Flag burning

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2 3

Shanti
True love

Member since 6/05

12653 total posts

Name:

Flag burning

Though it is something I would never do, I do think that burning the flag is an expression of free speech and should not be banned:

flag burning

Posted 6/27/06 12:40 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

unknown1
****

Member since 5/05

2771 total posts

Name:
lisa

Re: Flag burning

Many veterans, he said, see "disrespect for the American flag as disrespect for them, as disrespect for the sacrifices that they and their buddies have made."



I agree with this and not for nothing if it wasn't for them they wouldn't be living free.. so I don't think it should be freedom of speech it should be considered a crime

Posted 6/27/06 12:44 PM
 

Shanti
True love

Member since 6/05

12653 total posts

Name:

Re: Flag burning

Posted by unbelievable

Many veterans, he said, see "disrespect for the American flag as disrespect for them, as disrespect for the sacrifices that they and their buddies have made."



I agree with this and not for nothing if it wasn't for them they wouldn't be living free.. so I don't think it should be freedom of speech it should be considered a crime




Not all veterans are offended. My uncle is a Vietnam War vet and he said he fought against communism so people have the right to express themselves. He is opposed to this measure to ban flag burning. Like most segments of the population, veterans do not all agree on one topic.

Message edited 2006-06-27 12:47:18.200000.

Posted 6/27/06 12:46 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Flag burning

While I can't see myself burning a flag, I don't think we need to ban it. I say it's protected under free speech. I suppose they're going to have exemptions when we dispose of them since that's the proper way. I could see the flag burners now saying "I was disposing of it according to the guidelines."

Stupid ammendment. Pass something better like including sexual orientation under equal rights.

Posted 6/27/06 12:48 PM
 

dpli
Daylight savings :)

Member since 5/05

13973 total posts

Name:
D

Re: Flag burning

I do see it as disrespectful to soldiers and veterans and Americans in general. I also see it as such a violent expression that I associate it with terrorism.

However, I also think it is a freedom of speech issue and that a constitutional amendment is unnecessary. It will be interesting to see how this pans out. This has bee tried before, without success, but Congress is pretty conservative these days, so it may have a chance of passing.

Posted 6/27/06 12:48 PM
 

Snozberry
I might steal your diamonds

Member since 2/06

4680 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Flag burning

To ban flag burning is in violation of the first amendment. It's not something I would personally do but free speech also protects the speech that we hate.

First they vote to ban gay marriage, now flag burning? Don't we have much more pressing issues to contend with in this country?

Posted 6/27/06 12:49 PM
 

Shanti
True love

Member since 6/05

12653 total posts

Name:

Re: Flag burning

Don't we have much more pressing issues to contend with in this country?

You would think so!

Posted 6/27/06 12:49 PM
 

momAGAIN
so outrageous

Member since 7/05

3853 total posts

Name:
TJ

Re: Flag burning

I see it as complete disrespect for our country

Posted 6/27/06 12:50 PM
 

unknown1
****

Member since 5/05

2771 total posts

Name:
lisa

Re: Flag burning

Posted by DMcK

Posted by unbelievable

Many veterans, he said, see "disrespect for the American flag as disrespect for them, as disrespect for the sacrifices that they and their buddies have made."



I agree with this and not for nothing if it wasn't for them they wouldn't be living free.. so I don't think it should be freedom of speech it should be considered a crime




Not all veterans are offended. My uncle is a Vietnam War vet and he said he fought against communism so people have the right to express themselves. He is opposed to this. Like most segments of the population, veterans do not all agree on one topic.




Yes I understand that but it is a derogatory action that is mean spirited and imo harsh. My FFIL id a vietnam vet and what he endured was horrible He suffers from PTSD he also got malaria and shot in the head (he received a purple heart) and I have to tell you if he saw people burning the flag I tink it would push him over it is like mocking everything he had done

Posted 6/27/06 12:50 PM
 

Shanti
True love

Member since 6/05

12653 total posts

Name:

Re: Flag burning

Posted by unbelievable

Posted by DMcK

Posted by unbelievable

Many veterans, he said, see "disrespect for the American flag as disrespect for them, as disrespect for the sacrifices that they and their buddies have made."



