Re: Do you think the Constitution is outdated?
Posted 10/7/2008 8:16:49 PM by Kara


Posted by Cpt2007


Posted by MrsProfessor

I think it's a "living" document (I've heard others use this term.) and as such, should be regularly looked at. For example, I don't think our forefathers ever imagined the invention of assault rifles- I don't think that's what is meant by "the right to bear arms."



Many people do not agree, though, that it is a "living" document, such as Justices Scalia and Thomas.

Here's an article on their theory: Originalism



Modern-day constitutional scholars mostly believe that originalism and the idea that the constitution is a living document are largely compatible. Does that mean that originalists all believe it is a living document? Of course not -- but I would bet many do. Most originalists would also look to the legislative history of amendments when interpreting the constitution... That doesn't mean they don't think amendments to the constitution are valid (or that any future amendments wouldn't be valid).

ETA -- I personally believe the constitution is a living document in that there are procedures to amend and change it. I do think that people who feel it is outdated in some way should work with their representatives and senators to effectuate change.
Print Post      Close Window