Can you make a child be a good eater?

Posted By Message

Diana1215
Living on a prayer!!!

Member since 10/05

29450 total posts

Name:
Diana

Can you make a child be a good eater?

I thought Jack was going to be the best eater ever. He ate (and loved) all baby foods, ate different textures, etc.

Then one day it all stopped. Feeding him has been borderline torture since he was about 15 months old.

I was wondering, how can I prevent this from happening with Tyler? I don't think I could take another bad eater. I am also looking forward to the day when Jack truly understand what I mean when I say "You have to eat X amount of your dinner to get dessert" because I don't think he fully gets it just yet.

I would basically do anything to make sure that this doesn't happen with Tyler.

Posted 3/15/10 11:43 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Janice
Sweet Jessie Quinn

Member since 5/05

27567 total posts

Name:
Janice

Re: Can you make a child be a good eater?

I am not sure, but the opposite happened with josh.

this kid ate nothing till 18 mos. no cereal, baby food, hated puffs...

so i was so use to him never eating that if i put something on his tray, if he did not touch it, then i it was another oh well meal.

because of that, i did not offer substitutions since he never ate anyway.

now he will eat almost everything.

my mother had horrible eaters. when she is visiting, if josh doesn't finish his yogurt, she will offer him a million things...i say no, it just means he will eat more at lunch. she thinks it is unfair he is hungry.

Posted 3/15/10 11:50 PM
 

avamamma
My Girl

Member since 7/06

3395 total posts

Name:
Tara

Re: Can you make a child be a good eater?

I feel your pain. My DD hasn't eaten voluntarily since she was about 2- she is 5 1/2 now.

Up until then, she ate everything. I had her evaluated at 3 1/2, and she has a Sensory Issue. Texture, smell and temperature are the issues. She also used to gag a lot- not soo much any more.

She got OT and Speech to help, but it didn't really do much. She still hardly east anything except for pasta with butter and salt.

She no longer gets services, because her eating/lack of "doesn't interfere with her ability to learn in school". She gets terrible headaches from lack of eating.

I have read books, been to Nutritionists, Child Psychologists and most recently and Endocronologist.

Having a child who doesn't eat has really taken a toll on myself, my marraige and our family. It is extremely stressful. Other people who aren't dealing with it cannot possibly understand.

Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon


eta: when I first started Brody on solids and he didn't seem to like it, I remember busting into tears and calling my friend telling her that I cannot possibly do this again... So far, he is fine, but I don't think that I will feel "safe" until he is about 3.

Message edited 2010-03-15 23:57:11.210000.

Posted 3/15/10 11:53 PM
 

my3bugs
Mom of 2 Boys

Member since 5/05

4381 total posts

Name:

Re: Can you make a child be a good eater?

I am not sure you totally can but I think you can work with it to make it not as bad - if that makes sense. My older son was a great eater esp young - his first year of table food - he'd eat most anything you handed to him. He is 5 now and still a relatively good eater. He does eat a wide range of foods and will try many things but doesn't eat it all and there are things he flats our refuses to try. He did for a bit try to stop eating things I knew he loved and at first I started to give in and then I asked why - I kind of forced by incentive and he eventually went back to some of those old foods he loved. Having a child like that, I always thought bad eaters for the most part were allowed to be bad eaters - given in to or something, picked up bad habits amd wasn't forced to change them (outside of kids who had real texture issues and stuff).

Then son #2 came along. I don't feel we did anything differently. He sees his brother eating things - he refuses to try it. He started off definitely as a texture eater - only eating crunchy foods - ie crackers - outside of fruits and veggies. It drove me nuts - why won't he try things. We tried forcing, making big deal - everything - nothing seemed to work. We sit and eat all meals together as a family as much as possible. He is 2.5 now and while he isn't the pickiest of eaters compared to some kids I see but I feel like I am limited with him. For now - I just keep trying and don't give up and keep offering and hope he sees his brother and parents eating and enjoying new foods and he will too. I'd say in the last 6 months or so he has broadened his scope of what he'll eat so hoepfully one day he'll get there.

But to answer your question - I am not sure there is a way to get a great eater.

Posted 3/16/10 7:13 AM
 

Salason
♥

Member since 6/05

9878 total posts

Name:

Re: Can you make a child be a good eater?

I don't know... Nate sounds the same as Jack and I always beat myself up for it because I feel like I exposed him to junk (like McD's) and then that's all he wanted. I have a friend who is anal about what his kid eats (eg he's never had juice or McD's) and that child is the best eater I've ever seen. Who knows if it's true or if it's chance but with #2 I will be stricter.

