EI moms come in please

Posted By Message

Diana1215
Living on a prayer!!!

Member since 10/05

29450 total posts

Name:
Diana

EI moms come in please

How do you know if the therapist just isn't right for your child? Or if he just doesn't like having to "work"

I am so torn. I like her....I don't think he does. He basically whines/cries one day that she is here a week. He is fine the second day.

I don't know if it's because she pushes him and he doesn't want to be pushed to play....or if he would get along better with another therapist.

All I can say is that I dread Tuesdays/Thursdays.

What do you think?

Posted 4/23/09 11:19 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Merf99
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

3380 total posts

Name:

Re: EI moms come in please

We don't do EI, we do private but when the speech therapist comes over, my DD (who has been in speech with this therapist for almost a year and who loves her) will still cling to me or my nanny for a few minutes, then once she gets settled in, she's fine. If he's crying throughout the entire session and it's been a month or two, then that might be a problem.

Posted 4/23/09 11:27 AM
 

Diana1215
Living on a prayer!!!

Member since 10/05

29450 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: EI moms come in please

Posted by Merf99

We don't do EI, we do private but when the speech therapist comes over, my DD (who has been in speech with this therapist for almost a year and who loves her) will still cling to me or my nanny for a few minutes, then once she gets settled in, she's fine. If he's crying throughout the entire session and it's been a month or two, then that might be a problem.



Yea - he has a session with her now and has been crying and yelling for 25 minutes. How do I go about knowing if another therapist would be any better at clicking with him though?

Posted 4/23/09 11:28 AM
 

lbelle821
Arghhhhh

Member since 2/06

5285 total posts

Name:
Lisa

Re: EI moms come in please

My son has the same problem with any therapist and so that is why I have his sessions at daycare when I'm not around (i know that your situation is different).

Can you tell why he is yelling? Is it because he is afraid of her? Is she making him do stuff he doesn't want to? Does he want you?

All kids are different. My son is a few weeks younger than Jack but I know he has extreme separation anxiety from me so that this for what it's worth. If I saw that the therapist was being unkind or cold to him I might consider a new one. however, for us I'm pretty sure Matthew would react the same way to Mother Theresa as he would to Cruella Deville. And it's a tricky thing and one of the reasons why he isn't getting full blown speech therapy just yet (he is doing what they call developmental intervention). His therapist (who I love and who he loves as long as I"m not there) really feels strongly that he is too young and doesn't have enough of an attention span yet for speech therapy.

Again, could have much to do with Matthew and his personality so I'm not saying Jack is the same, but what I'm saying is that because they're still young he may have the same reaction to anyone because they're not so much into someone coming into their home, mommy going away and telling them what to do in a structured manner. KWIM?

Posted 4/23/09 12:47 PM
 

Diana1215
Living on a prayer!!!

Member since 10/05

29450 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: EI moms come in please

His problem is he wants to play with the toys he wants to play with -- when she makes him "work" for things that he doesn't want to do "Ex: point to specific animals that she is holding or in a book" he yells because he would rather be playing with Mr. Potato Head (and just points to her bag the entire time.

After I wrote this post we did make some major progress with him though. She has been doing the sign for "Give Me" since day one -- he would always put his arm out for her to do it on him - he has been doing it nonstop today. One teeny step forward!

I think I never thought that this would be so stressful. I saw it as someone coming in and playing with him - and she does - but she makes him work hard - and he's not used to that! Chat Icon

Posted 4/23/09 12:50 PM
 

lbelle821
Arghhhhh

Member since 2/06

5285 total posts

Name:
Lisa

Re: EI moms come in please

Posted by Diana1215

His problem is he wants to play with the toys he wants to play with -- when she makes him "work" for things that he doesn't want to do "Ex: point to specific animals that she is holding or in a book" he yells because he would rather be playing with Mr. Potato Head (and just points to her bag the entire time.

After I wrote this post we did make some major progress with him though. She has been doing the sign for "Give Me" since day one -- he would always put his arm out for her to do it on him - he has been doing it nonstop today. One teeny step forward!

I think I never thought that this would be so stressful. I saw it as someone coming in and playing with him - and she does - but she makes him work hard - and he's not used to that! Chat Icon




I know what you mean --- Matthew's therapy is very interactive and she is tough with him because he can sometimes really be tough! She trys as best she can to incorporate what he likes into the therapy as a motivator and attention grabber and it really does work!.

That's great that he got the sign!!! I know how exciting it is.

Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 4/23/09 12:56 PM
 

Diana1215
Living on a prayer!!!

