Generosity and family...

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

nyteacher13
Three Under Four!!! :-)

Member since 8/06

6405 total posts

Name:
~ THERESA ~

Generosity and family...

I know it's petty, but my mil bought us an exersaucer for the baby. That's it. Nothing else.

My MOM on the other hand has been beyond generous in all ways... bought the nursery furniture, countless toys, outfits, threw me a huge shower, you name it.

Anyone else experience such a difference in generosity between parents and inlaws?

TIA!

Message edited 2009-01-04 21:42:23.200000.

Posted 1/4/09 9:41 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

MrsRbk
<3 <3 <3 <3

Member since 1/06

19197 total posts

Name:
Michelle

Re: Generosity and family...

Honestly, I don't let that kind of stuff bother me.

We've purchased ourselves most of our big ticket stuff.

Crib
pack and play
swing/bouncer, etc..

Noone has offered, nor did we expect anyone to offer.

I'm sure after the baby is born, we'll get stuff, but if we don't, we don't.

Posted 1/4/09 9:49 PM
 

juju
Welcome to the World!

Member since 5/05

6747 total posts

Name:

Re: Generosity and family...

Maybe, they plan on getting you more things or $$.

Posted 1/4/09 9:50 PM
 

Angel321
...

Member since 4/08

15553 total posts

Name:

Re: Generosity and family...

unfortunately, i am positive we will experience the same thing. It has always been that way - since i've been with DH.

Dave has always been treated like the red headed step child in his family...

When he came to our first Christmas as my boyfriend (6 years ago), he was overwhelmed by the love, just overall thoughtfullness and gifts..... His parents even have a habit of leaving price tags on so we can see how little they spend on us.... It wouldn't bother me - but i can see how it bothers him... (one year - i got an ornament from his sister....please, let me add a BROKEN ornament - no joke).

I know full well we can expect this when the baby comes....i understand how you feel, totally and completely. I think if my family and our friends weren't so wonderful, it wouldn't be as obvious and painful to him...but when friends care more and do more to make you feel special than your own family, it stinks...

Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 1/4/09 9:51 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Generosity and family...

My mom started shopping the minute she found out I was pregnant. My MIL - nothing. She went through a very tough time losing a newborn, so she had a perfectly good reason for it. She didn't want me or DH to experience the pain of looking at anything if history repeated itself. My ILs were very generous AFTER the babies were born.

There maybe reasons for the difference in the amounts of gifts - anything from finances to superstition.

Posted 1/4/09 9:53 PM
 

nyteacher13
Three Under Four!!! :-)

Member since 8/06

6405 total posts

Name:
~ THERESA ~

Re: Generosity and family...

Don't get me wrong, I don't need anyone to do anything for me. Dh and I have more than we ever could imagine for this baby. We want/need for nothing at all. The baby will come into the world loved and completely blessed. I just saw the post about the exersaucer and it got me thinking again about this.

I know that people give what they can give, and I didn't expect a whole lot from her anyway. It just took me by surprise. Dh is surprised, too, because she's normally a very generous and giving person.

It is what it is... I was just curious to see if anyone else went through something similar.

Chat Icon

Posted 1/4/09 9:58 PM
 

LSP2005
Bunny kisses are so cute!

Member since 5/05

19461 total posts

Name:
L

Re: Generosity and family...

I just thought I would share that in my family (both sides) were very supersticious and did not get us anything before the baby was born. When I was in my 9th month they all finally got us the crib, changing table, tons of clothing and bedding. My parents also hosted DSs bris. I mistakenly thought that our families were not happy for us - but they were - it was just supersticion.

Posted 1/4/09 10:19 PM
 

nyteacher13
Three Under Four!!! :-)

Member since 8/06

6405 total posts

Name:
~ THERESA ~

Re: Generosity and family...

