Do you think the Constitution is outdated?

Posted By Message

klingklang77
kraftwerk!

Member since 7/06

11489 total posts

Name:
Völlig losgelöst

Do you think the Constitution is outdated?

I have heard a lot of talk about our founding fathers and how people are afraid that if one president gets elected then our country will be changed from what our founding fathers founded the country on.

For example, the right to bear arms. Many think it shouldn't be changed b/c it is in the Constitution.

The Constitution was written in the 18th century, and the world is a far different place than what it was.

Not really sure of my point here Chat Icon I haven't had my second cup of tea yet and it is morning here, but do you think the Constitution is outdated?

Message edited 2008-10-07 20:05:10.917000.

Posted 10/7/08 8:04 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

MrsProfessor
hi

Member since 5/05

14279 total posts

Name:

Re: Do you think the Constitution is outdated?

I think it's a "living" document (I've heard others use this term.) and as such, should be regularly looked at. For example, I don't think our forefathers ever imagined the invention of assault rifles- I don't think that's what is meant by "the right to bear arms."

Posted 10/7/08 8:07 PM
 

Cpt2007
A new love!

Member since 1/08

5946 total posts

Name:
Liz

Re: Do you think the Constitution is outdated?

No. The document itself (take out the Bill of Rights and other Amendments), is written in a way that it is still applicable to today. We all, as citizens of this nation, engage in and accept the basic social contract laid forth in the Constitution. The Amendment process is there to allow us to change this document over time should we collectively choose to do so.

There will always be debate over the "right to bear arms" b/c it is open to interpretation. But the 19th Amendment (allowing women to vote) was to correct statutory discrimination.

So, what I think it comes down to is more a question of this:

Are certain Amendments out of date? Do we need clearer definitions or interpretations of portions of the Bill of Rights?

Much more difficult questions that have to be taken on a case by case basis.

Posted 10/7/08 8:10 PM
 

Cpt2007
A new love!

Member since 1/08

5946 total posts

Name:
Liz

Re: Do you think the Constitution is outdated?

Posted by MrsProfessor

I think it's a "living" document (I've heard others use this term.) and as such, should be regularly looked at. For example, I don't think our forefathers ever imagined the invention of assault rifles- I don't think that's what is meant by "the right to bear arms."



Many people do not agree, though, that it is a "living" document, such as Justices Scalia and Thomas.

Here's an article on their theory: Originalism

Posted 10/7/08 8:11 PM
 

SweetestOfPeas
J'taime Paris!

Member since 3/06

32345 total posts

Name:

Re: Do you think the Constitution is outdated?

I am a firm believer and supporter of the right to bear arms.

and FYI - Hitler and Stalin stripped their citizens of arms when they came into power.

Message edited 2008-10-07 20:18:17.303000.

Posted 10/7/08 8:15 PM
 

Kara
Now Zagat Rated!

Member since 3/07

13217 total posts

Name:
They call me "Tater Salad"

Re: Do you think the Constitution is outdated?

Posted by Cpt2007

Posted by MrsProfessor

I think it's a "living" document (I've heard others use this term.) and as such, should be regularly looked at. For example, I don't think our forefathers ever imagined the invention of assault rifles- I don't think that's what is meant by "the right to bear arms."



Many people do not agree, though, that it is a "living" document, such as Justices Scalia and Thomas.

Here's an article on their theory: Originalism



Modern-day constitutional scholars mostly believe that originalism and the idea that the constitution is a living document are largely compatible. Does that mean that originalists all believe it is a living document? Of course not -- but I would bet many do. Most originalists would also look to the legislative history of amendments when interpreting the constitution... That doesn't mean they don't think amendments to the constitution are valid (or that any future amendments wouldn't be valid).

ETA -- I personally believe the constitution is a living document in that there are procedures to amend and change it. I do think that people who feel it is outdated in some way should work with their representatives and senators to effectuate change.

Message edited 2008-10-07 20:22:48.830000.

Posted 10/7/08 8:16 PM
 

klingklang77
kraftwerk!

Member since 7/06

11489 total posts

Name:
Völlig losgelöst

Re: Do you think the Constitution is outdated?

Posted by SweetestOfPeas

I am a firm believer and supporter of the right to bear arms.

and FYI - Hitler and Stalin stripped their citizens of arms when they came into power.



I think that could be another discussion. I personally believe that people should not be allowed to bear arms for personal protection, JMO. I think for hunting, pest control etc, ok, but you have to prove it. It seems to work here and you don't hear about shootings very often.

Posted 10/7/08 8:23 PM
 

SweetestOfPeas
J'taime Paris!

Member since 3/06

32345 total posts

Name:

Re: Do you think the Constitution is outdated?

Posted by klingklang77

Posted by SweetestOfPeas

I am a firm believer and supporter of the right to bear arms.

and FYI - Hitler and Stalin stripped their citizens of arms when they came into power.



I think that could be another discussion. I personally believe that people should not be allowed to bear arms for personal protection, JMO. I think for hunting, pest control etc, ok, but you have to prove it. It seems to work here and you don't hear about shootings very often.

you're entitled to your opinion.

I already stated how I feel.

Posted 10/7/08 8:24 PM
 

tourist

Member since 5/05

10425 total posts

Name:

Re: Do you think the Constitution is outdated?

Posted by klingklang77



The Constitution was written in the 18th century, and the world is a far different place than what it was.




But there have been amendments since then. I think that is such a key part of the constitution. I don't think it us outdated at all. It is a framework for laws to be created under.
Laws should be created to keep up with the times.

Posted 10/7/08 9:55 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Are flagstone patios outdated? [Poll] greenfreak 8/31/08 17 Home
LOL...anyone elses avatar significantly outdated... PrincessP 6/16/08 28 Parenting
Do you think this style will be outdated "soon"? smdl 6/2/08 4 Home
Pics of my outdated, undecorated BA! CaidensMommy 11/17/07 5 Home
spinoff to outdated words rose825 8/25/07 2 Families Helping Families ™
Old Fashioned/Outdated Words or Expressions LaPetiteSirène 8/25/07 20 Families Helping Families ™