For whoever got the flu shot

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2]

lala01
LIF Toddler

Member since 11/08

433 total posts

Name:

Re: For whoever got the flu shot

Got it yesterday...now I have a SORE arm!Chat Icon

Posted 10/1/09 9:01 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

mommyIam

Member since 7/09

9209 total posts

Name:
Shana

Re: For whoever got the flu shot

Posted by itsbabytime

Despite this complete lack of research, it is recommended for these moms anyway. Anyone see a problem with that?



There is a problem with it for sure, but how do you solve it? Its considered highly unethical to research or test anything on pregnant women.

There are no drugs ever tested on pregnant women, have you noticed how even Tylenol is a class B drug. Its never been tested on Pregnant women, would you have issues taking it?

see this article on drugs ratings for pregnancy

But the problem with swine flu vaccine is that while it is being studied, they haven't studied it as carefully as the usual flu vaccine.

Posted by JoJo2010

...but then when the person I know got the SHOT and got the flu it kind of scares me!



You can get the flu shot and at still get the flu! BUT not from the shot! The flu shot doesn't protect you from all flu strains, It protect you from the one the CDC predicts is the most prevalent that season. That's why you're told to get it every year.

Posted 10/1/09 9:31 AM
 

itsbabytime
LIF Adult

Member since 11/05

9644 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: For whoever got the flu shot

Posted by momytobein2010

Posted by itsbabytime

Despite this complete lack of research, it is recommended for these moms anyway. Anyone see a problem with that?



There is a problem with it for sure, but how do you solve it? Its considered highly unethical to research or test anything on pregnant women.

There are no drugs ever tested on pregnant women, have you noticed how even Tylenol is a class B drug. Its never been tested on Pregnant women, would you have issues taking it?

see this article on drugs ratings for pregnancy

But the problem with swine flu vaccine is that while it is being studied, they haven't studied it as carefully as the usual flu vaccine.




I see what you are saying but MANY women already get the flu shot while pregnant - so they are in effect testing the drugs just without being studied - what is the difference if they actually monitored these women in mass to see down the line if the baby had issues or if there were a large number in that group that did - in a sense for years - these woman ARE testing the shots - just nobody is studying them.

And, honestly, no - I don't take anything that is not absolutely necessary during pregnancy (like if I have an infection I would obviously have to take an antibiotic) - especially stuff that has never been tested. So , no, I have never taken a tylenol - not my last pregnancy and not this one.

Posted 10/1/09 10:10 AM
 

mommyIam

Member since 7/09

9209 total posts

Name:
Shana

Re: For whoever got the flu shot

Posted by itsbabytime

I see what you are saying but MANY women already get the flu shot while pregnant - so they are in effect testing the drugs just without being studied - what is the difference if they actually monitored these women in mass to see down the line if the baby had issues or if there were a large number in that group that did - in a sense for years - these woman ARE testing the shots - just nobody is studying them.



Your right, but scientific testing requires a monitored study with control group, and statistics to verify the outcome. If you just follow them around its only correlation, not evidence.

The industry standard way to test a drug is double blind study. You can't tell pregnant women, we might or might not give you the flu shot, but we'll monitor you.

Posted by itsbabytime

And, honestly, no - I don't take anything that is not absolutely necessary during pregnancy (like if I have an infection I would obviously have to take an antibiotic) - especially stuff that has never been tested. So , no, I have never taken a tylenol - not my last pregnancy and not this one.



Well I didn't mean you personally, I meant in general. I think we all have our own boundaries with our doctors on what we will and won't take.
And sometimes the risk of taking something that is not completely tested, overweighs the risk of serious complications due to illness.

Personally, though, I feel exactly the way you do. I wouldn't take a drug even for gas. Even when DH told me its given to newborns. I blew him off and said I rather suffer a little than risk a lot. But flu is deadly in pregnant women, so its been weighing on my mind.

Posted 10/1/09 10:24 AM
 
Pages: 1 [2]
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Ladies, have you gotton your flu shot and where? peabody 11/19/07 12 Pregnancy
What are the side effects of the flu shot?? missrock 11/14/07 8 Parenting
what was your baby's reaction to the flu shot? LoveBeingMrsT 11/5/07 9 Parenting
Egg based flu shot? Should I give him eggs first? Janice 9/30/07 10 Parenting
Did you/Will you pay a copay for the flu shot? 4monkeys 12/11/06 14 Parenting
Anyone know where I can get a Mercury-free flu shot? Cookiegobbler 10/28/06 0 Pregnancy