g-d parents

Posted By Message

bonch20
LIF Adult

Member since 9/09

1290 total posts

Name:
Bonnie

g-d parents

Anyone not have g-d parents? Or if you come from an interfaith relationship, how did you choose them for your child?

Posted 7/21/11 12:36 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

evrythng4areason
And then there were 4

Member since 1/10

5224 total posts

Name:
Kayla

Re: g-d parents

i dont have any..i'm christian but my church doesnt do godparents

Posted 7/21/11 12:42 PM
 

luckysmom
Yes it is! Going as planned:)

Member since 6/07

5339 total posts

Name:

Re: g-d parents

We only did a baptism for my twins becuase it was important to my husband. To me though, my twins are neither catholic (what DH is) or Jewish ( which is technically what i am). He wanted his brother as a god parent and I wanted mine if i was going to be forced to have a baptism. We had twins which worked out perfectly. We chose my brother nad his wife for DS and his brother and his wife for DD. We pretty much picked who we thought would be good role models for our kids.

Message edited 2011-07-21 12:44:24.617000.

Posted 7/21/11 12:43 PM
 

bonch20
LIF Adult

Member since 9/09

1290 total posts

Name:
Bonnie

Re: g-d parents

Posted by luckysmom

We only did a baptism for my twins becuase it was important to my husband. To me though, my twins are neither catholic (what DH is) or Jewish ( which is technically what i am). He wanted his brother as a god parent and I wanted mine if i was going to be forced to have a baptism. We had twins which worked out perfectly. We chose my brother nad his wife for DS and his brother and his wife for DD. We pretty much picked who we thought would be good role models for our kids.



DH and I both have brothers...and we don't think we'll have another baby, so chosing between them is causing major tension....especially since religon is such a senstive topic.

Just don't want DD to loose out cause we can't make a choice...wanted to see if there were others without them.

Posted 7/21/11 12:51 PM
 

LastLightGlow
Mystic.

Member since 4/07

2665 total posts

Name:

Re: g-d parents

Message edited 2011-10-05 14:49:05.217000.

Posted 7/21/11 1:29 PM
 

CathyB

Member since 5/05

19403 total posts

Name:

Re: g-d parents

We're an interfaith couple. I'm a practicing Catholic, DH was raised Jewish but does not believe in organized religion. When we had the kids Christened, it was important to me that their godparents be Catholic, since their job is to make sure the child is being raised in the faith. I know a lot of people choose people outside the faith as a godparent, but I don't understand how a Jewish person would be able to teach my children about Catholicism if something happened to me.

Message edited 2011-07-21 13:37:53.147000.

Posted 7/21/11 1:36 PM
 

imyself

Member since 10/06

2938 total posts

Name:
me

Re: g-d parents

We are interfaith and had a baby blessing for each kid. We decided to have a godparent from each religion for the baby. So each baby had a catholic godmother and a Jewish god father. Now if we go for #3 I am screwed because we don't have a Jewish woman for the godmother and we would have to have my brother as the godfather since my sisters are godmothers for the other 2 kids. The politics kill me sometimes lol

Posted 7/21/11 2:48 PM
 

LemonHead
Sour Girl

Member since 3/08

5271 total posts

Name:

Re: g-d parents

Posted by evrythng4areason

i dont have any..i'm christian but my church doesnt do godparents



Same here

Posted 7/21/11 2:52 PM
 

Otherme
Square head cutie pants

Member since 3/06

6899 total posts

Name:

Re: g-d parents

I don't have any, however i'm a godparent to 2 of my friends kids

DH and i decided not to have godparents for our upcoming baby (he's jewish, i'm not religious). Neither of us really feel there's a need for it for our situation

Posted 7/21/11 3:05 PM
 

Aries14
Can't plan life...

