Death by train...

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2] 3

Otherme
Square head cutie pants

Member since 3/06

6899 total posts

Name:

Re: Death by train...

Posted by Stacey1403

Posted by Otherme

Posted by WhatNow

If you want to kill yourself, fine... but why do it during rush hour and fluck up everyone's day???



i've thought the same thing myself whenever it happens and there are massive delays/cancellations and it takes 3 hours to get home

i know its minor compared to what the person and their family will go through, but it's something that has crossed my mind.
couldn't they at least do it at a time where they won't mess up a 2 million commuters rides home?



I would have to think if you are so depressed that the only solution is to jump into the path of an oncoming train the last thought you are having is messing up someones commute.



of course.. and nor should it be
it's just a thought that comes to mind having been stuck on the trains many times due to people killing themselves right before or during rush hour

no matter what, it's a horrible situation Chat Icon

Posted 7/29/10 2:02 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

WhatNow
Say Cheese!

Member since 1/06

8033 total posts

Name:
A (formerly WhatNow?)

Re: Death by train...

Posted by bri1980

Posted by Mici C

Posted by bri1980

Posted by WhatNow

I am sure this is going to sound SHOCKING to some, but the only people I feel bad for in situations like that are the poor innocent people on the train who are simply trying to get home to their families after hard day's work...

If you want to kill yourself, fine... but why do it during rush hour and fluck up everyone's day???




Thats a little mean...no?



I think it's just another perspective to look at it. Suicide is horrible, I'm sure we'll all agree about that. But what about the motorman that actually feels as if they killed someone? His/her life is completely effed up too. I hope I am never on a train that ends up killing someone either by accident or suicide. Yes, it is a great inconvenience to be on a train when something like this happens. And some would say that the person committing suicide is somewhat selfish simply because they got other people involved in it that had nothing to do with their life. That's unfair too.



I could understand the driver...that would be horrible to have that on your conscience. But to say they are selfish because they screwed up someone's commute....I dont agree. You dont know what that person is going through. I feel a lot worse for them than for the person who gets home an hour late.



Well, the thing is, in most cases, suicide is a selfish act by definition... It's a way out of life and all it's issues... leaving behind those who loved and cared for you, hearbroked, terrified, bewildered, forever with horrid questions on their minds... but that's a topic for a whole other post, i would imagine...

And it is never an hour later... as another poster said, there were delays for up to 5 hours... Having been a victim of such delays myself while my infant was at home crying for my leaking boobs, I can say with fair certainty that it was one of the most frustrating experiences I have ever gone through...

And that poor conductor... forget about him! I am guessing years of therapy are in his future...

Posted 7/29/10 2:53 PM
 

Superkat
More a stranger than a friend

Member since 5/06

9730 total posts

Name:
K

Re: Death by train...

As someone who lost a family member this way, I am offended that people can honestly talk about their 5 hour inconvenience versus the lifetime of pain that we will feel as a member of our family is dead and missing forever.

So yeah, your inconvenience was our first thought as we stood by his closed casket because his body was mutilated by the train. Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 7/29/10 2:59 PM
 

klingklang77
kraftwerk!

Member since 7/06

11489 total posts

Name:
Völlig losgelöst

Re: Death by train...

I don't know, but the timing that they did that during rush hour is the LAST thing on my mind. I think about how the driver must feel and how horrible the victim felt to do that. He/She must have been in a bad place. Then I think about how they identify the body, what exactly happened to the body and all the gruesome details that cross my morbid mind. Then I just feel sad.

But that's just me.

I recently had an experience here where someone got caught in the door (it was an old train) and the train kept moving and all the people on the platform were screaming. I was in the second car and all I thought about was horrible to be on that train and all the thoughts that must have been going through the person who was stuck. The train stopped just in time, btw. The last thing on my mind was that I would be late.

Message edited 2010-07-29 15:23:35.467000.

