Christmas Present In-Laws - Vent
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: 1 [2] | |
|
Re: Christmas Present In-Laws - Vent Posted by Shorty but I don't see why he wouldn't want to add it to your savings? Because the whole point of giving him the gift is so he could get something for himself. If his parents wanted the money to be shared... they would have given it to both of you. Not for nothing.. but remember it is HIS parents... blood related for life. And if this is something that all the kids get... and have been getting for years... you can't really say anything. |
|
Posted 1/12/06 9:19 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Christmas Present In-Laws - Vent I would be ****** off too. I think if he gets a side gift, you should get one too. Message edited 2006-01-12 23:12:11.840000. |
|
Posted 1/12/06 11:09 PM
|
|
|
QuoteTheRaven424
Member since 5/05 13659 total posts Name: |
Re: Christmas Present In-Laws - Vent i truly don't see the big deal here |
Posted 1/12/06 11:18 PM
|
|
|
Re: Christmas Present In-Laws - Vent Posted by Stefanie For Christmas, my MIL gave my DH 100 dollars and me 70... Aren't we putting it in the same place? I think that my parents spent more on my Dh than me this year...Whatever... See, something like this would bother me a whole lot more. Why not just give you both a check for $170 then? As for the original post, I can see why you're upset at DH for not telling you, but I don't think it's fair to be upset at his parents. DH's parents definitely gave him more and my parents definitely gave me more. |
|
Posted 1/12/06 11:25 PM
|
|
|
Re: Christmas Present In-Laws - Vent Posted by CaptainCharisma424 i truly don't see the big deal here 1. it's HIS parents, if they want to give him a separate gift, they are entitled 2. people are all miffed because he didn't tell his wife about the money. We're talking about $75 -- not a heck of alot of money. I truly do not see the big deal. If he was hiding or not telling her about hundreds or thousands, that would be one thing. But keeping $75 for yourself is not going to upset the apple cart at all, IMO Exactly. This thread is a prime example of pettiness at its best. Sometimes I feel people like to complain about their in-laws just for the sake of complaining. If my wife got an extra gift at xmas from my MIL without me knowing it.... and she went out and got a sweater without telling me.... if I ever found out I would say something like "nice color". Not for nothing... but I EXPECT my wife to get more gifts from her mom than I do. She gave birth to my wife for nuts sake. How long does she know me.... three / four years? Lets see.... 28 years compared to three.... hmmmmm. |
|
Posted 1/13/06 12:26 AM
|
|
|
Re: Christmas Present In-Laws - Vent I have to admit, I may be overly sensitive about this issue because my in-laws treat me like dirt.... but I don't like the sneakiness of it in any case |
|
Posted 1/13/06 12:42 AM
|
|
|
Re: Christmas Present In-Laws - Vent Posted by DjPiLL Posted by CaptainCharisma424 i truly don't see the big deal here 1. it's HIS parents, if they want to give him a separate gift, they are entitled 2. people are all miffed because he didn't tell his wife about the money. We're talking about $75 -- not a heck of alot of money. I truly do not see the big deal. If he was hiding or not telling her about hundreds or thousands, that would be one thing. But keeping $75 for yourself is not going to upset the apple cart at all, IMO Exactly. This thread is a prime example of pettiness at its best. Sometimes I feel people like to complain about their in-laws just for the sake of complaining. If my wife got an extra gift at xmas from my MIL without me knowing it.... and she went out and got a sweater without telling me.... if I ever found out I would say something like "nice color". Not for nothing... but I EXPECT my wife to get more gifts from her mom than I do. She gave birth to my wife for nuts sake. How long does she know me.... three / four years? Lets see.... 28 years compared to three.... hmmmmm. I don't think I am being petty here, It is how I feel... and you may not agree and that is fine..and you don't know my history with my In-laws either.... I can see everyone points on the issue and do agree with some of them... and thanks everyone! But let me just point out that this is the way my family is.. Fair is fair, you are married everything is equal.. Well maybe my family is wrong.. but you have to understand that this is where I am coming from and why I feel the way I do about this issue. About him not telling me about the money (I don't care if it was 75.00 or 100,000)... If you are not telling me something for the two years we have been married.. you must in the back of your mind think it is wrong.. Same deal with his parents... If you are giving the gifts to all three kids after everyone is done opening christmas presents and gone away.. then you must feel on some level that this is wrong and don't want anyone to know so that no one gets hurt... If his parents feel nothing is wrong with this, then answer me this.. Why not just give the cards with the money when everyone is opeing the presents. |
|
Posted 1/13/06 6:29 AM
|
|
|
Re: Christmas Present In-Laws - Vent Posted by mskimmy98 If his parents feel nothing is wrong with this, then answer me this.. Why not just give the cards with the money when everyone is opeing the presents. IMO, there is no need for secret gifts. And, it's VERY wrong for ANYONE to try get a married person to keep a secret from their spouse. |
|
Posted 1/13/06 8:53 AM
|
|
|
Re: Christmas Present In-Laws - Vent Posted by CaptainCharisma424 i truly don't see the big deal here 1. it's HIS parents, if they want to give him a separate gift, they are entitled i agree 100% perhaps his wording is another reason why you are angry. instead of referring to it as a "side" gift he could say it is an "additional" gift from my parents. either way, i don't think it is a reason to be upset. Message edited 2006-01-13 10:30:09.103000. |
|
Posted 1/13/06 10:28 AM
