Do you think this is healthy?

Posted By Message

Charly
LOVE!

Member since 5/05

12578 total posts

Name:

Do you think this is healthy?

My friends have a 16 month old daughter. The mom is stick thin and the dad is a big guy, but not fat. Apparently the dad was chubby as a child and is totally paranoid about weight. So they only give their DD lowfat milk, fat free cheese, lowfat or fat free yogurt. They won't give her foods like fish sticks because the fat content is too high. On her first birthday they would not even let her taste the cake.

I'm all for making smart healthy choices and teaching a young child to eat properly, but I thought a young child needs some fat (like whole milk, cheese and yogurt.) I let DD have a piece of cookie or cake on special occasions - I just don't offer it at home on a regular basis, etc.

I just worry this baby isn't getting what she needs nutrionally. Not really my business, just curious.

Message edited 2007-12-28 23:07:09.020000.

Posted 12/28/07 11:05 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

BaroqueMama
Chase is one!

Member since 5/05

27530 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Do you think this is healthy?

Definitely not healthy, but hopefully they are being guided by a doctor.

Posted 12/28/07 11:08 PM
 

Charly
LOVE!

Member since 5/05

12578 total posts

Name:

Re: Do you think this is healthy?

Posted by prncss

Definitely not healthy, but hopefully they are being guided by a doctor.



not sure about that, but I wouldn't feel better if they were. IMO their ped is quack - he told her she can leave formula out up to 10 hours, they can give Motrin like "candy", etc. Chat Icon I'm not a dr. that just doesn't sound right to me.

Their DD is really thin and they are always saying how she has a "belly." Honestly she doesn't. My DD has a bellyChat Icon

Posted 12/28/07 11:12 PM
 

nymommy2be
I love the summer

Member since 1/06

2063 total posts

Name:
Kara

Re: Do you think this is healthy?

My ped said that until they are 2 they need a high fat diet, so that diet does not sound right to me.

Posted 12/28/07 11:15 PM
 

BaroqueMama
Chase is one!

Member since 5/05

27530 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Do you think this is healthy?

Give motrin like candy? Sounds like they either have a terrible doctor or a really bad interpretation of what their doctor actually says.

Posted 12/28/07 11:21 PM
 

PrincessP
Big sister!!!!!!!!!!

Member since 12/05

17450 total posts

Name:

Re: Do you think this is healthy?

Posted by prncss

Give motrin like candy? Sounds like they either have a terrible doctor or a really bad interpretation of what their doctor actually says.



No joke...WTH does that mean???
Maybe they need to see a psych for their own issues

In terms of staying healthy...my dd can eat like a racehorse. I try to compensate by adding 2 jars of veggies, or cut up some veggies etc...
She can eat ya out of house and home but yet at her 1 yr appt she was only 20 punds 3 ozs...odd, no?

Posted 12/29/07 9:30 AM
 

btrflygrl
me and baby #3!

Member since 5/05

12013 total posts

Name:
Shana

Re: Do you think this is healthy?

absolutely NOT healthy....babies NEED fat in order for their brains to develop

Posted 12/29/07 9:31 AM
 

Charly
LOVE!

Member since 5/05

12578 total posts

Name:

Re: Do you think this is healthy?

Posted by PrincessP

Posted by prncss

Give motrin like candy? Sounds like they either have a terrible doctor or a really bad interpretation of what their doctor actually says.



No joke...WTH does that mean???
Maybe they need to see a psych for their own issues

In terms of staying healthy...my dd can eat like a racehorse. I try to compensate by adding 2 jars of veggies, or cut up some veggies etc...
She can eat ya out of house and home but yet at her 1 yr appt she was only 20 punds 3 ozs...odd, no?



When Hannah started teething I called her and asked her what did she give her DD and how much. Her exact words to me were "we just give her Motrin every 6 - 8 hours all day. The ped said we can give it like candy." I mean she followed the dosage and directions but would use it all the time. My ped said I should never use it for teething, only Tylenol. He reserves the use of Motrin for her ear infections.

My DD packs food away too - she's 25 lbs!!! Chat Icon

Message edited 2007-12-29 09:33:38.363000.

Posted 12/29/07 9:32 AM
 

PrincessP
Big sister!!!!!!!!!!

Member since 12/05

17450 total posts

Name:

Re: Do you think this is healthy?

Posted by Charly

Posted by PrincessP

Posted by prncss

Give motrin like candy? Sounds like they either have a terrible doctor or a really bad interpretation of what their doctor actually says.



No joke...WTH does that mean???
Maybe they need to see a psych for their own issues

In terms of staying healthy...my dd can eat like a racehorse. I try to compensate by adding 2 jars of veggies, or cut up some veggies etc...
She can eat ya out of house and home but yet at her 1 yr appt she was only 20 punds 3 ozs...odd, no?



When Hannah started teething I called her and asked her what did she give her DD and how much. Her exact words to me were "we just give her Motrin every 6 - 8 hours all day. The ped said we can give it like candy." I mean she followed the dosage and directions but would use it all the time. My ped said I should never use it for teething, only Tylenol. He reserves the use of Motrin for her ear infections.

My DD packs food away too - she's 25 lbs!!! Chat Icon


I would NEVER use it like it was a game...EVENTUALLY...it wont have the same effects anyhow. I didnt give tylenol or motrin regularly...just when I thought she needed it. Boy they have alot of game playing with their child Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 12/29/07 9:37 AM
 

Stacey1403
Where it all began....

Member since 5/05

24065 total posts

Name:

Re: Do you think this is healthy?