Posted 7/29/10 3:23 PM
 

maybemommy10
Big Brothers to Be !

Member since 2/10

3868 total posts

Name:

Re: Death by train...

What an incredibly sad way to go. I feel bad for the family and friends she left behindChat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 7/29/10 3:47 PM
 

Otherme
Square head cutie pants

Member since 3/06

6899 total posts

Name:

Re: Death by train...

Posted by Superkat

As someone who lost a family member this way, I am offended that people can honestly talk about their 5 hour inconvenience versus the lifetime of pain that we will feel as a member of our family is dead and missing forever.

So yeah, your inconvenience was our first thought as we stood by his closed casket because his body was mutilated by the train. Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon



i am very sorry for your loss, and in no way meant to somehow lessen the impact that a death like this has on anyone. Of course you shouldn't give a crap what the impact of this death was on anyone but you and your family.
believe me, any inconvenience to commuters is not the first thing that comes to mind when these deaths happen.. a terrible sadness for the person and their family is the first and most prevalent thought.
Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 7/29/10 3:55 PM
 

annoyedTTCer
LIF Adult

Member since 4/09

3272 total posts

Name:

Re: Death by train...

Posted by bri1980

Posted by Mici C

Posted by bri1980

Posted by WhatNow

I am sure this is going to sound SHOCKING to some, but the only people I feel bad for in situations like that are the poor innocent people on the train who are simply trying to get home to their families after hard day's work...

If you want to kill yourself, fine... but why do it during rush hour and fluck up everyone's day???




Thats a little mean...no?



I think it's just another perspective to look at it. Suicide is horrible, I'm sure we'll all agree about that. But what about the motorman that actually feels as if they killed someone? His/her life is completely effed up too. I hope I am never on a train that ends up killing someone either by accident or suicide. Yes, it is a great inconvenience to be on a train when something like this happens. And some would say that the person committing suicide is somewhat selfish simply because they got other people involved in it that had nothing to do with their life. That's unfair too.



I could understand the driver...that would be horrible to have that on your conscience. But to say they are selfish because they screwed up someones commute....I dont agree. You dont know what that person is going through. I feel a lot worse for them than for the person who gets home an hour late.



An hour late?

My commute has been delays 3-5 hours more than once because someone decided to jump in front of a train.

Would you want to leave work at 5 thinking you'd be home at 6 to only get in at 11pm?


Posted 7/29/10 3:55 PM
 

pinkandblue
Our family is complete, maybe

Member since 9/05

32436 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: Death by train...

how terrible, for everyone involved Chat Icon

Posted 7/29/10 4:38 PM
 

pinkandblue
Our family is complete, maybe

Member since 9/05

32436 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: Death by train...

Posted by Superkat

As someone who lost a family member this way, I am offended that people can honestly talk about their 5 hour inconvenience versus the lifetime of pain that we will feel as a member of our family is dead and missing forever.

So yeah, your inconvenience was our first thought as we stood by his closed casket because his body was mutilated by the train. Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon



I am so sorry Chat Icon

Posted 7/29/10 4:38 PM
 

Alexandra17
Keep It Positive

Member since 4/09

6262 total posts

Name:
Alexandra (ali)

Re: Death by train...

Posted by WhatNow

Posted by bri1980

Posted by Mici C

Posted by bri1980

Posted by WhatNow

I am sure this is going to sound SHOCKING to some, but the only people I feel bad for in situations like that are the poor innocent people on the train who are simply trying to get home to their families after hard day's work...

If you want to kill yourself, fine... but why do it during rush hour and fluck up everyone's day???




Thats a little mean...no?



I think it's just another perspective to look at it. Suicide is horrible, I'm sure we'll all agree about that. But what about the motorman that actually feels as if they killed someone? His/her life is completely effed up too. I hope I am never on a train that ends up killing someone either by accident or suicide. Yes, it is a great inconvenience to be on a train when something like this happens. And some would say that the person committing suicide is somewhat selfish simply because they got other people involved in it that had nothing to do with their life. That's unfair too.