I agree with this and not for nothing if it wasn't for them they wouldn't be living free.. so I don't think it should be freedom of speech it should be considered a crime




Not all veterans are offended. My uncle is a Vietnam War vet and he said he fought against communism so people have the right to express themselves. He is opposed to this. Like most segments of the population, veterans do not all agree on one topic.




Yes I understand that but it is a derogatory action that is mean spirited and imo harsh. My FFIL id a vietnam vet and what he endured was horrible He suffers from PTSD he also got malaria and shot in the head (he received a purple heart) and I have to tell you if he saw people burning the flag I tink it would push him over it is like mocking everything he had done



I hear you. I think we live in the greatest country on earth and I would never do it... I just think it falls under free speech, which is one of the things that makes our country so great.

Posted 6/27/06 12:51 PM
 

unknown1
****

Member since 5/05

2771 total posts

Name:
lisa

Re: Flag burning

Posted by DMcK

Posted by unbelievable

Posted by DMcK

Posted by unbelievable

Many veterans, he said, see "disrespect for the American flag as disrespect for them, as disrespect for the sacrifices that they and their buddies have made."



I agree with this and not for nothing if it wasn't for them they wouldn't be living free.. so I don't think it should be freedom of speech it should be considered a crime




Not all veterans are offended. My uncle is a Vietnam War vet and he said he fought against communism so people have the right to express themselves. He is opposed to this. Like most segments of the population, veterans do not all agree on one topic.




Yes I understand that but it is a derogatory action that is mean spirited and imo harsh. My FFIL id a vietnam vet and what he endured was horrible He suffers from PTSD he also got malaria and shot in the head (he received a purple heart) and I have to tell you if he saw people burning the flag I tink it would push him over it is like mocking everything he had done



I hear you. I think we live in the greatest country on earth and I would never do it... I just think it falls under free speech, which is one of the things that makes our country so great.



And I do see your point I just think people do mean things and hide behind the first ammendment.. yes freedom of speech is what was fought for but we thn in turn disrespect it ??? (no you I mean the flagburners)

Posted 6/27/06 12:54 PM
 

Shanti
True love

Member since 6/05

12653 total posts

Name:

Re: Flag burning

Posted by unbelievable

Posted by DMcK

Posted by unbelievable

Posted by DMcK

Posted by unbelievable

Many veterans, he said, see "disrespect for the American flag as disrespect for them, as disrespect for the sacrifices that they and their buddies have made."



I agree with this and not for nothing if it wasn't for them they wouldn't be living free.. so I don't think it should be freedom of speech it should be considered a crime




Not all veterans are offended. My uncle is a Vietnam War vet and he said he fought against communism so people have the right to express themselves. He is opposed to this. Like most segments of the population, veterans do not all agree on one topic.




Yes I understand that but it is a derogatory action that is mean spirited and imo harsh. My FFIL id a vietnam vet and what he endured was horrible He suffers from PTSD he also got malaria and shot in the head (he received a purple heart) and I have to tell you if he saw people burning the flag I tink it would push him over it is like mocking everything he had done



I hear you. I think we live in the greatest country on earth and I would never do it... I just think it falls under free speech, which is one of the things that makes our country so great.



And I do see your point I just think people do mean things and hide behind the first ammendment.. yes freedom of speech is what was fought for but we thn in turn disrespect it ??? (no you I mean the flagburners)



I know what you mean but one of the things about free speech is that you don't have to like it. Offensive and hateful speech is all part of it. We could go in circles all day, I understand your point and you understand mine - we just disagree that it is a free speech issue.

Posted 6/27/06 12:56 PM
 

Moehick
Ready for the sun!

Member since 5/05

30339 total posts

Name:
Properly perfect™

Re: Flag burning

When you think of all the people who have dies throughout the centuries protecting that flag and everything it stood for I find it disgusting that anyone would want to burn it.

But hey people love knocking over headstones and desecrating cemeteries and religious buildings too....just goes to show how flucked up people are.

Posted 6/27/06 12:59 PM
 

unknown1
****

Member since 5/05

2771 total posts

Name:
lisa

Re: Flag burning

Posted by DMcK

Posted by unbelievable

Posted by DMcK

Posted by unbelievable

Posted by DMcK

Posted by unbelievable

Many veterans, he said, see "disrespect for the American flag as disrespect for them, as disrespect for the sacrifices that they and their buddies have made."



