Does it bother you when......

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2] 3 4 5

Jenn627
Laaaaaaaambert!

Member since 5/08

9818 total posts

Name:
Jenn

Re: Does it bother you when......

I think she's just saying that people who openly call themselves atheists or are openly non-religious - when they celebrate the holiday - it just irks her. Like - "oh you don't agree with ANYTHING but you can take the nice fluffy stuff?"

I can see her point.

I personally don't care who does what with the holidays but I CAN see her point.

You guys can't? You don't understand what she's saying AT ALL? Even if you don't agree with it - you can't see where she's coming from?

I don't understand why she's being attacked for the way she feels.



Posted 3/18/10 1:28 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

eddiesmommy
best buds!

Member since 5/09

11524 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Does it bother you when......

Posted by Jenn627

I think she's just saying that people who openly call themselves atheists or are openly non-religious - when they celebrate the holiday - it just irks her. Like - "oh you don't agree with ANYTHING but you can take the nice fluffy stuff?"

I can see her point.

I personally don't care who does what with the holidays but I CAN see her point.

You guys can't? You don't understand what she's saying AT ALL? Even if you don't agree with it - you can't see where she's coming from?

I don't understand why she's being attacked for the way she feels.






thank you....that is my point.

Posted 3/18/10 1:30 PM
 

Otherme
Square head cutie pants

Member since 3/06

6899 total posts

Name:

Re: Does it bother you when......

As someone who is not religious, and who was brought up with no religion i guess i fall into that category of people that bothers you

My family has always celebrated Christmas as a season of good cheer, family get togethers and gift giving. When i was younger, we had easter egg hunts for the kids and then an Easter dinner.
To ME, those holidays are a chance for the family to celebrate being together since we're all over the country.

I understand the holidays are religious in their origin and continue to be religious in their meaning for religious people - but they're also holidays that have turned into more secular ones over the years, that include ALL people if they so desire.

We all went out and 'celebrated' St. Patricks Day yesterday didn't we? It's not limited to only Irish Catholics

You're entitled to your opinion of course, but IMO you shouldn't be concerned with how other people chose to live their lives and conduct their own family gatherings. How others live their lives doesn't take anything away from how you observe your holidays.

Posted 3/18/10 1:31 PM
 

DiamondGirl
You are my I love you

Member since 7/09

18802 total posts

Name:
DiamondMama

Re: Does it bother you when......

Posted by Jenn627

I think she's just saying that people who openly call themselves atheists or are openly non-religious - when they celebrate the holiday - it just irks her. Like - "oh you don't agree with ANYTHING but you can take the nice fluffy stuff?"

I can see her point.

I personally don't care who does what with the holidays but I CAN see her point.

You guys can't? You don't understand what she's saying AT ALL? Even if you don't agree with it - you can't see where she's coming from?

I don't understand why she's being attacked for the way she feels.






I see what she is saying but she has stated non-christians, which might mean people who observe other religions.

I have a friend who is Jewish and her family would get a tree and do "santa" bc she felt left out.

I CAN see how someone would feel left out. As a PP said it's all about "Christmas & Easter break".

The majority of people celbrate--so if you don't you feel excluded--I think that is why some non-christians choose to celebrate with family and friends.

Posted 3/18/10 1:32 PM
 

eddiesmommy
best buds!

Member since 5/09

11524 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Does it bother you when......

Posted by Otherme

As someone who is not religious, and who was brought up with no religion i guess i fall into that category of people that bothers you

My family has always celebrated Christmas as a season of good cheer, family get togethers and gift giving. When i was younger, we had easter egg hunts for the kids and then an Easter dinner.
To ME, those holidays are a chance for the family to celebrate being together since we're all over the country.

I understand the holidays are religious in their origin and continue to be religious in their meaning for religious people - but they're also holidays that have turned into more secular ones over the years, that include ALL people if they so desire.

We all went out and 'celebrated' St. Patricks Day yesterday didn't we? It's not limited to only Irish Catholics

You're entitled to your opinion of course, but IMO you shouldn't be concerned with how other people chose to live their lives and conduct their own family gatherings. How others live their lives doesn't take anything away from how you observe your holidays.



I guess I should rephrase and say that it bothers me that once sacred religious holidays have been so commercialized and become such "hallmark holidays" that I feel it cheapens them. They are not, whether people do or not agree, holidays for everyone. The are very deep rooted and holy days not just a time to eat and run to Macys. So yes, the over commercialization of Christian holidays totally bothers me, and it is my concern and place for it to bother bc they are my religious holidays to observe.

