Credit/Finance Question - Closing a CC

Posted By Message

SeaWolf14
*Crazy Cat Lady*

Member since 7/13

1324 total posts

Name:
Heather

Credit/Finance Question - Closing a CC

I'm thinking of transferring our small CC bills into one Visa w/0% apr for 12 months.

I'm told that I should keep the other cards open after we pay them off w/the balance transfer check. Psychologically, I'd really love to close those accounts so that in my mind we have ONE debt that we're paying down.

Someone who knows about credit/credit scores please tell me WHY I shouldn't close these other two cards (a visa and a mc)

Posted 9/3/13 11:59 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

mrsm-2011
He is my world!

Member since 6/12

3009 total posts

Name:
Theresa

Re: Credit/Finance Question - Closing a CC

One of the ways they get your credit score is how much debt versus open credit you have. The fact that the cards won't have a balance will be better for your credit. Keep the accounts open and put the cards in a safe or cut them up so you don't use them.

Posted 9/3/13 12:02 PM
 

Bridex100
Two Under Two Mommy

Member since 3/08

10420 total posts

Name:
Momx100

Re: Credit/Finance Question - Closing a CC

I'm not a credit expert and can only speak of my credit scores. There was a year that I changed my credit cards. I closed several random retail cards I had (Banana Republic, macy's, Ann Taylor, best buy, I even had a Pep boys card). I had a 0 balance for all these cards and just closed them all.

My credit score dropped by like 60 points!

Within a year or so, I only had 2 credit cards, the same 2 cards I use today. My credit score went back up. The dip seemed to be temporary.

Now I never open random lines of credit no matter how good the incentive is.

eta: I did receive a $20,000 credit increase on my AMEX so that may be why my credit score went back up. The increase was higher than the total of the retail card limits.

Message edited 2013-09-03 12:13:37.000000.

Posted 9/3/13 12:05 PM
 

MrsRapz
mahna mahna!

Member since 2/12

1952 total posts

Name:

Credit/Finance Question - Closing a CC

in addition to what PP said, the older your credit history, the better it is for you. In other words, if you close your oldest credit card (the one you've had longest), it'll drop your score.

Definitely keep the account open but cut up the credit card itself so you don't use it

Posted 9/3/13 12:05 PM
 

blustar214
So in love with my little girl

Member since 1/10

2471 total posts

Name:

Re: Credit/Finance Question - Closing a CC

I believe that people often say you are 'supposed' to keep cards b/c closing a card will often negatively impact your credit score. Your credit score is made up, in part, by the percentage of credit available to you. It is better to be utilizing a lower percentage of your credit limit (e.g., $200 on a card with a $1,000 limit vs. $200 on a card with a $500 limit). So if you close the account you lose the 'free credit available' to you and that messes with percentages. I have heard that if you really want to close the cards then you should close no more than 1 per month.

Posted 9/3/13 12:06 PM
 

SeaWolf14
*Crazy Cat Lady*

Member since 7/13

1324 total posts

Name:
Heather

Credit/Finance Question - Closing a CC

Ok ty for the advise. Mentally, I'd love to only have one as I'm sure you can understand, but I suppose I'll just cut them all up and leave them hanging around out there. I know right now our credit is great, and we already own our home and I just got my car in Feb, so I dont plan on making any purchases any time SOON that will require a credit check, but I guess its better to be safe than sorry.

Posted 9/3/13 12:15 PM
 

MrsM-6-7-08
<3

Member since 8/06

4249 total posts

Name:
Nicole

Re: Credit/Finance Question - Closing a CC

I had a few cards I had to close because there was an annual fee that I refused to pay on a zero balance. Yes your credit takes a slight dip, but as you pay down the One big bulk and free up credit it will go back up again.

If those cards have no annual fee, then you can keep it open some of mine even had a monthly maintenance charge as well, i cancelled them.

Posted 9/3/13 12:23 PM
 

JSDB
<3

Member since 1/13

1329 total posts

Name:

Re: Credit/Finance Question - Closing a CC

Like the others said, keep them open but carry 0 balance and just hide the cards so you dont use them.

Closing the cards will make your credit score dip slightly, temporarily. But, having lines of credit that you have had for a while help your credit score. Especially if you use them occasionally and then pay off your balance in full.

Posted 9/3/13 3:49 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Question about bank closing credit card Mommy2Boys 7/31/09 9 Families Helping Families ™
Question about paying off and closing credit card account Mommy2Boys 9/27/07 2 Families Helping Families ™
Finance Question - Credit Score MST9106 8/4/09 2 Families Helping Families ™
Tax credit closing deadline extended! Diva 6/17/10 4 Home
Closing Credit card with a balance maxsgirl 11/17/09 7 Families Helping Families ™
closing question and walk through question? nancygrace 1/6/07 3 Home