Hmm, this could start something....

Posted By Message

sumlynmad
...bonds...

Member since 4/07

2080 total posts

Name:
Summer

Hmm, this could start something....

well, after a long struggle within mySELF, i have decided that i am not doing the whole santa thing with hannah....i know, i know, i must be so coldhearted to take something like this away, or to not even introduce it.... i want her to know about Christmas, whos birthday it is, etc etc, not make it commercialized or anything.....like how it has become...my thoughts are- i want her to believe in God, believe in Jesus- that even though He you cant see Him, He is there....now, why introduce something like the Easter bunny and Santa, to get her to believe in something thats not there (when eventually shell learn that they are not real), and then im still supposed to have her believe me about God?

anyway, im sharing this bc i was wondering who else may or may not do santa/bunny, and do u do it for religious reason or otherwise....??

Posted 10/16/08 3:31 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

monkeybride
My Everything

Member since 5/05

20541 total posts

Name:

Re: Hmm, this could start something....

While we do the whole Santa, Easter bunny thing I can understand your point of view. If you're religious both of those holidays real meaning has definitely gotten lost in the secular part of the holiday.
You have to do what's right for your family.

Posted 10/16/08 3:33 PM
 

littlejoy06
Love

Member since 3/07

6944 total posts

Name:

Re: Hmm, this could start something....

I can understand your decision totally.

I will introduce her to Santa and the Easter bunny because I feel that it is something magical and this is how I was brought up. I did find out at an early age that they were not real, but I want my DD to share the experience I had.

Of course I WILL teach her the true meaning of Christmas and she will know her religion, but I just want her to have some imagination too.

Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 10/16/08 3:37 PM
 

JTK
my 4 boys!

Member since 6/06

7396 total posts

Name:
Kristi

Re: Hmm, this could start something....

Posted by sumlynmad

well, after a long struggle within mySELF, i have decided that i am not doing the whole santa thing with hannah....i know, i know, i must be so coldhearted to take something like this away, or to not even introduce it.... i want her to know about Christmas, whos birthday it is, etc etc, not make it commercialized or anything.....like how it has become...my thoughts are- i want her to believe in God, believe in Jesus- that even though He you cant see Him, He is there....now, why introduce something like the Easter bunny and Santa, to get her to believe in something thats not there (when eventually shell learn that they are not real), and then im still supposed to have her believe me about God?

anyway, im sharing this bc i was wondering who else may or may not do santa/bunny, and do u do it for religious reason or otherwise....??



a friend of mine did the exact same thing for the exact same reason. I don't think it's a bad idea.

Posted 10/16/08 3:37 PM
 

dandr10199
Grace is growing up too fast!

Member since 10/05

11561 total posts

Name:
Dina

Re: Hmm, this could start something....

Posted by littlejoy06

I can understand your decision totally.

I will introduce her to Santa and the Easter bunny because I feel that it is something magical and this is how I was brought up. I did find out at an early age that they were not real, but I want my DD to share the experience I had.

Of course I WILL teach her the true meaning of Christmas and she will know her religion, but I just want her to have some imagination too.

Chat Icon Chat Icon



ITA. I am a Christian and struggled with this as well. We are doing the Santa and easter bunny thing and explaining to her how these traditions got started. Also she will know the true meaning of both holidays.

I really struggled with Easter more as I feel it is the most important holiday for Christians.

I admire your decision. Chat Icon

Posted 10/16/08 5:30 PM
 

chelle
It's a Good Life

Member since 8/06

15404 total posts

Name:
Isn't it obvious?

Re: Hmm, this could start something....

Posted by littlejoy06

I can understand your decision totally.

I will introduce her to Santa and the Easter bunny because I feel that it is something magical and this is how I was brought up. I did find out at an early age that they were not real, but I want my DD to share the experience I had.

Of course I WILL teach her the true meaning of Christmas and she will know her religion, but I just want her to have some imagination too.

Chat Icon Chat Icon



I completely agree.

My question to you is this....what will she in turn tell the other kids? Chat Icon

Posted 10/16/08 5:47 PM
 

Xelindrya
Mommy's little YouTube Star!

Member since 8/05

14470 total posts

Name:
Veronica

Re: Hmm, this could start something....

Well I'd love to do the same..
I'd like to know how you deal with the public displays and other children.

Both my hubby and I would rather that Arianna not believe in Santa and the Bunny.

We were thinking of treating them like visiting cartoon characters with no real importance or meaning except that they only show up during these two seasons, just like you only get snow in the winter and flowers in the spring. *shrug*

We are still working out the details.. I'd hate AJ to show up at school and tell them "But Santa isn't real you know" and then we'd get hate mail from other parents/school. *Shrug*

Good Luck! and yes, I applaud you too! Chat Icon

Posted 10/16/08 6:28 PM
 

JTK
my 4 boys!