Member since 10/05

29450 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: EI moms come in please

Posted by lbelle821

Posted by Diana1215

His problem is he wants to play with the toys he wants to play with -- when she makes him "work" for things that he doesn't want to do "Ex: point to specific animals that she is holding or in a book" he yells because he would rather be playing with Mr. Potato Head (and just points to her bag the entire time.

After I wrote this post we did make some major progress with him though. She has been doing the sign for "Give Me" since day one -- he would always put his arm out for her to do it on him - he has been doing it nonstop today. One teeny step forward!

I think I never thought that this would be so stressful. I saw it as someone coming in and playing with him - and she does - but she makes him work hard - and he's not used to that! Chat Icon




I know what you mean --- Matthew's therapy is very interactive and she is tough with him because he can sometimes really be tough! She trys as best she can to incorporate what he likes into the therapy as a motivator and attention grabber and it really does work!.

That's great that he got the sign!!! I know how exciting it is.

Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon



Yes - she has to be tough with Jack too otherwise she has no shot Chat Icon

Tomorrow we are attempting playdoh for the first time with her....should be interestingChat Icon

Posted 4/23/09 1:00 PM
 

dottiemchugh
<3

Member since 5/05

8261 total posts

Name:

Re: EI moms come in please

Posted by Diana1215

His problem is he wants to play with the toys he wants to play with -- when she makes him "work" for things that he doesn't want to do "Ex: point to specific animals that she is holding or in a book" he yells because he would rather be playing with Mr. Potato Head (and just points to her bag the entire time.

After I wrote this post we did make some major progress with him though. She has been doing the sign for "Give Me" since day one -- he would always put his arm out for her to do it on him - he has been doing it nonstop today. One teeny step forward!

I think I never thought that this would be so stressful. I saw it as someone coming in and playing with him - and she does - but she makes him work hard - and he's not used to that! Chat Icon



I know exactly what you mean. Ry's old speech therapist was like this. They just did not click. She didn't "get" Ryan and would always annoy him by trying to force him to do something, and he would just scream and tantrum. It was a nightmare. I actually discussed it with Ry's special instruction therapist, and she stated that I could change if I wasn't happy. I ALMOST did, but stuck with her because I knew within a month he would be going into a center based program, and we would be done with her.

Looking back, I should have changed earlier. It was very stressful when she was there and Ry just would flip out the entire session, and would be FINE with the other therapist.

Posted 4/23/09 1:12 PM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: EI moms come in please

We have the same issue. DS starts whining the minutes he sees some therapists and one he does not. Sometimes it's good. Sometimes he freaks out. Sometimes I have to leave the room so he cannot see me and he can focus.

We have 6 therapists (I fired one of them last week!). So eventually we will be back to 7.

I think DS does not understand yet that it's supposed to be fun to do exercices, etc.. He does see as work. Having to stay still in a chair is work for him. All he wants to do is do whatever he wants...i.e. not being asked to do something he did not think to do by himself.

Also, our Team Leader is also here on Wednesday and Friday. So it's the same as you. On Wednesday, it has been 4 days since he last saw her. So it's like all over again. On Fridays, the time lapse in only 2 days, so he is better on Fridays with her. Maybe that could be the issue. Too much time between Thursday and Tuesday.

Posted 4/23/09 1:42 PM
 

greenybeans
:)

Member since 8/06

6435 total posts

Name:

Re: EI moms come in please

How long has he been working with her?

Lance's speech therapist is great with him. She is only really structured if she has to be. Usually it's a very relaxed approach, and she gets sooo much out of him.

I would think about changing if he is crying through 25 minutes of a session.

Posted 4/23/09 1:44 PM
 

Diana1215
Living on a prayer!!!

Member since 10/05

29450 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: EI moms come in please

Posted by smdl



Also, our Team Leader is also here on Wednesday and Friday. So it's the same as you. On Wednesday, it has been 4 days since he last saw her. So it's like all over again. On Fridays, the time lapse in only 2 days, so he is better on Fridays with her. Maybe that could be the issue. Too much time between Thursday and Tuesday.



I absolutely think that there is too much time between the Thursday and the Tuesday. She also wasn't here this Tuesday (is making it up tomorrow) - so it was a week since he saw her last.

He is a mess on Tuesdays normally and great on Thursdays!

Posted 4/23/09 1:51 PM
 

Diana1215
Living on a prayer!!!

Member since 10/05

29450 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: EI moms come in please

Posted by KerriSteve

How long has he been working with her?

Lance's speech therapist is great with him. She is only really structured if she has to be. Usually it's a very relaxed approach, and she gets sooo much out of him.