I could understand the driver...that would be horrible to have that on your conscience. But to say they are selfish because they screwed up someone's commute....I dont agree. You dont know what that person is going through. I feel a lot worse for them than for the person who gets home an hour late.



Well, the thing is, in most cases, suicide is a selfish act by definition... It's a way out of life and all it's issues... leaving behind those who loved and cared for you, hearbroked, terrified, bewildered, forever with horrid questions on their minds... but that's a topic for a whole other post, i would imagine...

And it is never an hour later... as another poster said, there were delays for up to 5 hours... Having been a victim of such delays myself while my infant was at home crying for my leaking boobs, I can say with fair certainty that it was one of the most frustrating experiences I have ever gone through...

And that poor conductor... forget about him! I am guessing years of therapy are in his future...



You know nothing about suicide. You don't know the gut wrenching feeling that shoots through your body, the questions that go unanswered.
TWO things:
my friend from grade school jump in between train cars. I should just apologize now, I guess, for him screwing up everyone's day. How awful THAT day was for YOU.

and second..
I devote part of my job to a post suicide group called Joe's Project..the next time someone calls at 3am in hysterics because a loved one just completed the act, I will say that it was selfish and fall back to sleep.
grow a heart

Posted 7/29/10 4:45 PM
 

WhatNow
Say Cheese!

Member since 1/06

8033 total posts

Name:
A (formerly WhatNow?)

Re: Death by train...

Posted by Alexandra17

Posted by WhatNow

Posted by bri1980

Posted by Mici C

Posted by bri1980

Posted by WhatNow

I am sure this is going to sound SHOCKING to some, but the only people I feel bad for in situations like that are the poor innocent people on the train who are simply trying to get home to their families after hard day's work...

If you want to kill yourself, fine... but why do it during rush hour and fluck up everyone's day???




Thats a little mean...no?



I think it's just another perspective to look at it. Suicide is horrible, I'm sure we'll all agree about that. But what about the motorman that actually feels as if they killed someone? His/her life is completely effed up too. I hope I am never on a train that ends up killing someone either by accident or suicide. Yes, it is a great inconvenience to be on a train when something like this happens. And some would say that the person committing suicide is somewhat selfish simply because they got other people involved in it that had nothing to do with their life. That's unfair too.



I could understand the driver...that would be horrible to have that on your conscience. But to say they are selfish because they screwed up someone's commute....I dont agree. You dont know what that person is going through. I feel a lot worse for them than for the person who gets home an hour late.



Well, the thing is, in most cases, suicide is a selfish act by definition... It's a way out of life and all it's issues... leaving behind those who loved and cared for you, hearbroked, terrified, bewildered, forever with horrid questions on their minds... but that's a topic for a whole other post, i would imagine...

And it is never an hour later... as another poster said, there were delays for up to 5 hours... Having been a victim of such delays myself while my infant was at home crying for my leaking boobs, I can say with fair certainty that it was one of the most frustrating experiences I have ever gone through...

And that poor conductor... forget about him! I am guessing years of therapy are in his future...



You know nothing about suicide. You don't know the gut wrenching feeling that shoots through your body, the questions that go unanswered.
TWO things:
my friend from grade school jump in between train cars. I should just apologize now, I guess, for him screwing up everyone's day. How awful THAT day was for YOU.

and second..
I devote part of my job to a post suicide group called Joe's Project..the next time someone calls at 3am in hysterics because a loved one just completed the act, I will say that it was selfish and fall back to sleep.
grow a heart



I would assume you would guess, based on my description and the fact the you work with a post suicide group, that I do... but I will not get into that ... There is no need to get personal here as we are discussing a random story of someone none of us knows...

And it is selfish, don;t you think, just based on the 3am calls you just described of the people left behind and hearbroked? It IS all left on THEIR shoulders and hearts, forever...

