Comprehensive & Collision

Posted By Message

longislemom
LIF Adult

Member since 8/06

912 total posts

Name:

Comprehensive & Collision

Is it necessary to have it? I'm just wondering. Anyone not have it?

I called Geico and my policy as it is now with the comprehensive and collision and roadside assistance, liability, etc. would be sooo much lower than I have with Allstate. I dont know why I hadnt called them before.

Posted 7/19/14 12:05 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

MorningCuppaCoffee
Tired!

Member since 12/07

16353 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: Comprehensive & Collision

I lease so yes.

I also would want to be protected even if I wasn't leasing.

I think in NYS there is a certain amount of coverage you are required to have (doesn't mean collision though).

As an aside, I had Allstate years ago and they were one of the most expensive companies.

You should shop around.

Everyone's policy will probably vary.

Posted 7/19/14 12:27 PM
 

Shh2010hiding
LIF Infant

Member since 1/14

302 total posts

Name:

Comprehensive & Collision

It depends on what year your car is? If it is over 10 years old I would think about removing comp and collision

Posted 7/19/14 1:33 PM
 

Bellaocchi
Hope Faith Love

Member since 2/07

5694 total posts

Name:

Re: Comprehensive & Collision

Posted by Shh2010hiding

It depends on what year your car is? If it is over 10 years old I would think about removing comp and collision




Good point. Just curious though, why so?

Posted 7/19/14 1:39 PM
 

longislemom
LIF Adult

Member since 8/06

912 total posts

Name:

Comprehensive & Collision

Thanks for your responses Ladies. It is a 2006 Toyota Sienna. The rep told me I should remove the comp and collision since I've never been in an accident. Then my prem. would be $66. It's tempting but there is always the what if. I mean...God forbid I do and its my fault. I'd be sol
KWIM

Posted 7/19/14 1:44 PM
 

SecretlyTTC14
LIF Adult

Member since 12/13

1770 total posts

Name:
B

Re: Comprehensive & Collision

Something to keep in mind if your going with Geico: Even if the car is old they will give you the actual value of the car if it is totaled (not just book value). So, even on an older car, I think it's worth it to carry full coverage. There are so many things that can happen and body shops are so expensive.

Posted 7/19/14 2:19 PM
 

Kathy042806
LIF Adult

Member since 5/06

1417 total posts

Name:
Kathy

Re: Comprehensive & Collision

Posted by SecretlyTTC14

Something to keep in mind if your going with Geico: Even if the car is old they will give you the actual value of the car if it is totaled (not just book value). So, even on an older car, I think it's worth it to carry full coverage. There are so many things that can happen and body shops are so expensive.




My parked car was totaled. The responsible party's insurance was Geico, and they paid me market value as if wasn't totaled. I don't have comp or collision on my other vehicle. It is older though and over 140000 miles, so if something does happen, I'd have to get another car because even with full coverage it wouldn't be worth it to me with this old car

Posted 7/19/14 7:34 PM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: Comprehensive & Collision

Posted by longislemom

Thanks for your responses Ladies. It is a 2006 Toyota Sienna. The rep told me I should remove the comp and collision since I've never been in an accident. Then my prem. would be $66. It's tempting but there is always the what if. I mean...God forbid I do and its my fault. I'd be sol
KWIM



The reason you don't need comp and collision on an old car is because at a certain point the car has very little value left. We have a 2002 Civic (DHs commuter car) and we haven't carried comp and collision on it for at least 4 yrs. if it gets totally it's worth maybe $1K at best. There is no reason to pay yearly for a coverage on my car that is worth so little.

ETA - I have Geico

Message edited 2014-07-19 21:50:16.877000.

Posted 7/19/14 9:49 PM
 

SecretlyTTC14
LIF Adult

Member since 12/13

1770 total posts

Name:
B

Re: Comprehensive & Collision

Yeah, if the car is worth less then a few grand I def wouldn't keep full coverage on it. Even though it's an older car I'm thinking the value of the OP's car is prob over 5k so it's prob worth it to keep the full coverage. JMO

Posted 7/19/14 11:11 PM
 

longislemom
LIF Adult

Member since 8/06

912 total posts

Name:

Comprehensive & Collision

Maybe I'm not understanding this whole insurance thing then Kristen. If I don't have comprehensive and collision and I get into an accident and it's my fault who is going to pay the other driver? ..and pay me for my car?

