Disney debarbs stingrays

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2]

MsMBV
:P

Member since 5/05

28602 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Disney debarbs stingrays

Posted by CaptainCharisma424

ok, but let me just state up front

i do NOT hate animals

and it may not have been the best choice to make

but, in this case, it might have been the only option

Let me pose a question.

Suppose you're on a Disney cruise and you pay for the stingray excursion

and god-forbid something happens to you, ala Steve Irwin.

what do you do?

Disney is simply protecting itself from a lawsuit, even though the chances are slim. The Irwin thing was a freak accident, but it can happen.

They examined the risk and realize that it will be easier to deal with the animal rights folks, then a big lawsuit, that will gain them negative media attention and hurt business.

I understand your point, but then why continue to allow the Stingray excursions? Wouldn't that be the best option if you are willing to go to such an extreme to avoid a potential lawsuit? Aren't there a million & 1 other things that you can do when on that cruise?

Posted 2/9/07 4:10 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

QuoteTheRaven424
22 Months?!!!!

Member since 5/05

13659 total posts

Name:
And If That Isn't A True Blue Miracle

Re: Disney debarbs stingrays

Posted by MsMBV

Posted by CaptainCharisma424

ok, but let me just state up front

i do NOT hate animals

and it may not have been the best choice to make

but, in this case, it might have been the only option

Let me pose a question.

Suppose you're on a Disney cruise and you pay for the stingray excursion

and god-forbid something happens to you, ala Steve Irwin.

what do you do?

Disney is simply protecting itself from a lawsuit, even though the chances are slim. The Irwin thing was a freak accident, but it can happen.

They examined the risk and realize that it will be easier to deal with the animal rights folks, then a big lawsuit, that will gain them negative media attention and hurt business.

I understand your point, but then why continue to allow the Stingray excursions? Wouldn't that be the best option if you are willing to go to such an extreme to avoid a potential lawsuit? Aren't there a million & 1 other things that you can do when on that cruise?




point extremely well taken and i agree with that.

but let's say you're not on the excursion

can they swim near the shore where the beach goers are?

Posted 2/9/07 4:12 PM
 

baghag
:P

Member since 5/05

10278 total posts

Name:

Re: Disney debarbs stingrays

Posted by CaptainCharisma424
ok, but let me just state up front

i do NOT hate animals

and it may not have been the best choice to make

but, in this case, it might have been the only option

Let me pose a question.

Suppose you're on a Disney cruise and you pay for the stingray excursion

and god-forbid something happens to you, ala Steve Irwin.

what do you do?

Disney is simply protecting itself from a lawsuit, even though the chances are slim. The Irwin thing was a freak accident, but it can happen.

They examined the risk and realize that it will be easier to deal with the animal rights folks, then a big lawsuit, that will gain them negative media attention and hurt business.



I totally understand your point.

However- this is a wild animal in it's natural habitat. That's the distinction for me. It's not a closed environment. As far as I can tell (and I may be wrong), ANY stingray from the ocean can swim into this area. Is Disney going to trap and de-barb every single one in the area?

It's not a feasible solution and it provides a false sense of security. I actually think it might make matters worse, that people and their kids won't give them the space and respect that they would if they had their barbs.

Posted 2/9/07 4:13 PM
 

baghag
:P

Member since 5/05

10278 total posts

Name:

Re: Disney debarbs stingrays

Posted by CaptainCharisma424

can they swim near the shore where the beach goers are?



They can, and they do.

I'm glad they are concerned for safety, but this isn't the solution.

Posted 2/9/07 4:15 PM
 

QuoteTheRaven424
22 Months?!!!!

Member since 5/05

13659 total posts

Name:
And If That Isn't A True Blue Miracle

Re: Disney debarbs stingrays

Posted by baghag

Posted by CaptainCharisma424

can they swim near the shore where the beach goers are?



They can, and they do.

I'm glad they are concerned for safety, but this isn't the solution.



ok - totally legit question here

if you don't do that, then what?

