Hardwood vs. Pergo

Posted By Message

VirginiaDeb
Don't eat me, hippo!

Member since 5/05

9252 total posts

Name:
Deb

Hardwood vs. Pergo

So, we were set on putting hardwood in our kitchen/dining room. The living room would stay carpeting, and the hall the marble. However, my step-dad said that there might be a problem w/ the thickness of the wood? And to get the Pergo?

Does it make a difference in the resale of the home? I had originally wanted to get Pergo, but DH hates it for some reason.

Thoughts?

Posted 3/24/09 6:51 AM
 
Prudential Douglas Elliman Real Estate
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
  |   Long Island Weddings

GoldenRod
10 years on LIF!

Member since 11/06

26792 total posts

Name:
Shawn

Re: Hardwood vs. Pergo

Pergo can't be refinished, since it's just a photograph of wood on top of a manufactured product, so if it gets scratched and worn, it can't be fixed. I'm not a fan of it, but I know that it's really popular.

Posted 3/24/09 7:43 AM
 

Elbee
Zanzibar

Member since 5/05

10767 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Hardwood vs. Pergo

For ressale value, Hardwood is better.
For looks, it is up to you.
I have pergo, I hate it. Because it is laminate, it is ALWAYS streaky. I've given up trying to get rid of the streaks. Once a week I make it perfect and then before the night is over, there are the inevitable streaks left.
I also don't think it stands up to wear and tear as well as hardwood. I have a few scratches and one place has a small crack. With hardwood, you could always resand/restain. With pergo, it is what it is and cannot be fixed.

Hope that helps!

Posted 3/24/09 7:55 AM
 

JerseyMamaOf3
Boo!

Member since 6/05

15144 total posts

Name:

Re: Hardwood vs. Pergo

I love hardwood and am not a fan of laminate flooring, but we did just put it in our kitchen (I have a post a few up from this one with what it looks like). It wasn't my first choice but I actually like the way it came out and it was in our budget (we found it on clearance at lowe's for 80 cents a sq/ft).

You can also buy different thickness' of real wood flooring. The only difference between each one is how many times you can refinish it if need be down the road.

Besides laminate and hardwood they have engineered which is the base of a laminate but then their is a thin sheet of real wood over it. It can be refinished once or twice I believe and it clicks together like laminate. This was the option we were originally going to go with but for the one we wanted it was way to much.

Another thing to consider, maybe running the wood floors into the living room too. I think it will look like to many different floor materials if you have carpeting, tile and then wood all in the same vicinity.

Posted 3/24/09 8:25 AM
 

Faithx2
All good things in 2016!!

Member since 8/05

20181 total posts

Name:

Re: Hardwood vs. Pergo

Posted by GoldenRod

Pergo can't be refinished, since it's just a photograph of wood on top of a manufactured product, so if it gets scratched and worn, it can't be fixed. I'm not a fan of it, but I know that it's really popular.



We aren't either. HArdwood all the way...

Posted 3/24/09 8:50 AM
 

Cheeks24
Living a dream

Member since 1/08

8589 total posts

Name:
Cheeks

Re: Hardwood vs. Pergo

Definitely go with hardwood. As others said you can refinish it time and time again. It's much more valuable when you resell your home too.

Posted 3/24/09 10:44 AM
 

Nifheim
allo

Member since 1/09

5476 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Hardwood vs. Pergo

hardwood hands down.

Posted 3/24/09 11:11 AM
 

CaMacho
Sisters :)

Member since 7/06

15112 total posts

Name:
Jess

Re: Hardwood vs. Pergo

If $$ isn't the issue, i'd go with hardwood (even though we recently put down laminate in our house).

We kept a tight budget with home improvement projects so we went with the laminate wood flooring. We did choose a higher end laminate that came in single planks and was super thick so it doesn't look like the typical pergo with several thin "planks" per piece. It's holding up really well and we just love it, plus just about everyone down here in FL has laminate so for resale it wouldn't be an issue for us. I have pics in my home album.