Posted 7/19/14 11:13 PM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: Comprehensive & Collision

Posted by longislemom

Maybe I'm not understanding this whole insurance thing then Kristen. If I don't have comprehensive and collision and I get into an accident and it's my fault who is going to pay the other driver? ..and pay me for my car?



Comp and collision are for YOUR car, not the other drivers car. Property damage liability covers a car you hit.

As your car ages it's worth less and less. At a certain point even if your car gets really damaged in an accident insurance isn't going to pay out for $3K worth of repairs on a car worth $1K, as an example. Basically, you don't get the comp and collision and assume the risk of should you get in an accident, you will eat the loss of your car because it's not worth repairing.

Like I said, I have a 12 yr old Civic, if it's damaged in an accident quite honestly, it's just not worth repairing.......it has so little value that it makes no sense to repair. That's why I dropped comp and collision on that car and saved the money in premiums.

Here's a link with more info. Chat Icon

Comp and Collision

Message edited 2014-07-19 23:45:20.213000.

Posted 7/19/14 11:44 PM
 

Xelindrya
Mommy's little YouTube Star!

Member since 8/05

14470 total posts

Name:
Veronica

Comprehensive & Collision

I always keep full coverage. I have an 01 and 03. I hate dented cars and I like knowing I get a check if it's damaged. My 03 in kbb is still over 6k. My savings per month to drop it on my 01 isn't enough to interest me.

My warning about GEICO is check your coverages. Rental, towing, loads of use, deductibles etc. My buddy got a great deal then lost his head when he had an accident and found his coverage lacking ( other driver drove away).

Rental for some only comes with full coverage. Some minor repair on your car out of your pocket will now also include out of pocket for a replacement car while it's being repaired. Knew a woman who dropped full coverage on her mini van but had it on her Mercedes. Uninsured hit her really bad. Her kids all couldn't fit in the Mercedes and they needed a family car. No comp and collision have her no rental.

Message edited 2014-07-20 02:37:24.017000.

Posted 7/20/14 2:34 AM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: Comprehensive & Collision

Posted by Xelindrya


My warning about GEICO is check your coverages. Rental, towing, loads of use, deductibles etc. My buddy got a great deal then lost his head when he had an accident and found his coverage lacking ( other driver drove away).






This is true of ANY type of insurance OR insurance carrier. Not just GEICO. It's on you to make sure you have adequate coverage for your needs.

I've had GEICO for years, my insurance is very comprehensive with them (I did my HW), and I have always gotten a great deal. When some a$$hole plowed into me at 50mph on the LIE and totaled my car GEICO was awesome! I got more than I even paid for my car, they were so easy to work with, and paid out FAST. I have had nothing but good experiences with GEICO. Chat Icon

Posted 7/20/14 7:16 AM
 

Xelindrya
Mommy's little YouTube Star!

Member since 8/05

14470 total posts

Name:
Veronica

Re: Comprehensive & Collision

Posted by Hofstra26

Posted by Xelindrya


My warning about GEICO is check your coverages. Rental, towing, loads of use, deductibles etc. My buddy got a great deal then lost his head when he had an accident and found his coverage lacking ( other driver drove away).






This is true of ANY type of insurance OR insurance carrier. Not just GEICO. It's on you to make sure you have adequate coverage for your needs.

I've had GEICO for years, my insurance is very comprehensive with them (I did my HW), and I have always gotten a great deal. When some a$$hole plowed into me at 50mph on the LIE and totaled my car GEICO was awesome! I got more than I even paid for my car, they were so easy to work with, and paid out FAST. I have had nothing but good experiences with GEICO. Chat Icon



Great! There's that too. One person's good or bad experience isn't generally a rule. I love my insurance. Been with them nearly 12 years!!! No down payment. 12 month policy. In NY I believe I only paid 10 months so two months were payment free. In TX I pay 11 months but get a dividend check each year. 3 claims with them. So worth it and affordable. I'm with Amica. Direct only... No agents and for me (an agent) that means something too.

Message edited 2014-07-20 11:04:05.000000.

