Eh...another swine question...sorry

Posted By Message

pixie

Member since 7/07

2089 total posts

Name:

Eh...another swine question...sorry

So sorry, Im sure your all sick of the vaccination debate.
My question: I cannot find an H1N1 shot without mercury. I do believe in vaccinating, DD is 11 months, pedi has it and wants DD to get it. Im nervous about the mercury.
Has this swayed anyone elses decision? Am I fixating on the mercury and not looking at the big picture?
Also...pedi dosnt think that she may have enough for the 2nd shot, but still wants me to get #1. Does this matter? I have done all the reading and research and my eyes are tired so Im going to the experts Chat Icon

Posted 10/26/09 7:56 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

pickles16
Real Estate Professional

Member since 11/07

17227 total posts

Name:
Jen

Re: Eh...another swine question...sorry

My ped has the one with the mercury too and is getting the non mercury one in...He was preparing me that in the even that he doesn't get the mercury free one that he would still recommend the one with the mercury..He said the mercury in the vaccine is the same mercury you find in fish, there are apprantly two types of mercury, one that stays in the body longer than the other. The vaccine happens to have the one that does not stay in the body long, the same as fish would have...Yes, he doesn't not WANT to give DD (10 mos) the one with mercury, BUT if it is and ends up being my only option before we leave for vacation then he would recommend it....

Message edited 2009-10-26 20:15:58.900000.

Posted 10/26/09 8:10 PM
 

SweetTooth
I'm a tired mommy!

Member since 12/05

20105 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: Eh...another swine question...sorry

The amount of mercury in the shot is minuscule. I understand your concern, but if this is the only shot he will be getting with mercury, I wouldn't worry.
I'm not sure about the two shots - I would think at least he would have SOME immunity from the one shot, which is better than none.
We are going next week, and I am hoping our ped has it.

Posted 10/26/09 8:14 PM
 

BaroqueMama
Chase is one!

Member since 5/05

27530 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Eh...another swine question...sorry

The amount of mercury in the shot is really miniscule. Less than in some fish. I was on the fence about the shot, leaning towards getting it for Ava, and then I was at the ped. for something else today and we talked about it yet again, and again he reiterated why he doesn't think we should get it and now I'm back to square one.
I'm so scared because it's all over my school right now, including in Ava's class, and I'm pregnant. This is not an easy decision.Chat Icon

Posted 10/26/09 8:16 PM
 

SweetTooth
I'm a tired mommy!

Member since 12/05

20105 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: Eh...another swine question...sorry

Posted by prncsslehcar

The amount of mercury in the shot is really miniscule. Less than in some fish. I was on the fence about the shot, leaning towards getting it for Ava, and then I was at the ped. for something else today and we talked about it yet again, and again he reiterated why he doesn't think we should get it and now I'm back to square one.
I'm so scared because it's all over my school right now, including in Ava's class, and I'm pregnant. This is not an easy decision.Chat Icon



I think in the same way some parents don't do what their peds say in regards to getting the shot, if you feel Ava SHOULD get the shot, then you should get it for her. If your ped won't give it, then find one who will. In all honesty, I think its irresponsible for peds or any other health professional to be discouraging people from getting vaccinated. The CDC and all other health organizations are recommending it and saying it is safe. The doctors who are discouraging it are interjecting their own personal opinions on their patients decisions, which I think is wrong.

Posted 10/26/09 8:20 PM
 

pixie

Member since 7/07

2089 total posts

Name:

Re: Eh...another swine question...sorry

Posted by prncsslehcar

The amount of mercury in the shot is really miniscule. Less than in some fish. I was on the fence about the shot, leaning towards getting it for Ava, and then I was at the ped. for something else today and we talked about it yet again, and again he reiterated why he doesn't think we should get it and now I'm back to square one.
I'm so scared because it's all over my school right now, including in Ava's class, and I'm pregnant. This is not an easy decision.Chat Icon



Would you mind me asking why he dosent want you to get it? I just dont understand how pedi's can be all over the place on this one...my pedi would love to get a hold of DDs arm any chance she can get, including this one

Posted 10/26/09 8:22 PM
 

BaroqueMama
Chase is one!

