EI evulation question LONG but need input

Posted By Message

Kissy331
My two miracles!

Member since 5/06

17826 total posts

Name:
Kristen

EI evulation question LONG but need input

DS was followed by Child Find up until 15 months when they released him due to him being unable to qualify for services & the county doing cutbacks on evulations. I was told to let our Ped doing one in the office at his 18 month checkup, which they did & said that DS was right on par.

My DH has been getting a lot of chirping in his ear from his family that DS does not speak well enough & that he should be saying more words (he says about 10 but can point to others & understands but is yet to say them). They are all concerned bc the majority of the kids in DH's family have required some type of service along the way & also bc of DS diagnosis while in utero.

I noticed DH asking DS this weekend a lot to say things that he normally says repatively. I asked him why & he said that I think we should get him evulated, he has not saying enough words. I asked where this was coming from & found out it was from his family. He wants to be able to tell them he was evulated & nothing was wrong.

How would you handle this situation if you were in my shoes? We already have a "case" worker that we worked with for 15 months & now DH went behind my back & got a # from his brother for their case worker & DH wants to call tomorrow to get an evulation done. I am livid bc I feel that he is listening to his family who spends all of 15 minutes a week with him & I am with him 24/7. I know there is no harm in getting him evulated but he was just released at 15 months & the Ped said he is fine.

WWYD?

Posted 3/20/11 9:14 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

munchkinfacemama
LOVE

Member since 11/07

15800 total posts

Name:
<FONT COLOR="#FF0099">Michelle</FONT>

Re: EI evulation question LONG but need input

Oh that would make me angry too. I would tell him that 1. DS was evaluated and determined not to need services. 2. Boys are slower with speech than girls and give him time as the word explosion tends to occur between 18-24 months. 3. You want to wait until he is closer to two because since he does say 10 words and he is 18 months, they will likely not qualify him and tell you that a lot can happen in 6 months (which is true). 4. You guys are the parents and decisions should be made not behind each other's backs.

And according to my ped, 10 words puts a child on a 20-21 month level. She said they expect a minimum of 6 at 18 months. HTH! Chat Icon

Posted 3/20/11 9:21 PM
 

Janice
Sweet Jessie Quinn

Member since 5/05

27567 total posts

Name:
Janice

Re: EI evulation question LONG but need input

how old is he now?

I am trying to see it from dh's side, that my mother kept bothering me to get josh evaluated-i finally caved and did.
so i can see where he is coming from...but on the other hand, you are on top of it...you know more then they do.

sorry...but glad he is doing better!

Posted 3/20/11 9:42 PM
 

Kissy331
My two miracles!

Member since 5/06

17826 total posts

Name:
Kristen

Re: EI evulation question LONG but need input

Posted by Janice

how old is he now?

I am trying to see it from dh's side, that my mother kept bothering me to get josh evaluated-i finally caved and did.
so i can see where he is coming from...but on the other hand, you are on top of it...you know more then they do.

sorry...but glad he is doing better!



he's 18.5 months

Posted 3/20/11 10:06 PM
 

Janice
Sweet Jessie Quinn

Member since 5/05

27567 total posts

Name:
Janice

Re: EI evulation question LONG but need input

that is a baby.
you have it under control.
He was with EI, was released.
ped has seen him.


Posted 3/20/11 10:17 PM
 

MaMaTeenie
Party of 5

Member since 4/08

6489 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: EI evulation question LONG but need input

I would give him til he is 2. DS talked a lot, very young. His cousin (a girl) is 3 weeks older and didn't talk much. At 18 mos my SIL was concerned and spoke with her ped who said hold off on getting an eval til 2 and sure enough at about 22mos she started talking a lot more. I don't even think she had 10 words at 18 mos, but she understood everything and communicated by point and grunting etc.

Being the recent release and the Ped saying he is right on target I'd try to compromise with DH and suggest waiting a few more months.

Posted 3/20/11 10:21 PM
 

SweetCin
My green-eyed boy

Member since 5/05

13499 total posts

Name:
Cin

Re: EI evulation question LONG but need input

Wow, I'd be mad too at DH. He's only 18 months...10 words is great. My DD literally had maybe 5-6 words by 18 months & then a few days after 2 started rambling & never stopped.

You know your son. If anything I'd wait until 2.

Posted 3/20/11 10:40 PM
 

clmj2
cant believe hes gone

Member since 3/07

4407 total posts

Name:
Candice

Re: EI evulation question LONG but need input

at 18m my DD had like 4 words....she didnt start speaking a lot until 20-21m.
i think its too early yet

Posted 3/20/11 11:30 PM
 

InShock
life is good

Member since 10/06

9258 total posts

Name:

Re: EI evulation question LONG but need input

I think given your DS's diagnosis from birth, the evaluation couldn't hurt. I think that's a factor that can't be ignored. I'd want to be as proactive as possible. It's free, easy, and IF he qualifies, he'll be getting help as early as possible. Good luck! Chat Icon

Posted 3/20/11 11:48 PM
 

sasha96
lovin' my 2 little ladies!