I would think about changing if he is crying through 25 minutes of a session.



Since the first week of March - almost two months!

Posted 4/23/09 1:51 PM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: EI moms come in please

Posted by Diana1215

Posted by smdl



Also, our Team Leader is also here on Wednesday and Friday. So it's the same as you. On Wednesday, it has been 4 days since he last saw her. So it's like all over again. On Fridays, the time lapse in only 2 days, so he is better on Fridays with her. Maybe that could be the issue. Too much time between Thursday and Tuesday.



I absolutely think that there is too much time between the Thursday and the Tuesday. She also wasn't here this Tuesday (is making it up tomorrow) - so it was a week since he saw her last.

He is a mess on Tuesdays normally and great on Thursdays!




If he is great on the 2nd day, then it's not really her. I think it's could be the lapse of time from one week to another.

Posted 4/23/09 1:59 PM
 

dm24angel
Happiness

Member since 5/05

34581 total posts

Name:
Donna

Re: EI moms come in please

Its so hard to say. I do know I must leave the room or Noah will not cooperate with her as well.

And somedays he will throw a fit. I go in another room with the door closed....but he has never cried for more then 2-3 min.'s tops.

But one of our issues is "attending" to activities...focusing on only one thing at a time and we work on it every session. He will ( as Jack will , as ALL 2 yr olds will) get upset when a toy is changed but she makes sure to occupy him in what the new toy is so well , he quickly forgets about the old one.

Our Therapist is VERY animated and loud and she distracts him very quickly and she knows to move from one thing to the next very quickly, almost to not give him time to think about it.

Plus b/c it is an issue that might stand in his way she likes for us to spend 5-10 minutes a day trying to get him to stick with an activity we WANT more...and it has worked wonders in a very short time.

If it was an issue like what your saying and not fun anymore, he is not gonna learn as much and I think in this situation it would be best to speak to her about focusing more on attending for a bit b/c it upsets you to see him upset.
Chat Icon Chat Icon

eta- Even though its a typical 2 yr old behavior , I think the therapist has to be much more flexible with kids their age and adjust to his frustrations. A typical "attending" period for his age should not be more then 3-5 min's on one thing TOPS...Thats all they can handle. Is that what she is doing?

Message edited 2009-04-23 14:02:05.790000.

Posted 4/23/09 1:59 PM
 

greenybeans
:)

Member since 8/06

6435 total posts

Name:

Re: EI moms come in please

Posted by Diana1215

Posted by KerriSteve

How long has he been working with her?

Lance's speech therapist is great with him. She is only really structured if she has to be. Usually it's a very relaxed approach, and she gets sooo much out of him.

I would think about changing if he is crying through 25 minutes of a session.



Since the first week of March - almost two months!




2 months is a fair amount of time. She might not be the best fit for him.

I can only tell you from my experience that therapy is usually fun for them. IMHO, they learn better when they enjoy what they are doing. Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 4/23/09 2:09 PM
 

dm24angel
Happiness

Member since 5/05

34581 total posts

Name:
Donna

Re: EI moms come in please

Posted by KerriSteve

Posted by Diana1215

Posted by KerriSteve

How long has he been working with her?

Lance's speech therapist is great with him. She is only really structured if she has to be. Usually it's a very relaxed approach, and she gets sooo much out of him.

I would think about changing if he is crying through 25 minutes of a session.



Since the first week of March - almost two months!




2 months is a fair amount of time. She might not be the best fit for him.

I can only tell you from my experience that therapy is usually fun for them. IMHO, they learn better when they enjoy what they are doing. Chat Icon Chat Icon



On that Note, does he get excited when he see's her? Like he knows she has toys etc?

Noah runs to open the door when Ours comes and jumps and giggles...She is like the toy lady.

If Jack does show signs of liking her that way, then it could just be something he will grow out of if she works harder at being flexible.

Posted 4/23/09 2:11 PM
 

Diana1215
Living on a prayer!!!

Member since 10/05

29450 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: EI moms come in please

He does get excited when he sees her....he goes right into her bag and starts pulling out the toys he wants.

She is good - when he is done he will start cleaning up - and she is fine with that and moves onto another toy.

I don't know if I'm explaining it exactly the right way. When she is doing something he really enjoys he seems to like her. When it's something she kind of forces on him to try and get a response that she wants - that's when he has a fit. She also started doing the harder things in the beginning of the session - versus the end.

I just don't know anymore! Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 4/23/09 2:17 PM
 

dm24angel
Happiness

Member since 5/05

34581 total posts

Name:
Donna

Re: EI moms come in please

Posted by Diana1215

He does get excited when he sees her....he goes right into her bag and starts pulling out the toys he wants.