At any rate, there is a different way of looking at this and clearly, there are people on both side of the fence... and they are all entitled to their opinions...

Posted 7/29/10 7:52 PM
 

LadyBugN2Buggies
<3

Member since 5/10

6691 total posts

Name:

Re: Death by train...

Everyone is entitled to his or her opinion.

However, for everyone who arrives late home from work after someone kills themselves, I pray it's never one of your family members. At least you will make it home to see your family.

You choose to have a job where you take PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION. That means you are under the public's and natures every whim, be it bad weather, electric issues, a passenger's possible heart attack, a derailment, or, yes, a suicide.

I guess all of you have to deal with these darn suicides too much. I'm sorry. Perhaps you should drive then.


Posted 7/29/10 11:43 PM
 

LadyBugN2Buggies
<3

Member since 5/10

6691 total posts

Name:

Re: Death by train...

Oh, and guess what, selfish LIRR'ers: there is traffic and accidents on the major highways, too.

Some idiot texting causes a crash, some jerk who had a few too many during happy hour, etc.

We *all* have a place to be, at a time we want. Whether we are trying to make it to work or home, we all have to deal with certain transportation issues.

You're not on some golden train that flies in the sky with wings. There is no white-gloved service for you.

Get over it.

Posted 7/29/10 11:46 PM
 

blondiebabyZ
Ohhhh yeaaahh!!

Member since 6/10

1033 total posts

Name:

Re: Death by train...

Its a sad situatuion all around. And I hope noone attacks me for my opinion but I feel bad for the conductor who sees the person and has no way of stopping the inevitable of hitting them. Thats gotta be a crazy situation to experience, to know your about to end someones life and have no control over it. Then I feel bad for those who witnessed the accident! Thats trippy and Im sure witnesses are certainly scarred from it. I then feel bad for the train riders. Just because your absolutely stuck wherever you are while they are cleaning up. If your in the middle of train stations they dont let you go anywhere, your stuck on that train for however long it takes to clean and possibly do a police investigation. Meanwhile as someone stated before accidents happen on the roads all the time...but at least you have the option to take other roads to get home, or exits you can get off and grab a bite to eat while there is traffic on your highway. We have no option on the railways. Its an all around horrible situation for everyone involved...and I do agree that i have wished that someone waited until off peak hours to end their life.

Posted 7/30/10 9:11 AM
 

bri1980
LIF Adult

Member since 9/06

1364 total posts

Name:
Brianne

Re: Death by train...

Posted by annoyedTTCer

Posted by bri1980

Posted by Mici C

Posted by bri1980

Posted by WhatNow

I am sure this is going to sound SHOCKING to some, but the only people I feel bad for in situations like that are the poor innocent people on the train who are simply trying to get home to their families after hard day's work...

If you want to kill yourself, fine... but why do it during rush hour and fluck up everyone's day???




Thats a little mean...no?



I think it's just another perspective to look at it. Suicide is horrible, I'm sure we'll all agree about that. But what about the motorman that actually feels as if they killed someone? His/her life is completely effed up too. I hope I am never on a train that ends up killing someone either by accident or suicide. Yes, it is a great inconvenience to be on a train when something like this happens. And some would say that the person committing suicide is somewhat selfish simply because they got other people involved in it that had nothing to do with their life. That's unfair too.



I could understand the driver...that would be horrible to have that on your conscience. But to say they are selfish because they screwed up someones commute....I dont agree. You dont know what that person is going through. I feel a lot worse for them than for the person who gets home an hour late.



An hour late?

My commute has been delays 3-5 hours more than once because someone decided to jump in front of a train.

Would you want to leave work at 5 thinking you'd be home at 6 to only get in at 11pm?





I dont think you realize how awful you sound...
I hope something like this never happens to someone you love.

Posted 7/30/10 9:34 AM
 

Otherme
Square head cutie pants

Member since 3/06

6899 total posts

Name:

Re: Death by train...