Like I said, I dont make a big deal of it, Ive never lectured or said anything to anyone......it just bothers me and I was curious if the commercialization of very holy Chrsitian holidays, so much so, that atheists and agnostics and non-christians celebrate them bothered anyone else.

Message edited 2010-03-18 13:39:13.183000.

Posted 3/18/10 1:36 PM
 

Salason
♥

Member since 6/05

9878 total posts

Name:

Re: Does it bother you when......

Posted by Jenn627
I think she's just saying that people who openly call themselves atheists or are openly non-religious - when they celebrate the holiday - it just irks her. Like - "oh you don't agree with ANYTHING but you can take the nice fluffy stuff?"

I can see her point.

I personally don't care who does what with the holidays but I CAN see her point.

You guys can't? You don't understand what she's saying AT ALL? Even if you don't agree with it - you can't see where she's coming from?

I don't understand why she's being attacked for the way she feels.



I kind of agree with this. I personally do not care what other people do so it doesnt bother me but I get that it bothers her that people pick and choose the "good parts" of certain religions especially those who denounce most of the other parts (if I am understanding her correctly)...

Posted 3/18/10 1:37 PM
 

eddiesmommy
best buds!

Member since 5/09

11524 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Does it bother you when......

Posted by DiamondGirl

Posted by Jenn627

I think she's just saying that people who openly call themselves atheists or are openly non-religious - when they celebrate the holiday - it just irks her. Like - "oh you don't agree with ANYTHING but you can take the nice fluffy stuff?"

I can see her point.

I personally don't care who does what with the holidays but I CAN see her point.

You guys can't? You don't understand what she's saying AT ALL? Even if you don't agree with it - you can't see where she's coming from?

I don't understand why she's being attacked for the way she feels.






I see what she is saying but she has stated non-christians, which might mean people who observe other religions.

I have a friend who is Jewish and her family would get a tree and do "santa" bc she felt left out.

I CAN see how someone would feel left out. As a PP said it's all about "Christmas & Easter break".

The majority of people celbrate--so if you don't you feel excluded--I think that is why some non-christians choose to celebrate with family and friends.



I get this, but thats kind of my point, that the holidays have been so commercialized and become so secular when in fact they are very holy christian holidays that kids feel "left out" bc its ALL over the place as nothing more than a hallmark holiday so people celebrate it as such.....bothers me.

Posted 3/18/10 1:38 PM
 

JessInCA
live laugh love

Member since 8/06

5082 total posts

Name:
Jess

Re: Does it bother you when......

It doesn't bother me at all.

What DOES bother me is the mass consumerism that has surrounded and even overtaken many religious holidays... but I don't think that's the same issue.

Posted 3/18/10 1:38 PM
 

DiamondGirl
You are my I love you

Member since 7/09

18802 total posts

Name:
DiamondMama

Re: Does it bother you when......

Posted by eddiesmommy

Posted by DiamondGirl

Posted by Jenn627

I think she's just saying that people who openly call themselves atheists or are openly non-religious - when they celebrate the holiday - it just irks her. Like - "oh you don't agree with ANYTHING but you can take the nice fluffy stuff?"

I can see her point.

I personally don't care who does what with the holidays but I CAN see her point.

You guys can't? You don't understand what she's saying AT ALL? Even if you don't agree with it - you can't see where she's coming from?

I don't understand why she's being attacked for the way she feels.






I see what she is saying but she has stated non-christians, which might mean people who observe other religions.

I have a friend who is Jewish and her family would get a tree and do "santa" bc she felt left out.

I CAN see how someone would feel left out. As a PP said it's all about "Christmas & Easter break".

The majority of people celbrate--so if you don't you feel excluded--I think that is why some non-christians choose to celebrate with family and friends.



I get this, but thats kind of my point, that the holidays have been so commercialized and become so secular when in fact they are very holy christian holidays that kids feel "left out" bc its ALL over the place as nothing more than a hallmark holiday so people celebrate it as such.....bothers me.



I think people feel left out bc we are the majority, Christians that is. So since there are more of, there are more people to celebrate, more people for Hallmark to advertise to etc.

Posted 3/18/10 1:40 PM
 

Otherme
Square head cutie pants

Member since 3/06

6899 total posts

Name:

Re: Does it bother you when......

