Chicken pox vaccine spin off
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: [1] 2 3 | |
|
Chicken pox vaccine spin off I was wondering why everyone is so against the chicken pox vaccine? |
|
Posted 1/23/11 9:38 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Chicken pox vaccine spin off im with you. i thought having a vaccine for it is a great idea. i vaccinated DS at 12 months. |
|
Posted 1/23/11 9:40 PM
|
|
|
Re: Chicken pox vaccine spin off I am completely against it to a certain extent. If DS does not naturally contract it by the time he is a teen I will get the vaccine. |
|
Posted 1/23/11 9:45 PM
|
|
|
Re: Chicken pox vaccine spin off Its a live vaccine, and it wears off, the disease is just annoying not deadly for children |
|
Posted 1/23/11 9:49 PM
|
|
|
Re: Chicken pox vaccine spin off Posted by katiebug I am completely against it to a certain extent. If DS does not naturally contract it by the time he is a teen I will get the vaccine. I don't like the vaccine because it is a harmless childhood illness, and when contracted naturally you are protected for life. This is not the case for the vaccine. They have no idea how long it lasts, so there will be an epidemic of adult chicken pox in the next 10 to 15 years. When you get it as an adult it is much more severe. For me, I would LOVE for DS to get it when he is a small child. I need to find myself a chicken pox party. Also, every pediatrician I have spoken to about this vaccine hates it. How do you plan on enrolling him in school without it? It's required for NY schools.... |
|
Posted 1/23/11 9:50 PM
|
|
|
Re: Chicken pox vaccine spin off Posted by OrganicMama Posted by katiebug I am completely against it to a certain extent. If DS does not naturally contract it by the time he is a teen I will get the vaccine. I don't like the vaccine because it is a harmless childhood illness, and when contracted naturally you are protected for life. This is not the case for the vaccine. They have no idea how long it lasts, so there will be an epidemic of adult chicken pox in the next 10 to 15 years. When you get it as an adult it is much more severe. For me, I would LOVE for DS to get it when he is a small child. I need to find myself a chicken pox party. Also, every pediatrician I have spoken to about this vaccine hates it. How do you plan on enrolling him in school without it? It's required for NY schools.... This is what I thought, but Christine said it wasn't on the list of vaccines for R. I need to look into it. And I need to find a kid with Chicken Pox for E to hug
|
|
Posted 1/23/11 9:52 PM
|
|
|
Re: Chicken pox vaccine spin off I was 8 or 9 when I got it |
|
Posted 1/23/11 9:53 PM
|
|
|
Re: Chicken pox vaccine spin off Posted by katiebug I don't like the vaccine because it is a harmless childhood illness, and when contracted naturally you are protected for life. I had chicken pox in elementary school (I must have been in kindergarten or first grade) and was told that because I was so young when I had it that I could be at risk for shingles. Can you share where you got your information because I'd love to read it...and I mean that seriously...not to go against what you are saying. Message edited 2011-01-23 21:59:14.887000. |
|
Posted 1/23/11 9:56 PM
|
|
|
Re: Chicken pox vaccine spin off Posted by Ang-Rich Posted by katiebug I don't like the vaccine because it is a harmless childhood illness, and when contracted naturally you are protected for life. I had chicken pox in elementary school (I must have been in kindergarten or first grade) and was told that because I was so young when I had it that I could be at risk for shingles. Can you share where you got your information because I'd love to read it...and I mean that seriously...not to go against what you are saying. I have never heard that if you get chicken pox young you are at more risk of contracting shingles. Anyone who has had Chicken pox is at risk of contracting Shingles, bit it usually happens to people with compromised immune systems. You cannot contract shingles from someone with shingles, but you can contract chickenpox from someone who has had shingles. I believe most of the time they have no idea why shingles springs up in people. If it makes you feel any better, my older brother had chickenpox at the age of 2. No one ever mention shingles to him, and he has been around tons of people with chicken pox and has never had a problem I should have clarified you are immune to chickenpox, not to shingles. If you still want links I can get them for you. |
|
Posted 1/23/11 10:28 PM
|
|
|
Re: Chicken pox vaccine spin off Posted by katiebug Posted by Ang-Rich Posted by katiebug I don't like the vaccine because it is a harmless childhood illness, and when contracted naturally you are protected for life. I had chicken pox in elementary school (I must have been in kindergarten or first grade) and was told that because I was so young when I had it that I could be at risk for shingles. Can you share where you got your information because I'd love to read it...and I mean that seriously...not to go against what you are saying. I have never heard that if you get chicken pox young you are at more risk of contracting shingles. Anyone who has had Chicken pox is at risk of contracting Shingles, bit it usually happens to people with compromised immune systems. You cannot contract shingles from someone with shingles, but you can contract chickenpox from someone who has had shingles. I believe most of the time they have no idea why shingles springs up in people. If it makes you feel any better, my older brother had chickenpox at the age of 2. No one ever mention shingles to him, and he has been around tons of people with chicken pox and has never had a problem I should have clarified you are immune to chickenpox, not to shingles. If you still want links I can get them for you. I thought if you DIDN'T get chicken pox you were susceptile to shingles. None the less, this is the ONLY vaccine I plan on delaying, and only until I have to. But I plan on finding a chicken pox party with Katiebug and having DD hug E.