She is good - when he is done he will start cleaning up - and she is fine with that and moves onto another toy.

I don't know if I'm explaining it exactly the right way. When she is doing something he really enjoys he seems to like her. When it's something she kind of forces on him to try and get a response that she wants - that's when he has a fit. She also started doing the harder things in the beginning of the session - versus the end.

I just don't know anymore! Chat Icon Chat Icon




ahh gotcha....Well Yes Noah does that too but she is not so rigid with it, b/c spending too mcuh time onit if he is not gonna have it is not worth it.

YET my son will only make a sound when you push him HARD, other wise he stays mute, so she does push him.

Wow, Its really hard to say in your situation.

I think no harm can come from talking to her and saying your a bit bothered by how upsethe is, is this normal, is there something you can do to help etc and see how she feels or WHAT she is trying to accomplish kwim?

Posted 4/23/09 2:19 PM
 

Diana1215
Living on a prayer!!!

Member since 10/05

29450 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: EI moms come in please

I did tell her that I want them to start doing different activities - that he may have a little more fun doing.

I have playdoh for them. And this coloring station. I think if she keeps it fresh he may be ok. She does have a variety of things but they end up doing the same things over and over.

Posted 4/23/09 2:23 PM
 

BMonster
:)

Member since 2/06

2959 total posts

Name:
Denise

Re: EI moms come in please

It's hard to tell... We love all of Ethan's therapists now, but I did have an issue with one a while back and we switched to another one. That was because I had some issues with her AND I think he didn't like her either, but he was less than a year old.

Now it's different with each therapist. Some I can stay in the room, and with others (one in particular) he does better if I'm not in the room. Do you do what the therapist does on a regular basis? I find that if I follow through with it at least sometimes (I don't want to always take the toy away to do "give me" or "more", he'd always be annoyed) he doesn't complain as much with the therapist and does better overall. Hope that makes sense.

You do need to go with your gut, though. If you feel deep down you need a different therapist for Jack, don't feel bad about it. Maybe you need to see how he does with another one without getting rid of the current one (like one day a week for a couple weeks). Either you'd feel good about switching, or you'lll decide you love the current one.

Sorry, I'm done rambling now Chat Icon HTHChat Icon

Posted 4/23/09 2:33 PM
 

Merf99
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

3380 total posts

Name:

Re: EI moms come in please

Posted by Diana1215

He does get excited when he sees her....he goes right into her bag and starts pulling out the toys he wants.

She is good - when he is done he will start cleaning up - and she is fine with that and moves onto another toy.

I don't know if I'm explaining it exactly the right way. When she is doing something he really enjoys he seems to like her. When it's something she kind of forces on him to try and get a response that she wants - that's when he has a fit. She also started doing the harder things in the beginning of the session - versus the end.

I just don't know anymore! Chat Icon Chat Icon



Personally to me, this sounds typical. And that he gets frustrated with her because she is making him do things that he does not want to do. But if you feel in your gut, that something is wrong or he's not getting out of it, what he should, then maybe talk tro your coordinator to switch. Or maybe you can ask to try someone new, just to see how it works for a few sessions.

Posted 4/23/09 3:01 PM
 

ml110
LIF Adult

Member since 1/06

5435 total posts

Name:

Re: EI moms come in please

Posted by BMonster



Do you do what the therapist does on a regular basis? I find that if I follow through with it at least sometimes (I don't want to always take the toy away to do "give me" or "more", he'd always be annoyed) he doesn't complain as much with the therapist and does better overall. Hope that makes sense.



I'm a speech therapist who did EI for a little while, and I agree with this. It sounds like just typical 2-year old stuff Chat Icon shes making him do something he doesn't want to do, or is hard for him- so hes getting mad. I think its so important for you to push him sometimes too so that he doesn't only associate the "hard work" with the therapist.... it helps him realize "oh! i have to do this for everybody, not just this lady that comes here twice a week" Chat Icon Good luck!!

Posted 4/23/09 3:36 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Moms that delivered at St Charles Marcie 3/23/06 7 Parenting
All Moms-to-be Check in! MrsJ 3/23/06 55 Pregnancy
8 - 10 month old moms - Nap question MM2004 3/22/06 10 Parenting
Moms who keep busy during the day with their kids... monkeybride 3/20/06 10 Parenting
BTDT Moms....Finding out the sex Ali1 3/17/06 2 Multiple Births
C-Section Moms... AndreaLMT 3/16/06 7 Parenting