Posted by eddiesmommy

Posted by DiamondGirl

Posted by Jenn627

I think she's just saying that people who openly call themselves atheists or are openly non-religious - when they celebrate the holiday - it just irks her. Like - "oh you don't agree with ANYTHING but you can take the nice fluffy stuff?"

I can see her point.

I personally don't care who does what with the holidays but I CAN see her point.

You guys can't? You don't understand what she's saying AT ALL? Even if you don't agree with it - you can't see where she's coming from?

I don't understand why she's being attacked for the way she feels.






I see what she is saying but she has stated non-christians, which might mean people who observe other religions.

I have a friend who is Jewish and her family would get a tree and do "santa" bc she felt left out.

I CAN see how someone would feel left out. As a PP said it's all about "Christmas & Easter break".

The majority of people celbrate--so if you don't you feel excluded--I think that is why some non-christians choose to celebrate with family and friends.



I get this, but thats kind of my point, that the holidays have been so commercialized and become so secular when in fact they are very holy christian holidays that kids feel "left out" bc its ALL over the place as nothing more than a hallmark holiday so people celebrate it as such.....bothers me.



Then rally against society for turning the holidays that way... not the people who are "incorrectly celebrating"
I get your pov .. but as one of the so called offenders, i also think it's really none of your business what i do with my family. As i said.. it doesn't take away anything from the meaning you associate with the holiday.

Posted 3/18/10 1:42 PM
 

GoldenRod
10 years on LIF!

Member since 11/06

26792 total posts

Name:
Shawn

Re: Does it bother you when......

How about non-Christians who celebrate Winter Solstice in various forms (including the German Yule Log, "Christmas tree", wreaths, etc)? Should they be bothered that Christians have taken over their celebrations, when most experts agree that Jesus could not have been born on December 25th.

Winter Solstice, with large family meals and gift giving has been around long before Christianity.

Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 3/18/10 1:44 PM
 

eddiesmommy
best buds!

Member since 5/09

11524 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Does it bother you when......

Posted by Otherme

Posted by eddiesmommy

Posted by DiamondGirl

Posted by Jenn627

I think she's just saying that people who openly call themselves atheists or are openly non-religious - when they celebrate the holiday - it just irks her. Like - "oh you don't agree with ANYTHING but you can take the nice fluffy stuff?"

I can see her point.

I personally don't care who does what with the holidays but I CAN see her point.

You guys can't? You don't understand what she's saying AT ALL? Even if you don't agree with it - you can't see where she's coming from?

I don't understand why she's being attacked for the way she feels.






I see what she is saying but she has stated non-christians, which might mean people who observe other religions.

I have a friend who is Jewish and her family would get a tree and do "santa" bc she felt left out.

I CAN see how someone would feel left out. As a PP said it's all about "Christmas & Easter break".

The majority of people celbrate--so if you don't you feel excluded--I think that is why some non-christians choose to celebrate with family and friends.



I get this, but thats kind of my point, that the holidays have been so commercialized and become so secular when in fact they are very holy christian holidays that kids feel "left out" bc its ALL over the place as nothing more than a hallmark holiday so people celebrate it as such.....bothers me.



Then rally against society for turning the holidays that way... not the people who are "incorrectly celebrating"
I get your pov .. but as one of the so called offenders, i also think it's really none of your business what i do with my family. As i said.. it doesn't take away anything from the meaning you associate with the holiday.



AGAIN...I said I have never and would never say anything to anyone about how they celebrate their holidays, I was just curious if it bothered anyone else. Am I not allowed to be bothered my the commercialization an secularization of my religious holidays?

Posted 3/18/10 1:49 PM
 

Otherme
Square head cutie pants

Member since 3/06

6899 total posts

Name:

Re: Does it bother you when......

Posted by GoldenRod

How about non-Christians who celebrate Winter Solstice in various forms (including the German Yule Log, "Christmas tree", wreaths, etc)? Should they be bothered that Christians have taken over their celebrations, when most experts agree that Jesus could not have been born on December 25th.

Winter Solstice, with large family meals and gift giving has been around long before Christianity.

Chat Icon Chat Icon




Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 3/18/10 1:50 PM
 

eddiesmommy
best buds!

Member since 5/09

11524 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Does it bother you when......