Posted by LSP2005

I just thought I would share that in my family (both sides) were very supersticious and did not get us anything before the baby was born. When I was in my 9th month they all finally got us the crib, changing table, tons of clothing and bedding. My parents also hosted DSs bris. I mistakenly thought that our families were not happy for us - but they were - it was just supersticion.



interesting thought... this could be a possiblity. They are also piissed off that we don't know the sex of the baby - they're always complaining about how difficult it is to find gender neutral stuff... never thought of it this way. Chat Icon

Posted 1/4/09 10:26 PM
 

nrvbrd
LIF Adolescent

Member since 5/05

796 total posts

Name:
Kysha

Re: Generosity and family...

I have not had my shower yet, so I cannot speak on it, but I can say this neither DH nor myself come from families that have much money, so we are totally not expecting alot. We are already convinced that we will be buying alot of our must have items ourself.

MIL has already hinted what she is NOT doing for us.

It is what it is, we are not as lucky as some. Chat Icon I was at my cousin's shower today and they got soooooooooooo much stuff plus a ton of giftcards. I will be lucky if I get a quarter of what they got at my showerChat Icon

Posted 1/4/09 10:35 PM
 

HelenZ
So worth the wait :)

Member since 10/07

2862 total posts

Name:
Helen

Re: Generosity and family...

well for me its kind of the opposite, although my mom has a very low income so it doesn't bother me at all. She has spent $50- $100 for each of my sisters showers and for my bridal shower, whereas my MIL is extremely generous with gifts at family showers- I don't know what she'll be getting us, but I'm just appreciative of how generous she has been, especially considering the fact she has seven children!!

Posted 1/4/09 11:00 PM
 

Angel321
...

Member since 4/08

15553 total posts

Name:

Re: Generosity and family...

as the OP stated - it has nothing to do with money....it's the feeling of uneven-ness.

Posted 1/4/09 11:10 PM
 

nyteacher13
Three Under Four!!! :-)

Member since 8/06

6405 total posts

Name:
~ THERESA ~

Re: Generosity and family...

Posted by davenjess

as the OP stated - it has nothing to do with money....it's the feeling of uneven-ness.



Thanks for that. And, as I mentioned to you in my fm (and I'll mention it on here), it's not what she gave me and how much, it's the fact that I feel the relationship is uneven. Almost like a friendship that one-sided. I feel more like an asss than anything, and I feel terrible for dh because it just confirms their feelings for him. He has always been the overlooked one in the family, and this is just another way of blowing him off.

I just know from now on not to expect much from them. Hopefully their love and kindness towards the baby (dear god, I hope so...) is more than their efforts to provide in a materialistic way. That is more important anyway, but let's see...

Posted 1/4/09 11:15 PM
 

brownie
Baby #1 is here!

Member since 11/08

13903 total posts

Name:

Re: Generosity and family...

Posted by nyteacher13

I know it's petty, but my mil bought us an exersaucer for the baby. That's it. Nothing else.

My MOM on the other hand has been beyond generous in all ways... bought the nursery furniture, countless toys, outfits, threw me a huge shower, you name it.

Anyone else experience such a difference in generosity between parents and inlaws?

TIA!



yep, but not just now, for our wedding, birthdays, christmas etc

I know part of it is because my parents make more and I'm an only child, and DH's parents makes less and he has 3 siblings.

I try not to make a big deal about it cause I understand, but sometimes it gets under my skin...I know it shouldn't but the uneven-ness gets to me sometimes. Sometimes DH doesn't want to accept a gift from my parents cause he thinks I hold it against him. I hate comparing parents but I do it in my head all the time...a habit I really should quit Chat Icon

Posted 1/4/09 11:18 PM
 

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: Generosity and family...

Posted by davenjess

as the OP stated - it has nothing to do with money....it's the feeling of uneven-ness.



C'mon, even with the feeling of "uneven-ness" it comes down to money.

To me, the OP is saying that her MIL isn't buying/spending enough for their new baby, THAT has to do with money, plain and simple.

Listen, my MIL barely knows my son, she does buy gifts (my parents buy more too, and are way more involved in his life) but I'd love for her to save all of the money she has spent on gifts in the 20 months of his life and spend it on a plane ticket, but she won't.