I agree with this and not for nothing if it wasn't for them they wouldn't be living free.. so I don't think it should be freedom of speech it should be considered a crime




Not all veterans are offended. My uncle is a Vietnam War vet and he said he fought against communism so people have the right to express themselves. He is opposed to this. Like most segments of the population, veterans do not all agree on one topic.




Yes I understand that but it is a derogatory action that is mean spirited and imo harsh. My FFIL id a vietnam vet and what he endured was horrible He suffers from PTSD he also got malaria and shot in the head (he received a purple heart) and I have to tell you if he saw people burning the flag I tink it would push him over it is like mocking everything he had done



I hear you. I think we live in the greatest country on earth and I would never do it... I just think it falls under free speech, which is one of the things that makes our country so great.



And I do see your point I just think people do mean things and hide behind the first ammendment.. yes freedom of speech is what was fought for but we thn in turn disrespect it ??? (no you I mean the flagburners)



I know what you mean but one of the things about free speech is that you don't have to like it. Offensive and hateful speech is all part of it. We could go in circles all day, I understand your point and you understand mine - we just disagree that it is a free speech issue.



This was probably the first debate where I agrred to disagree .. I must be maturing LOL Chat Icon

Posted 6/27/06 1:01 PM
 

Lisa
I'm a PANK!!!

Member since 5/05

22334 total posts

Name:
Professional Aunts No Kids

Re: Flag burning

Posted by momAGAIN

I see it as complete disrespect for our country



I totally agree!!

I really do not see how burning a flag is freedom of speech. If you dont like the counrty you live in, then find another one that you like better! Chat Icon

Posted 6/27/06 1:02 PM
 

Shanti
True love

Member since 6/05

12653 total posts

Name:

Re: Flag burning

Posted by unbelievable

Posted by DMcK

Posted by unbelievable

Posted by DMcK

Posted by unbelievable

Posted by DMcK

Posted by unbelievable

Many veterans, he said, see "disrespect for the American flag as disrespect for them, as disrespect for the sacrifices that they and their buddies have made."



I agree with this and not for nothing if it wasn't for them they wouldn't be living free.. so I don't think it should be freedom of speech it should be considered a crime




Not all veterans are offended. My uncle is a Vietnam War vet and he said he fought against communism so people have the right to express themselves. He is opposed to this. Like most segments of the population, veterans do not all agree on one topic.




Yes I understand that but it is a derogatory action that is mean spirited and imo harsh. My FFIL id a vietnam vet and what he endured was horrible He suffers from PTSD he also got malaria and shot in the head (he received a purple heart) and I have to tell you if he saw people burning the flag I tink it would push him over it is like mocking everything he had done



I hear you. I think we live in the greatest country on earth and I would never do it... I just think it falls under free speech, which is one of the things that makes our country so great.



And I do see your point I just think people do mean things and hide behind the first ammendment.. yes freedom of speech is what was fought for but we thn in turn disrespect it ??? (no you I mean the flagburners)



I know what you mean but one of the things about free speech is that you don't have to like it. Offensive and hateful speech is all part of it. We could go in circles all day, I understand your point and you understand mine - we just disagree that it is a free speech issue.



This was probably the first debate where I agrred to disagree .. I must be maturing LOL Chat Icon



Chat Icon

Posted 6/27/06 1:02 PM
 

FireIslandLove

Member since 5/05

12119 total posts

Name:

Re: Flag burning

Posted by Lisa

Posted by momAGAIN

I see it as complete disrespect for our country



I totally agree!!

I really do not see how burning a flag is freedom of speech. If you dont like the counrty you live in, then find another one that you like better! Chat Icon


Good point! In England you cannot speak against the Queen, the least you could do here is not burn the flag!

Posted 6/27/06 1:04 PM
 

SweetestOfPeas
J'taime Paris!

Member since 3/06

32345 total posts

Name:

Re: Flag burning

just out of curiosity, how does burning a flag fall under the catergory of "free speech"? Chat Icon

you'e not saying anything, you're burning something.

and IMO, American flag burners put themselves in the same category as Palestinian or other arabs who burn our flag. what is the image they're aiming for? Chat Icon

Posted 6/27/06 1:05 PM
 

Shanti
True love

Member since 6/05

12653 total posts

Name:

Re: Flag burning

This article summed up how I feel:

newsweek

Posted 6/27/06 1:07 PM
 

jilmadison
Another on the way!