|
|
Posted 1/23/11 10:35 PM
|
|
|
Re: Chicken pox vaccine spin off I am against this vaccine because I witnessed my friend's DS go into seizures as a result of it. It was the scariest thing. THANK GOD he is okay. The doctors advised her had it happened while everyone was asleep, the episode could have turned into a tragedy. |
|
Posted 1/23/11 10:37 PM
|
|
|
Re: Chicken pox vaccine spin off Posted by labonnevie Posted by katiebug Posted by Ang-Rich Posted by katiebug I don't like the vaccine because it is a harmless childhood illness, and when contracted naturally you are protected for life. I had chicken pox in elementary school (I must have been in kindergarten or first grade) and was told that because I was so young when I had it that I could be at risk for shingles. Can you share where you got your information because I'd love to read it...and I mean that seriously...not to go against what you are saying. I have never heard that if you get chicken pox young you are at more risk of contracting shingles. Anyone who has had Chicken pox is at risk of contracting Shingles, bit it usually happens to people with compromised immune systems. You cannot contract shingles from someone with shingles, but you can contract chickenpox from someone who has had shingles. I believe most of the time they have no idea why shingles springs up in people. If it makes you feel any better, my older brother had chickenpox at the age of 2. No one ever mention shingles to him, and he has been around tons of people with chicken pox and has never had a problem I should have clarified you are immune to chickenpox, not to shingles. If you still want links I can get them for you. I thought if you DIDN'T get chicken pox you were susceptile to shingles. None the less, this is the ONLY vaccine I plan on delaying, and only until I have to. But I plan on finding a chicken pox party with Katiebug and having DD hug E. Nope. If you have chickenpox you get shingles. shingles Maybe we need to put an ad on craigslist for chicken pox party
|
|
Posted 1/23/11 10:42 PM
|
|
|
Re: Chicken pox vaccine spin off Wish I would've known there was a demand for a chicken pox party - DS had them in November when he was 11 months old. One of his daycare classmates got them from her cousin in England. |
|
Posted 1/24/11 8:11 AM
|
|
|
Re: Chicken pox vaccine spin off Posted by katiebug I am completely against it to a certain extent. If DS does not naturally contract it by the time he is a teen I will get the vaccine. I don't like the vaccine because it is a harmless childhood illness, and when contracted naturally you are protected for life. This is not the case for the vaccine. They have no idea how long it lasts, so there will be an epidemic of adult chicken pox in the next 10 to 15 years. When you get it as an adult it is much more severe. ITA. I had it at 8. I was itchy and miserable for a few days, and then was fine. My mother caught it from me, but she was in her thirties, and was very ill for a long time. If I give DD the shot, the immunity doesn't last. She could plausibly be protected as a child, and contract it as a young adult, when it's more serious. I plan on hunting for a chicken pox party for DD. |
|
Posted 1/24/11 8:31 AM
|
|
|
Re: Chicken pox vaccine spin off Posted by katiebug I am completely against it to a certain extent. If DS does not naturally contract it by the time he is a teen I will get the vaccine. I don't like the vaccine because it is a harmless childhood illness, and when contracted naturally you are protected for life. This is not the case for the vaccine. They have no idea how long it lasts, so there will be an epidemic of adult chicken pox in the next 10 to 15 years. When you get it as an adult it is much more severe. For me, I would LOVE for DS to get it when he is a small child. I need to find myself a chicken pox party. Also, every pediatrician I have spoken to about this vaccine hates it. I agree. |
|
Posted 1/24/11 8:38 AM
|
|
|
Re: Chicken pox vaccine spin off i will vaccinate against chicken pox. reason being, I had it at 6 months therefore, I can get it again. I do not want to risk exposing my son if I get it... |
|
Posted 1/24/11 8:50 AM
|
|
|
Re: Chicken pox vaccine spin off While I like the more permenant solution of having chicken pox and then being immune. |
|
Posted 1/24/11 9:01 AM
|
|
|
Re: Chicken pox vaccine spin off Posted by Kelly9904 While I like the more permenant solution of having chicken pox and then being immune. Chicken pox is not a "harmless" childhood illness. My brother was hospitalized due to what started as chicken pox, but because his immune system was down became much worse. So DS was vaccinated. I have to say that the above is correct I had a friend in elementary school who had severe complications from CP so you might want to ask some of the MDs or NPs on the boards what their experience has been but there are some people who have severe complications. BTW having it does not guarantee immunity. I had it at age 5. I had a total of 5 spots. For many years - (they didn't test me until I was thinking of getting pregnant and asked to be tested) my PCP and OB told me there was a very large chance that I would not have immunity. What you choose is your choice - but I am 99.9% sure I saw on NYS's website that it was required for K-12 and I thought for nursery school - but that I'm not sure about. |