Posted 2/9/07 4:19 PM
 

MsMBV
:P

Member since 5/05

28602 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Disney debarbs stingrays

Posted by CaptainCharisma424

Posted by baghag

Posted by CaptainCharisma424

can they swim near the shore where the beach goers are?



They can, and they do.

I'm glad they are concerned for safety, but this isn't the solution.



ok - totally legit question here

if you don't do that, then what?

Don't sponsor the excursion anymore.

Posted 2/9/07 4:24 PM
 

MrsDiamondgrlie
Bailey

Member since 5/05

12810 total posts

Name:
D

Re: Disney debarbs stingrays

I think that is wrong but I wonder if they did extensive research on whether or not there are actually predators in the area.

Posted 2/9/07 4:27 PM
 

MrsPorkChop
Twinning!!

Member since 5/05

9941 total posts

Name:
Missy

Re: Disney debarbs stingrays

yeah it bothers me but then i felt this other instinct-
how would i feel if a child died playing in the water with a stingray?
to me thats more tragic so the debarbing doesnt bother me quite as much

eta - and i agree with the captain- god what is this world coming to? Chat Icon Chat Icon

Message edited 2007-02-09 16:30:35.507000.

Posted 2/9/07 4:29 PM
 

baghag
:P

Member since 5/05

10278 total posts

Name:

Re: Disney debarbs stingrays

Posted by MsMBV

Posted by CaptainCharisma424

ok - totally legit question here

if you don't do that, then what?

Don't sponsor the excursion anymore.



I agree.

I wouldn't be happy about it, I did it and it was a great experience. BUT I take full responsibility for it and had I gotten hurt or killed I wouldn't be suing anyone. Nor would DH, in my absence.

Plus, if you keep this going, where does it end? I'm a newbie diver. I can't go and remove all the teeth of all the sharks in the ocean to avoid getting bitten, kwim?

Posted 2/9/07 4:32 PM
 

MsMBV
:P

Member since 5/05

28602 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Disney debarbs stingrays

Posted by MrsPorkChop

yeah it bothers me but then i felt this other instinct-
how would i feel if a child died playing in the water with a stingray?
to me thats more tragic so the debarbing doesnt bother me quite as much

Here's the thing...it is voluntary, no one is required to go play with the stingrays. I think when you do something like this; whether it is parasailing, swimming with dolphins, jet skiiing, you have to realize that there is a danger involved. That is why it bothers me. No one is forcing anyone on the cruise to go into the water with the stingrays.

What are they going to do next, take all of the teeth out of area sharks who might swim through the water? KWIM?

I am not unsympathetic, and I do think that it would be tragic if someone got hurt, but the animal is being "harrassed" in its own natural habitat. To me it is innocent & we are the offenders.Chat Icon

Posted 2/9/07 4:33 PM
 

MrsDiamondgrlie
Bailey

Member since 5/05

12810 total posts

Name:
D

Re: Disney debarbs stingrays

Posted by baghag


Plus, if you keep this going, where does it end? I'm a newbie diver. I can't go and remove all the teeth of all the sharks in the ocean to avoid getting bitten, kwim?



But sadly, if someone owned the whole ocean and was afraid of a potential lawsuit perhaps they would try to "de-tooth" the sharks. Chat Icon Very sad how the world revolves around money.

Posted 2/9/07 4:38 PM
 

QuoteTheRaven424
22 Months?!!!!

Member since 5/05

13659 total posts

Name:
And If That Isn't A True Blue Miracle

Re: Disney debarbs stingrays

Posted by MsMBV

Posted by CaptainCharisma424

Posted by baghag

Posted by CaptainCharisma424

can they swim near the shore where the beach goers are?



They can, and they do.

I'm glad they are concerned for safety, but this isn't the solution.



ok - totally legit question here

if you don't do that, then what?

Don't sponsor the excursion anymore.



ok, but they still can come in contact with them right?

Posted 2/9/07 4:40 PM
 

SweetTooth
I'm a tired mommy!

Member since 12/05

20105 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: Disney debarbs stingrays

Posted by CaptainCharisma424

Posted by MsMBV

Posted by CaptainCharisma424

Posted by baghag

Posted by CaptainCharisma424

can they swim near the shore where the beach goers are?



