Re: Does the Town Code supersede the Village Code?
Posted 10/23/2012 5:52:17 PM by The Law Office of Kerie P. Stone

I'm surprised there is a conflict in the rules but I probably shouldn't be surprised. I would get actual copies of the rules (well, one of them was already quoted above) and read closely. It could be that there is a way to have chickens without violating either one. There could be restrictions on what your reason is (like whether you plan to sell them).

I know a great animal rights attorney who may know these answers. FM me if you want her contact info. She is so nice and very dedicated. If she does not know your answer she probably knows someone who does.

Another option may be to call the Suffolk County Bar Association & tell them you need a zoning and land use attorney. That's who works with these rules all day. I think it may be better to get someone right in your town but I know someone who does this type of work in the Town of Smithtown & the villages within Smithtown. If you go through the referral service, the most they would charge you is $25 for a consultation to answer your question. They may not be too happy that it's not a big case but I see it as a service that they give to someone who might recommend them later.

There are law school classes in Conflicts of Law and this is the type of thing they addressed. It was one of my favorite classes but now I can't really remember (graduated in 1993). We also went over situations where there were conflicts between state and federal laws or if a contract involved people in 2 states, etc. So the issue of village codes was only a very small part, if we even went over it. To me this is fascinating but I don't want to give you an incorrect answer. Let us know what you find out.
Print Post      Close Window