|
Posted 1/24/11 10:47 AM
|
|
|
Re: Chicken pox vaccine spin off Posted by Lillykat Posted by Kelly9904 While I like the more permenant solution of having chicken pox and then being immune. Chicken pox is not a "harmless" childhood illness. My brother was hospitalized due to what started as chicken pox, but because his immune system was down became much worse. So DS was vaccinated. I have to say that the above is correct I had a friend in elementary school who had severe complications from CP so you might want to ask some of the MDs or NPs on the boards what their experience has been but there are some people who have severe complications. BTW having it does not guarantee immunity. I had it at age 5. I had a total of 5 spots. For many years - (they didn't test me until I was thinking of getting pregnant and asked to be tested) my PCP and OB told me there was a very large chance that I would not have immunity. What you choose is your choice - but I am 99.9% sure I saw on NYS's website that it was required for K-12 and I thought for nursery school - but that I'm not sure about. You can have complications from a cold. It happens, but for the most part 95% of the time you are immune and it is a harmless childhood disease. I too had very few spots, so it has crossed my mind that I could contract it again. I thought it was required but a mother told me it wasn't. I will check it out when DS is of age if he does not contract it by then. ETS: I found this on a site about chickenpox: A mild case of chickenpox produces immunity to varicella as does a moderate or severe case. A child with a reliable history of chickenpox does not need to receive varicella vaccine. However, if there is any doubt that the mild illness really was chickenpox, it is best to vaccinate the child. There is no harm in vaccinating a child who is already immune. Message edited 2011-01-24 11:15:43.827000. |
|
Posted 1/24/11 10:59 AM
|
|
|
Re: Chicken pox vaccine spin off I totally agree with you. At first I questioned the chicken pox shot, but gave it to my DC. Then recently my friend posted the following on facebook: |
|
Posted 1/24/11 11:30 AM
|
|
|
Re: Chicken pox vaccine spin off its like the flu, you suffer through it and walk away with your body beating it. Now in cases where you could have a weaken immunity then of course I completely understand getting it. |
|
Posted 1/24/11 11:31 AM
|
|
|
Re: Chicken pox vaccine spin off Posted by katiebug You can have complications from a cold. It happens, but for the most part 95% of the time you are immune and it is a harmless childhood disease. I too had very few spots, so it has crossed my mind that I could contract it again. I thought it was required but a mother told me it wasn't. I will check it out when DS is of age if he does not contract it by then. ETS: I found this on a site about chickenpox: A mild case of chickenpox produces immunity to varicella as does a moderate or severe case. A child with a reliable history of chickenpox does not need to receive varicella vaccine. However, if there is any doubt that the mild illness really was chickenpox, it is best to vaccinate the child. There is no harm in vaccinating a child who is already immune. I can tell you that having a light dose can mean you are still not immune. Apparently I have no idea on the numbers (sorry not an MD) but I can tell you that I have 2 friends who had light cases and after titers were found to not be immune. As far as comparing to a cold I'm not a doctor or a nurse - so maybe they can chime in but I don't think it isn't quite the same - most people who have complications for a common cold do so b.c they didn't take care of themselves (i.e. had a cough that turned into a bacterial infection and they put off going to the doctor so they ended up with pneumonia.) - whereas the people who have complications from CP are often healthy in other ways (whenever you have immunosuppred people anything they get will be worse I'm speaking about the average healthy person). I can say that the child I knew was very healthy with no pre-existing conditions who had severe issues. Actually what I'm curious to hear about are some real life experiences from people who see these things regularly (nurses in the hospital, peds etc). |
|
Posted 1/24/11 11:37 AM
|
|
|
Re: Chicken pox vaccine spin off if you have had CP, you are susceptible to shingles AT ANY AGE. |
|
Posted 1/24/11 11:44 AM
|
|
|