Posted by speakthetruth

Oh, and guess what, selfish LIRR'ers: there is traffic and accidents on the major highways, too.

Some idiot texting causes a crash, some jerk who had a few too many during happy hour, etc.

We *all* have a place to be, at a time we want. Whether we are trying to make it to work or home, we all have to deal with certain transportation issues.

You're not on some golden train that flies in the sky with wings. There is no white-gloved service for you.

Get over it.



ok come on.. that's a bit much don't you think?

this is obviously a sensitive topic, but it's getting way too personal


Posted 7/30/10 1:51 PM
 

LadyBugN2Buggies
<3

Member since 5/10

6691 total posts

Name:

Re: Death by train...

Posted by Otherme

Posted by speakthetruth

Oh, and guess what, selfish LIRR'ers: there is traffic and accidents on the major highways, too.

Some idiot texting causes a crash, some jerk who had a few too many during happy hour, etc.

We *all* have a place to be, at a time we want. Whether we are trying to make it to work or home, we all have to deal with certain transportation issues.

You're not on some golden train that flies in the sky with wings. There is no white-gloved service for you.

Get over it.



ok come on.. that's a bit much don't you think?

this is obviously a sensitive topic, but it's getting way too personal





fine, I take it back.Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 7/30/10 1:53 PM
 

Peainapod
Peanuts are here!

Member since 1/09

13591 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: Death by train...

Posted by speakthetruth

Posted by Otherme

Posted by speakthetruth

Oh, and guess what, selfish LIRR'ers: there is traffic and accidents on the major highways, too.

Some idiot texting causes a crash, some jerk who had a few too many during happy hour, etc.

We *all* have a place to be, at a time we want. Whether we are trying to make it to work or home, we all have to deal with certain transportation issues.

You're not on some golden train that flies in the sky with wings. There is no white-gloved service for you.

Get over it.



ok come on.. that's a bit much don't you think?

this is obviously a sensitive topic, but it's getting way too personal





fine, I take it back.Chat Icon Chat Icon



I in no way intended for this to start drama...i've been through commuting hell more times than i care to remember as I travel 2 hrs each way on a normal day. and the past few days since then when I get to that stop i just cant help to think of this person and why someone would end their life this way. Its just awful all around.

I feel terrible that this young person chose to end her life this way. I feel terrible for everyone involved..witnesses, the family, the motorman, commuters who had to look out their train window and be witness to the scene. Dear god...

Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 7/30/10 2:14 PM
 

yankinmanc
Happy Days!

Member since 8/05

18208 total posts

Name:

Re: Death by train...

In a strange scheduling coincidence, I have just watched a film on TV called "One Under" and the effect that suicide by train has on drivers & family. Very interesting and sad.

One Under on Channel 4

Posted 7/30/10 3:22 PM
 

DiamondGirl
You are my I love you

Member since 7/09

18802 total posts

Name:
DiamondMama

Re: Death by train...

My 2 cents.

People who commit suicide are mentally ill. They are not thinking of the consequences on others, how it will effect others, they are thinking of themselves, so yes in that sense they are selfish--but they are also sick.

If I was waiting for a train and it was delayed and I heard the reason was bc someone killed themselves it would never cross mind to feel anything other than sadness and sympathy.

And I think it is a damn shame that anyone would be worried about being late to get home.

Call someone on your cell or use your ipod for a while. Jesus.

It would make me think Life is precious and feel so lucky that I am going home to my living, breathing, healthy family

Message edited 2010-07-30 15:29:02.230000.

Posted 7/30/10 3:27 PM
 

bri1980
LIF Adult

Member since 9/06

1364 total posts

Name:
Brianne

Re: Death by train...

Posted by DiamondGirl

My 2 cents.

People who commit suicide are mentally ill. They are not thinking of the consequences on others, how it will effect others, they are thinking of themselves, so yes in that sense they are selfish--but they are also sick.

