What Do You Do?

Forum Opinion Poll
I take comfort and faith from her words. 12 20.34%
I think she's a little kooky, but she's still my friend. 36 61.02%
I am angry that she would say something like this and challenge her to prove it or retract 1 1.69%
I think she's nuts and distance myself right quick! 3 5.08%
I get closer so I can investigate to see what she thinks she is.. 7 11.86%
 

Vote in this poll

View poll

Do You Believe Them?

Posted By Message

rojerono
Happiest.

Member since 8/06

13803 total posts

Name:
Jeannie

Do You Believe Them?

So you are friends with someone for quite some time and although they are .. unique.. they really have no outward signs of serious mental illness. You enjoy their company.

One day your friend tells you that God Exists and that she knows this as fact. You aren't an atheist - but the certainty in her voice is something different. So you press the issue. She gets a little alarmed at the realization of what she's said and basically says "I know God Exists. I can't tell you how I know or what I am or who I am... but if you believe anything I've ever said... believe that God is Real and you never have anything to worry about."

Do you believe her and take comfort in the words? Do you not believe her but figure she's harmless and continue on as normal? Or do you pull away thinking she's clearly bat sh*t and headed for a mental hospital in the near future?

Posted 12/22/09 8:20 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Jax430
Hi!

Member since 5/05

18919 total posts

Name:
Jackie

Re: Do You Believe Them?

Well, since I'm a psychologist, I'd probably do a little exploration to get more specifics about what she means, and try to determine if she is having a religious experience or a delusional experience....although the two can be hard to separate in cases like this! I'd definitely be looking for other signs of a thought disorder, and if I thought she was mentally ill, I would try to steer her toward getting help, although that is difficult if someone doesn't recognize her mental illness.

Posted 12/22/09 8:27 AM
 

headoverheels
s'il vous plaît

Member since 6/07

42079 total posts

Name:
LB

Re: Do You Believe Them?

I would probably just let it go. If she's never does anything malicious, harmful or scary, and has generally been a good friend, I would just chalk it up to being on of her "quirks."

That being said, I'm not an aetheist, I'm agnostic - I believe in God (or a higher power) but not in organized religion. So I would try and take comfort in her words and maybe pay a bit closer attention to what she says and does. But I'm also a very cynical person so I might find it difficult to take her seriously.

Posted 12/22/09 8:32 AM
 

Domino
Always My Miracle

Member since 9/05

9924 total posts

Name:

Re: Do You Believe Them?

Posted by rojerono
She gets a little alarmed at the realization of what she's said and basically says "I know God Exists. I can't tell you how I know or what I am or who I am... but if you believe anything I've ever said... believe that God is Real and you never have anything to worry about."



This would bother me and would make me investigate further. She may need help

Posted 12/22/09 8:37 AM
 

GioiaMia
Let's Go Rangers!

Member since 1/07

14818 total posts

Name:

Re: Do You Believe Them?

Well, I know God exists too . . . Chat Icon but the "what i am, who i am" comment is setting off alarm bells for me. I would try to get her to elaborate. . .

Posted 12/22/09 9:40 AM
 

dpli
Daylight savings :)

Member since 5/05

13973 total posts

Name:
D

Re: Do You Believe Them?

Posted by rojerono

She gets a little alarmed at the realization of what she's said and basically says "I know God Exists. I can't tell you how I know or what I am or who I am... but if you believe anything I've ever said... believe that God is Real and you never have anything to worry about."




This is a red flag to me. I would ask more questions to try to figure out if she needs help.

Posted 12/22/09 10:08 AM
 

eroxgirl
My Loves

Member since 5/05

15697 total posts

Name:
Rebecca

Re: Do You Believe Them?

Posted by headoverheels

I would probably just let it go. If she's never does anything malicious, harmful or scary, and has generally been a good friend, I would just chalk it up to being on of her "quirks."

That being said, I'm not an aetheist, I'm agnostic - I believe in God (or a higher power) but not in organized religion. So I would try and take comfort in her words and maybe pay a bit closer attention to what she says and does. But I'm also a very cynical person so I might find it difficult to take her seriously.



I don't necessarily define myself as agnostic but if I think about it, it fits. Overall, I could have written the same.

Posted 12/22/09 10:12 AM
 

Otherme
Square head cutie pants

Member since 3/06

6899 total posts

Name:

Re: Do You Believe Them?

Posted by rojerono

" I can't tell you how I know or what I am or who I am... but if you believe anything I've ever said... believe that God is Real and you never have anything to worry about."



This is the quote that would bother me. I'd first off question if she was on something hallucinagenic (seriously) because that sounds like drugs talking.
If you're sure she's not on anything, then i'd genuinely ask her what she meant by it. If she insists that she's 'something' supernatural (or whatever the choice of word might be) then it sounds like she might be delusional.
If this persists, i'd ask her if she's considered seeing anyone about to talk about it.
If it's not really brought up again or you don't see any other signs and she's not harming herself with this delusion.. then just be a supportive friend, while keeping a close eye on her

As for taking comfort in it.. well, only you can answer that for yourself.
Personally, i'd scoff at it, but that's just cynical ol me Chat Icon

Message edited 2009-12-22 10:15:29.080000.

Posted 12/22/09 10:15 AM
 

Kara
Now Zagat Rated!

Member since 3/07

13217 total posts

Name:
They call me "Tater Salad"

Re: Do You Believe Them?

Posted by Tilde

Well, I know God exists too . . . Chat Icon but the "what i am, who i am" comment is setting off alarm bells for me. I would try to get her to elaborate. . .



My thoughts exactly. If knowing that God exists makes someone crazy, then count me in.