Re: Chicken pox vaccine spin off Posted by Lillykat Posted by katiebug You can have complications from a cold. It happens, but for the most part 95% of the time you are immune and it is a harmless childhood disease. I too had very few spots, so it has crossed my mind that I could contract it again. I thought it was required but a mother told me it wasn't. I will check it out when DS is of age if he does not contract it by then. ETS: I found this on a site about chickenpox: A mild case of chickenpox produces immunity to varicella as does a moderate or severe case. A child with a reliable history of chickenpox does not need to receive varicella vaccine. However, if there is any doubt that the mild illness really was chickenpox, it is best to vaccinate the child. There is no harm in vaccinating a child who is already immune. I can tell you that having a light dose can mean you are still not immune. Apparently I have no idea on the numbers (sorry not an MD) but I can tell you that I have 2 friends who had light cases and after titers were found to not be immune. As far as comparing to a cold I'm not a doctor or a nurse - so maybe they can chime in but I don't think it isn't quite the same - most people who have complications for a common cold do so b.c they didn't take care of themselves (i.e. had a cough that turned into a bacterial infection and they put off going to the doctor so they ended up with pneumonia.) - whereas the people who have complications from CP are often healthy in other ways (whenever you have immunosuppred people anything they get will be worse I'm speaking about the average healthy person). I can say that the child I knew was very healthy with no pre-existing conditions who had severe issues. Actually what I'm curious to hear about are some real life experiences from people who see these things regularly (nurses in the hospital, peds etc). I honestly thought the same as you with mild cases. I have a doctor appointment this week and I am going ask about it. But maybe your friends didn't actually have chickenpox? I am really curious about this. And as for my cold vs cp, I was simply pointing out that you can have complications from anything. And I would much prefer my child having chickenpox when the chance of having complications is much less, then when they are teenagers for adults. That is WHY I want them to get chickenpox for better immunization then the vaccination offers. |
|
Posted 1/24/11 12:24 PM
|
|
|
Re: Chicken pox vaccine spin off Posted by katiebug Posted by Lillykat Posted by katiebug You can have complications from a cold. It happens, but for the most part 95% of the time you are immune and it is a harmless childhood disease. I too had very few spots, so it has crossed my mind that I could contract it again. I thought it was required but a mother told me it wasn't. I will check it out when DS is of age if he does not contract it by then. ETS: I found this on a site about chickenpox: A mild case of chickenpox produces immunity to varicella as does a moderate or severe case. A child with a reliable history of chickenpox does not need to receive varicella vaccine. However, if there is any doubt that the mild illness really was chickenpox, it is best to vaccinate the child. There is no harm in vaccinating a child who is already immune. I can tell you that having a light dose can mean you are still not immune. Apparently I have no idea on the numbers (sorry not an MD) but I can tell you that I have 2 friends who had light cases and after titers were found to not be immune. As far as comparing to a cold I'm not a doctor or a nurse - so maybe they can chime in but I don't think it isn't quite the same - most people who have complications for a common cold do so b.c they didn't take care of themselves (i.e. had a cough that turned into a bacterial infection and they put off going to the doctor so they ended up with pneumonia.) - whereas the people who have complications from CP are often healthy in other ways (whenever you have immunosuppred people anything they get will be worse I'm speaking about the average healthy person). I can say that the child I knew was very healthy with no pre-existing conditions who had severe issues. Actually what I'm curious to hear about are some real life experiences from people who see these things regularly (nurses in the hospital, peds etc). I honestly thought the same as you with mild cases. I have a doctor appointment this week and I am going ask about it. But maybe your friends didn't actually have chickenpox? I am really curious about this. And as for my cold vs cp, I was simply pointing out that you can have complications from anything. And I would much prefer my child having chickenpox when the chance of having complications is much less, then when they are teenagers for adults. That is WHY I want them to get chickenpox for better immunization then the vaccination offers. I got chicken pox at 16.. i never had a light case... I was next to my cousin at 5 when she had chicken pox- I was in school w/ people that had it- I never, ever got it- not until 16.... and it was terrible.. so just b/c you don't vaccinate- that doesn't mean your child is going to get chicken pox at a young age and get a mild case. |
|
Posted 1/24/11 12:28 PM
|
|
| Pages: [1] 2 3 | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Feeling TONS of ANXIETY right now that tomorrow Chloe is supposed to get her MMR and Chicken Pox Vaccine... | BabyLove08 | 12/27/09 | 9 | Parenting |
| Does anyone's ped give the MMR and Chicken Pox vaccine together? | headoverheels | 12/17/09 | 22 | Parenting |
| When did you give the Chicken Pox and MMR vaccine (esp if you delay/space out vaccines)? | Goobster | 11/11/09 | 15 | Parenting |
| when would a reaction to the chicken pox vaccine show up? | browneyedgirl | 9/21/09 | 8 | Parenting |
| Those who delayed the MMR and Chicken pox vaccine. | beachgirl | 5/4/09 | 0 | Parenting |
| Anyone get a reaction to the chicken pox vaccine? | lipglossjunky73 | 11/6/08 | 5 | Parenting |














