Having dinner with a married man
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: 1 [2] 3 4 | |
|
Re: Having dinner with a married man Posted by anonttcer Not weird at all. Almost all my friends are male. And married. As long as it's a strictly platonic relationship, It is no different than having dinner with a female friend IMO. I kind of disagree with this-I do think there is a difference, but I guess I kind of subscribe to the "When Harry Met Sally" philosophy. Not completely, but at least somewhat. For me, I amend the rule to new friends or people you are recently reacquainted with-you can't go to dinner with them. People you were always friends with-okay. I have lots of guy friends like this. But once DH met me, he met "the one" and there is no need for any new 1:1 female friendships. I'm it (plus the people that he knew before me). Yeah-it's complicated being married to me-what with all my rules and caveats
|
|
Posted 9/15/09 11:27 AM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Having dinner with a married man Posted by CrankyPants Posted by anonttcer Not weird at all. Almost all my friends are male. And married. As long as it's a strictly platonic relationship, It is no different than having dinner with a female friend IMO. I kind of disagree with this-I do think there is a difference, but I guess I kind of subscribe to the "When Harry Met Sally" philosophy. Not completely, but at least somewhat. For me, I amend the rule to new friends or people you are recently reacquainted with-you can't go to dinner with them. People you were always friends with-okay. I have lots of guy friends like this. But once DH met me, he met "the one" and there is no need for any new 1:1 female friendships. I'm it (plus the people that he knew before me). Yeah-it's complicated being married to me-what with all my rules and caveats I can relate to what you are saying. But I think the reason that I see it so differently is because if it weren't for my male friends, I really wouldn't have much of a social life... I just don't have many female friends- because I don't relate well to women- at ALL. I swear I should have been a dude!
|
|
Posted 9/15/09 11:55 AM
|
|
|
Re: Having dinner with a married man Posted by anonttcer I don't relate well to women- at ALL. Maybe you only relate to women who go to dinner with married men.
Message edited 2009-09-15 12:42:54.617000. |
|
Posted 9/15/09 12:30 PM
|
|
|
Re: Having dinner with a married man I think it is so sad to even be hesitant to go out with a married individual for dinner. WHO THE HELL CARES if your married or not you can go out to dinner with whom ever you would like to go out to dinner with. Marriage is not prison and women who feel terrified over their husband going out to dinner with a old friend need to get their head examined. |
|
Posted 9/15/09 12:34 PM
|
|
|
Re: Having dinner with a married man Don't think I would do this nor would it be ok for us. |
|
Posted 9/15/09 12:53 PM
|
|
|
Re: Having dinner with a married man Posted by Nifheim I think it is so sad to even be hesitant to go out with a married individual for dinner. WHO THE HELL CARES if your married or not you can go out to dinner with whom ever you would like to go out to dinner with. Marriage is not prison and women who feel terrified over their husband going out to dinner with a old friend need to get their head examined. Different strokes for different folks. Neither my Dh or I would go out to dinner with someone of the opposite sex alone. That doesn't mean that our marriage is a prison. |
|
Posted 9/15/09 12:59 PM
|
|
|
Re: Having dinner with a married man Posted by Nifheim I think it is so sad to even be hesitant to go out with a married individual for dinner. WHO THE HELL CARES if your married or not you can go out to dinner with whom ever you would like to go out to dinner with. Marriage is not prison and women who feel terrified over their husband going out to dinner with a old friend need to get their head examined. But a marriage IS a partnership and IS a compromise. People have different levels of comfort in these types of situations and I think it is unfair to cast aspersions on people who don't have the same level of comfort that you have. Honestly - if I'm going out to supper I am inviting my husband. Whether it's with a girl or a guy. Because I'd rather spend time with him than anyone else. Sometimes he'll pass on the invite - other times he won't. But if he told me that he wasn't comfortable with me going out with someone alone.. I would defer to him. We'd have a discussion about it but I would never tell him that he needs his head examined. I'd know that those feelings are coming from somewhere and WE would work through them together. And I would expect that if he wanted to go out with someone and I had some discomfort about it - he would defer to me without telling me I needed my head examined. |
|
Posted 9/15/09 1:00 PM
|
|
|
Re: Having dinner with a married man Posted by Nifheim WHO THE HELL CARES if your married or not apparently, a lot of people. |
|
Posted 9/15/09 1:09 PM
|
|
|
Re: Having dinner with a married man dinner is different but lunch or just something early will be ok with it.. sometimes I hang out or gtg with one of my guy friends but I know his wife and i let her know that i am going to gtg with him.. If it was my Husband I would have more of a problem if it was a single friend that he was gtg with... It may sound weird but its my own personal reasoning |
|
Posted 9/15/09 1:13 PM
|
|
|
Re: Having dinner with a married man Posted by Tilde In our situation it just wouldn't happen. To me that is basically a "date" so lunch/dinner/coffee alone with a member of the opposite sex (unrelated) would be crossing a BIG line for *US*. same here. i would be really upset if FH even asked me if it would be ok for him to dine with another female. |
|
Posted 9/15/09 1:14 PM
|
|
|
Re: Having dinner with a married man I don't see a problem with it at all... |
|
Posted 9/15/09 1:21 PM
|
|
|
Re: Having dinner with a married man Posted by greenfreak Posted by anonttcer I don't relate well to women- at ALL. Maybe you only relate to women who go to dinner with married men. Yes! Chicks like that I CAN relate to!
