CIO...a DIFFERENT pediatrician's advice...
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: 1 [2] | |
|
Re: CIO...a DIFFERENT pediatrician's advice... I would be finding a new doctor. That is horrible advice. Google Reactive Attachment Disorder. Newborns should not be left to CIO. |
|
Posted 7/2/10 1:06 AM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: CIO...a DIFFERENT pediatrician's advice... Posted by Mimms Posted by prncsslehcar What?! Omg. That's terrible! My thoughts exactly She's too little to cio, IMO.Don't do it! They are nuts. That is way too young. At that point they just need their needs met. They can't understand cause/effect. |
|
Posted 7/2/10 7:08 AM
|
|
|
Re: CIO...a DIFFERENT pediatrician's advice... Posted by ChrisDee Posted by Diana1215 Posted by SweetTooth Posted by ChrisDee I read(in multiple places) that once a baby is 10lbs, they do not need to be feed during the night My SIL ped. agreed with this as well. But what about babies who are born at 10lbs? this seems to be strange advice. exactly. My son was born at 10lbs and he needed to eat every three hours when he was born. To the OP - It doesn't make sense. A baby that age needs to be comforted and to feel secure. I would absolutely be looking for another practice. I do not agree with this advice, I just thought it was interesting that I have heard it multiple times. Peyton was 9lbs 3oz at birth(2 weeks early) and I can not see it either. oh no, I know you didn't agree - didn't want to come off like I was coming at you! I was just reiterating the fact that those peds are nuts
|
|
Posted 7/2/10 7:09 AM
|
|
|
Re: CIO...a DIFFERENT pediatrician's advice... Poor little baby! I think that is way too young! |
|
Posted 7/2/10 7:25 AM
|
|
|
Re: CIO...a DIFFERENT pediatrician's advice... Wow. I am one to follow the ped's advice as they are the medical expert - but not for that. I was told to feed them every 2-3 hours but if they slept through the night to let it go. Message edited 2010-07-02 07:43:03.050000. |
|
Posted 7/2/10 7:42 AM
|
|
|
Re: CIO...a DIFFERENT pediatrician's advice... Posted by ChrisDee I read(in multiple places) that once a baby is 10lbs, they do not need to be feed during the night My SIL ped. agreed with this as well. I read that too but that comes rom a physiological point of view -- a baby smaller than that needs to eat more often to survive... a 10lb baby can go longer without (physical) health risks. Doesn't mean they will or they should. My DD was 15lbs by 2 months old so I was hopeful...but she didn't drop her night feedings until 5 months. I would never let a baby CIO that young, no matter how much they weighed. |
|
Posted 7/2/10 8:02 AM
|
|
|
Re: CIO...a DIFFERENT pediatrician's advice... My doctor told me that he doesn't think that you should do it until 6 months, but that if your circumstances demand it - i.e. two parents going back to work - that you can do it at 4 months. He said he and his wife are both working parents so they did it at 4 months. I think my son was about 5 months when we did it. My next one I will do it at 4, even though I am a stay at home mom, I think that CIO was the best thing for our family. And honestly my son is a better sleeper now than all of my friends children that never did CIO. |
|
Posted 7/2/10 8:15 AM
|
|
|
Re: CIO...a DIFFERENT pediatrician's advice... Posted by Deedlebugs No way! At that age, the baby still needs to be fed on demand and comforted. There is no way a newborn can self soothe. I agree. I definatley could NOT do it that young
|
|
Posted 7/2/10 8:27 AM
|
|
|
Re: CIO...a DIFFERENT pediatrician's advice... It breaks my heart thinking about that... so young and helpless. |
|
Posted 7/2/10 8:27 AM
|
|
|
Re: CIO...a DIFFERENT pediatrician's advice... i had a pED gi dr. tell us to let our DS who was a week old at the time CIO!! that sleeping on me was creating a monster. let him cry it out in the bassinett, rub his back so he knows we are there. |
|
Posted 7/2/10 9:04 AM
|
|
|
Re: CIO...a DIFFERENT pediatrician's advice... Way too young! That won't teach a newborn anything except that they can't trust you. They need to be comforted to build trust. I hope their other patients aren't listening to them. I would change Ped's immediately! Message edited 2010-07-02 09:20:18.313000. |
|
Posted 7/2/10 9:14 AM
|
|
|
Re: CIO...a DIFFERENT pediatrician's advice... Please don't flame, but I don't really think that it's that horrible as long as you are certain that they are getting enough food during the day. DS was around the same age when the ped told me I could start doing that with naps and build up to doing it at night. DS was only waking up 1x per night (usually around 4am) for a bottle. Different strokes for different folks, but I figured the ped must know a little something about babies since they are a ped afterall. The result for us has been DS STTN by 7 weeks old and now has fantastic sleeping habits. Its a personal decision I guess, but I don't think the ped would recommend it if it were completely inappropriate. ETA: it also depends on what they mean by CIO. Leaving the baby in the crib to cry and cry and cry? Or doing what the prescribed method is which is going in at increasing intervals to offer re-assurance? Personal opinion here, but I am doubtful that the baby would develop mistrust if you are going in and giving support and re-assurance at increasing intervals. I'm not a child psychologist by any means, but I do know that DS does not have any attachment/mistrust issues. Again different strokes for different folks. Dr's are not always right, but it seems like the opinion varies greatly by physician and parent. Have you questioned as to why so early if you have your doubts? I would not run and change doctors necessarily, but if it will ease your mind, maybe seek a second opinion. Message edited 2010-07-02 09:31:12.610000. |
|
Posted 7/2/10 9:24 AM