Posted 3/24/09 11:17 AM
 

neener1211
:-)

Member since 4/07

22952 total posts

Name:
J

Re: Hardwood vs. Pergo

I wanted Hardwood, but pergo fit our budget at the time. I like the pergo, although I don't let anyone walk on it with shoes.

I would consider changing it 10-15 years from now if it got damaged. I don't plan on selling our house, so the resale value has no burden on me.

Posted 3/24/09 11:25 AM
 

Nik211
my little monkey<3

Member since 5/08

3303 total posts

Name:
Nik

Re: Hardwood vs. Pergo

we have laminate now in our apartment - we put it down last year and we bought the cheapest thing Home Depot had Chat Icon Reason being we rent the apartment from DH's parents for the time being while we are saving for a house - we didn't want to spend a lot since its not our home and DH's parents still made out on the deal b/c any laminate is better than carpeting (for cleanliness when it comes to future renters after we are gone)....

we have a nick or two in the flooring - its nothing compared to the scatches upstairs on the real wood floor that his parents have. with that said real wood looks beautiful and our laminate looks fake - you can tell immediately that it is a laminate floor and ours is the same deal as pergo with the streaks and smudges right after you clean it - depending on the laminate it is hard to keep it looking spotless....

for our new home we were considering wood, bamboo and laminate - trying to weigh the pros and cons of each....from what i've been seeing the bamboo may not hold up well with the dog and lots of traffic - wood is on the more expensive side and needs to be re-finished every so often (and we are going to be on a tight budget!) i was on the fence with laminate b/c it of its look but the floor that camacho has looks really nice - i actually thought it was hardwood b/c of the shine and plank style - so that is something we are def going to look into when we are ready to do flooring again....


Message edited 2009-03-24 11:46:04.410000.

Posted 3/24/09 11:44 AM
 

GoldenRod
10 years on LIF!

Member since 11/06

26792 total posts

Name:
Shawn

Re: Hardwood vs. Pergo

Posted by Nik211

for our new home we were considering wood, bamboo and laminate - trying to weigh the pros and cons of each....from what i've been seeing the bamboo may not hold up well with the dog and lots of traffic - wood is on the more expensive side and needs to be re-finished every so often (and we are going to be on a tight budget!) i was on the fence with laminate b/c it of its look but the floor that camacho has looks really nice - i actually thought it was hardwood b/c of the shine and plank style - so that is something we are def going to look into when we are ready to do flooring again....





The right bamboo is harder and stronger than almost any wood out there. My contractor commented numerous times about how strong the bamboo that I used was. It's going to be even funnier when I have him back to do our kitchen and dining room because I found an even harder bamboo from the same company.... Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 3/24/09 12:36 PM
 

KimberlyScott
Graceyn=My World <3

Member since 10/08

4173 total posts

Name:
Kimberly

Re: Hardwood vs. Pergo

Personally, I love the look of hardwood but it's high maintenance. I had hardwood in my condo and my little Shih Tzu scratched the hell out of it.

The new house we went with Pergo laminate becuase we have 3 dogs and it rains here a lot and everyone knows water + harwood floors = NO NO. So, I would go this way since you plan on putting it in your kitchen. Kitchen is also high traffic. A lot of wear & tear and the Pergo is durable.

So far, I have no complaints. I don't find it streaky like the other poster claimed. My dogs don't scratch it and it was in our budget. I wet mop it every night with a micro fiber mop and it looks great.

My friend put down a Bruce laminate on her living area and it looks great too.

Message edited 2009-03-24 12:44:19.690000.