If I was waiting for a train and it was delayed and I heard the reason was bc someone killed themselves it would never cross mind to feel anything other than sadness and sympathy.

And I think it is a damn shame that anyone would be worried about being late to get home.

Call someone on your cell or use your ipod for a while. Jesus.

It would make me think Life is precious and feel so lucky that I am going home to my living, breathing, healthy family



I agree, but people are selfish.

Posted 7/30/10 3:46 PM
 

nicrae
He's here!

Member since 12/06

9289 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: Death by train...

Posted by bri1980

Posted by DiamondGirl

My 2 cents.

People who commit suicide are mentally ill. They are not thinking of the consequences on others, how it will effect others, they are thinking of themselves, so yes in that sense they are selfish--but they are also sick.

If I was waiting for a train and it was delayed and I heard the reason was bc someone killed themselves it would never cross mind to feel anything other than sadness and sympathy.

And I think it is a damn shame that anyone would be worried about being late to get home.

Call someone on your cell or use your ipod for a while. Jesus.

It would make me think Life is precious and feel so lucky that I am going home to my living, breathing, healthy family



I agree, but people are selfish.



I don't think selfish is the right word.

I commute everyday and it is long and tiring. When a train hits someone it causes problems for hundreds of people. Service is terminated for hours. So yes while I feel sorry that someone committed suicide and am grateful for my family, I am still annoyed.

It is not just about me using my cell or listening to my iPod and sucking it up for a few hours. It is about trying to find someone to pick my kids up at daycare and stay with them....therefore inconveniencing them as well. I have two children and being delayed 5 hours is a big problem. I don't think me wanted to get home to my children is selfish.

Message edited 2010-07-30 16:37:39.237000.

Posted 7/30/10 4:35 PM
 

saraH
happy birthday sweet kate!

Member since 5/05

16555 total posts

Name:
I know that God exsists, I held her in my arms...

Re: Death by train...

My dh is an engineer (he drives the train) and this is truly his worst fear.

It's incredibly tramautic for everyone involved.

And I think its sad for that person jumping too. I can't imagine having so much pain that I couldn't take living for one more second that I have to throw myself in front of a train.

Chat Icon

Posted 7/30/10 5:41 PM
 

Beth
The Key to your new home....

Member since 2/06

24849 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: Death by train...

I lost 4 friends before the age of 16 to the LIRR

2 on purpose and 2 by accident

this post is distrubing on so many levels

my heart goes out to everyone that has also been thru this and cringes at the sound of the train whistle like so many of the people I grew up with....

Posted 7/30/10 6:01 PM
 

mypumpkin
It's a beautiful day! :)

Member since 7/08

2296 total posts

Name:
Dee

Re: Death by train...

I too feel so bad for the families involved and the engineer who will replay that moment over & over!!

I was bringing my kids home from school one day. My block is just before you would cross over the tracks. To the right of my car were 2 kids riding their bikes. The train had just gone by and a 10th grade girl had knelt down right in front of the tracks, cutting her head off. A parent was blocking the scene with his car, but the 2 boys saw everything:(

3 kids in the same grade that year died, 2 were suicide and 1 was by accident(he was jumping across the tracks with his friends and didn't make it).

There was sooooo much sadness that school year. Even now I still feel sad when I drive over the tracks and see candles and flowers that people still bring:(((((

Posted 7/30/10 8:19 PM
 
Pages: 1 [2] 3
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Drunk Boston woman on train tracks narrowly cheats death [video] greenfreak 11/10/09 13 Families Helping Families ™
Great article - Throw Roger from the train! Aga 12/21/05 0 Families Helping Families ™
Preacher Vent-Train CowgirlChick97 12/6/05 0 Families Helping Families ™
Back on the Weight Watchers Train trnity44 11/19/05 3 Diet & Fitness
path train Michi 11/11/05 9 Families Helping Families ™
Train Crash on GH... preciouslove 11/9/05 14 Families Helping Families ™