I know how frustrating it is Chat Icon

Posted 3/16/10 7:33 AM
 

hbugal
Lesigh

Member since 2/07

15928 total posts

Name:

Re: Can you make a child be a good eater?

I dont know if you can so much make your child be a good eater as you can make them NOT be a good eater...

I find that we all fall into the trap of only feeding them the few things that they will eat. We fall into their demands of chicken nuggets, french fries, & pizza...

We do this out of the desire to just have them eat something. We are very unwilling to allow them to go hungry...

I was guilty of this with all of my girls. At some point I got sick of kid fair and decided they could either eat the dinner that I prepared or go hungry. It took YEARS but, for the most part, they will eat the dinner that is placed before them. 2 of my girls are now far from picky...one of them still is and Im guessing always will be at this point.

Caden was always expected to eat what was placed before him. If he didnt eat it that was fine but he wasnt getting anything else. He has his picky days but for the most part is a pretty good eater.

Meal time becomes a battle of wills at a very young age. They know we want them to eat and they know that it is one of the few things that they control. The best advice that I can give is to not give in...(easier said than done)

Chat Icon

Posted 3/16/10 7:57 AM
 

nbc188
Best friends!

Member since 12/06

23090 total posts

Name:
C

Re: Can you make a child be a good eater?

You know I've been struggling with DD's eating FOREVER, literally since we began solids at 6 months. It has been a struggle the whole time. For about the last year, it's not as much of a struggle IF she's eating what she wants....but there is absolutely NO WAY I can get her to eat/try something new, she won't have it and flat-out refuses. And I'm not talking about sushi or something far-fetched....she literally eats a banana and applesauce every day, that's it for fruit. And the majority of her veggies are the Dr. Praegers veggie things or sweet potato fries, nothing "fresh". It still frustrates me to no end Chat Icon Chat Icon

I have often wondered if I started her on solids if she would have been a better eater from the beginning....I debate starting earlier with #2, we'll see...I'm SO hoping #2 loves fruits and veggies Chat Icon

Posted 3/16/10 8:14 AM
 

Bxgell2
Perfection

Member since 5/05

16438 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: Can you make a child be a good eater?

Alex is a phenomenal eater - though she has gotten more picky through the years.

What has worked for us is to follow some basic rules -

1 - she eats what we eat, or she goes to bed hungry - I'm not a short order chef. We make one meal and that's it, and if she doesn't want to eat it, I never force her to, but she knows she isn't getting anything else.

2 - I never require that she finish everything on her plate - I think it sets them up for bad eating habits down the road. I also never bribe her to eat her meal so she can get dessert - again, I think it sets up bad habits. I do give her treats, but never associated with other food (i.e. eat this, and you'll get a treat) - I try to intersperse treats throughout the week at random times of the day

3- she must try new things at least once. If we make something new and she turns her nose up at it, she is asked to take at least one bite, and then decide if she wants to eat it. If not, that's fine, as long as she at least tries it.

4 - we introduce a lot of strange, healthy, unusual foods from an early age. Alex has been eating veggies, tofu, salad, hummus, fish, etc., since she was one. If she refused, I just kept trying over and over again at other meals

5 - model good behavior. Alex wants to eat what I eat. If I'm eating ice cream, how can I tell her to eat healthy? I try to live by my own word and eat as healthy as I would like for her to eat.

Posted 3/16/10 8:27 AM
 

JenBenMen
party of five

Member since 9/06

11343 total posts

Name:
Jen

Re: Can you make a child be a good eater?

Chris is the same picky bad eater as Jack. On the other hand Carlo will eat and does eat anything!!!

I think it might be genetic and that Carlo just likes to eat. On the other hand I think I was so easy going with carlo that he just naturally enjoyed it better.

With Chris I had charts/books of what to give when and how much to give. I was nervous and looking back I probably didnt make it a pleasant experience.

With Carlo I still looked out for allergies etc but I had more fun/less worry and I have to think that added to his great appetite.

Posted 3/16/10 9:19 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
My good eater is not so good anymore...Is it just a stage? CookiePuss 11/7/07 10 Parenting
What are some good dad/child songs? JRD2008 6/6/09 11 Parenting
Gyms and good child care Bellez95 4/9/09 2 Families Helping Families ™
Who said video games AREN'T good for a child HeathKernandez 8/1/08 3 Parenting
Spinoff: If your DC was a good eater as an infant did they stay a good eater? nicknmb 2/9/10 7 Parenting
DD#2 not a good eater and rolling over a little trickier than with #1 clwp 12/27/09 3 Parenting