co-op Vs. Condo

Posted By Message

Melmel821
Love being a mom!

Member since 5/08

2776 total posts

Name:
Melanie

co-op Vs. Condo

What are the differences between them? pros and cons?

Posted 3/11/09 9:01 PM
 
Prudential Douglas Elliman Real Estate
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
  |   Long Island Weddings

nov04libride
big brother <3

Member since 5/05

14672 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: co-op Vs. Condo

Co-ops mean you own shares of the corporation; buyers generally need approval from the board. Can be harder to sell. Generally between a similar co-op and condo, the condos are more expensive, but co-ops have higher common charges that include taxes and more other things.

Here's a link to a helpful thread. The general concensus seems to be that condos are "better", but more expensive. Fewer restrictions in terms of board approval.

Message edited 2009-03-11 21:50:31.580000.

Posted 3/11/09 9:12 PM
 

Melmel821
Love being a mom!

Member since 5/08

2776 total posts

Name:
Melanie

Re: co-op Vs. Condo

I thought a condo would be a better buy but they are more expensive. I'm not sure sure if it's worth it to buy as a first home or to continue rent until we buy our forever home? A coop costs less and generally the cost would be the same as our rent. I feel we can pay what we would have and hopefully sustain some equity instead of just throwing money away. A coop seems more temporary to me and a condo seems a little more sustainable - we'd stay in a condo longer than a coop. Does that make sense?

Message edited 2009-03-12 07:43:03.150000.

Posted 3/12/09 7:40 AM
 

nov04libride
big brother <3

Member since 5/05

14672 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: co-op Vs. Condo

Posted by Melmel821

I thought a condo would be a better buy but they are more expensive. I'm not sure sure if it's worth it to buy as a first home or to continue rent until we buy our forever home? A coop costs less and generally the cost would be the same as our rent. I feel we can pay what we would have and hopefully sustain some equity instead of just throwing money away. A coop seems more temporary to me and a condo seems a little more sustainable - we'd stay in a condo longer than a coop. Does that make sense?



We had a condo for the past 5 years, and just sold it for less than we paid. You can't predict the economy, but I can say that our condo sold in less than 2 weeks (priced well), while many of my friends selling co-ops have had them on the market 6 mos.+. Honestly, 5 years ago, I wished we would have continued to rent instead of buy. With realtor commissions/lawyer fees/etc., we're losing about $15,000 from what we paid for the condo 5 years ago, AND we put money into it. If you're thinking short term, after what I've been through, I would rent instead of buying.

Posted 3/12/09 9:27 AM
 

Sandy55
My family ROCKS!!!

Member since 2/08

1219 total posts

Name:
Sandy

Re: co-op Vs. Condo

Posted by nov04libride

Co-ops mean you own shares of the corporation; buyers generally need approval from the board. Can be harder to sell. Generally between a similar co-op and condo, the condos are more expensive, but co-ops have higher common charges that include taxes and more other things.

Here's a link to a helpful thread. The general concensus seems to be that condos are "better", but more expensive. Fewer restrictions in terms of board approval.



This is why we went for a condo. Didn't want to deal with the board and the restrictions, etc.

Posted 3/12/09 9:57 AM
 

JldDolphin

Member since 1/07

6929 total posts

Name:
Jen

Re: co-op Vs. Condo

the co-op boards are a pain in the a$$. lots of restrictions and the common fees can be high depending on where you are looking. If you are going to spend the money and want something to call your own (an investment), I would go for the Condo. GL in your decision.Chat Icon

Posted 3/12/09 10:19 AM
 

tourist

Member since 5/05

10425 total posts

Name:

Re: co-op Vs. Condo

Not all co-op boards are as bad as people make them out to be. I think mine is fairly reasonable, but it is another thing you have to look into when buying one.

Message edited 2009-03-12 10:58:11.740000.

Posted 3/12/09 10:40 AM
 

shiv
Twinsanity!!

Member since 5/07

4747 total posts

Name:
Shiv

Re: co-op Vs. Condo

Posted by JldDolphin

the co-op boards are a pain in the a$$. lots of restrictions and the common fees can be high depending on where you are looking. If you are going to spend the money and want something to call your own (an investment), I would go for the Condo. GL in your decision.Chat Icon



i agree, i have a coop, that's not even that fancy BTW, and the board is so difficult to deal with. Everything is a process. Right now I have a renter whose perfect except that he doesn't make 4 times the rent, but he has hundreds of thousands in savings/investments (he's close to retirement). but they are still giving me a hard time about him! It's my risk renting to him, i have to pay the maintenance regardless of whether he pays me rent or not so why do they care???!!! So frustrating!

Posted 3/12/09 10:53 AM
 

banda61007
LIF Infant

Member since 7/07

296 total posts

Name:
Bonnie

Re: co-op Vs. Condo

Posted by tourist

Not all co-op boards are as bad as people make them out ot be. I think mine is fairly reasonable, but it is another thing you have to look into when buying one.




Same here. Our co-op is really lenient. We just finished a major rennovation and other than making us submit a plan and use licensed contractors, we had no issues.