Member since 6/06

7396 total posts

Name:
Kristi

Re: Hmm, this could start something....

don't worry about what they will tell other kids.. plenty of kids don't celebrate.. Johovahs' witnesses, jewish kids ect. my kids come home every year and say so and so told me there is no santa. i would just tell them the truth that some people tell their kids that they exsist like a fairy tale and not to ruin it for other kids.

Posted 10/16/08 6:31 PM
 

nancy6485
So in love

Member since 10/05

3363 total posts

Name:
Nancy

Re: Hmm, this could start something....

Posted by littlejoy06

I can understand your decision totally.

I will introduce her to Santa and the Easter bunny because I feel that it is something magical and this is how I was brought up. I did find out at an early age that they were not real, but I want my DD to share the experience I had.

Of course I WILL teach her the true meaning of Christmas and she will know her religion, but I just want her to have some imagination too.

Chat Icon Chat Icon



i completely agree!

Posted 10/16/08 6:35 PM
 

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: Hmm, this could start something....

Well, I defiantely see where you are coming from. But I just feel like Santa is a very innocent thing, I mean, most kids stop believing at what, 7, 8 years old?

I am not religious, I was not raised in a religious household, but we still believed in Santa and I have some great memories of reading the notes "he" left for us, getting the cookies and milk and celery ready with my dad for the reigndeerChat Icon

I guess I don't see Santa as being commercializedChat Icon

Posted 10/16/08 6:40 PM
 

NS1976
My princess!

Member since 5/05

6548 total posts

Name:

Re: Hmm, this could start something....

Posted by littlejoy06

I can understand your decision totally.

I will introduce her to Santa and the Easter bunny because I feel that it is something magical and this is how I was brought up. I did find out at an early age that they were not real, but I want my DD to share the experience I had.

Of course I WILL teach her the true meaning of Christmas and she will know her religion, but I just want her to have some imagination too.

Chat Icon Chat Icon



I totally agree as well!

Posted 10/16/08 6:59 PM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: Hmm, this could start something....

I totally understand where you are coming and we will teach Emerson the true meaning behind the holidays and she will got to religion class too as we did BUT we're totally on board with Santa and the Easter Bunny. I just think it's SO magical, especially Santa and Xmas, and some of my best memories as a child center around the holidays and not just because of the gifts but because of all the traditions with my family. The traditional baking get together's, the decorating, the coming home and having hot cocoa after picking out the perfect tree on a cold night, the anticipation of Santa coming, etc. I think it's such a sweet time in your childhood to believe in Santa and the Easter Bunny and I personally would not want to take that away from my daughter. I want her to have the same wonderful memories as me. Chat Icon

Message edited 2008-10-16 19:09:22.680000.

Posted 10/16/08 7:08 PM
 

MrsGmomof3
...

Member since 6/08

3290 total posts

Name:
Irrelevant

Re: Hmm, this could start something....

Posted by KateDevine

Well, I defiantely see where you are coming from. But I just feel like Santa is a very innocent thing, I mean, most kids stop believing at what, 7, 8 years old?

I am not religious, I was not raised in a religious household, but we still believed in Santa and I have some great memories of reading the notes "he" left for us, getting the cookies and milk and celery ready with my dad for the reigndeerChat Icon

I guess I don't see Santa as being commercializedChat Icon



I agree completely. I really do not think that Santa is "commercial". I think that its innocent enough. My sons religious classes talk about Santa (he is 5 yrs. old). They do "St. Nick" in my other sons preschool. To me, its all part of the magic of Christmas. We make a big deal every year of buying gifts for a family off the "Giving Tree" at my sons preschool too.

However, Its totally your decision (obviously!) and you have to do what is right for your family.

Posted 10/16/08 7:09 PM
 

HillW9608
Hello Summer!

Member since 5/08

5916 total posts

Name:
Hill

Re: Hmm, this could start something....

I dont think there is anything wrong with it. I was told at a young age there was no Santa and such, because my mother had become a Jehovahs Witness.

So in turn, I WANT Kaila to believe. I feel like kids get such joy out of all that and since I didnt really have it, I want her too. Dont get me wrong, my father and I celebrated together but it wasnt the same. To me, it is important that she thinks Santas comming on Christmas morning, it makes me happy Chat Icon

Posted 10/16/08 7:11 PM
 

EmmaNick
*

Member since 12/06

16001 total posts

Name:
*

Re: Hmm, this could start something....

Commercial to me is valentines day, mother's day, father's day, bosses day, admin asst. day, etc. I don't think of Santa as commercial and you can have a happy medium of your child knowing the "meaning" behind christmas and still having santa.

Posted 10/16/08 7:13 PM
 

sometimesmommy
Always in my heart.....

Member since 11/06

6686 total posts

Name:

Re: Hmm, this could start something....

Posted by Summerrluvv

Commercial to me is valentines day, mother's day, father's day, bosses day, admin asst. day, etc. I don't think of Santa as commercial and you can have a happy medium of your child knowing the "meaning" behind christmas and still having santa.