|
|
|
Re: CIO...a DIFFERENT pediatrician's advice... Posted by LittleBlueBug Please don't flame, but I don't really think that it's that horrible as long as you are certain that they are getting enough food during the day. DS was around the same age when the ped told me I could start doing that with naps and build up to doing it at night. DS was only waking up 1x per night (usually around 4am) for a bottle. Different strokes for different folks, but I figured the ped must know a little something about babies since they are a ped afterall. The result for us has been DS STTN by 7 weeks old and now has fantastic sleeping habits. Its a personal decision I guess, but I don't think the ped would recommend it if it were completely inappropriate. ETA: it also depends on what they mean by CIO. Leaving the baby in the crib to cry and cry and cry? Or doing what the prescribed method is which is going in at increasing intervals to offer re-assurance? Personal opinion here, but I am doubtful that the baby would develop mistrust if you are going in and giving support and re-assurance at increasing intervals. I'm not a child psychologist by any means, but I do know that DS does not have any attachment/mistrust issues. Again different strokes for different folks. Dr's are not always right, but it seems like the opinion varies greatly by physician and parent. Have you questioned as to why so early if you have your doubts? I would not run and change doctors necessarily, but if it will ease your mind, maybe seek a second opinion. I'm not flaming you, but I am disagreeing with you. CIO works when a child is ready, as a BTDT, I have NO IDEA how a baby that young could possibly be ready to CIO. My ped told us to try at 5 months and it didn't work for us until DS was ONE. AND the method where you go in doesn't work for everyone either... I really honestly believe that a baby has to be 6 months, or OLDER before they are ready for CIO |
|
Posted 7/2/10 9:33 AM
|
|
|
Re: CIO...a DIFFERENT pediatrician's advice... Posted by KateDevine Posted by LittleBlueBug Please don't flame, but I don't really think that it's that horrible as long as you are certain that they are getting enough food during the day. DS was around the same age when the ped told me I could start doing that with naps and build up to doing it at night. DS was only waking up 1x per night (usually around 4am) for a bottle. Different strokes for different folks, but I figured the ped must know a little something about babies since they are a ped afterall. The result for us has been DS STTN by 7 weeks old and now has fantastic sleeping habits. Its a personal decision I guess, but I don't think the ped would recommend it if it were completely inappropriate. ETA: it also depends on what they mean by CIO. Leaving the baby in the crib to cry and cry and cry? Or doing what the prescribed method is which is going in at increasing intervals to offer re-assurance? Personal opinion here, but I am doubtful that the baby would develop mistrust if you are going in and giving support and re-assurance at increasing intervals. I'm not a child psychologist by any means, but I do know that DS does not have any attachment/mistrust issues. Again different strokes for different folks. Dr's are not always right, but it seems like the opinion varies greatly by physician and parent. Have you questioned as to why so early if you have your doubts? I would not run and change doctors necessarily, but if it will ease your mind, maybe seek a second opinion. I'm not flaming you, but I am disagreeing with you. CIO works when a child is ready, as a BTDT, I have NO IDEA how a baby that young could possibly be ready to CIO. My ped told us to try at 5 months and it didn't work for us until DS was ONE. AND the method where you go in doesn't work for everyone either... I really honestly believe that a baby has to be 6 months, or OLDER before they are ready for CIO I respect your opinion and agree that it does not work the same for every child. Every baby is different...heck every baby in the same family is different. I don't agree that it should universally wait until 6 months for all babies because I have seen it work out well for babies younger than that and they are happy and healthy as any other baby. Basically you have to see what works for you. DS was taking almost 36 oz of formula when we started, which at the time, was a heck of a lot. I started making the bottles smaller and smaller at night, and when he was just waking up, eating 1oz and then falling back to sleep, I realized it wasn't because he was hungry. Again, that is what worked for us and I'm just sharing. DS never required rocking to go to sleep and actually hated the swing for a long time, so again, it was just specific to our baby I guess. I guess I would have hated it if someone would have said "oh your crazy or doing some sort of psychological damage" to my son while we were doing it. However, after the fact, when we say that DS STTN at 7 weeks old everyone always says how wonderful that is and how happy DS is all the time. That's all I guess. |
|
Posted 7/2/10 9:41 AM
|
|
| Pages: 1 [2] | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Need advice/thoughts -- Pediatrician related (a little long) | LoveMySMT09 | 2/9/10 | 3 | Parenting |
| MD vs DO - advice on first pediatrician's visit needed | spa118 | 12/27/09 | 18 | Parenting |
| X-Post.. Advice needed on picking a pediatrician | randella | 12/18/08 | 0 | Parenting |
| Advice on picking a pediatrician (a little long) | randella | 12/18/08 | 7 | Pregnancy |
| Advice needed about my job and pediatrician......Sort of a vent also | missrock | 11/19/07 | 6 | Parenting |
| Pediatrician...need advice on making the call | Ang-Rich | 3/6/07 | 8 | Pregnancy |






My SIL ped. agreed with this as well.
I was just reiterating the fact that those peds are nuts