They can, and they do.

I'm glad they are concerned for safety, but this isn't the solution.



ok - totally legit question here

if you don't do that, then what?

Don't sponsor the excursion anymore.



ok, but they still can come in contact with them right?



you can come in contact with a rabid raccoon walking in the park. if it bit you and you died of rabies, would your family sue the park?

if I am swimming in the ocean, I am taking the chance that I might get hurt.

to mutilate animals is not the answer. there is always the chance of getting hurt no matter what you are doing or where you are.

Message edited 2007-02-09 16:50:38.897000.

Posted 2/9/07 4:50 PM
 

baghag
:P

Member since 5/05

10278 total posts

Name:

Re: Disney debarbs stingrays

Posted by CaptainCharisma424
ok, but they still can come in contact with them right?



Yup.

I don't think Disney is "out to get" the stingrays or did it out of malice. I think it's a good intention, just a not real solution.


Posted 2/9/07 4:51 PM
 

ssbride05
:-)

Member since 5/05

2654 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Disney debarbs stingrays

Posted by CaptainCharisma424

Posted by MsMBV

Posted by CaptainCharisma424

uh-oh

did the captain learn his lesson from this past week, when he offered an opinion that went against the popular grain of thought? Chat Icon

will he keep his big mouth shut? Chat Icon

<Bracing self>

Go ahead Don, I am bored todayChat Icon



ok, but let me just state up front

i do NOT hate animals

and it may not have been the best choice to make

but, in this case, it might have been the only option

Let me pose a question.

Suppose you're on a Disney cruise and you pay for the stingray excursion

and god-forbid something happens to you, ala Steve Irwin.

what do you do?

Disney is simply protecting itself from a lawsuit, even though the chances are slim. The Irwin thing was a freak accident, but it can happen.

They examined the risk and realize that it will be easier to deal with the animal rights folks, then a big lawsuit, that will gain them negative media attention and hurt business.



I understand and respect what you're saying.. in my opinion, this is all at the expense of the animals rights and taht's what bothers me. I don't think we have a right.. then they shouldn't have the exhibit. Why can't animals just be respected? I think it's wrong. Chat Icon

Posted 2/9/07 4:52 PM
 

QuoteTheRaven424
22 Months?!!!!

Member since 5/05

13659 total posts

Name:
And If That Isn't A True Blue Miracle

Re: Disney debarbs stingrays

all the points are valid

i still say disney made the decision they thought was best for its patrons and for business

Posted 2/9/07 4:52 PM
 

SweetTooth
I'm a tired mommy!

Member since 12/05

20105 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: Disney debarbs stingrays

Posted by CaptainCharisma424

all the points are valid

i still say disney made the decision they thought was best for its patrons and for business



i'm sure you are 100% right about that!

Posted 2/9/07 4:54 PM
 

ssbride05
:-)

Member since 5/05

2654 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Disney debarbs stingrays

Posted by CaptainCharisma424

all the points are valid

i still say disney made the decision they thought was best for its patrons and for business



I totally agree... but when do you begin to weigh the importance of your business and respect for wildlife. honestly, they have so many exhibits in disney.. do they really need the sting ray exhibit? I don't know, I think it's pretty selfish on Disney's part. Chat Icon

ETA: that Disney is so powerful.. they own so much and EVERYONE knows Disney.. what kind of example are they setting for the public? It's ok to disrespect animals so you can make money? Chat Icon I am sorry, I respect other people's opinions.. I am just such an animal lover.. this kind of stuff breaks my heart!

Message edited 2007-02-09 17:03:43.887000.

Posted 2/9/07 4:58 PM
 

JenniferEver
The Disney Lady

Member since 5/05

18163 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Disney debarbs stingrays

I need more info. Are those buoys connected to a net that keeps those stingrays in and away from predators? If so then it's a zoo-like situation. Are the stingrays being preserved? Is there an eduication program? What are the effects of de-barbing these rays?