Member since 5/05

7401 total posts

Name:
Julianne

Re: EI evulation question LONG but need input

Was the dx made in utero and confirmed after birth? The way you wrote that made it sound like it was made in utero but not found in tests after he was born.

Regardless, I think we have specialists (I'm a SLP) for a reason and wouldn't go based on the Ped.'s eval. I'd see how he does on the tests now and then have him retested at 2 if you don't see him with a large growth in vocabulary and 2 words into sentences. In normal development, we do see big vocabulary growth starting at his age especially. I'd also be requesting a SEIT eval.

Besides just his expressive language, how is his comprehension? Can he follow some directions? Is his vocabulary, both expressive and receptive, varied...nouns, verbs, events recurring, rejecting, denying, location, etc? How is his play? Does he do some pretend play? Does he use objects as a tool? How is he doing with visual spatial tasks-puzzles, blocks, etc.? Does he understand a bunch of basic concepts and prepositions?

Message edited 2011-03-21 07:19:14.780000.

Posted 3/21/11 7:12 AM
 

A3CM
Avatar Title

Member since 9/08

3762 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: EI evulation question LONG but need input

i would have him evaluated... but then again i am neurotic when it comes to speech and other delays.

there is NO harm in having a child go through EI... my DD was evaled after being discharged through child find as well.

at 18 months she was saying about 5-10 words and she understood everything... at 18.5-19 months her speech exploded but i still had the evals done.

i would not be mad... my Ped said my DS was right on par with developmental milestones as well... always assured me he was fine... even though at 6 months old i knew he was off. well i was right.. my DS is Autistic.

so even if your childs ped said they are OK, and your DH has a feeling let him go with it.. 99% of the time those feelings are right and if they arent it gives a piece of mind.

Posted 3/21/11 7:18 AM
 

sfp0701
Liam's Mommy!

Member since 1/07

9764 total posts

Name:
Tricia

Re: EI evulation question LONG but need input

Honestly, as an SLP I don't think he will qualify. He says 10 words at 18 months and understand a lot more.

Does he point to things in books? Does he follow one step commands? Does he gesture? Point?

But, sometimes just doing it to shut up someone else it worth it.

I know you worry because of his diagnosis but, I think you said it would not really show up until later on in life anyway. Right?

He was released from EI at 15 months I don't think something would have gone so wrong in 3 months. Give it about 3 months. Liam's language really exploded around then.

Message edited 2011-03-21 07:41:22.243000.

Posted 3/21/11 7:36 AM
 

Kissy331
My two miracles!

Member since 5/06

17826 total posts

Name:
Kristen

Re: EI evulation question LONG but need input

Posted by sasha96

Was the dx made in utero and confirmed after birth? The way you wrote that made it sound like it was made in utero but not found in tests after he was born.

Regardless, I think we have specialists (I'm a SLP) for a reason and wouldn't go based on the Ped.'s eval. I'd see how he does on the tests now and then have him retested at 2 if you don't see him with a large growth in vocabulary and 2 words into sentences. In normal development, we do see big vocabulary growth starting at his age especially. I'd also be requesting a SEIT eval.

Besides just his expressive language, how is his comprehension? Can he follow some directions? Is his vocabulary, both expressive and receptive, varied...nouns, verbs, events recurring, rejecting, denying, location, etc? How is his play? Does he do some pretend play? Does he use objects as a tool? How is he doing with visual spatial tasks-puzzles, blocks, etc.? Does he understand a bunch of basic concepts and prepositions?



He was diagnosed in utero with CACC (complete agensis of the corpus colosum) & it was never confirmed after birth. We had him evulated several times by both EI & also Dr's & so far nothing has come to show of it. With that understanding, kids that are born with CACC & no other genetic issues may never show signs of it or could have delays later (learning or trouble hitting puberty).

His comprehension is great. He understands everything we tell him & can even follow some two step directions. He is an ace at 1 step directions. He loves to pretend play & will look at a picture (example: his cousin plays ice hockey) & will pick up his hockey stick & pretend he is skating around the house & will shoot with the stick. He uses many of his toys as tools & knows what most of them do in real life (phone, computer, ball). He is learning how to put pieces back in a puzzle & loves to stack blocks & books.

After considering a lot last night, I am going to call his case worker this morning & see if we can get him evulated just to put my husband off my back. It is just annoying & hurtful that people have to put their two sense in knowing I have complete control of the situation.

Posted 3/21/11 8:12 AM
 

hbugal
Lesigh

Member since 2/07

15928 total posts

Name:

Re: EI evulation question LONG but need input

In JJ's case I can understand where the concerns lie. This is more involved than just a child not qualifying for services. I say this from first hand experience. Ariel technically did not qualify for services until she was over 2 years old. Back then her diagnosis alone was enough to qualify her for, in the least, monitoring of her condition from EI. (Things have changed since then though thanks to Mr Pataki...God Bless his grandchildren someday)

In JJs case, like Ariel, his condition is known to cause delays. It's hovering over our heads constantly and is cause of constant constant worry. In this case I think DH's usual "worry" has been exacerbated by his family. Honestly...I would bite the bullet on this one and allow DH to call the case worker. No harm can come of this...and, best case scenario you get to tell DH "I TOLD YOU SO".....