Posted by Otherme

Posted by GoldenRod

How about non-Christians who celebrate Winter Solstice in various forms (including the German Yule Log, "Christmas tree", wreaths, etc)? Should they be bothered that Christians have taken over their celebrations, when most experts agree that Jesus could not have been born on December 25th.

Winter Solstice, with large family meals and gift giving has been around long before Christianity.

Chat Icon Chat Icon




Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon



they certainly can be if they want to be.

For the record though, some scholars believe that its a coincdence bc its noted that Jesus was crucified on March 25th of the Roman Calendar. It was then celebrated as the day of Annuciation or Jesus' conception.....which 9 months later, happens to be Dec 25th.

It is also noted that Christmas was first celebrated around 250a.d., and that they did not adopt pagan symbolism until the 14th century. But in 250ad there is NO WAY Christians would outwardly adopt pagan traditions.

No one knows for sure though.

Posted 3/18/10 2:04 PM
 

justmefornow
LIF Adolescent

Member since 9/08

859 total posts

Name:
n

Re: Does it bother you when......

We can get technical about a lot of holidays. January 1st, New Years Day is based on the Christian calendar but most people in the world celebrate it (well I don't know if ultra-orthodox/religious people do), it is commercialized in that sense too. What about Valentines Day (early Christianity turned into a cultural holiday) and Halloween (religious holiday turned cultural also)?

Posted 3/18/10 2:04 PM
 

eddiesmommy
best buds!

Member since 5/09

11524 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Does it bother you when......

Posted by Otherme

Posted by GoldenRod

How about non-Christians who celebrate Winter Solstice in various forms (including the German Yule Log, "Christmas tree", wreaths, etc)? Should they be bothered that Christians have taken over their celebrations, when most experts agree that Jesus could not have been born on December 25th.

Winter Solstice, with large family meals and gift giving has been around long before Christianity.

Chat Icon Chat Icon




Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon



Then those who do not bellieve in the Christian roots of Christmas and Easter can celebrate Winter Solstice instead and call it that, if they just want to celebrate the symbolic portions of the holiday without the religious aspect, no?

Posted 3/18/10 2:06 PM
 

greenfreak
.

Member since 9/06

11483 total posts

Name:
greenfreak

Re: Does it bother you when......

We aren't religious but do things like Easter baskets and have a Christmas tree and whatnot. We share these experiences with my family and it's fun. It never occurred to me that others would be annoyed by this. I still don't feel guilty or obligated to change our ways. I guess it will be just another thing we do that some people won't like but we won't care about. Chat Icon

Posted 3/18/10 2:06 PM
 

eddiesmommy
best buds!

Member since 5/09

11524 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Does it bother you when......

Posted by justmefornow

We can get technical about a lot of holidays. January 1st, New Years Day is based on the Christian calendar but most people in the world celebrate it (well I don't know if ultra-orthodox/religious people do), it is commercialized in that sense too. What about Valentines Day (early Christianity turned into a cultural holiday) and Halloween (religious holiday turned cultural also)?



You are right but I am concerned about major Catholic holidays that are sanctioned and recognized as such by the Vatican today. I was not asking about ALL holidays, I was addressing those Christians who celebrate Christmas and Easter and asking if it bothered them that they were becoming viewed as secular holidays.

Posted 3/18/10 2:08 PM
 

LeShellem
A new beginning

Member since 2/07

3600 total posts

Name:
LeShelle

Re: Does it bother you when......

I can see your point, but no it doesn't bother me. To each his own. I have way too much on my plate to worry if non-christians are celebrating christian holidays in a secular fashion.

Posted 3/18/10 2:08 PM
 

CookiePuss
Cake from Outer Space!

Member since 5/05

14021 total posts

Name:

Re: Does it bother you when......





On the flip side, those that do celebrate the sacrament and religious aspect of said holidays...is it hypercritical if they participate in the secular aspect of the holiday as well? Doesn't that feed in to the commercialism and secularization of the religious holiday?

Posted 3/18/10 2:10 PM
 

eddiesmommy
best buds!

Member since 5/09

11524 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Does it bother you when......

Posted by greenfreak

We aren't religious but do things like Easter baskets and have a Christmas tree and whatnot. We share these experiences with my family and it's fun. It never occurred to me that others would be annoyed by this. I still don't feel guilty or obligated to change our ways. I guess it will be just another thing we do that some people won't like but we won't care about. Chat Icon



And I dont think you should feel guilty and not have fun.....I never said anyone wasnt entitled to live their lives as they see fit or they CANT celebrate the holidays in a secular way. Just that it bothers me that very religious Christian holidays are treated as secular holidays.