Posted 3/24/09 12:41 PM
 

Nik211
my little monkey<3

Member since 5/08

3303 total posts

Name:
Nik

Re: Hardwood vs. Pergo

Posted by GoldenRod

Posted by Nik211

for our new home we were considering wood, bamboo and laminate - trying to weigh the pros and cons of each....from what i've been seeing the bamboo may not hold up well with the dog and lots of traffic - wood is on the more expensive side and needs to be re-finished every so often (and we are going to be on a tight budget!) i was on the fence with laminate b/c it of its look but the floor that camacho has looks really nice - i actually thought it was hardwood b/c of the shine and plank style - so that is something we are def going to look into when we are ready to do flooring again....





The right bamboo is harder and stronger than almost any wood out there. My contractor commented numerous times about how strong the bamboo that I used was. It's going to be even funnier when I have him back to do our kitchen and dining room because I found an even harder bamboo from the same company.... Chat Icon Chat Icon



Get out! Do you know what brand? I read a lot of reviews and most people complained that it scratched and dented easier than most regular hardwood floors....

I do remember reading about one company that harvests their bamboo at about 6 years of age and supposedly it is stronger than some of the other companies who harvest theirs earlier....We looked at a house that had bamboo floors and it was gorgeous and I did not see any scratches so that is why I became so interested in it - but then when I went to research it I read bad reviews and got discouraged...

Message edited 2009-03-24 13:19:01.130000.

Posted 3/24/09 1:18 PM
 

GoldenRod
10 years on LIF!

Member since 11/06

26792 total posts

Name:
Shawn

Re: Hardwood vs. Pergo

Posted by Nik211

Posted by GoldenRod

Posted by Nik211

for our new home we were considering wood, bamboo and laminate - trying to weigh the pros and cons of each....from what i've been seeing the bamboo may not hold up well with the dog and lots of traffic - wood is on the more expensive side and needs to be re-finished every so often (and we are going to be on a tight budget!) i was on the fence with laminate b/c it of its look but the floor that camacho has looks really nice - i actually thought it was hardwood b/c of the shine and plank style - so that is something we are def going to look into when we are ready to do flooring again....





The right bamboo is harder and stronger than almost any wood out there. My contractor commented numerous times about how strong the bamboo that I used was. It's going to be even funnier when I have him back to do our kitchen and dining room because I found an even harder bamboo from the same company.... Chat Icon Chat Icon



Get out! Do you know what brand? I read a lot of reviews and most people complained that it scratched and dented easier than most regular hardwood floors....

I do remember reading about one company that harvests their bamboo at about 6 years of age and supposedly it is stronger than some of the other companies who harvest theirs earlier....We looked at a house that had bamboo floors and it was gorgeous and I did not see any scratches so that is why I became so interested in it - but then when I went to research it I read bad reviews and got discouraged...



http://www.teragren.com/

They are also environmentally friendly. No formaldehyde in the glues, they sustainably harvest the bamboo, etc.

Right now, I have the flat grain natural "Signature Natural" in my office. The natural is tougher than the darker colors (they bake the bamboo to give it the color). Their Synergy line is processed differently, making it even stronger than traditional bamboo flooring. We are going with the Synergy line for our diningroom and possibly the kitchen.

Posted 3/24/09 1:26 PM
 

OrganicMama
So in love with my little man!

Member since 6/08

5172 total posts

Name:
Mama

Re: Hardwood vs. Pergo

I had Pergo in my house in Florida (cheap fix) and hated it. I dropped something on the floor once and it took a big chunk out and you could see the backing (looked like cardboard).

If you're worried about the height difference, I would do engineered hardwood. The backing is usually 6-10 thin layers of wood with the grain running perpendicular to each other (keeps it from expanding and contracting), and the top layer is usually about 1/4" thick and pre-finished. Depending on the thickness of the top layer, it can usually be sanded down 1-2 times.