Member since 3/06

1267 total posts

Name:

Re: Flag burning

Posted by Lisa

Posted by momAGAIN

I see it as complete disrespect for our country



I totally agree!!

I really do not see how burning a flag is freedom of speech. If you dont like the counrty you live in, then find another one that you like better! Chat Icon



I agree.

Posted 6/27/06 1:12 PM
 

Sassyz75
Turning a new page

Member since 5/05

9731 total posts

Name:
Dina

Re: Flag burning

#1- we have a lot bigger things to worry about- another example of how the Republican adminstration sends up these "smoke screen" issues to get America's mind off of REAL issues.
#2- if we do ban flag desecration- it really says something of us as a country b/c the only OTHER countries in the ENTIRE WORLD that ban this are:
Cuba, China & Iran- do we really want to have the same liberties THEY do?

edited to add- i'm really glad that our government (congress) can vote themselves a raise, vote DOWN a raise in minimum raise, and then continue to push issues that don't do a THING to help the Americans that need the help- it's ridiculous- and I think it's insulting to the veterans that fight for freedom that this issue would be so important to them that they'd rather have this amendment then something done for those that really need it.

Message edited 2006-06-27 13:31:41.903000.

Posted 6/27/06 1:30 PM
 

Snozberry
I might steal your diamonds

Member since 2/06

4680 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Flag burning

Posted by SweetestOfPeas

just out of curiosity, how does burning a flag fall under the catergory of "free speech"? Chat Icon

you'e not saying anything, you're burning something.



Free speech includes freedom of expression.

Civil disobedience, flag burning, the hood of a KKK member, works of art - all are worlds apart but, without words, leave a [varied but] profound impression.

If they weren't 'saying' anything, then I don't think that it would elicit such a reaction from people.

Posted 6/27/06 1:33 PM
 

CookiePuss
Cake from Outer Space!

Member since 5/05

14021 total posts

Name:

Re: Flag burning

Posted by unbelievable


And I do see your point I just think people do mean things and hide behind the first ammendment.. yes freedom of speech is what was fought for but we thn in turn disrespect it ??? (no you I mean the flagburners)



I agree with this and, not all speech is protected by the first amendment. I find it ironic that they are burning a symbol of the very government that they are trying to use to protect them.

Posted 6/27/06 1:34 PM
 

Shanti
True love

Member since 6/05

12653 total posts

Name:

Re: Flag burning

Posted by Sassyz75

#1- we have a lot bigger things to worry about- another example of how the Republican adminstration sends up these "smoke screen" issues to get America's mind off of REAL issues.
#2- if we do ban flag desecration- it really says something of us as a country b/c the only OTHER countries in the ENTIRE WORLD that ban this are:
Cuba, China & Iran- do we really want to have the same liberties THEY do?

edited to add- i'm really glad that our government (congress) can vote themselves a raise, vote DOWN a raise in minimum raise, and then continue to push issues that don't do a THING to help the Americans that need the help- it's ridiculous- and I think it's insulting to the veterans that fight for freedom that this issue would be so important to them that they'd rather have this amendment then something done for those that really need it.



Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 6/27/06 1:35 PM
 

Sassyz75
Turning a new page

Member since 5/05

9731 total posts

Name:
Dina

Re: Flag burning

if they ban flag desecration- what is next? what about the use of a flag in a work of art- if anyone finds that offensive- is that unprotected speech? What if someone is protesting the war and using the flag- is that unprotected speech b/c it is linked with something that isn't "positive"? why should the government be able to legislate in a way that is open to interpretation to take away our rights?

Posted 6/27/06 1:36 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2 3
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Senate rejects flag burning ban by one vote Snozberry 6/27/06 0 Families Helping Families ™
DVD Burning nrthshgrl 2/23/06 1 Families Helping Families ™
DVD Burning question... neenie 2/17/06 2 Families Helping Families ™
Burning yourself with TOO much info... PrincessP 2/15/06 1 Families Helping Families ™
Stoves CowgirlChick97 1/5/06 1 Home
D A M N You, Non-Working FM Flag!! mrswask 11/30/05 1 Families Helping Families ™