When we were looking to purchase, I went and read the last 12 months of the board minutes (most managemnt companies will allow you to do this) before signing out contract. I was able to get a sense of what types of things they focused on, whether they rejected people's requests, rejected proposed sales, etc. I highly recommend doing that if you are interested in a co-op.

I will say, the application was a PITA!!!

Posted 3/12/09 11:02 AM
 

tourist

Member since 5/05

10425 total posts

Name:

Re: co-op Vs. Condo

Posted by banda61007

When we were looking to purchase, I went and read the last 12 months of the board minutes (most managemnt companies will allow you to do this) before signing out contract.



I (well, really my DH, b/c he works closer) did this too--our lawyer reccommened it.


Message edited 2009-03-12 11:12:20.473000.

Posted 3/12/09 11:09 AM
 

Melmel821
Love being a mom!

Member since 5/08

2776 total posts

Name:
Melanie

Re: co-op Vs. Condo

Posted by nov04libride

Posted by Melmel821

I thought a condo would be a better buy but they are more expensive. I'm not sure sure if it's worth it to buy as a first home or to continue rent until we buy our forever home? A coop costs less and generally the cost would be the same as our rent. I feel we can pay what we would have and hopefully sustain some equity instead of just throwing money away. A coop seems more temporary to me and a condo seems a little more sustainable - we'd stay in a condo longer than a coop. Does that make sense?



We had a condo for the past 5 years, and just sold it for less than we paid. You can't predict the economy, but I can say that our condo sold in less than 2 weeks (priced well), while many of my friends selling co-ops have had them on the market 6 mos.+. Honestly, 5 years ago, I wished we would have continued to rent instead of buy. With realtor commissions/lawyer fees/etc., we're losing about $15,000 from what we paid for the condo 5 years ago, AND we put money into it. If you're thinking short term, after what I've been through, I would rent instead of buying.



Did it really turn into a loss? I understand that the resale could be less but I figure you must come out of it with something. With rent you never get that back but at least if you own you are getting something back on your investment right?

I have a feeling we will rent until we find our forever home (which could be a really nice condo or a single family). I play around with the idea of a starter home but I'm not really sure about that. I kind of like the idea of buying a place and that's it. It's ours.

Posted 3/12/09 5:40 PM
 

NASP09
...

Member since 6/05

6030 total posts

Name:

Re:

Message edited 2010-03-04 21:23:52.297000.

Posted 3/12/09 5:55 PM
 

KrisT
Two Boys for Me!!

Member since 1/07

5213 total posts

Name:
Kristin

Re: co-op Vs. Condo

Posted by tourist

Not all co-op boards are as bad as people make them out to be. I think mine is fairly reasonable, but it is another thing you have to look into when buying one.




I agree. We really have had no problems with our board and they don't have any crazy rules.

Posted 3/12/09 5:55 PM
 

nov04libride
big brother <3

Member since 5/05

14672 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: co-op Vs. Condo

Posted by Melmel821
Did it really turn into a loss? I understand that the resale could be less but I figure you must come out of it with something. With rent you never get that back but at least if you own you are getting something back on your investment right?

I have a feeling we will rent until we find our forever home (which could be a really nice condo or a single family). I play around with the idea of a starter home but I'm not really sure about that. I kind of like the idea of buying a place and that's it. It's ours.



No, it's really a loss. We're selling for less than we paid, and we're losing $10,000 of the selling price to realtor fees. Add onto that another $2,000 in lawyer/bank fees for the sale. We also probably put $3-4,000 into the condo in terms of repair/painting/new carpet, etc. Any tax benefits don't come near to recooping the losses.

We paid down our mortgage more than we had to, but if we hadn't, we wouldn't even get back the amount that we initially put down.

Message edited 2009-03-12 18:01:49.480000.

Posted 3/12/09 5:58 PM
 

KimberlyScott
Graceyn=My World <3

Member since 10/08

4173 total posts

Name:
Kimberly

Re: co-op Vs. Condo

Buy a condo. The co-op board is a pain in the arse.

Message edited 2009-03-12 18:13:40.457000.

Posted 3/12/09 6:12 PM
 

NASP09
...

Member since 6/05

6030 total posts

Name:

Re:

Message edited 2010-03-04 21:23:30.497000.

Posted 3/12/09 6:13 PM
 

ihilani
LIF Adolescent

Member since 9/07

858 total posts

Name:
alias

Re: co-op Vs. Condo

Another thing to consider is the location. There are no condos in my area.

Also, a recent NYT article about some of the implications of condo vs. co-op ownership. linky

Posted 3/12/09 6:17 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
SECOND OPEN HOUSE Sunday, 2/15 1-3PM *For Sale DIAMOND +++ LARGEST 1B CONDO UPPER UNIT W/ TERRACE* DeedeeNY 1/26/09 14 Home
Anyone Looking for a Condo in Florida NOW w. PICS shellybean 6/24/08 3 Home
Went to 3 more condo open houses this weekend. MUCH BETTER Ophelia 3/3/08 4 Home
New Here! And I have a Condo vs. Coop Question alisha 4/19/07 15 Home
We just put in an offer on a condo!!!!!!!!! UPDATE 2/9 CaMacho 2/8/07 45 Home
Check this out... giving away a jag w/ sale of condo!!!! CaMacho 12/21/06 30 Home