CIO not working - UPDATE

Posted By Message

mrandmrs12
LIF Adult

Member since 1/07

1687 total posts

Name:

CIO not working - UPDATE

I am afraid CIO isn't working. DD is 5 1/2 months. We jumped the gun a ilttle and did it before 6 months because the ped okayed it, and because we know others who have done it early, and because DD wakes up CONSTANTLY at night.

So last night was night #3. She goes to sleep on her own, but wakes up all night. So the first night she cried for an hour and 20 minutes - on and off. I only went in twice because she kept stopping, and then starting again. She cried a couple other times that night but I didn't have to go in because she stopped so fast. The second night she cried for 35 minutes on and off. And she cried a couple other times, but I didn't have to go in. Last night she cried for about 10 minutes on and off. BUT then she kept crying all night on and off. ALL NIGHT.

Her voice seems horse (sp?). Yesterday for the first time EVER in her life (lol) i had trouble getting her to nap. She has always been a good napper. She was not having it yesterday. Maybe she is afraid I will make her cry more She does seem like her happy self mostly. But I am so worried this whole CIO thing is backfiring.

Do we abandon CIO for now?? and just live with her waking up all the time for a few more months? Or do we stick to it? I hate to continue it, but I hate to "waste" the crying I already tortured her with. Chat Icon

Message edited 2011-03-06 09:43:22.730000.

Posted 3/5/11 9:54 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

mommyIam

Member since 7/09

9209 total posts

Name:
Shana

Re: CIO not working

How did you normally handle it when she woke at night? Is she hungry? Teething? Sick?

imo, CIO works beautifully when baby is clean, painfree, comfortable, and well fed.

I get the feeling something else is wrong, that is disturbing her... especially since she has no issues going to sleep on her own.

Posted 3/5/11 10:01 AM
 

aliwnec10
mom of 3 boys

Member since 4/06

11426 total posts

Name:
Ali

Re: CIO not working

You either need to decide if you're going to do Ferbers method or the extinction method. For us, going in only made it worse.

I wouldn't give up on it yet. I mean it already seems like progress. 1st night an hour and 20 minutes. The 2nd night was only 35 minutes. The 3rd night was 10 minutes. So it seems like that is progress to me. Yes she may be crying on and off during the night, but give it another night or two and she may stop that. Chat Icon

She's fighting the naps because she's tired and not rested during the night, which is normal.

We had to do CIO for naps and bedtime.

I would give it another 2 nights and see what happens. Chat Icon

Posted 3/5/11 10:13 AM
 

CucumberGirl
You give the best smiles!

Member since 1/09

2398 total posts

Name:
M~

Re: CIO not working

Posted by aliwnec10

You either need to decide if you're going to do Ferbers method or the extinction method. For us, going in only made it worse.

I wouldn't give up on it yet. I mean it already seems like progress. 1st night an hour and 20 minutes. The 2nd night was only 35 minutes. The 3rd night was 10 minutes. So it seems like that is progress to me. Yes she may be crying on and off during the night, but give it another night or two and she may stop that. Chat Icon

She's fighting the naps because she's tired and not rested during the night, which is normal.

We had to do CIO for naps and bedtime.

I would give it another 2 nights and see what happens. Chat Icon



ITA. We also had to do extinction.

Posted 3/5/11 10:24 AM
 

yankinmanc
Happy Days!

Member since 8/05

18208 total posts

Name:

Re: CIO not working

I don't think CIO works on every baby, who is going in the room to soothe?

I found if I send my huband, it works much better

Posted 3/5/11 10:58 AM
 

KennysMommy
Never knew LOVE like it before

Member since 3/10

2640 total posts

Name:
Danielle

Re: CIO not working

I did CIO at 4 months old but only for putting DS to bed. He still woke 2xs in the night to nurse and I just went in, attended to his needs, and he went back to sleep on his own. I did that until he was 9 months when I then did CIO for MOTN wakings too. DS was never a good sleeper from day one.

