Holiday Gift Giving

Posted By Message

JennCo
My greatest joy is my baby boy

Member since 1/07

2772 total posts

Name:

Holiday Gift Giving

I'm in a debate with my DH about how his family is handling holiday gifts for the kids. They prefer to give the kids cash as gifts it seems and I find that so cold and lazy. Wanted to know your thoughts.

BIL family have kids that are 14, 13 and 10

SIL family has kids that are 10, 8,6 and 4

I have a 4 yr old and a 2 yr old.

Last year BIL And SIL decided this and just handed out cash meanwhile I walked in with gifts for each kid to open while my toddlers stood there and cried not understanding why they only got a card. Granted there was cash in it, but it's hard when your 3 yr old is handing out gifts to his cousins and they hand him a card in return.

This year it seems like it's going to go down the same way with the cash gifts. WWYD? My DH just says go with it, it makes our lives easier. Do I just go along with it even though I disagree or speak up?

Posted 12/4/14 1:55 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

luvbuffet
LIF Adult

Member since 7/10

6470 total posts

Name:

Re: Holiday Gift Giving

just tell your kid that you will take them shopping with the cash they give you. "they wanted to make your christmas extra special, so they are giving you money to pick out your own toy" take half to spend and the other half in the bank. im not a parent , but I think thats what I would do

Posted 12/4/14 1:58 PM
 

JennCo
My greatest joy is my baby boy

Member since 1/07

2772 total posts

Name:

Re: Holiday Gift Giving

Posted by luvbuffet

just tell your kid that you will take them shopping with the cash they give you. "they wanted to make your christmas extra special, so they are giving you money to pick out your own toy" take half to spend and the other half in the bank. im not a parent , but I think thats what I would do



Yes, that is exactly what we did last year. He got it and he was fine.

I just think though that this whole situation is weird. I mean, my 88 grandma goes to the $1 store to buy a toy...it's just silly to exchange cash. Maybe it's just me...

Posted 12/4/14 2:10 PM
 

MrsD121011
LIF Adult

Member since 5/12

1460 total posts

Name:
Elicia

Holiday Gift Giving

What we ended up doing in our family many years ago is the parents would pick up gifts for thier own kids put the aunts and uncle names on it and then the adults would exchange cash to cover the gifts. Seems silly at first but the parents knew what the kids wanted/needed and at the end of the day everyone had something to open and everyone left happy.

Posted 12/4/14 2:19 PM
 

beachgirl
LIF Adult

Member since 7/05

7967 total posts

Name:
sara

Re: Holiday Gift Giving

Honestly i would love it!1 I would much prefer that my kids get to choose something they like and want than something they have already or really dont want. I suspect your BIL whose youngest child is 10 might not know what the best gift would be for your younger kids.

I would build it up as in they are going to go shopping the next day and choose their own gift.

I would not say anything and go with it and tell your kids to smile and say thanks.

Posted 12/4/14 2:25 PM
 

cupcakegal
LIF Infant

Member since 3/14

155 total posts

Name:

Holiday Gift Giving

You could just also bring 2 small gifts wrapped gifts with you and give it to your children to unwrap when the cousins are unwrapping as well. I know not the greatest answer but at least they won't feel to to left when the other kids are opening gifts. Can you suggest that they buy a Toys r us gift card rather than cash for your kids so they can see they can go shopping with it?? Just suggestions.. I always feel like cash for kids is cold as well..

Posted 12/4/14 2:28 PM
 

MarisaK
HELLO Manolo !!

Member since 5/06

14562 total posts

Name:
Marisa

Re: Holiday Gift Giving

I would have been annoyed last year because you were left out of the loop and your kids were upset .......but going forward, just go with it. It makes YOUR life SO SO much easier.....you don't end up w/ a ton of extra junk in your house, and your kids can pick out what they want

Posted 12/4/14 2:31 PM
 

MrsO
Big Brothers to Be

Member since 1/07

4521 total posts

Name:
Maureen

Re: Holiday Gift Giving

I think the little ones should defiantly get something to open. This period is such a short time in their lives for the excitement of opening a present. Even if is just something small and the monetary gift is a supplement.