And how do you know (especially since you don't know the sex) that she isn't going to show up at the hospital with an entire year's worth of boy or girl clothes? Maybe she is waiting to purchase your bedding?

I wouldn't keep tally with an unborn child's gifts, JMHO though.

Posted 1/4/09 11:29 PM
 

Angel321
...

Member since 4/08

15553 total posts

Name:

Re: Generosity and family...

Posted by KateDevine

Posted by davenjess

as the OP stated - it has nothing to do with money....it's the feeling of uneven-ness.



C'mon, even with the feeling of "uneven-ness" it comes down to money.

To me, the OP is saying that her MIL isn't buying/spending enough for their new baby, THAT has to do with money, plain and simple.

Listen, my MIL barely knows my son, she does buy gifts (my parents buy more too, and are way more involved in his life) but I'd love for her to save all of the money she has spent on gifts in the 20 months of his life and spend it on a plane ticket, but she won't.

And how do you know (especially since you don't know the sex) that she isn't going to show up at the hospital with an entire year's worth of boy or girl clothes? Maybe she is waiting to purchase your bedding?

I wouldn't keep tally with an unborn child's gifts, JMHO though.



As i have been dealing with this for 6 years with Dave's family, I politely disagree 100%. For us/him it has very little to do with money. His family has treated him poorly and like a 'black sheep' (to use a phrase from a friend) his entire life.

If something goes wrong, we don't get a phone call. Both of his parents have been hospitalized and we don't get a call for a week, if we're LUCKY. His sister? SHE TAKES THEM THERE....but does she inform us? NO.

If my dad so much as has a cold - he lets me know he's not feeling well and is heading to the doc....

I had spinal surgery a few years ago. My family was at my side for SEVERAL days (and they live out of state), Dave's family - who live 20 minutes away came over once for a half hour....his sister - never even called.

We are treated differently in every day life - not just monetarily....there is a HUGE sense of un-evenness in the way things are and we fully expect it to stay that way once the baby arrives.

Posted 1/4/09 11:57 PM
 

nyteacher13
Three Under Four!!! :-)

Member since 8/06

6405 total posts

Name:
~ THERESA ~

Re: Generosity and family...

Posted by KateDevine

Posted by davenjess

as the OP stated - it has nothing to do with money....it's the feeling of uneven-ness.



C'mon, even with the feeling of "uneven-ness" it comes down to money.

To me, the OP is saying that her MIL isn't buying/spending enough for their new baby, THAT has to do with money, plain and simple.

Listen, my MIL barely knows my son, she does buy gifts (my parents buy more too, and are way more involved in his life) but I'd love for her to save all of the money she has spent on gifts in the 20 months of his life and spend it on a plane ticket, but she won't.

And how do you know (especially since you don't know the sex) that she isn't going to show up at the hospital with an entire year's worth of boy or girl clothes? Maybe she is waiting to purchase your bedding?

I wouldn't keep tally with an unborn child's gifts, JMHO though.



no, it doesn't. I'm telling you that it has to do with a feeling of reciprocity in general. If you knew me, you'd know that I'm not a materialistic person, nor do I play "tit for tat." It's my feeling like an assshole that I thought this baby's grandmother would be more emotionally involved than she is at this point. For all other family members, she went above and beyond being there for them when they were pregnant. For me, not the case at all. Maybe I should have added that she doesn't call at all, nor does she even ask how I'm feeling. Maybe you can get a clearer picture.

So I disagree with your statement wholeheartedly - it does not come down to money.

ETA: Not sure what you're insinuating by saying that you "wouldn't keep a tally on my baby's gifts." You missed the boat with this post.

Message edited 2009-01-05 00:05:28.510000.

Posted 1/5/09 12:04 AM
 

ReiRei13
Life is Good!!

Member since 1/08

6460 total posts

Name:

Re: Generosity and family...

My parents have ALWAYS done so much more for me and my DH than my MIL and the trend has continued on already with this baby!! It is what it is- we're used to it!