Member since 8/08

2860 total posts

Name:

Re: g-d parents

Posted by bonch20

Posted by luckysmom

We only did a baptism for my twins becuase it was important to my husband. To me though, my twins are neither catholic (what DH is) or Jewish ( which is technically what i am). He wanted his brother as a god parent and I wanted mine if i was going to be forced to have a baptism. We had twins which worked out perfectly. We chose my brother nad his wife for DS and his brother and his wife for DD. We pretty much picked who we thought would be good role models for our kids.



DH and I both have brothers...and we don't think we'll have another baby, so chosing between them is causing major tension....especially since religon is such a senstive topic.

Just don't want DD to loose out cause we can't make a choice...wanted to see if there were others without them.



I wouldn't NOT christen my baby just bc we couldn't make a decision like that. It's one thing if you dont believe in it but to not do it soley bc the two of you cant agree on whose brother to choose isn't fair to your DD (IMHO).

Message edited 2011-07-21 15:09:14.827000.

Posted 7/21/11 3:08 PM
 

bonch20
LIF Adult

Member since 9/09

1290 total posts

Name:
Bonnie

Re: g-d parents

Posted by Aries14

Posted by bonch20

Posted by luckysmom

We only did a baptism for my twins becuase it was important to my husband. To me though, my twins are neither catholic (what DH is) or Jewish ( which is technically what i am). He wanted his brother as a god parent and I wanted mine if i was going to be forced to have a baptism. We had twins which worked out perfectly. We chose my brother nad his wife for DS and his brother and his wife for DD. We pretty much picked who we thought would be good role models for our kids.



DH and I both have brothers...and we don't think we'll have another baby, so chosing between them is causing major tension....especially since religon is such a senstive topic.

Just don't want DD to loose out cause we can't make a choice...wanted to see if there were others without them.



I wouldn't NOT christen my baby just bc we couldn't make a decision like that. It's one thing if you dont believe in it but to not do it soley bc the two of you cant agree on whose brother to choose isn't fair to your DD (IMHO).




that's not what i said....i don't want DD to miss out on g-d parents....not the service

Posted 7/21/11 3:31 PM
 

Aries14
Can't plan life...

Member since 8/08

2860 total posts

Name:

Re: g-d parents

Posted by bonch20

Posted by Aries14

Posted by bonch20

Posted by luckysmom

We only did a baptism for my twins becuase it was important to my husband. To me though, my twins are neither catholic (what DH is) or Jewish ( which is technically what i am). He wanted his brother as a god parent and I wanted mine if i was going to be forced to have a baptism. We had twins which worked out perfectly. We chose my brother nad his wife for DS and his brother and his wife for DD. We pretty much picked who we thought would be good role models for our kids.



DH and I both have brothers...and we don't think we'll have another baby, so chosing between them is causing major tension....especially since religon is such a senstive topic.

Just don't want DD to loose out cause we can't make a choice...wanted to see if there were others without them.



I wouldn't NOT christen my baby just bc we couldn't make a decision like that. It's one thing if you dont believe in it but to not do it soley bc the two of you cant agree on whose brother to choose isn't fair to your DD (IMHO).




that's not what i said....i don't want DD to miss out on g-d parents....not the service



I got that. I wasnt talking about the service either.

Maybe I'm not understanding the issue. Do you want to christen your DD but the only thing that is standing in the way is that you both dont agree on which brother should be the godfather?

Posted 7/21/11 3:34 PM
 

Goldi0218
My miracles!

Member since 12/05

23902 total posts

Name:
Leslie

Re: g-d parents

We are Jewish as are our children. Abby does not have G-dparents. Jeremy had ceremonial participants for his bris - my brother and DH's sister. They held the baby before and after the ceremony. Many Jews call them G-dparents but they are not. They have roles in the religious ceremony, but technically none thereafter and should not be compared to G-dparenting in other faiths. It is, however a very high honor to be asked to do this and can be a source of strife in many families.

Message edited 2011-07-21 15:40:24.107000.

Posted 7/21/11 3:39 PM
 

luvmyReese
Hello Kitty

Member since 1/08

7542 total posts

Name:
Catt

Re: g-d parents

My DD does not have Godparents. We had her baptized regardless.