Posted 3/21/11 8:13 AM
 

Diana1215
Living on a prayer!!!

Member since 10/05

29450 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: EI evulation question LONG but need input

I don't think there is anythinig wrong with 10 words at 18 months, but given the history I would get an evaluation in place. I always looked at it as "If he qualified and was getting help - great. If he didn't qualify or need the help, that was even better" but at least I knew what the professions thought!

Good luck! Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 3/21/11 8:17 AM
 

sasha96
lovin' my 2 little ladies!

Member since 5/05

7401 total posts

Name:
Julianne

Re: EI evulation question LONG but need input

Posted by Kissy331

Posted by sasha96

Was the dx made in utero and confirmed after birth? The way you wrote that made it sound like it was made in utero but not found in tests after he was born.

Regardless, I think we have specialists (I'm a SLP) for a reason and wouldn't go based on the Ped.'s eval. I'd see how he does on the tests now and then have him retested at 2 if you don't see him with a large growth in vocabulary and 2 words into sentences. In normal development, we do see big vocabulary growth starting at his age especially. I'd also be requesting a SEIT eval.

Besides just his expressive language, how is his comprehension? Can he follow some directions? Is his vocabulary, both expressive and receptive, varied...nouns, verbs, events recurring, rejecting, denying, location, etc? How is his play? Does he do some pretend play? Does he use objects as a tool? How is he doing with visual spatial tasks-puzzles, blocks, etc.? Does he understand a bunch of basic concepts and prepositions?



He was diagnosed in utero with CACC (complete agensis of the corpus colosum) & it was never confirmed after birth. We had him evulated several times by both EI & also Dr's & so far nothing has come to show of it. With that understanding, kids that are born with CACC & no other genetic issues may never show signs of it or could have delays later (learning or trouble hitting puberty).

His comprehension is great. He understands everything we tell him & can even follow some two step directions. He is an ace at 1 step directions. He loves to pretend play & will look at a picture (example: his cousin plays ice hockey) & will pick up his hockey stick & pretend he is skating around the house & will shoot with the stick. He uses many of his toys as tools & knows what most of them do in real life (phone, computer, ball). He is learning how to put pieces back in a puzzle & loves to stack blocks & books.

After considering a lot last night, I am going to call his case worker this morning & see if we can get him evulated just to put my husband off my back. It is just annoying & hurtful that people have to put their two sense in knowing I have complete control of the situation.



I remember the dx in utero but didn't know what happened after he was born. I remember writing you b/c I've had students with CACC. Sounds like he is coming along nicely. With 10 words and those comprehension skills, he probably won't qualify now. It may be worth it to do the eval for your DH's sake and keep an eye on how he progresses. There can be such variation in children with the dx, if he does in fact have CACC. Chat Icon

Posted 3/21/11 8:35 AM
 

twiceasnice
LIF Adult

Member since 2/08

1126 total posts

Name:

Re: EI evulation question LONG but need input

I understand your being upset with your DH but he is probably tired of hearing this stuff from his family.
Most likely, your DS will do just fine during his evalulation and your DH's family can just stop talking about it...plus in the future they may not offer their opinions so quickly. If he ends up needing EI, then great for your DS.

My opinion...your DS won't qualify. My DS only spoke 5-10 words and was evaluated at 24 months. His comprehension and understanding was on a 3 year old level and he didn't qualify. By 2 1/2 he had his word explosion and I honestly dont even remember what it was like when he didn't talk.

Posted 3/21/11 8:40 AM
 

CaidensMommy
My 3 Miracles!

Member since 5/05

5777 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: EI evulation question LONG but need input

I don't know anything about EI, but I just wanted to say that Connor (my youngest), only said about 3-5 words until he turned 2 yrs old. He would only point and grunt. We had started to be concerned around 18 months old. About 1-2 weeks after he turned 2, OMG, he just started talking up a storm. I mean sentences out of nowhere! We were shocked to say the least. It's like he was just holding it all in until he felt like talking. Now, he's 4.5 and he speaks better than my older son did at his age. I just wanted to say that it "may" be nothing. But you know your child. We thought we did. Part of me was worried, and the other part kept saying, he'll talk. Chat Icon

Good luck and I hope he doesn't need EI! Chat Icon

Posted 3/21/11 8:44 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
THanks for the input, question answered NASP09 7/17/08 10 Families Helping Families ™
Drs Input..Another Metformin Question..gas x OK. shaye3 9/11/07 4 Infertility
Serious question..Long story..but wanted your input mitabtrfly 4/12/07 10 Families Helping Families ™
Situation Specific Sleep Training Question-- Please help with any input or advice. randella 6/30/09 9 Parenting
I have a question and Forgive me post( another question on bottom) luvsbob4603 6/16/06 14 Families Helping Families ™
Another question before I become a mom- Hospital question Shelly 4/10/06 11 Parenting