celebrating mediocrity?

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2]

DiamondGirl
You are my I love you

Member since 7/09

18802 total posts

Name:
DiamondMama

Re: celebrating mediocrity?

Posted by Kara

Celebrating effort and progress isn't celebrating mediocrity. Celebrating one's personal best isn't celebrating mediocrity either, even if one person's best is another person's mediocre.



Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 2/9/10 4:03 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

lbelle821
Arghhhhh

Member since 2/06

5285 total posts

Name:
Lisa

Re: celebrating mediocrity?

Posted by Kara

Posted by lbelle821

As a mother to a child with special needs I need to chime in here...

I find myself celebrating less than mediocrity every day! I celebrate steps in the right direction. I celebrate when he tried his personal best. I celebrate and compliment the tiniest things.

No, I will never get him a car for staying out of rehab for 30 hours. But would I get him a gift if he got a 70. Maybe. Depends on how hard he had to work to get that 70. If I know he busted his butt and that got him a 70...I sure would encourage that mainstream mediocrity. Maybe it wouldn't actually be a material item. But it sure would be a ton of praise and encouragement from me. Maybe that makes me an enabler. I more look at it like building confidence and self-esteem. And makes him want to do even better next time.

Disclaimer though -- i do see my situation as being different than the ones you listed (i.e. rehab) and certainly do see a lot of that type of behavior going around ... but needed to just say that I do think a child's genuine effort should be celebrated to an extent but not necessarily with material items.




I don't see any of this as celebrating mediocrity. "Mediocre" and "excellent" are relative terms. What is mediocre for one person may be another person's absolute best.

If I played 18 holes of golf and got 110, I'd be estatic. (Mostly because the game was over, but also because I don't think I could ever even come close to that score in real life.) If my father, an avid golfer who normally shoots in the low 80s, got 110 for a round of golf, it would for sure be beyond mediocre. if Tiger Woods got 110, it would be pathetic.

Celebrating effort and progress isn't celebrating mediocrity. Celebrating one's personal best isn't celebrating mediocrity either, even if one person's best is another person's mediocre.



I agree with you...that was my point. Special needs or not, what I was saying was that sometimes you should celebrate a 70 on a test because of exactly what you said in the last paragraph. I referred to it as "mainstream mediocrity" as a baseline.

Chat Icon

Message edited 2010-02-09 16:40:52.003000.

Posted 2/9/10 4:39 PM
 

MamaNDaddyof3
:)

Member since 5/05

7267 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: celebrating mediocrity?

my oldest dd(13) works very hard for her good grades she always does her hw and studies and spends days on projects is NEVER absent.....she made honor roll last quarter and this quarter

We take her and a friend to dinner to celebrate

It annoys me when other children I know get $20 for their report card when they are absent at least 2 days a week and fail subjects never do hw and get calls home from the teachers all the time!!

also my 8yr old is plays soccer and she is very good but she also works VERY VERY hard she practiices 4 times a week and she plays her best at every game she always goes to practice and never complains(she has gotten MVP awards a few times)
so I feel that is deserved and she should get a special award to reward all her hard work and effort (not just a participation award)

Posted 2/9/10 4:46 PM
 

Candy Girl
Candy girl- you are so sweet!

Member since 11/07

6349 total posts

Name:
erin

Re: celebrating mediocrity?

Ah, I get it now.

I don't know. I guess I agree with some of the other posters that what may be considered mediocre for one person is actually a great achievement for another.

I was always terrible in math. When i got a D in my college required math course I went out on the town. Celebrating mediocrity? Maybe, but I sure felt great passing that class. It was really difficult for me!

I love how Kara phrased her answer--celebrating effort and progress are beautiful concepts.

I think it's silly when all of them teams get trophies, even the losing ones. I don't plan to enroll my DD in sports though.

The school that I teach in urges teacher to pass as many kids as possible-not to give them high grades, but just pass them--so that the school's credit accumulation looks high when they are reviewed by the city. I don't know if this would be considered celebrating mediocrity. I do know it's crooked!

Edited: a mistake/typo here and there...

Message edited 2010-02-09 17:04:07.760000.

Posted 2/9/10 5:02 PM
 

munchkinfacemama
LOVE

Member since 11/07

15800 total posts

Name:
<FONT COLOR="#FF0099">Michelle</FONT>

Re: celebrating mediocrity?