|
|
Posted 9/15/09 1:24 PM
|
|
|
Re: Having dinner with a married man I'm a little confused at the responses that say that dinner is not ok but lunch would be ok. |
|
Posted 9/15/09 1:26 PM
|
|
|
Re: Having dinner with a married man Posted by Nifheim I think it is so sad to even be hesitant to go out with a married individual for dinner. WHO THE HELL CARES if your married or not you can go out to dinner with whom ever you would like to go out to dinner with. Marriage is not prison and women who feel terrified over their husband going out to dinner with a old friend need to get their head examined. Honestly, no one here is "terrified" of their husband going out to dinner with another woman, and the boundaries in your relationship are not superior to those in someone else's relationship. The simple fact of the matter is that what works for one relationship doesn't necessary work for another. So you really shouldn't make assumptions about the boundaries in someone else's marriage. And obviously some people DO care -- and the OP was asking for opinions. As I said earlier, even if this would fly in the OP's own marriage, it might not be okay with her friend and his wife. The OP's boundaries don't dictate what is and isn't okay in someone else's marriage, so I actually think it's helpful for her to read different people's POVs. (I'm assuming that's why she asked the question and got so many varied responses.) Yours isn't the only POV and it isn't the only right POV either. While I am sure your POV is as appreciated as anyone else's, it would have been nice if you could have stated it without putting down those who have a different POV than your own. No one position on this is "right" or "wrong" so it's really not necessary to act as if your opinion is the only valid one, so everyone who disagrees with you must be insane. My head is fine, thanks. As an aside (NOT directed to the person I quoted), every time anyone here actually says that they have certain boundaries in their relationship, people have to jump all over them and accuse them of imprisoning their spouse, not trusting their spouse, etc. 99 times out of 100, that is absolutely not true. That argument seriously grates on my nerves. Who is anyone on this board to tell me that I don't trust my husband or that he doesn't trust me just because we have different boundaries than you do in your relationship? If I'm not married to you, then the boundaries of my marriage really shouldn't bother you so much, and if you're not married to me then you have no idea why the boundaries of my marriage are what they area. It's not your place to assume it's a lack of trust (or anything else for that matter). And if you do assume it's a lack of trust, you're sorely mistaken. Quite frankly, it's really obnoxious to tell someone that it must be a lack of trust that led to a certain boundary in their relationship. Some people (women and men) actually just have different ideas about what is and isn't appropriate. This is why we all marry different people and have different marriages. Different strokes for different folks is right -- and that doesn't mean the person who doesn't live their life exactly as you do is wrong. It just means they are different. Message edited 2009-09-15 13:36:15.303000. |
|
Posted 9/15/09 1:33 PM
|
|
|
Re: Having dinner with a married man Posted by anonttcer I'm a little confused at the responses that say that dinner is not ok but lunch would be ok. I just dont' get that reasoning. You can have a very romantic lunch...or a very casual dinner. I don't think the time of day or the meal should make a difference in whether you would be comfortable with it or not... I was just thinking the same thing!! Why is one meal ok but not another? But anyway, I don't see a problem and wouldn't have one if it were my relationship. |
|
Posted 9/15/09 1:34 PM
|
|
|
Re: Having dinner with a married man Posted by Nifheim I think it is so sad to even be hesitant to go out with a married individual for dinner. WHO THE HELL CARES if your married or not you can go out to dinner with whom ever you would like to go out to dinner with. Marriage is not prison and women who feel terrified over their husband going out to dinner with a old friend need to get their head examined. I have all male friends, I go out with them alone all the time (oh my god how horrible am i? LoL) if my husband wanted to go out with a old female friend then go on - hope you reconnect then we all can go out to dinner. If my husband wants to cheat on me then he is going to do just the same if i was going to cheat on my husband i would be doing it regardless of the situation. Go meet up with the old friend, tell your husband of course i mean if you kept it secret then i can see an issue have some dinner and drinks and then see if a connection is there to start a friendship again and if so invite all the spouses out next time. i dont think such hostility is necessary in your response. my marriage is not a prison. actually, i just left the country for ten days without my husband! i am not "terrified" of my husband going out with another woman, i just feel that has no place in our marriage. for me there is a difference between trusting my husband and doing things that i feel have no place in our marriage. |