Posted 12/4/14 2:33 PM
 

MrsD121011
LIF Adult

Member since 5/12

1460 total posts

Name:
Elicia

Re: Holiday Gift Giving

Posted by MrsO

I think the little ones should defiantly get something to open. This period is such a short time in their lives for the excitement of opening a present. Even if is just something small and the monetary gift is a supplement.

Chat Icon

Posted 12/4/14 2:41 PM
 

stinger
LIF Adult

Member since 11/11

4971 total posts

Name:

Re: Holiday Gift Giving

Posted by MrsO

I think the little ones should defiantly get something to open. This period is such a short time in their lives for the excitement of opening a present. Even if is just something small and the monetary gift is a supplement.



Agree. I think up until around 8 yo toys and "stuff" is nice. However, as a parent I would rather see them get gift cards and cash as they get older. Toys and plastic junk end up sitting around. My 11 yo wants more expensive clothes and electronics now. She could use cash to pay for these things.

Posted 12/4/14 2:43 PM
 

alli3131
Peanut is here!!!!!!

Member since 5/09

18388 total posts

Name:
Allison

Holiday Gift Giving

I would rather cash. My DS gets tons of gifts from others that the last thing we need in another toy. Cash is put in his account and saved. While he may not understand for the immediate time but would forget after a few minutes when he is playing with something else.

Posted 12/4/14 3:11 PM
 

mrs717
LIF Infant

Member since 7/10

124 total posts

Name:

Holiday Gift Giving

I think its weird that you basically exchange Cash with eachother. Whats the point?? while as the parent, you may enjoy cash for the kids, at that age, half the fun for them is opening the gift. At least something small to open wiht the money would be better

Posted 12/4/14 4:19 PM
 

PregowithTwins
My boys turned 8

Member since 5/11

2451 total posts

Name:

Re: Holiday Gift Giving

Posted by mrs717

I think its weird that you basically exchange Cash with eachother. Whats the point?? while as the parent, you may enjoy cash for the kids, at that age, half the fun for them is opening the gift. At least something small to open wiht the money would be better



I agree with this. Does she give money because hard to fiqure what to get kids? Maybe you both should create a list for each other with 3 items.

Posted 12/4/14 8:34 PM
 

queensgal
Smile

Member since 4/09

3287 total posts

Name:

Re: Holiday Gift Giving

I see your point and find this odd also. I mean for the older teens fine but if you all walk in with 100 bucks split into 3 cards what is the point?

But I feel this way about gift cards. Sometimes yes they make a lot if sense and yes I do give and receive. But we stopped doing sibling gifts as we wound up just handing each other a 50 card or whatever. Seemed silly. And in your situation with kids, to me seems to defeat the purpose of gift giving.

But people seem very different on this view. I start thinking months in advance and planning, observing, asking. To me, that is the whole point- the thinking and effort. I think I have come up with some awesome and unique ideas over the years, tailored and specific to the person receiving. But many people are fine with the cash or gift card purchased day of.

Posted 12/4/14 8:46 PM
 

Mags1227
Just a mommy ...

Member since 10/10

2665 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Holiday Gift Giving

DHs family gives cash for all special occasions. No card, just cash in an envelope.
At first, i found it weird. Now, i appreciate it. Makes me life easier and i can use it towards something i actually want. SOOO much better than the "gifts" they think are appropriate (my 2 year old got an erector set for his birthday once. it's still sitting in his closet unopened as it is beyond his 4 year old abilities)

I would just get two small gifts for the kids and give it to them to open.

Posted 12/5/14 6:35 AM
 

KarenK122
The Journey is the Destination

Member since 5/05

4431 total posts

Name:
Karen

Holiday Gift Giving

I think you need to sit down with your family and decide on how you want to give gifts. I think every child should have a box to open. If you are just passing cash around then why even do it. Now that some of the kids in our family are preteens, we do do gift cards but it is always supplemented with a small gift so they have something to open.

Posted 12/5/14 8:42 AM
 

jams92

Member since 1/12

6105 total posts

Name:

Holiday Gift Giving

my family all gives cash - but they give the parents the amount. for example i was told my kids are each getting $150 in cash...its up to me to either buy presents for them to open at our celebration or keep the cash and take them shopping at a later date. i got a few small thigns for them to open and the rest of their cash goes into their bank account

i personally love this. so much easier then having to make a list of what they want or have to deal with returns for items we dont want/need.