Posted 1/5/09 5:03 AM
 

Katie111806
Team Pink!

Member since 12/06

5349 total posts

Name:
Katie

Re: Generosity and family...

Posted by nyteacher13

Posted by KateDevine

Posted by davenjess

as the OP stated - it has nothing to do with money....it's the feeling of uneven-ness.



C'mon, even with the feeling of "uneven-ness" it comes down to money.

To me, the OP is saying that her MIL isn't buying/spending enough for their new baby, THAT has to do with money, plain and simple.

Listen, my MIL barely knows my son, she does buy gifts (my parents buy more too, and are way more involved in his life) but I'd love for her to save all of the money she has spent on gifts in the 20 months of his life and spend it on a plane ticket, but she won't.

And how do you know (especially since you don't know the sex) that she isn't going to show up at the hospital with an entire year's worth of boy or girl clothes? Maybe she is waiting to purchase your bedding?

I wouldn't keep tally with an unborn child's gifts, JMHO though.



no, it doesn't. I'm telling you that it has to do with a feeling of reciprocity in general. If you knew me, you'd know that I'm not a materialistic person, nor do I play "tit for tat." It's my feeling like an assshole that I thought this baby's grandmother would be more emotionally involved than she is at this point. For all other family members, she went above and beyond being there for them when they were pregnant. For me, not the case at all. Maybe I should have added that she doesn't call at all, nor does she even ask how I'm feeling. Maybe you can get a clearer picture.

So I disagree with your statement wholeheartedly - it does not come down to money.

ETA: Not sure what you're insinuating by saying that you "wouldn't keep a tally on my baby's gifts." You missed the boat with this post.



I totally get what you are saying bc I experience the same thing. There is such a marked difference in generosity between my parents and his that I sometimes feel bad/embarrassed for DH. It appears now that I've been completely eliminated for gifts for xmas. Dh got pretty much what he normally does (relatively minimal), the baby got a few items and I got two dollar store ornaments. To me its about the major differences in what is done for other people versus what is done for me. My mil also did not ask me one time in 40w how I felt. She is obsessed with ds now in a smothering, not good way and didn't even kiss me hello or goodbye bc she was all up in his business.

Posted 1/5/09 6:37 AM
 

gck0708
She is love!

Member since 11/08

1863 total posts

Name:
Grace

Re: Generosity and family...

Posted by davenjess

unfortunately, i am positive we will experience the same thing. It has always been that way - since i've been with DH.

Dave has always been treated like the red headed step child in his family...

When he came to our first Christmas as my boyfriend (6 years ago), he was overwhelmed by the love, just overall thoughtfullness and gifts..... His parents even have a habit of leaving price tags on so we can see how little they spend on us.... It wouldn't bother me - but i can see how it bothers him... (one year - i got an ornament from his sister....please, let me add a BROKEN ornament - no joke).

I know full well we can expect this when the baby comes....i understand how you feel, totally and completely. I think if my family and our friends weren't so wonderful, it wouldn't be as obvious and painful to him...but when friends care more and do more to make you feel special than your own family, it stinks...

Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon



This sounds exactly like my in-laws. They didn't get us anything for our wedding (no gift - nothing), so I'm not expecting much with the baby. Like you said in later posts, it doesn't all come down to money, it just seems like they don't care as much and that hurts my DH. And it isn't that they don't have the means to be generous, which makes it more difficult to understand. My DH is always self conscious of how much more generous my parents are.

I think if my family and our friends weren't so wonderful, it wouldn't be as obvious and painful to him...but when friends care more and do more to make you feel special than your own family, it stinks...



Exactly.

Posted 1/5/09 6:54 AM
 

Smalls72
OMG, time is going way to fast

Member since 9/08

3797 total posts

Name:
Bali

Re: Generosity and family...

I haven't had my shower yet, but so far my parents and my in-laws have been very generous. DH and myself had originally bought all the furniture because we found it on sale, but both sets of parents chipped in and paid half each.