HOWEVER, the "I can't tell you how I know or who I am" thing would make me think she's a little kooky. I really don't think I'd think she is mentally ill or anything, though, based on this alone. Has she exhibited any other abnormal behaviors? Did you press the issue farther?

Maybe ask her to explain a little more to find out if you should be worried or if she's just a little eccentric.

Message edited 2009-12-22 10:24:31.517000.

Posted 12/22/09 10:19 AM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Do You Believe Them?

Posted by Jax430

I'd probably do a little exploration to get more specifics about what she means, and try to determine if she is having a religious experience or a delusional experience....although the two can be hard to separate in cases like this! I'd definitely be looking for other signs of a thought disorder, and if I thought she was mentally ill, I would try to steer her toward getting help, although that is difficult if someone doesn't recognize her mental illness.



I agree completely.

Posted 12/22/09 10:21 AM
 

DiamondGirl
You are my I love you

Member since 7/09

18802 total posts

Name:
DiamondMama

Re: Do You Believe Them?

Posted by Tilde

Well, I know God exists too . . . Chat Icon but the "what i am, who i am" comment is setting off alarm bells for me. I would try to get her to elaborate. . .



I agree...

I know someone who is bipolar and has spoken like this during one of her maniac times...

Posted 12/22/09 10:30 AM
 

MeNBobs
*****

Member since 4/07

3765 total posts

Name:

Re: Do You Believe Them?

I would wait until this person started speaking in tongues and got a little flame over their head.

Doubting Rojerono is a good nickname for you.

Posted 12/22/09 10:43 AM
 

MissingLI
Such a Big Boy!

Member since 1/06

1602 total posts

Name:
C

Re: Do You Believe Them?

If I'm going to tell the truth, the first thing that popped in my head when I read all that was, take comfort.

How long have you known her? Has she ever displayed any types of mental unbalance where she could hurt herself or others? If not, I wouldn't look more into it.

Has she ever expressed that she has any psycic or meduimship abilities? This is what crossed my mind. It could also be that I'm reading a James Van Praagh book right now that's making me lean the way I am.

Her message, in the whole is one of letting you know that you are not alone, it's meant to give comfort. Take it for what it's worth. Chat Icon

JMHO

Posted 12/22/09 10:43 AM
 

MarathonKnitter
HAPPY

Member since 2/07

17374 total posts

Name:
EMBRACING CHANGE

Re: Do You Believe Them?

another vote for what tilde says.

i KNOW there is a God!
it's the fact that she's lost on the other aspects of the conversation.

if she "just found religion", there are going to be things she can't describe, yet... but she'll have some reference point. many people who are born again, can't always answer questions when they first find Jesus, but they will tell you that they're reading the Bible or attending services.

if she can't "back it up", then i would investigate a little further.

i pray that she really did find God

Posted 12/22/09 10:47 AM
 

rojerono
Happiest.

Member since 8/06

13803 total posts

Name:
Jeannie

Re: Do You Believe Them?

Soo.. what if the person didn't say "I can't tell you who/what I am.." but instead seemed uncomfortable about how emphatic and 'in the know' she seemed to be relevant to God's existance? Like .. it is OBVIOUS she is holding back some knowledge but will not be forthcoming about it. Would this make a difference?




Message edited 2009-12-22 10:55:04.277000.

Posted 12/22/09 10:52 AM
 

MissingLI
Such a Big Boy!

Member since 1/06

1602 total posts

Name:
C

Re: Do You Believe Them?

I don't know. Again, I'm not the type of person to jump to mental illness all the time, it could be the people I associate with as well. I would wonder, if she had some other thing going that she is just not comfortable talking about because she may think you'll think she's crazy? KWIM? Maybe she had some experience, that was purely unique to her, that really made her know, but doesn't know how to share it. For whatever reason, she felt that this was a message you needed to hear at this time.

Posted 12/22/09 11:02 AM
 

MarathonKnitter
HAPPY

Member since 2/07

17374 total posts

Name:
EMBRACING CHANGE

Re: Do You Believe Them?

Posted by rojerono

Soo.. what if the person didn't say "I can't tell you who/what I am.." but instead seemed uncomfortable about how emphatic and 'in the know' she seemed to be relevant to God's existance? Like .. it is OBVIOUS she is holding back some knowledge but will not be forthcoming about it. Would this make a difference?



to me: yes.

most people who i know, who have just found God, want to share the news and what they've learned with EVERYONE who will listen.

again, i am limiting my this to my experience as a christian. most people who find Jesus want to shout it from the rooftops. the fact that she's being mysterious about it makes me worry just a bit.

Posted 12/22/09 11:05 AM
 

Pray4Baby2010
<3 Cutest Giants Fan

Member since 10/09

5796 total posts

Name:
MB

Re: Do You Believe Them?

I voted that I would take comfort in her words- I think that God tries to communicate and be there for those of us that need him/her at specific times and sometimes in unusual ways....

But I have to admit after re-reading the part about "who I am"- I would be concerned about your friend and just check on her as a couple pp mentioned.

Posted 12/22/09 11:14 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Nope. I don't believe it. I won't believe it.... lipglossjunky73 3/3/08 22 Parenting
Snoop Doggs- New hot dogs coming out. You have to read it to believe it. DebG 11/18/05 8 Families Helping Families ™
OMG - I can't believe this was 18 years ago! beena 10/14/05 6 Families Helping Families ™
We had candy talk, I believe chip talk, soo... lvdolphins 9/30/05 16 Families Helping Families ™
I cannot believe this...I got offered a teaching job! CaseyGirl 7/22/05 25 Families Helping Families ™
I cant believe this yankee fan needs mets fans help! UPDATE WITH ANOTHER QUESTION! NS1976 7/15/05 8 Families Helping Families ™