Posted 7/21/11 6:17 PM
 

luckysmom
Yes it is! Going as planned:)

Member since 6/07

5339 total posts

Name:

Re: g-d parents

Posted by bonch20

Posted by luckysmom

We only did a baptism for my twins becuase it was important to my husband. To me though, my twins are neither catholic (what DH is) or Jewish ( which is technically what i am). He wanted his brother as a god parent and I wanted mine if i was going to be forced to have a baptism. We had twins which worked out perfectly. We chose my brother nad his wife for DS and his brother and his wife for DD. We pretty much picked who we thought would be good role models for our kids.



DH and I both have brothers...and we don't think we'll have another baby, so chosing between them is causing major tension....especially since religon is such a senstive topic.

Just don't want DD to loose out cause we can't make a choice...wanted to see if there were others without them.



Well, which one of them would teach you're DD they way you would want? For me it was important that our twins are not taught just about Catholosism but other religions as well. I don't believe in the catholic church and I want my kids to be able to pick their own religion. The only reason we did the baptism was because DH wanted them to have some sort of blessing. We could have done some other kind of ceremony but he wanted it this way. But we both agreed that noone will impose religion on our kids and they'll learn about other religionsand decide from there. All sets of god parents agreed so we're happy.

Posted 7/21/11 6:26 PM
 

peanutbutter2
Carpe diem!

Member since 11/10

5287 total posts

Name:

Re: g-d parents

Could you maybe have two godfathers? I know in the Catholic Church, you can only have one person stand as godfather, but you can maybe consider them both godfathers?

For example: I'm Catholic. However, my godmother is Protestant and my godfather is Christian Science. In the Catholic Church, at least one Catholic has to stand at the ceremony. Therefore, my Grandfather stood as my godfather at the ceremony, so while on paper I have one godfather, in my mind and in my life, I have two.

Would something like that work for you? Perhaps have the more religious of the brothers stand at the ceremony but consider both of them godfathers?

Posted 7/21/11 7:23 PM
 

Sweetlax22
LIF Adult

Member since 5/10

1904 total posts

Name:

Re: g-d parents

I might try to figure out how to let both have the title.

Posted 7/21/11 8:55 PM
 

watersdeb04
Back to school is here

Member since 12/07

1052 total posts

Name:
Deb

Re: g-d parents

I see no problem with having 2 godparents of the same gender. I would check with your pastor/priest and see if they have some advice.

Posted 7/22/11 10:55 AM
 

RocPin
Life's Beachy <3

Member since 2/08

6765 total posts

Name:
Heather

Re: g-d parents

DH and I are not religious therefor see no reason to christen or assign godparents.

My father is religious so if he wants to take on the responsibility of teaching my child about religion, he can have at it.

Posted 7/22/11 11:02 AM
 

bonch20
LIF Adult

Member since 9/09

1290 total posts

Name:
Bonnie

Re: g-d parents

thanks ladies, having both of them might be an option....i just did a little research and actually the jewish tradition doesn't include g-d parents (odd since i have them!). i'm not too religious but i feel a baby naming is important...so she has a blessing of somesort. when she's older she can choose whatever she wants. i will speak with the rabbi and see what she says.

Posted 7/22/11 11:04 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Who here has parents who were born in a different country? Moehick 9/2/05 26 Families Helping Families ™
If your parents were married, how old were they? Janice 9/1/05 108 Families Helping Families ™
How is it that 2 kids, from the same parents can be so different? Scotty-CassidysMom 8/10/05 7 Families Helping Families ™
Do you tell your parents EVERYTHING about your inlaws? Janice 8/8/05 27 Families Helping Families ™
Need Some Ideas?? Having a surprise 40th Anniversary party for my parents this month.... maybride2004 8/4/05 10 Families Helping Families ™
When you get Pg how do you plan to tell your Dh and parents? 04bride 7/12/05 7 TTC