Posted 12/5/14 8:50 AM
 

JDubs
different, not less

Member since 7/09

13160 total posts

Name:

Re: Holiday Gift Giving

Posted by alli3131

I would rather cash. My DS gets tons of gifts from others that the last thing we need in another toy. Cash is put in his account and saved. While he may not understand for the immediate time but would forget after a few minutes when he is playing with something else.



This. My MIL always gives cash and I love when she does, we put it straight into his account. He already has a ton of toys.

Posted 12/5/14 9:02 AM
 

bunnyluck
LIF Adult

Member since 1/14

3196 total posts

Name:

Holiday Gift Giving

I personally wouldn't say anything unless asked. My BIL is the opposite, their kids are trained to ask for cash for college, lol. These kids have so many toys, their basement is a plastic jungle. I'd rather give cash lol

Message edited 2014-12-05 09:14:35.913000.

Posted 12/5/14 9:14 AM
 

BaysideForever
LIF Adult

Member since 1/11

9976 total posts

Name:

Re: Holiday Gift Giving

I see your point. For the little ones, it is hard for them to understand. That being said, I'd prefer cash anyway. So either bring a gift for your child in addition (save one for this time period) so he has something to "open" and play with... and just tell him they gave you money, now you can pick something you want at the store (or whatever you feel comfortable with).

Posted 12/5/14 11:57 AM
 

WannaBeAMom11
LIF Adult

Member since 1/11

7391 total posts

Name:
Name

Holiday Gift Giving

If they give cash I'd give cash. Yes it's cold but I know dd would be really upset if other kids wereally getting toys and she wasn't.

Posted 12/5/14 12:05 PM
 

summerBaby10
let's be nice

Member since 9/07

10208 total posts

Name:
Wifey

Re: Holiday Gift Giving

Oh man, I would LOVE that so much!
DH's side always end up getting the kids so much junky toys that they don't even like most of the time. They end up being a waste of money. If we received all cash, I would take a portion of it & let them pick a few things out for themselves & save the rest.

If your child is feeling left out, I think it's a great idea to bring a gift for your child to open there.

Message edited 2014-12-05 12:15:17.373000.

Posted 12/5/14 12:13 PM
 

twicethefun
Loving life

Member since 7/06

4088 total posts

Name:

Re: Holiday Gift Giving

SO after years of finding their kids gifts, now its their turn and they won't put the effort in. That would really upset me. IMO they could make an age limit for gift buying and money gifting. I guess when their kids are too old to accept money, than your kids are done too. I'm sorry but that just stinks for you.

Posted 12/5/14 11:22 PM
 

Mrs213
????????

Member since 2/09

18986 total posts

Name:

Re: Holiday Gift Giving

Posted by mrs717

I think its weird that you basically exchange Cash with eachother. Whats the point?? while as the parent, you may enjoy cash for the kids, at that age, half the fun for them is opening the gift. At least something small to open wiht the money would be better



I agree, you're just exchanging cash?? No fun

Posted 12/5/14 11:34 PM
 

butterfly20
Party of 5 - 2015

Member since 4/06

7390 total posts

Name:

Holiday Gift Giving

ask them if its they dont have time to buy gifts can they tell you the amount and you will buy them and wrap them for your kids and they can give you the cash.

If they want cash for their kids then just get them gift cards.

Posted 12/6/14 1:49 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Is it lame to get a pre-school teacher a gift card for a holiday gift? johnsae 12/13/10 15 Parenting
Let's talk holiday gift giving!!! MissJones 9/23/06 14 Families Helping Families ™
Holiday Gift Suggestions Jacquie 11/30/05 3 Families Helping Families ™
Holiday gift suggestion? missus-hbradio 11/29/05 10 Families Helping Families ™
dh got part of my holiday gift today bklyngirl 11/19/05 10 Families Helping Families ™
Holiday Family Gift Giving Arrangements Blazesyth 10/26/05 15 Families Helping Families ™