Posted 7/20/14 11:03 AM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: Comprehensive & Collision

Posted by Xelindrya

Posted by Hofstra26

Posted by Xelindrya


My warning about GEICO is check your coverages. Rental, towing, loads of use, deductibles etc. My buddy got a great deal then lost his head when he had an accident and found his coverage lacking ( other driver drove away).






This is true of ANY type of insurance OR insurance carrier. Not just GEICO. It's on you to make sure you have adequate coverage for your needs.

I've had GEICO for years, my insurance is very comprehensive with them (I did my HW), and I have always gotten a great deal. When some a$$hole plowed into me at 50mph on the LIE and totaled my car GEICO was awesome! I got more than I even paid for my car, they were so easy to work with, and paid out FAST. I have had nothing but good experiences with GEICO. Chat Icon



Great! There's that too. One person's good or bad experience isn't generally a rule. I love my insurance. Been with them nearly 12 years!!! No down payment. 12 month policy. In NY I believe I only paid 10 months so two months were payment free. In TX I pay 11 months but get a dividend check each year. 3 claims with them. So worth it and affordable. I'm with Amica. Direct only... No agents and for me (an agent) that means something too.



Yep, I agree. Everyone is always going to have a different experience. For every positive there will be a negative. Just how how it goes. Chat Icon

Message edited 2014-07-20 11:13:13.197000.

Posted 7/20/14 11:12 AM
 

Bradley & Parker, Inc
LIFamilies Business

Member since 3/12

170 total posts

Name:
Jennifer Jennings

Comprehensive & Collision

I always tell people to compare the value of your car to what you are paying per year in insurance for the comp & collision. If the value of the car is a lot more, than it may be worth it to keep it on.
As far as the Geico discussion goes, sometimes I do see that people are lacking coverage. Make sure you have OBEL, Max PIP with NO deductible, your SUM matching your BI, full glass (if you have comp). Those are the coverages I find they either keep low, or do not give.

Posted 7/20/14 3:01 PM
 

longislemom
LIF Adult

Member since 8/06

912 total posts

Name:

Comprehensive & Collision

Thanks everyone.
Yes, the value is more so I'm going to keep it for a couple more years.
I'm not sure about the obel, but I sure did ask about max pip no ded (since I had that with Allstate) and definitely the full glass.
It turned out that he conveniently left those off and had I not had my AS policy in front of me (he asked if I was reading from my policy), I wouldn't have gotten them.

Posted 7/20/14 7:31 PM
 

sj-girl
Happy Family of 4

Member since 5/08

5654 total posts

Name:

Re: Comprehensive & Collision

Posted by longislemom

Thanks for your responses Ladies. It is a 2006 Toyota Sienna. The rep told me I should remove the comp and collision since I've never been in an accident. Then my prem. would be $66. It's tempting but there is always the what if. I mean...God forbid I do and its my fault. I'd be sol
KWIM




I work in the insurance field and I would not recommend that. Your vehicle is still worth a decent amount.

While you may have never been in a accident. What if your car is hit while parked and the other vehicle leaves the scene? What is a tree falls on your car? With out comp and collision you now have no coverage on your car. You can always increase your ded to lower your prem. If you have any questions please feel free to ask me.

Posted 7/21/14 9:13 AM
 

ElizaRags35
My 2 Girls

Member since 2/09

20494 total posts

Name:
Me

Comprehensive & Collision

I have an older car - '02 Civic. I just priced what it would cost to remove comp/coll and I would save around $5 a month. For $5, I'd rather keep it just in case.

Posted 7/21/14 12:29 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Would you believe this??? DO NOT GO TO CASTLE COLLISION IN DEER PARK! popabubble 11/6/12 22 Families Helping Families ™
Anyone use Womens Comprehensive Health Center in Manhasset and been delivered by one of theirr OBs? KS13 2/23/12 7 Parenting
Ladies who use Comprehensive OB/GYN in West Islip... koala 10/25/11 2 Parenting
Those who go to Comprehensive Ob Gyn in West Islip... MrsKellyBride 2/25/11 2 Pregnancy
Comprehensive "Who are you Voting for?" Poll (with more choices) Kara 9/4/08 71 Families Helping Families ™
is/has anyone used comprehensive womens obgyn in west islip? keltastic 7/15/07 5 Pregnancy