Display of low standards

Edited to elaborate-To be it is a display of low standards when it is someone's mediocrity. I do not mean celebrating for one what is an achievement and to another what is mediocre (like in a school setting-celebrating a B in history for me was ridiculous, whereas someone struggling it would be a great idea). I don't think there is a standard as to what is mediocre across the board.

Message edited 2010-02-09 17:07:02.413000.

Posted 2/9/10 5:03 PM
 

JennB
My princess <3

Member since 5/09

2473 total posts

Name:
Jenn

Re: celebrating mediocrity?

it bothers me. But I think these are two seperate issues.
ITA that children should be rewarded for their efforts and progress, it's what motivates them and depending on a child's ability, that is how they should be assessed and rewarded.
For example, I have students who do the bare minimum to pass and then are happy with the 65. They have the newest video games, clothes, sneakers, etc. I think that is rewarding mediocrity and DO NOT agree with it
I have also had students who are new to the country, for example, worked their butts off and got a 70. I absoultely reward a child for that, considering the circumstances.

Posted 2/9/10 7:41 PM
 

twicethefun
Loving life

Member since 7/06

4088 total posts

Name:

Re: celebrating mediocrity?

Posted by LeShellem

I will chime in here because this has been on my mind for years now. I am so sick of kids playing sports and there are no winners and no losers. You better believe the kids know who really outplayed the other. We need to teach that there are winners and there are losers and just because you tried your best and you did not succeed doesn't mean we celebrate because you tried you best. You tried you best but you still loss. All you are getting from me is kudos for trying your best. And no trying you best isn't all that matters, its a start, but there are things like skill, determination and just plain heart. Kids today are woefully unprepared for the real world and I for one will not add to this problem.
"yes son you tried your best, but you did not win. Try again and try harder and lets see how you do next time."



What sports have no winners and no losers? in kindergarten or first grade? The sports today are extremely competive. Kids practice all week long and can get cut from team as early as 8 yrs old. Sports are way more competive than when we were little.

I was really disturbed by your post.I mean give these kids a break. They work at it until they drop and then we should not clebrate their amazing effort and determination becausee they lost?!

I expect a lot from my kids. They do not get toys except on special occasions, or when they earn and save enough money to buy them themselves. I try to teach them to be internally motivated. They do not expect a lollipop for sitting in the restaurant like a human or walking through the store. But when it counts, I applaud their extraordinary effort to complete homework, complete a mathathon for St Jude or succeed in sports even if they lose. I teach them that winning is not everything. Your philosophy can easily misguide children into believing that winning is everything.

And in the real world people do get paid even when they just do their best, even when they don't win as a lawyer or save a life as a doctor. I think I am preparing my children for the real world teaching them to be proud, hardworking people who accept failures, but continue to strive to be the best. My kids are winners because they try, they care and they work at it. I celebrate them because they are my kids. And I do not have low standards.

Posted 2/9/10 8:32 PM
 

Shelly
She's 7!!!

Member since 8/05

14624 total posts

Name:

Re: celebrating mediocrity?

Its funny you should post this today. My DD is 3. She is potty trained, but recently started having accidents again. So I started again with the reward chart- she gets a sticker for every day she doesn't have an accident. She gets so excited.

But I worry if I am setting her up to expect praise for every accomplishment she has. We all know that in the real world- it doesn't always happen like that.

But with a young child, I am more concerned about developing her self esteem. So I will continue to praise her for good behavior, for being a good friend, a good sharer, knowing her numbers, etc... But I also teach her that being proud of herself is more important than anyone else being proud of her.

Posted 2/9/10 9:49 PM
 
Pages: 1 [2]
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
To all the mommys celebrating their DC's first Christmas... beautyq115 12/24/09 26 Parenting
XPost: THURSDAY APRIL 10TH IS ASPCA DAY PLEASE TAKE PART IN CELEBRATING!!!! HoneyBadger 4/8/08 1 Families Helping Families ™
THURSDAY APRIL 10TH IS ASPCA DAY PLEASE TAKE PART IN CELEBRATING!!!! HoneyBadger 4/7/08 14 Pets
For all the new mommies celebrating their 1st holiday as a family ..... babybugsmum 11/16/07 8 Parenting
anyone else celebrating national children's book week this week? wowcoulditbe 11/12/07 0 Teachers
It's somebody's b-day and I'm celebrating with picture overload! Dragonfly75 11/6/07 37 Parenting