Member since 5/05

27530 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Eh...another swine question...sorry

Posted by SweetTooth

Posted by prncsslehcar

The amount of mercury in the shot is really miniscule. Less than in some fish. I was on the fence about the shot, leaning towards getting it for Ava, and then I was at the ped. for something else today and we talked about it yet again, and again he reiterated why he doesn't think we should get it and now I'm back to square one.
I'm so scared because it's all over my school right now, including in Ava's class, and I'm pregnant. This is not an easy decision.Chat Icon



I think in the same way some parents don't do what their peds say in regards to getting the shot, if you feel Ava SHOULD get the shot, then you should get it for her. If your ped won't give it, then find one who will. In all honesty, I think its irresponsible for peds or any other health professional to be discouraging people from getting vaccinated. The CDC and all other health organizations are recommending it and saying it is safe. The doctors who are discouraging it are interjecting their own personal opinions on their patients decisions, which I think is wrong.



Sorry, I trust my ped. and don't think he's doing me a disservice by giving me his reasons for not wanting us to get the shots. Ultimately, he would give it to us if we wanted, but I'm personally trying to weight the positives and the negatives in my own mind. I happen to be of the mind that I care what my pediatrician's opinion as a person is, as well as his medical opinion. He gave me both opinions and I'm grateful for that.

Posted 10/26/09 8:23 PM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: Eh...another swine question...sorry

Hi..if you are asking for opinions, well that is one thing. For me, I would personally not get it with the mercury. Why? Bc all teh research I have done has shown that ingested mercury is not the same as injected mercury (which directly bypasses the blood brain barrier).

What I wanted to ask you was, wasn't your DD having vaccine reactions? I recall a long time ago, you were not vaccinating b/c she was having such harsh reactions. Has she been vaccinted recently, has she reacted harshly? What vaccines has she gotten?

Only you can decide, it's such a touch decision.Chat Icon

Posted 10/26/09 8:25 PM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: Eh...another swine question...sorry

Posted by prncsslehcar

The amount of mercury in the shot is really miniscule. Less than in some fish. I was on the fence about the shot, leaning towards getting it for Ava, and then I was at the ped. for something else today and we talked about it yet again, and again he reiterated why he doesn't think we should get it and now I'm back to square one.
I'm so scared because it's all over my school right now, including in Ava's class, and I'm pregnant. This is not an easy decision.Chat Icon



Can I ask you again, why is your ped saying no to it? If you ffeel like reiterating as I am sure you have said it previously.Chat Icon

Posted 10/26/09 8:26 PM
 

jerseypanda
Life is good.

Member since 1/07

9164 total posts

Name:
Amanda

Re: Eh...another swine question...sorry

For me, personally, I am not concerned about the mercury. The amount in the shots is so trace, that I just don't believe that there is reason to be concerned. Many people would disagree with me, but that is my feeling on it.

I am 34 weeks pregnant and just got the seasonal flu shot (with mercury) last week because I couldn't find the preservative free on anywhere, despite calling every single place I could find.

I am planning on getting the H1N1 shot as well. If it has the mercury in it, so be it. I will try to find the mercury free one, but I can only do so much.

DS will be getting the shot too once his ped gets it in. Don't know if it will be the mercury or mercury free one but it doesn't matter to me. My good friend from high school currently has 2 daughters who have the swine flu and she said they are miserable. I would like to avoid it if I can.

Posted 10/26/09 8:27 PM
 

pixie

Member since 7/07

2089 total posts

Name:

Re: Eh...another swine question...sorry

Posted by Goobster

Hi..if you are asking for opinions, well that is one thing. For me, I would personally not get it with the mercury. Why? Bc all teh research I have done has shown that ingested mercury is not the same as injected mercury (which directly bypasses the blood brain barrier).

What I wanted to ask you was, wasn't your DD having vaccine reactions? I recall a long time ago, you were not vaccinating b/c she was having such harsh reactions. Has she been vaccinted recently, has she reacted harshly? What vaccines has she gotten?