|
Posted 9/15/09 1:35 PM
|
|
|
Re: Having dinner with a married man Posted by Tilde for me there is a difference between trusting my husband and doing things that i feel have no place in our marriage. Exactly! It seems that is something that a lot of people just can't fathom on LIF. |
|
Posted 9/15/09 1:36 PM
|
|
|
Re: Having dinner with a married man Wow, I'm surprised at how many people have a problem with it. I have a few male friends who I've worked at past jobs and we still get together on occasion, sometimes with a group or one on one. |
|
Posted 9/15/09 1:39 PM
|
|
|
Re: Having dinner with a married man Posted by Kara The OP's boundaries don't dictate what is and isn't okay in someone else's marriage, so I actually think it's helpful for her to read different people's POVs. (I'm assuming that's why she asked the question and got so many varied responses.) Very true. That's why I put it two ways - what people thought about my situation, knowing all the details and also how they would feel if they were in that situation. I can separate the two, and take all the opinions and draw out my own conclusions from them. |
|
Posted 9/15/09 1:40 PM
|
|
|
Re: Having dinner with a married man Posted by anonttcer I'm a little confused at the responses that say that dinner is not ok but lunch would be ok. I just dont' get that reasoning. You can have a very romantic lunch...or a very casual dinner. I don't think the time of day or the meal should make a difference in whether you would be comfortable with it or not... I don't really understand it either, but I have to say this isn't the first I have heard this. Perhaps because (traditionally) evening time would be time you would spend together during the week, whereas you might be different places for lunch? I realize that's not true for everyone, though. Maybe some of the people who feel this way can explain why. |
|
Posted 9/15/09 1:46 PM
|
|
|
Re: Having dinner with a married man Posted by steph4777 Wow, I'm surprised at how many people have a problem with it. I have a few male friends who I've worked at past jobs and we still get together on occasion, sometimes with a group or one on one. You know, this is a really good point. Another little tidbit that adds detail to my situation, and maybe why I feel the way I do about it. In my ambulance corps and in my job (I.T.), I was one of very few women. So I got used to being around a lot of men all the time, and I think sometimes I got along with them better. So having male friends is normal to me and yes, many of them are married. DH has been accustomed to that over the past 10 years and has never had a problem with it. Not even with the ex boyfriends who were still friends of mine. As an added bonus, many of my male friends became friends of his too, and they had their own things in common that I did not. |
|
Posted 9/15/09 1:48 PM
|
|
|
Re: Having dinner with a married man there will always be differing opinions on this because every marriage is different and also because there is no RIGHT answer to can men and women just be friends |
|
Posted 9/15/09 1:52 PM
|
|
|
Re: Having dinner with a married man Its depends on the situation and how the marriage works for each party. If you husband is ok with it and his wife doesnt mind than its no big deal. However, if one spouse is uncomfortable or one person is hiding it from their spouse than I wouldnt be having dinner with that person. |
|
Posted 9/15/09 3:18 PM
|
|
|
Re: Having dinner with a married man Hmm...I guess if you've gone out with your spouses and you're all friendly, why not? |
|
Posted 9/15/09 4:08 PM
|
|
|
Re: Having dinner with a married man I have dinner with my married guy friend once every few months, it's our catch up time....his wife always knows, my DH always knows....we've been friends forever, why wouldn't I!? One of my best friends since 5th grade is a guy and he'll be married in January.....we would never not go to dinner with one another b/c we're married now! |
|
Posted 9/15/09 5:05 PM
|
|
| Pages: 1 [2] 3 4 | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Shameless post....I made our first married thanksgiving dinner | NewlyMrs | 11/26/06 | 4 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Whitney has a new man - and he is a married minister! | TheLorax | 9/15/06 | 2 | Celebrities & Entertainment |
| The Tin Man I married | nrthshgrl | 1/4/06 | 8 | Families Helping Families ™ |















