. Both my dad and my FIL have changed DS diaper. I think he just wants to be involved.

Posted 4/29/10 12:00 PM
 

Michelle1123
Baby #5 on the way!

Member since 9/05

7919 total posts

Name:

Re: Honest opinions please

I dnt think its weird at all. My f-i-l offers to change both my kids when we are at their house.

Posted 4/29/10 12:05 PM
 

Xelindrya
Mommy's little YouTube Star!

Member since 8/05

14470 total posts

Name:
Veronica

Re: Honest opinions please

I dont think its weird at all.

My husband never was shy about changing her. Neither was my father.

For us its a badge of honor.. I changed the baby (at least when they are that young) Its always "Hey i changed your poopy diaper young lady/man" I still tease my kid brothers and sisters.

I'm sorry but I think you may be overreacting just a lil bit.

I'd prolly watch him change her ONLY to see that he does it right. I am not one to assume anything err... "unappropriate" of people asking to help until I've seen them in action. I apologize if I am reading this wrong but you seem to me to be leaning towards suggesting sexual inappropriate behavior. Chat Icon

A drunk is one thing.. a preditor is another. The most scary sexual prediator is the 'nice' guy next door type. I don't think its 100% (tho slightly) fair to put alcohol and inability to care of a child into the same catagory.

Sorry. You did ask honest opinions. I think you need to let him help. If nothing else it may grow a bond and in turn help him want to stay sober. Like I said, though, I'd prolly watch him but only cause I'm such a stickler for proper changes. I do that with EVERYONE even btdt moms.

Message edited 2010-04-29 12:23:38.430000.

Posted 4/29/10 12:22 PM
 

computergirl
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

3118 total posts

Name:

Re: Honest opinions please

I don't think it's weird. My dad has volunteered to change diapers with both my kids (boy and girl). I know that he sees it as both helping me with a chore and also bonding/taking care of the baby.

(Ironically, my mom has never ever changed either one of my kids' diapers. She totally hands-off. My dad is so much more the "nurturing" one of my parents)

Would you feel differently about this if he didn't have a drinking problem?

Posted 4/29/10 12:32 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Honest opinions please

To answer the question - yes, from my own experience it is a chore most PEOPLE (not just men) pass off.

I'm not saying he's a predator or anything is amiss, but if you feel it's strange, I'd say go with your gut. You're in charge of changing.

Posted 4/29/10 12:33 PM
 

OOSMommy
LIF Adolescent

Member since 10/09

860 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Honest opinions please

If something is making you uncomfortable, don't ignore it. It doesn't mean that he's a pedophile, it just means that your mommy instinct is telling you something isn't 100% right with the situation.

It does sound like he's trying to be helpful, but on the off chance it was something else you would never forgive yourself.

Maybe if it comes up again you can let him change her, but you go with him and do something else in her room while he's doing it - put away laundry, change her crib sheet, something, so that you're in the room but not necessarily standing over him supervising. If after that, he never brings it up again, then that's that, but if he continues to ask to change her, I would think that is a little weird.

JMO.

Posted 4/29/10 12:41 PM
 

spa118
LIF Adult

Member since 3/09

2157 total posts

Name:
Shari

Re: Honest opinions please

Thank you everyone. I really appreciate all the thoughtful and honest opinions.

Its just an odd feeling I get, and I don't know why.
I don't know if it has anything to do with the drinking, I just wanted to give as much background as possible.

I really did want the honesty, and I do appreciate it. Its very interesting to see how someone on the outside sees it.

Posted 4/29/10 1:07 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Honest opinions on my hair please!! UPDATED: I DID IT!!! Jax430 10/29/07 38 Fashion & Beauty!
Need honest opinions... WR! KGools 10/26/07 20 Fashion & Beauty!
Etiquette Question Re: Shower/Sprinkle.. NEed HONEST opinions Please! LuvMy2Girls 4/17/07 21 Pregnancy
gym question, you can be honest just looking for opinions.. Janice 3/25/07 19 Parenting
Need honest opinions about these suffolk south shore school districts? MrsKellyBride 3/7/07 3 Home
What Do You Think? Honest Opinions Pls! bikramaddict 2/19/07 20 Home