|
|
|
Re: Christmas Present In-Laws - Vent You hit the nail on the head- I don't think this has as much to do with the gift as it does with your overall relationship with your IL's. |
|
Posted 1/13/06 10:32 AM
|
|
|
Re: Christmas Present In-Laws - Vent Posted by mskimmy98 About him not telling me about the money (I don't care if it was 75.00 or 100,000)... If you are not telling me something for the two years we have been married.. you must in the back of your mind think it is wrong.. Same deal with his parents... If you are giving the gifts to all three kids after everyone is done opening christmas presents and gone away.. then you must feel on some level that this is wrong and don't want anyone to know so that no one gets hurt... If his parents feel nothing is wrong with this, then answer me this.. Why not just give the cards with the money when everyone is opeing the presents. Because maybe his parents want to genuinely get him a gift. Remember this is a GIFT. Its not like he worked overtime and hid that money from you. Maybe he didn't tell you because he knew you would end up complaining about it and would want to take this GIFT away from him. |
|
Posted 1/13/06 10:44 AM
|
|
|
Re: Christmas Present In-Laws - Vent They can give him whatever he wants...and he can do whatever he wants with it. Granted, I would like him to tell me but really, $75... it's a dinner out for two. |
|
Posted 1/13/06 11:02 AM
|
|
|
Re: Christmas Present In-Laws - Vent Posted by VickiC My parents try to be fair with all of us, but honestly, we're their daughters. We definitely get a few more things to open on Christmas Day. They're not stingy with their Sons-in-law, but they tend to give us an extra gift or two. I think that's only natural. Exactly. We'll get equal joint gifts of $$$ but my mom always throws in something "girly" for me & my sister. This year was spa gift certificates. IL's do the same thing. My DH doesn't mind at all. I wouldn't be piss'ed at all. But if it was a significant $$$ amount higher..I'd question him about it.. $75 bucks I could easily spend "picking-up" a few things after work at the grocery store. |
|
Posted 1/13/06 12:10 PM
|
|
|
Re: Christmas Present In-Laws - Vent I'll be honest here, my mom gave me a little more than she gave DH. She gave us both the same, but then later told me she had a little extra and wanted to help me with my student loans. I do not pay my loans from our joint savings, I pay from my personal account, and she wanted this money specifically to go to that to help me out. I see nothing wrong with that--I thought it was so generous of her but I can see why, as parents, they would want to help their own kids out a little more. |
|
Posted 1/13/06 1:13 PM
|
|
|
Re: Christmas Present In-Laws - Vent I don't think it's that big a deal that his mother gives him a little extra on the side. I think it's odd that it's a secret. |
|
Posted 1/13/06 1:16 PM
|
|
|
Re: Christmas Present In-Laws - Vent Posted by suvenR IMO, there is no need for secret gifts. And, it's VERY wrong for ANYONE to try get a married person to keep a secret from their spouse. That was my thought exactly! To me, an extra gift is no big deal but, why does it have to be a secret? Why wouldn't they just give it to him with the rest of his gifts? Neither DH or I would think twice about it then. |
|
Posted 1/13/06 1:40 PM
|
|
|
Re: Christmas Present In-Laws - Vent Posted by WoodIAm Why wouldn't they just give it to him with the rest of his gifts? 1. Because if the gift is given in public... then you run the risk of being pursuaded by the wife on how you should spend your gift. 2. Because if its done in person... thats rude in itself. Do you really think "its cool" to hand the wife a $25... and the son $100 ??? I'll be DAMMED if I am forced to give my future DIL/SIL an equal amount of gifts, cash, whatever as I do my own flesh and blood. |
|
Posted 1/13/06 1:54 PM
|
|
|
Re: Christmas Present In-Laws - Vent Posted by DjPiLL 2. Because if its done in person... thats rude in itself. Do you really think "its cool" to hand the wife a $25... and the son $100 ??? But they didn't give the wife a check did they? Maybe I missed that part. Honestly though, I don't see anything wrong with them giving a check in front of others. But my Mom or MIL would have the cash/check wrapped up in a box and added it in with the gifts. I'll be DAMMED if I am forced to give my future DIL/SIL an equal amount of gifts, cash, whatever as I do my own flesh and blood. I agree (even though my Mom and MIL do give us equal amounts). But, my point was that I don't agree with it being so secretive. |
|
Posted 1/13/06 2:21 PM
|
|
|
Re: Christmas Present In-Laws - Vent if it makes you feel better....I got absolutely nothing from my IL for Christmas. |
|
Posted 1/17/06 5:54 PM
|
|
|
Re: Christmas Present In-Laws - Vent My parents (divorced but do the same thing) usually give us a gift, then a few me gifts and then something for DH. We don't hide them though and my mom is the kind that makes sure that DH opens an us gift too. ie: if she gives us $100, she'll give him a card and me a card each with $50 in it. |
|
Posted 1/17/06 6:15 PM
|
|
|
Re: Christmas Present In-Laws - Vent This is why my MIL gives ME the $$$ and not to him. |
|
Posted 1/17/06 6:17 PM
|
|
| Pages: 1 [2] | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| MIL Vent | DonnaJoe708 | 8/28/06 | 15 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Am I the only one who thinks about Christmas? | Michi | 8/28/06 | 26 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Mother-In-Laws | LAMGAJ28 | 3/17/06 | 37 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Spinoff to Laws broken.. | GROWUP | 2/23/06 | 86 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| NYS Laws - Disability vs. Maternity Leave | Elbee | 2/14/06 | 6 | Pregnancy |
| Write your reps to try to change the fertility coverage laws | michele31 | 1/31/06 | 1 | Infertility |






Aren't we putting it in the same place? I think that my parents spent more on my Dh than me this year...