Engineered hardwood flooring is a product made up of a core of hardwood, plywood or HDF and a top layer of hardwood veneer that is glued on the top surface of the core and is available in almost any hardwood species. The product thus has the natural characteristics of the selected wood species as opposed to a photographic layer. The “engineered” product has been designed to provide greater stability, particularly where moisture or heat pose problems for solid hardwood floors.

http://flooring.builddirect.com/Engineered-Hardwood-Floors/Engineered-Hardwood-Flooring-FAQ_8804.aspx#What%20is%20engineered%20hardwood

Posted 3/24/09 1:30 PM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Hardwood vs. Pergo

I have the "thickness" issue at my house since I have a slab and hardwood would raise my floors too much.

Have you concidered Engineered Flooring? It has the look of hardwood and can be refinished 1-2 times. Its' not has thick.

Posted 3/24/09 1:33 PM
 

CrankyPants
I'm cranky

Member since 7/06

18178 total posts

Name:
Mama Cranky

Re: Hardwood vs. Pergo

Posted by Seles81

IBesides laminate and hardwood they have engineered which is the base of a laminate but then their is a thin sheet of real wood over it. It can be refinished once or twice I believe and it clicks together like laminate. This was the option we were originally going to go with but for the one we wanted it was way to much.
.



This is what we have, the warranty says it can be refinished up to 3 times. I prefer hardwood, but this was in when we bought the house and I like the look of it.

Posted 3/24/09 1:47 PM
 

Nifheim
allo

Member since 1/09

5476 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Hardwood vs. Pergo

Posted by smdl
Have you concidered Engineered Flooring? It has the look of hardwood and can be refinished 1-2 times. Its' not has thick.



My parents have this, very thin only thing is it will scratch just like hardwood (my father after having it installed THREE weeks he scrapped it by moving the fridge by himself.) But its very nice looking.

Posted 3/24/09 1:48 PM
 

Janice
Sweet Jessie Quinn

Member since 5/05

27567 total posts

Name:
Janice

Re: Hardwood vs. Pergo

we went back and forth with this for awhile.

Downstairs is already hardwood.

Upstairs is carpet.

New construction...but my kid can't have carpet in room.

It is only 140 sq feet of room...DH wanted hardwood, I did not see the need. Between dresser, bed, bookcase...so little of the floor is showing.

Final decision was made when we found laminate on clearance for 69 cents a sq foot at HD. And, DH can lay it himself easily.

Posted 3/24/09 3:08 PM
 

imas98
Love my Furbaby

Member since 10/07

1140 total posts

Name:

Re: Hardwood vs. Pergo

We had Pergo put in our living room about 2 years ago. I wanted real wood but it wasn't in the budget Chat Icon But the look of the Pergo has grown on me and after dropping stuff on it, I like that its really durable ! We have it in a high traffic area where it has gotten wet a bunch of times too and it's held up perfectly. We plan on getting a dog so I'm happy I won't have to worry about scratches either.

Posted 3/24/09 4:29 PM
 

lbride
Lovin' my mini man!

Member since 3/07

2475 total posts

Name:
Lisa

Re: Hardwood vs. Pergo

love hardwoods.... we have laminate in our downstairs den - we used St. James 12mm thick single wide planks. Everyone single person who has seen them thinks that it is real wood. They look gorgeous. Got them at lumber liquidators. when you walking on them - it sounds and feels much diff. than hardwood

Message edited 2009-03-24 17:27:45.993000.

Posted 3/24/09 5:27 PM
 

VirginiaDeb
Don't eat me, hippo!

Member since 5/05

9252 total posts

Name:
Deb

Re: Hardwood vs. Pergo

Ack! So much to think about! Thank you everyone for your responses! I guess we're going to price both and see what happens. They're all small spaces, so it should be too much.

Posted 3/24/09 6:14 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Hardwood/Pergo floors sunflowerjesss 1/23/08 13 Home
Hardwood Floors - refinishing beena 3/24/06 2 Home
Hardwood floors in the kitchen? Elizabeth 3/18/06 8 Home
refinishing hardwood floors - ok price? Leeners 3/18/06 6 Home
Hardwood or carpet?? Summer05 3/6/06 30 Home
Hardwood Floors ARIELSMOM 2/21/06 4 Home