Posted 3/18/10 2:10 PM
 

GioiaMia
Let's Go Rangers!

Member since 1/07

14818 total posts

Name:

Re: Does it bother you when......

Posted by shamrock124





On the flip side, those that do celebrate the sacrament and religious aspect of said holidays...is it hypercritical if they participate in the secular aspect of the holiday as well? Doesn't that feed in to the commercialism and secularization of the religious holiday?




I 100% think that it does, and I do participate and it is something that I do struggle with!

Posted 3/18/10 2:12 PM
 

eddiesmommy
best buds!

Member since 5/09

11524 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Does it bother you when......

Posted by Tilde

Posted by shamrock124





On the flip side, those that do celebrate the sacrament and religious aspect of said holidays...is it hypercritical if they participate in the secular aspect of the holiday as well? Doesn't that feed in to the commercialism and secularization of the religious holiday?




I 100% think that it does, and I do participate and it is something that I do struggle with!



It does, and Im no saint either, but I think as long as its true meaning is your primary reason for celebrating the holiday and you take part in the religious rites and traditions followed by all the pomp and circumstancce, then I am OK with that.

Posted 3/18/10 2:16 PM
 

CookieMomster
Golden

Member since 5/09

6414 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Does it bother you when......

Posted by Otherme

Posted by eddiesmommy

Posted by DiamondGirl

Posted by Jenn627

I think she's just saying that people who openly call themselves atheists or are openly non-religious - when they celebrate the holiday - it just irks her. Like - "oh you don't agree with ANYTHING but you can take the nice fluffy stuff?"

I can see her point.

I personally don't care who does what with the holidays but I CAN see her point.

You guys can't? You don't understand what she's saying AT ALL? Even if you don't agree with it - you can't see where she's coming from?

I don't understand why she's being attacked for the way she feels.






I see what she is saying but she has stated non-christians, which might mean people who observe other religions.

I have a friend who is Jewish and her family would get a tree and do "santa" bc she felt left out.

I CAN see how someone would feel left out. As a PP said it's all about "Christmas & Easter break".

The majority of people celbrate--so if you don't you feel excluded--I think that is why some non-christians choose to celebrate with family and friends.



I get this, but thats kind of my point, that the holidays have been so commercialized and become so secular when in fact they are very holy christian holidays that kids feel "left out" bc its ALL over the place as nothing more than a hallmark holiday so people celebrate it as such.....bothers me.



Then rally against society for turning the holidays that way... not the people who are "incorrectly celebrating"
I get your pov .. but as one of the so called offenders, i also think it's really none of your business what i do with my family. As i said.. it doesn't take away anything from the meaning you associate with the holiday.


She never said it was her buisness. She said it IRKED her she asked if it IRKS someone else. Never once did she say "Does everyone do this??"

Posted 3/18/10 2:17 PM
 

eddiesmommy
best buds!

Member since 5/09

11524 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Does it bother you when......

Posted by KateDevine

Posted by eddiesmommy

I dont celebrate Hanukkah so I can receive gifts for 8 nights and have another reason to get together with family. I dont mean this directly at you, just speaking in general.




I just want to point out that Jewish people do not have off from work for Hanukkah, most of the population has off for Christmas AND Easter. So, therefore, I think a lot of people (including Jewish people) end up spending Christmas and Easter WITH their families (who have similar beliefs one would think) because they are all off from work and since everyone else is out being religious, they end up spending it together.




I can see that Chat Icon

Posted 3/18/10 2:22 PM
 
Pages: 1 [2] 3 4 5
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Would it bother you if DH/SO fell asleep on the couch rather than go up to bed with you? nyteacher13 1/26/07 35 Families Helping Families ™
Does it bother you to hear some of post fashion commentary? Lanabean 1/17/07 3 Celebrities & Entertainment
Why are people so annoying? Does this bother anyone else? LittleBlueBug 1/11/07 7 Families Helping Families ™
I am sorry to bother everyone again...LONG VENT! ssbride05 4/24/06 12 Families Helping Families ™
Tell me if this would bother you....it's about my stupid neighbors and what they plan on doing to Lynbrook aliasPook 3/31/06 23 Home
Should I even bother fighting with DH over this? Diva 3/28/06 40 Families Helping Families ™