Maybe consider using CIO only for going to bed and then tackle MOTN wakings differently. Chances are if she's not going down for a nap, she's OVER tired and that is not a good thing. In that case, it is backfiring on you. I'd just stick to CIO for bedtime and worry about the other wakings in the coming weeks.

Posted 3/5/11 1:48 PM
 

SecretTTCer
LIF Adult

Member since 6/08

2284 total posts

Name:

Re: CIO not working

It isn't working because you are going in. Every time you go in, you are teaching her to cry for a longer period of time. Read a bit on how to do it properly and then try again. It will definitely work.

Posted 3/5/11 3:04 PM
 

mrandmrs12
LIF Adult

Member since 1/07

1687 total posts

Name:

Re: CIO not working

i have to say that i HAVE read a ton about the proper way to do CIO.

Anyway, thanks to everyone for you advice.

I don't think that DD is uncomfortable in any way... I agree it will only work if all her needs are met. I have given her tylenol and mylicon before bed, so I could be sure she is not gassy or in any teething pain (I do think she is teething...I feel like she's been teething forever, lol).

She is EBF and does need to nurse still at night. She was doing a 7 hour stretch or so, but was doing less and less the more she was waking at night, because i was running out of ways to get her back to sleep. SO, when we started cIO, I decided to nurse her around 7, and then I would nurse her at midnight the earliest...and then again around 5 am(whenever she woke up next). This worked great the first two nights of CIO. It was just last night that she woke up a million times. I ended up nursing her last night at 1230, 230 and 430. Chat Icon

It is always me who goes in to get her. DH has tried a few times, before CIO, and it never goes well. She gets more upset and I end up going in anyway. When seh was younger, she would just take the pacifier and go back to sleep easily. After a while ,she wouldn't take the bniky anymore and I'd have to pick her up and rock her. Sometimes I'd have to nurse her.

Maybe we have to go the extinction route. And maybe we just have to giver her a little more time. DS was so easy - two nights and hardly any crying - but he was 9 months old. I was hoping it would be just as easy! Chat Icon

Thansk again, ladies.

Posted 3/5/11 4:09 PM
 

Purplegirl77
i love my kids!

Member since 1/09

1963 total posts

Name:
Debbie

Re: CIO not working

First I want to say that you are doing a great job. I know it is so hard to do the CIO (hearing your baby cry)....we tried it when DD was around 8 months or so and it didn't work and then tried it at 1 yr and it worked. For us we had to go in and soothe her when she cried....but I was the one who did and I only went in 1 or 2x and didn't talk, rubbed her back and walked out....now when she is crying in the middle of the night is it screaming or just crying? DD (17 months) still sometimes cries in the middle of the night but most of the time it is in her sleep and she stops or we have to just rub her back for a minute and she is fine. Does your DD use music to sleep to? Our DD does so sometimes I even turn her CD back on when she is crying at night and that helps. If your Ped told you that she wasn't too young for CIO then she is fine...I think I would stick w/ it only b/c you have already done 3 nights already and I feel like it would be a waste if not....also how long is she crying for in the MOTN? and like I asked is is screaming where you have to get her or can you put music on or just rub her back to help her back to sleep?

Posted 3/5/11 4:19 PM
 

mrandmrs12
LIF Adult

Member since 1/07

1687 total posts

Name:

Re: CIO not working

purplegirl77 - THANK YOU! I am so unsure of myself lately with DD, it helps to hear that maybe i'm doing ok. Chat Icon

DD does go to sleep to music. Sometimes I try to put it back in the middle of the night for her. Sometimes it works, sometimes it doesn't. When she cries at night it's usually a pretty icky cry. Not just a wimper or anything.

DH and I decided we are going to stick with it for tonight....night 4.... hoping this will do it. Otherwise we might forget it and try it when she is older if we need to. I hope we don't have to! I have no idea how to get her to sleep if this doesn't work.... Chat Icon

Posted 3/5/11 9:12 PM
 

Purplegirl77
i love my kids!

