cord blood banking

Posted By Message

Peainapod
Peanuts are here!

Member since 1/09

13591 total posts

Name:
Diana

cord blood banking

I asked my dr. about this yesterday and holy sh** i got an earful.

He said its the biggest scam out there next to those NIgerian email scams, how he wouldnt recommend it to his own family, and how the only pple making $$ off it are the people who own the companies, etc.

I was a little taken back by how adamant he was about it. I have some pamphlets from VIacord which im going to look at, but was wondering who here is doing it and why?

TIA!

Posted 10/15/09 9:09 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Jonsgirl04
Love my two girls! xoxo

Member since 9/08

6079 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: cord blood banking

I am using Viacord. I dont know why a doctor would say that its a scam. I have a friend of the family whos child had gotten very sick and wound up having Leukemia. If it was not for the Cord Blood, she may have lost her son. We are choosing this option and hope to never need it.Chat Icon

Posted 10/15/09 9:24 AM
 

Peainapod
Peanuts are here!

Member since 1/09

13591 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: cord blood banking

Posted by Jonsgirl04

I am using Viacord. I dont know why a doctor would say that its a scam. I have a friend of the family whos child had gotten very sick and wound up having Leukemia. If it was not for the Cord Blood, she may have lost her son. We are choosing this option and hope to never need it.Chat Icon




thanks..he said there wasnt much research to back it up and that they just play on parents emotions & fears etc.

I appreciate your feedback.

Posted 10/15/09 9:49 AM
 

mommyIam

Member since 7/09

9209 total posts

Name:
Shana

Re: cord blood banking

I felt exactly the way your doctor did. But you have to know the facts and make the decision for yourself.

Here are some reasons why he may feel so strongly.
The main thing is that They can't guarantee for how long they can preserve the cord blood. They think it may last 15 years.
The next thing to consider the cord blood from Baby A will likely never be good for Baby A's treatment. It might be good for Baby B, C and maybe other relatives.
The type of stem cells that can be harvested through cord blood, have been shown that they can also be harvested from other body parts (ovaries, bone marrow, etc) of a grown adult and used for similar therapies.
There are public cord blood banks, and you can publicly bank your cord blood for free (if hospital does it). I'm not sure the details of how available it is, but I think banking it yourself privately gives you greater priority than in public bank.

There are only a few test cases where cord blood has been used to effectively treat children. But the numbers of those cases have grown in the years. Problem from a scientific perspective there isn't enough controlled research on when and how and why it works. But it seams to be working, and for a lot of different things.

At some point I was really thinking why would I bother paying to bank my babies cord blood if its likely they will not be able to use it themselves. Its free to donate it and then it will be used for people who need it right now, or it will be used for research. I felt it made more sense. But considering we have a very young niece and nephew and they have family history of cancer, considering it may help them one day was enough for use to privately bank it.

Posted 10/15/09 10:36 AM
 

conigs25
So in love with this kid!

Member since 5/06

11197 total posts

Name:
Michele

Re: cord blood banking

I signed up for Viacord. I am one of those "better safe than sorry" people. What is $1500 in the grand scheme of my childs life?

Posted 10/15/09 10:38 AM
 

Peainapod
Peanuts are here!

Member since 1/09

13591 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: cord blood banking

Posted by conigs25

I signed up for Viacord. I am one of those "better safe than sorry" people. What is $1500 in the grand scheme of my childs life?



agreed...

im going to talk further with my former midwife about it. I wasnt thrilled with the dr's reaction. he made me feel like an *** for even thinking about it.

Posted 10/15/09 10:41 AM
 

conigs25
So in love with this kid!

Member since 5/06

11197 total posts

Name:
Michele

Re: cord blood banking

Posted by Peainapod

Posted by conigs25

I signed up for Viacord. I am one of those "better safe than sorry" people. What is $1500 in the grand scheme of my childs life?



agreed...

im going to talk further with my former midwife about it. I wasnt thrilled with the dr's reaction. he made me feel like an *** for even thinking about it.



its funny bcmost docs talk it up too much (i think they must get a kickback lol)

Posted 10/15/09 10:42 AM
 

mommyIam

Member since 7/09

9209 total posts

Name:
Shana

Re: cord blood banking

Posted by conigs25

its funny bcmost docs talk it up too much (i think they must get a kickback lol)



They do! They charge anywhere from $150-$400 to use a needle and collect some blood. DH said he can just do this himself in 2 minutes for me.

Not sure yet, but if some insurance covers the cord blood extraction, the docs are are probably getting back around 500 for the procedure.

Posted 10/15/09 10:47 AM
 

Fallbaby09
number 3...coming soon!

Member since 4/09

1811 total posts

Name:
Jackie

Re: cord blood banking

My previous OB was not too crazy about the idea either. She said that you are basically gambling with your money and on research. I personally do not like the way that the cord banks promote/market themselves. I hate the way they try to sell it and I can understand why people can be leery of them. That said, I don't know if this is a good enough reason to not do it, but it's something to consider. My current OB is for it.

Posted 10/15/09 10:49 AM
 

annoyedTTCer
LIF Adult

Member since 4/09

3272 total posts

Name:

Re: cord blood banking

Posted by conigs25

I signed up for Viacord. I am one of those "better safe than sorry" people. What is $1500 in the grand scheme of my childs life?



$1500 is a good price.

The paperwork I received recently was $2400 including the first year of storage plus Dr collection fees

I know insurance doesn't cover any of this but does anyone know if you can expense it using FSA?

Posted 10/15/09 10:49 AM
 

Bean08
LIF Adolescent

Member since 3/09

795 total posts

Name:

Re: cord blood banking

Thanks for posting this, and for all of the responses. I'm in the midst of deciding myself if we are going to do it or not, and I just can't make up my mind. My OB definitely wasn't like yours, but his opinion was if you have the money to do it, go for it, but if that money could be better spent on other things, save it. We also talked to 2 pediatricians who said the same thing. For us, with our family medical history, signs would point to not doing it, but, guilt and the "what if's" are what get me...

Posted 10/15/09 11:06 AM
 

HLT407
So lucky

Member since 11/07

1910 total posts

Name:
Heather

Re: cord blood banking

I was going to do it.. 99.9% positive & ready to go. However, after talking to a friend of mine in the field she said she doesn't think its worth it- just yet.

They aren't sure how long they can harvest the blood. It only is "effective" for children up to the age of 11. It isn't guaranteed to help all children. Right now, in the grand scheme of things, there aren't many diseases they can 'cure'. She said hoepfully within the next few years they'll have a better idea, but until then she said if it were her, she'd skip it..

Needless to say, we passed on this one, but God willing- with out next baby, we plan to bank the blood and are hoping theres more info by then..

Posted 10/15/09 11:09 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Are you doing cord blood banking? Public or Private? Bridex100 1/13/09 6 Pregnancy
I don't know what to do about cord blood banking... SweetTooth 11/25/08 12 Pregnancy
Another q. about cord blood banking? SweetTooth 11/20/08 0 Pregnancy
Has anyone considered Cord blood banking with places other than CBR and viacord? SweetTooth 11/20/08 5 Pregnancy
Are there other Cord Blood Banking sites, other than CBR? shell 8/4/08 6 Pregnancy
Did anyone look into Maze for cord blood banking? curliegirl 5/11/07 1 Pregnancy