Posted 1/5/09 7:57 AM
 

StressedNoMore
LIF Toddler

Member since 6/05

493 total posts

Name:
Christine

Re: Generosity and family...

Posted by davenjess

unfortunately, i am positive we will experience the same thing. It has always been that way - since i've been with DH.

Dave has always been treated like the red headed step child in his family...

When he came to our first Christmas as my boyfriend (6 years ago), he was overwhelmed by the love, just overall thoughtfullness and gifts..... His parents even have a habit of leaving price tags on so we can see how little they spend on us.... It wouldn't bother me - but i can see how it bothers him... (one year - i got an ornament from his sister....please, let me add a BROKEN ornament - no joke).

I know full well we can expect this when the baby comes....i understand how you feel, totally and completely. I think if my family and our friends weren't so wonderful, it wouldn't be as obvious and painful to him...but when friends care more and do more to make you feel special than your own family, it stinks...

Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon



OMG!!! this so sounds like DH's family... the first Christmas we bought his whole side of the family adults and kids big ticket items and his brother and sister in law gave us a basket with chocolate covered pretzels in it-(only 5 may I add)... So I knew not to expect much from them when I was pregnant with DS... They all bought 1 item no more then 60 bucks... And like my bridal shower... nothing that was actaully on the registry.. it was what they felt like buying... While my mom bought the whole baby's bedroom set plus some... and now that I am having # 2, my mom is wanting to buy me the double stroller and other major things I need and I can just imagine what they will get us, if anything...

Posted 1/5/09 8:51 AM
 

MarisaK
HELLO Manolo !!

Member since 5/06

14562 total posts

Name:
Marisa

Re: Generosity and family...

I understand 100% - It's not like you're keeping a running tally of who spent what and how much - But I can totally relate to your situation -

My ILs just don't make a big deal, they don't spend a lot of money on anything or anyone ........They're not overly generous people, they're very frugal - it's just the way they are - I don't expect any different from them now b/c we're having a baby -

Posted 1/5/09 9:04 AM
 

nyteacher13
Three Under Four!!! :-)

Member since 8/06

6405 total posts

Name:
~ THERESA ~

Re: Generosity and family...

Again, thanks for all of your replies.

I'm going to put this to rest now because, as I said yesterday, a post that I was reading triggered these emotions again.

I'll end with this. Regardless of who buys what for my baby, I just hope that the love they have and show for him/her is unconditional and the same as it's shown for every other grandchild in the family.

Chat Icon T

Posted 1/5/09 5:22 PM
 

nrvbrd
LIF Adolescent

Member since 5/05

796 total posts

Name:
Kysha

Re: Generosity and family...

Posted by MarisaK

I understand 100% - It's not like you're keeping a running tally of who spent what and how much - But I can totally relate to your situation -

My ILs just don't make a big deal, they don't spend a lot of money on anything or anyone ........They're not overly generous people, they're very frugal - it's just the way they are - I don't expect any different from them now b/c we're having a baby -



Sister you just summed up my situation with my inlaws.

I have grown to accept, it is what it is.

Posted 1/5/09 5:57 PM
 

Bridex100
Two Under Two Mommy

Member since 3/08

10420 total posts

Name:
Momx100

Re: Generosity and family...

Is your family weathier than DH's family?

It is rough economic times for a lot of people these days.

My family is a lot more generous in general than DH's family. DH's parents are divorced though. I don't know if that has to do with it.

My mom keeps wanting to buy things for us. I know she means well but it can get bothersome.

Posted 1/5/09 6:04 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Snowbound family rescued after 17 days!! Lisa 3/22/06 3 Families Helping Families ™
Need advice on how to broach a sensitive subject with family members CathyB 3/20/06 7 Parenting
Dear ALL Friends and Family Mrs-Boop 3/18/06 7 Families Helping Families ™
Belly shots by Nrthshgrl (and other family pics) CunningOne 3/13/06 25 Pregnancy
Anyone's family live out of state? Dragonfly75 3/13/06 12 Pregnancy
family gossip saraH 3/12/06 7 Families Helping Families ™