ETA: I ask these questions because I have done a lot of ahrd thinking about zoos. We capture animals from the wild and bring them into zoos and aquariums, but I figure the huge benefit of this is that these programs educate people who may be much more likely to go on to become conservationsists than if they had not seen animals up close, and also the zoos are committed to conservation. I wonder if Disney has a similar program in place, and how the safety and comfort of the stingrays is being guarded.

We live ina culture that right or wrong uses animals, for food, for clothing, for pack animals, for amusement. This is just a question of where to draw the line at "using" animals, and I think how it effects the animals is the key question. Whether or not the animals are being harmed is a key question

Message edited 2007-02-09 20:48:56.867000.

Posted 2/9/07 8:35 PM
 

Booklady1017
Information Goddess

Member since 5/05

4149 total posts

Name:
Michelle

Re: Disney debarbs stingrays

I don't think its right. We were in Grand Caymans with the Stingrays and htye were not debarbed. There are no problems with the stingrays there.

Message edited 2007-02-09 20:44:23.153000.

Posted 2/9/07 8:43 PM
 

Xelindrya
Mommy's little YouTube Star!

Member since 8/05

14470 total posts

Name:
Veronica

Re: Disney debarbs stingrays

ok.. here's my two cents.. *sigh*

I know i get myself in trouble sometimes, I hope this isnt one of them..

I think this is sad. poor animals were altered. Still I would hope that the defenses the barbs allow them aren't needed in this new home for them.

Meaning if there is a predator that could endanger a stingray, wouldnt it be even more dangers to humans and therefore make this whole scenario impossible?

So altho I agree its wrong to mess with mother nature like this, I would hope these animals are kept safe by the altered environment.

Ok stepping away from the theory podium.

Posted 2/9/07 8:49 PM
 

JenniferEver
The Disney Lady

Member since 5/05

18163 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Disney debarbs stingrays

I don't see a lot of info on this on the web, but it says these rays are also "trained." I'm sure in that case that they are somehow contained, because I don't think Disney is going to spend money to debarb and train stingrays just to have them go out into the ocean with predators and dangers out there.

So really it's the same in some ways as keeping seals, dolphins, etc at an aquarium, provided that the debarbing is painless and has no negative effects. In some ways it's the same trade off as with all zoo animals and pets, they are offered protection.

As I said the idea of keeping animals in captivity makes me uneasy, but I feel that the educational aspect of it, as in fostering a love of those creatures in the people who see them first hand, may lead to more conservation efforts, thus protecting the species as a whole and may outweigh the wrong of having captured those few particular rays.

Posted 2/9/07 8:56 PM
 

Ladybugz
LIF Toddler

Member since 12/06

451 total posts

Name:
Laurie

Re: Disney debarbs stingrays

I bet those stingrays are livin' large in their Disney lagoon, swimming safely and eating good! I am sure they don't mind at all. Maybe Disney is afraid some little bully kids may provoke them.

I don't think I agree with it though.

Posted 2/9/07 9:12 PM
 

MsMBV
:P

Member since 5/05

28602 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Disney debarbs stingrays

Posted by SweetTooth

you can come in contact with a rabid raccoon walking in the park. if it bit you and you died of rabies, would your family sue the park?

if I am swimming in the ocean, I am taking the chance that I might get hurt.

to mutilate animals is not the answer. there is always the chance of getting hurt no matter what you are doing or where you are.

Precisely. Disney is not worried about safety in an altruistic sense. Let's face it, they are worried about safety as it applies to them getting sued & to how they appear to their buying public.

Posted 2/10/07 8:23 AM
 
Pages: 1 [2]
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
I miss Disney! cj7305 3/2/06 6 Families Helping Families ™
Disney Question GraciesMom 2/23/06 7 Parenting
That Disney Commercial... Holly 2/22/06 5 Families Helping Families ™
Has anyone ever stayed IN Disney? ChristineR 2/2/06 34 Travel & Vacations
Disney DVC members christy 1/29/06 1 Travel & Vacations
Disney DVC members christy 1/29/06 0 Families Helping Families ™