I agree with this. We will do Santa but I also want my girls to understand the meaning behind it. Also with our older DD we have explained that "ONE" gift comes from Santa and the others are mommy and daddy and whoever else. They also will donate toys close to Xmas in order to get new toys to encourage them to be givers and not just takers.

Posted 10/16/08 7:30 PM
 

KristinasMama
How did she turn 2 so quickly?

Member since 10/07

8257 total posts

Name:
Blessed Mama of Kristina Elena

Re: Hmm, this could start something....

What are you talking about.... Santa totally exists!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Chat Icon Chat Icon

I will teach Kristina Santa, but since we're Greek Orthodox, we don't do the Easter Bunny.

Posted 10/16/08 7:30 PM
 

dooodles
When you wish upon a star

Member since 5/05

11997 total posts

Name:
Because 2 people fell in love

Re: Hmm, this could start something....

I had a long discussion with my BFF about this. I loved having Santa in my memories from my childhood and Christmas is one of my favorite holidays - I just couldn't do it when I would be too disappointed myself not to.

My BFF was raised to not believe in Santa because of the same reasons you list. I asked her what she would do if/when she has children and she is leaning towards rasiing them the same way. It's what she knows and grew up with.

Posted 10/16/08 7:34 PM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Hmm, this could start something....

I grew up with both side by side. I knew what Christmas was and why it existed and we had Santa. It was a festive time bringing both the birth of Jesus and Santa bringing toys to all children celebrating this joyous day. It was not just about Santa. It was the spirit of the whole time of the season.

It was the same for Easter. It was a religious day and we celebrated with chocolate eggs.

I think you can do both together without just the commercial aspect.

Christmas is really the only holiday/time I cannot live without and do celebrate. I have fond memories of it. I do want DS to have those memories.

I do plan on telling DS why there is Christmas and Easter and why we celebrate those days. Then Santa will come and bring joy like Jesus did.

Posted 10/16/08 7:41 PM
 

Diana1215
Living on a prayer!!!

Member since 10/05

29450 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: Hmm, this could start something....

I agree with the others. I still remember driving home from my grandparents house on Christmas Eve and looking out the window trying to find Santa. I remember hearing every little noise and looking out the window. To a young child - that is magic. It gives them something to believe in that they can understand at a young age.

Now, to see the looks on my nieces/nephews faces when my uncles dresses up like Santa - absolutely priceless. My niece - at 7 knew it was my uncle dressed up - but she didn't ruin it for the younger ones.

To me - these holidays create wonderful memories with family. I will teach my son the meaning behind Christmas - of course -- but I still get excited to come downstairs on Christmas morning -- I cannot wait to share that with my son.

But, to each his own....you don't want to do Santa and the Easter Bunny - that's your choice!

Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 10/16/08 7:52 PM
 

MelToddJulia
Love my Family!

Member since 7/05

29064 total posts

Name:
Mel

Re: Hmm, this could start something....

Posted by monkeybride

While we do the whole Santa, Easter bunny thing I can understand your point of view. If you're religious both of those holidays real meaning has definitely gotten lost in the secular part of the holiday.
You have to do what's right for your family.




ITA!!

Posted 10/16/08 7:54 PM
 

lvdolphins
My Loves!

Member since 5/05

46292 total posts

Name:

Re: Hmm, this could start something....

Posted by littlejoy06

I can understand your decision totally.

I will introduce her to Santa and the Easter bunny because I feel that it is something magical and this is how I was brought up. I did find out at an early age that they were not real, but I want my DD to share the experience I had.

Of course I WILL teach her the true meaning of Christmas and she will know her religion, but I just want her to have some imagination too.

Chat Icon Chat Icon



ITA!

Posted 10/16/08 7:56 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Hmm, this could start something....

Posted by littlejoy06

I can understand your decision totally.

I will introduce her to Santa and the Easter bunny because I feel that it is something magical and this is how I was brought up. I did find out at an early age that they were not real, but I want my DD to share the experience I had.

Of course I WILL teach her the true meaning of Christmas and she will know her religion, but I just want her to have some imagination too.

Chat Icon Chat Icon



I completely agree. Of course, my kids believe in leprachauns too...

My feeling is that time of year is magical with or without the idea of Santa Claus. Do whatever you feel is right in your heart for your family.


Chat Icon

Posted 10/16/08 8:00 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Hmm, would YOU trust this face? (warning, if you thought the runaway bride had "fun" eyes...) Shorty 6/8/05 21 Families Helping Families ™
HMM Not sure if I am ovulating lulugrrl 7/28/06 4 TTC
Hmm, overbooking myself much? VirginiaDeb 6/27/06 7 Families Helping Families ™
hmm what to do today? Blondie805 5/7/06 2 Families Helping Families ™
TMI TMI TMI..hmm NS1976 12/9/05 2 TTC
Hmm..christmas party question CowgirlChick97 12/1/05 1 Families Helping Families ™