Member since 1/09

1963 total posts

Name:
Debbie

Re: CIO not working

Posted by mrandmrs12

purplegirl77 - THANK YOU! I am so unsure of myself lately with DD, it helps to hear that maybe i'm doing ok. Chat Icon

DD does go to sleep to music. Sometimes I try to put it back in the middle of the night for her. Sometimes it works, sometimes it doesn't. When she cries at night it's usually a pretty icky cry. Not just a wimper or anything.

DH and I decided we are going to stick with it for tonight....night 4.... hoping this will do it. Otherwise we might forget it and try it when she is older if we need to. I hope we don't have to! I have no idea how to get her to sleep if this doesn't work.... Chat Icon





I hope it worked tonight.....but if not it's ok your DD is so young ...I rocked my DD to sleep till 1 wk before her 1st bday!!! I don't regret any of it...she is only a baby 1x and then she was ready older for cio. It will all work out don't worry just enjoy DD....you're doing great!!!

Posted 3/5/11 10:00 PM
 

mrandmrs12
LIF Adult

Member since 1/07

1687 total posts

Name:

Re: CIO not working UPDATE

Well, last night was night #4. She went to sleep easily at 830, woke up at 915 and cried for ten minutes very on and off, and then again at 10 very on and off.

She woke up at 1230 to nurse, then slept till 530 when she nursed, then slept till 830.

SO, THAT was good!!!!!!!! Much better than her waking up every hour or more! we'll see what happens tonight.

Thanks everybody for your advice!

Posted 3/6/11 9:42 AM
 

MamaB17
Back for baby #3

Member since 5/09

4065 total posts

Name:
N

Re: CIO not working - UPDATE

Glad you had a better night. My dd is also BF almost 11months. She gets up a million times a night when she is teething. It is terrible. I kwim about teething forever! She has her two bottom teeth, and I still feel like I don't have it figured it out. My ped said the pain comes in cycles. So they are teething on and off, all the time. I did CIO for bedtime, and it worked great. I still get up to BF during the night. DD goes to bed around 7:30pm, and then wakes up to nurse around midnight. She then goes back to bed and wakes again, around 4am. Then back to sleep until 6:30 when we are up for the day.
Last night b/c she is having some teething pain, she went to bed normal time (7:30), woke up at 11:00, then 12:45, 3:30am, 5:45, and 6:45 for the day. It sucks. She wants to comfort nurse all night. Chat Icon I am not planning to do cio during the night for a little bit. She was a preemie, and is still so small. She only weighs 16lbs so I don't want to stop the motn feedings. Kwim? Now that she is crawling I think she is just hungry trying to make up for all those calories she is burning too. Good luck! It will keep getting easier. I promise! Teething messes everything up, we have had to redo cio after they broke. Hang in there. Chat Icon

Posted 3/6/11 10:50 AM
 

Purplegirl77
i love my kids!

Member since 1/09

1963 total posts

Name:
Debbie

Re: CIO not working - UPDATE

Posted by mrandmrs12

Well, last night was night #4. She went to sleep easily at 830, woke up at 915 and cried for ten minutes very on and off, and then again at 10 very on and off.

She woke up at 1230 to nurse, then slept till 530 when she nursed, then slept till 830.

SO, THAT was good!!!!!!!! Much better than her waking up every hour or more! we'll see what happens tonight.

Thanks everybody for your advice!




YAY!!!! I am so happy for you!!!! I was thinking about you last night and this morning and hoping you had a good night!!! that is awesome!!! You did great!!!!!!

Posted 3/6/11 11:11 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
CIO not working... please help! mrandmrs12 5/14/09 2 Parenting
i don't know if CIO is working...PLEASE HELP!! browneyedgirl 12/5/08 20 Parenting
OMG! CIO IS working!!!!! TiggerBounce 9/12/07 7 Parenting
CIO Not Working jrbaby 12/26/08 8 Parenting
My version of CIO is working! Rycois 9/12/08 8 Parenting
cio is working for us.... wowcoulditbe 4/16/07 0 Parenting