Does the Town Code supersede the Village Code?

Posted By Message

OffWithHerHead23
Keep passing the open windows

Member since 10/06

3627 total posts

Name:
Meaghan

Does the Town Code supersede the Village Code?

I'm not sure if I'm wording this right. I'm a little slow today.

We want to get chickens. We are in the town of Babylon but the village of Lindenhurst. I called the town and they said chickens are not allowed to be kept in the town of Babylon. I asked the guy, "Even in the village of Lindenhurst?" He said not even in the village. DH called the village and they said you can keep chickens with a permit.

We have one set of neighbors who would absolutely make a huge stink if every I wasn't dotted and every t wasn't crossed. So which law do I go by, the town or village? Like, if I got a village permit for the chickens, and my neighbors calle the town of Babylon, could I still get in trouble?

Posted 10/23/12 1:18 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Does the Town Code supersede the Village Code?

I'm pretty sure that Village supercedes town. But I wouldn't take someone on the phone's word for it.

I would email the Town of Babylon & confirm the chicken option. Here's their town code:
No person shall keep, house or harbor any livestock, horse, farm animal or draft animal within 100 feet of any dwelling house or place of human habitation.

Village Code:
No person, firm or corporation shall harbor, keep, possess or maintain within the village limits any livestock or wild animal without first obtaining a permit from the Zoning Board of Appeals of the village pursuant to Article XV of Chapter 193 of the Village Code. Nothing in this Article shall be deemed to prohibit the temporary keeping of not more than 200 fowl for resale purposes for periods not in excess of 72 hours, provided that the same shall be kept continuously confined in crates, wire coops, cages or other similar enclosures and provided that the same shall not be kept on residentially zoned property.

Message edited 2012-10-23 15:49:53.393000.

Posted 10/23/12 3:43 PM
 

chilltocam
LIF Adult

Member since 11/11

9141 total posts

Name:

Does the Town Code supersede the Village Code?

I believe, generally, a Village code can be more restrictive than a Town code, but it cannot be less restrictve. That being said, it appears from the above post that if you got a permit from the Village, you'd be OK. Have you looked into getting the permit? Is it something they will easliy grant?

Posted 10/23/12 4:30 PM
 

The Law Office of Kerie P. Stone
LIFamilies Business

Member since 6/08

139 total posts

Name:

Re: Does the Town Code supersede the Village Code?

I'm surprised there is a conflict in the rules but I probably shouldn't be surprised. I would get actual copies of the rules (well, one of them was already quoted above) and read closely. It could be that there is a way to have chickens without violating either one. There could be restrictions on what your reason is (like whether you plan to sell them).

I know a great animal rights attorney who may know these answers. FM me if you want her contact info. She is so nice and very dedicated. If she does not know your answer she probably knows someone who does.

Another option may be to call the Suffolk County Bar Association & tell them you need a zoning and land use attorney. That's who works with these rules all day. I think it may be better to get someone right in your town but I know someone who does this type of work in the Town of Smithtown & the villages within Smithtown. If you go through the referral service, the most they would charge you is $25 for a consultation to answer your question. They may not be too happy that it's not a big case but I see it as a service that they give to someone who might recommend them later.

There are law school classes in Conflicts of Law and this is the type of thing they addressed. It was one of my favorite classes but now I can't really remember (graduated in 1993). We also went over situations where there were conflicts between state and federal laws or if a contract involved people in 2 states, etc. So the issue of village codes was only a very small part, if we even went over it. To me this is fascinating but I don't want to give you an incorrect answer. Let us know what you find out.

Posted 10/23/12 5:52 PM
 

OffWithHerHead23
Keep passing the open windows

Member since 10/06

3627 total posts

Name:
Meaghan

Does the Town Code supersede the Village Code?

The Vilae Code, as written, would seem to allow it. I called the Village Hall after I posted this this afternoon, and spoke to the Code Enforcement officer. He said that it is against the village code (I didn't read it like that, and I read the same thing Barb quoted above) but we have to file for an exemption and go before the Board of Appeals. However, like a PP said, since the Town of Babylon IS more restrictive so there is definitely a conflict there.

If I had decent neighbors I would just get the 6 chickens that I want (no rooster) and leave it like that. I know people in the Town of Babylon who keep illegal chickens and it's never been a problem. However, we have one neighbor who is a total asshole, and I KNOW he would be on the phone with every town official known to man trying to shut down my coop!! So if I can't do it legally, I'm not going to do it at all, KWIM?

Posted 10/23/12 6:08 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Huntington town code on door-to-door solicitations (info included) nrthshgrl 6/14/11 0 Home
Yankee Candle CODE!! KPtoys 9/28/05 3 Families Helping Families ™
birthdayexpress.com coupon code? RyansMommy 9/21/05 0 Parenting
What are good discount code websites? JennChris 9/14/05 3 Families Helping Families ™
Can some reccommend a book for me..I love DaVinci Code and Angels and Demons mishu 7/24/05 11 StoryBoard
Coldwater creek 50% off code Myrockette 7/17/05 0 Families Helping Families ™