Not only is it unhealthy but they are setting her up to be a closet eater as she gets older. To me this is child abuseChat Icon

Posted 12/29/07 9:47 AM
 

ddunne2
LIF Adult

Member since 7/05

4189 total posts

Name:
Doreen

Re: Do you think this is healthy?

Not healthy at all! In fact, I still give Jack whole milk at age 3 since that is what our doc reccomends since his is on the slim side. No baby should be eating lowfat yogurt with has artificial sweetners or lowfat milk. They need the fat for heatlhy development. They need to learn the difference between good and bad fats at this age. Whole milk=good. Whole twinkies=bad. That poor child! All they are teaching her is to be self consious and obsessive about her weight as she gets older.

Posted 12/29/07 9:51 AM
 

Bxgell2
Perfection

Member since 5/05

16438 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: Do you think this is healthy?

Any extreme will be damaging to a child, but you know what, I think in this Country there are too few parents who actually think long and hard about what exactly they are feeding their children, and the poor eating habits they are forming at such an early age. DH and I are extremely mindful of what we feed Alex, and recently we did make the switch from whole milk products to low fat, and we don't give her cake, cookies or unhealthy, processed snacks. Her typical snack is whole wheat pita with hummus, cucumbers, tomatoes and then some raisins.

That doesn't mean she doesn't get enough fat in her diet - by all means she does with the fatty fish she eats and the dairy products, even if they have a lower fat content. We don't entirely deprive her either - she does, on occasion, have a cookie, or cake, but it's very rare. And the end product? SHe's just about the only kid in her class who actually LOVES vegetables and eats them happily, and prefers mango and melon to the big red-frosted elmo cake at birthday parties.

Posted 12/29/07 9:54 AM
 

dm24angel
Happiness

Member since 5/05

34581 total posts

Name:
Donna

Re: Do you think this is healthy?

OMg thats sooo wrong. Babies need FULL FAT milk products!

Posted 12/29/07 1:22 PM
 

MelToddJulia
Love my Family!

Member since 7/05

29064 total posts

Name:
Mel

Re: Do you think this is healthy?

Posted by Stacey1403

Not only is it unhealthy but they are setting her up to be a closet eater as she gets older. To me this is child abuseChat Icon





ITA!! I feel bad for the kid!Chat Icon

Posted 12/29/07 1:25 PM
 

dandr10199
Grace is growing up too fast!

Member since 10/05

11561 total posts

Name:
Dina

Re: Do you think this is healthy?

Posted by btrflygrl

absolutely NOT healthy....babies NEED fat in order for their brains to develop



ITA!

Posted 12/29/07 1:41 PM
 

Mommy2Boys
My Boys!!!!

Member since 6/06

14437 total posts

Name:
C

Re: Do you think this is healthy?

Absolutely NOT healthy! Unless the baby is severly over weight which I doubt, will a dr. recommend low-fat anything. Babies need to eat fat for brain development and general growth.

Those 2 sounds like quacks...and i highly doubt their dr. told them any of that. They are probably just saying that to make themselves feel better for being stupid. I feel bad for their child.

Posted 12/29/07 1:57 PM
 

MamaNDaddyof3
:)

Member since 5/05

7267 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: Do you think this is healthy?

that poor kid
no cake on your own bdayChat Icon that is just terrible

Posted 12/29/07 2:06 PM
 

EtWaFM
LIF Infant

Member since 8/06

178 total posts

Name:

Re: Do you think this is healthy?

That is VERY UNHEALTHY! Babies until 2 years of age should have FULL FAT milk products to help brain growth. The brain needs fat to develop properly.

"The general advice from the American Academy of Pediatrics is that you don't limit a toddler's fat intake until they are two years old and that you should not switch to low fat milk until that time.

The American Dietetic Society also warns that 'efforts to limit fat intake for infants and toddlers are unwise. Infants and toddlers under two years need fat and calories to fuel their rapid growth.'"

Posted 12/29/07 2:24 PM
 

casey31
Mommy of 3!

Member since 5/05

2967 total posts

Name:
Mommy to two boys and a girl

Re: Do you think this is healthy?

They are setting up that poor girl for an eating disorder later in life, JMO. She will feel so deprived she might have issues with food.

I try and have Matty eat right at 13 months but he is not a big eater at all- he eats 3 meals and we try and make them healthy but he only eats a few bites. My DR. said to reduce his formula-and to switch to whole milk at a year but I'm scared to because he likes his baba more than food. He is only in the 40% for weight and 80% for height- but I was a slender child and DH was a stick.

Sometimes we give Matty pieces of cookies when he is really cranky and we are at our wits end. Chat Icon But mostly he has fun giving them to our dogs- who have gained to much weight since Matty started solids! Chat Icon

Message edited 2007-12-29 17:32:31.017000.

Posted 12/29/07 5:31 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
NASSAU MOMS - HEalthy products for your homes! (event THursday) 4monkeys 6/13/07 3 Parenting
What are you eating throughout the day? I feel like I am not eating healthy enough for baby. Mommy2Boys 8/10/06 3 Pregnancy
do u think its easier to have a boy or a girl AND DONT SAY AS LONG AS ITS HEALTHY! lol Michi 12/28/05 32 Families Helping Families ™
healthy appetizers needed dooodles 3/22/06 3 Diet & Fitness
Enusre: Healthy Mom Drinks MrsSchwags 3/3/06 9 Pregnancy
Healthy Crockpot Recipes Elbee 2/14/06 1 Dining In or Out