Only you can decide, it's such a touch decision.Chat Icon



Oh that makes me feel special you remembered Chat Icon DD did have horrible reactions to any shots for some time. When she turned 8 months or so we started to slooowwllly introduce shots again. Now it is only one at a time spread out at least 3 weeks. She is far behind but thats okay. She did get 2nds of shots that previously gave her terrible reactions, but now with a stronger immunity perhaps she does fine with them.
Shes only caught up with the dtap minus one.

Posted 10/26/09 8:29 PM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: Eh...another swine question...sorry

Posted by pixie

Posted by Goobster

Hi..if you are asking for opinions, well that is one thing. For me, I would personally not get it with the mercury. Why? Bc all teh research I have done has shown that ingested mercury is not the same as injected mercury (which directly bypasses the blood brain barrier).

What I wanted to ask you was, wasn't your DD having vaccine reactions? I recall a long time ago, you were not vaccinating b/c she was having such harsh reactions. Has she been vaccinted recently, has she reacted harshly? What vaccines has she gotten?

Only you can decide, it's such a touch decision.Chat Icon



Oh that makes me feel special you remembered Chat Icon DD did have horrible reactions to any shots for some time. When she turned 8 months or so we started to slooowwllly introduce shots again. Now it is only one at a time spread out at least 3 weeks. She is far behind but thats okay. She did get 2nds of shots that previously gave her terrible reactions, but now with a stronger immunity perhaps she does fine with them.
Shes only caught up with the dtap minus one.


Glad to hear she is doing much better. I remember you posting about some scary reactions she was having, that they thought was to the preservatives or something in them...

I would be beating a dead horse to say that for me personally, I would likely wait until the mercury free one came in, esp based on her history. But re you asking about doing one and maybe not getting another, I would think one should provide SOME level of protection. So if you wanted to do that, I would do it and see what happens with getting #2.Chat Icon

Posted 10/26/09 8:44 PM
 

SweetTooth
I'm a tired mommy!

Member since 12/05

20105 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: Eh...another swine question...sorry

Posted by prncsslehcar

Posted by SweetTooth

Posted by prncsslehcar

The amount of mercury in the shot is really miniscule. Less than in some fish. I was on the fence about the shot, leaning towards getting it for Ava, and then I was at the ped. for something else today and we talked about it yet again, and again he reiterated why he doesn't think we should get it and now I'm back to square one.
I'm so scared because it's all over my school right now, including in Ava's class, and I'm pregnant. This is not an easy decision.Chat Icon



I think in the same way some parents don't do what their peds say in regards to getting the shot, if you feel Ava SHOULD get the shot, then you should get it for her. If your ped won't give it, then find one who will. In all honesty, I think its irresponsible for peds or any other health professional to be discouraging people from getting vaccinated. The CDC and all other health organizations are recommending it and saying it is safe. The doctors who are discouraging it are interjecting their own personal opinions on their patients decisions, which I think is wrong.



Sorry, I trust my ped. and don't think he's doing me a disservice by giving me his reasons for not wanting us to get the shots. Ultimately, he would give it to us if we wanted, but I'm personally trying to weight the positives and the negatives in my own mind. I happen to be of the mind that I care what my pediatrician's opinion as a person is, as well as his medical opinion. He gave me both opinions and I'm grateful for that.



I'm sorry! I misunderstood your post! I thought you were saying you wanted to get it but then the ped wouldn't give it to you.
You should absolutely do what you feel is best for you and your daughter! Chat Icon

Posted 10/26/09 11:13 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
sorry if this is TMI.Question about CM 04bride 9/30/05 4 TTC
I, also have another weird question, maybe TMI ( Sorry) princess99 9/22/05 4 TTC
sorry, I have another paint question wp 9/1/05 5 Home
Sorry I have one last Myspace question.. AJsMommy122 8/16/05 4 Families Helping Families ™
Sorry for the annoying question! Mrs 7/28/05 9 TTC
Sorry another pre-Qual question Redhead 7/1/05 13 Home