in these circumstances, alcoholic or no?
| Forum Opinion Poll | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
can ...
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: [1] 2 | |
|
can ... a person who drinks daily (a few glasses of wine or a couple beers EVERY day) but does not get drunk be an alcoholic? Message edited 2010-07-12 22:24:54.983000. |
|
Posted 7/12/10 10:21 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: can ... I just found this defintion: |
|
Posted 7/12/10 10:27 PM
|
|
|
Re: can ... I'm sure they CAN be an alcoholic. But I will say that my DH drinks a couple of glasses of wine pretty much every night and I do not consider him an alcoholic. |
|
Posted 7/12/10 10:28 PM
|
|
|
Re: can ... IMO when the alcohol starts to interfere with their daily life with family and/or work....that is when it is a problem. |
|
Posted 7/12/10 10:28 PM
|
|
|
Re: can ... I think if the person can't go a day without drinking, than that defines someone as an alcoholic. Its the dependency and the addictive behavior defines them as an alcoholic. |
|
Posted 7/12/10 10:34 PM
|
|
|
Re: can ... Posted by Sash I think if the person can't go a day without drinking, than that defines someone as an alcoholic. Its the dependency and the addictive behavior defines them as an alcoholic. There is such a thing as a functioning alcoholic, so just because someone can go to work and do daily routines doesn't necessarily rule alcoholism out. so even if the alcohol isnt interferring in activities of daily living or relationships or work, he/she can be an alcoholic? i tend to agree, dependency without interference |
|
Posted 7/12/10 10:37 PM
|
|
|
Re: can ... Absolutely. That was my grandfather. he couldn't go a day without those drinks at 5. He depended on them to relax him and to cope with stress even though he never got drunk. |
|
Posted 7/12/10 10:38 PM
|
|
|
Re: can ... Posted by prncsslehcar Absolutely. That was my grandfather. he couldn't go a day without those drinks at 5. He depended on them to relax him and to cope with stress even though he never got drunk. so you would say that he was, or was not an alcoholic?
|
|
Posted 7/12/10 10:40 PM
|
|
|
Re: can ... Posted by prncsslehcar Absolutely. That was my grandfather. he couldn't go a day without those drinks at 5. He depended on them to relax him and to cope with stress even though he never got drunk. Just to play devils advocate, if someone isnt getting drunk and it isn't negatively effecting their relationships or work, is it a problem? KWIM? And when I think "alcholic" I think of some sort of behavior or situation with a negative outcome.. |
|
Posted 7/12/10 10:41 PM
|
|
|
Re: can ... Posted by DiamondGirl Posted by prncsslehcar Absolutely. That was my grandfather. he couldn't go a day without those drinks at 5. He depended on them to relax him and to cope with stress even though he never got drunk. Just to play devils advocate, if someone isnt getting drunk and it isn't negatively effecting their relationships or work, is it a problem? KWIM? And when I think "alcholic" I think of some sort of behavior or situation with a negative outcome.. but what if they cannot function without those drinks? |
|
Posted 7/12/10 10:44 PM
|
|
|
Re: can ... Posted by mamakap Posted by DiamondGirl Posted by prncsslehcar Absolutely. That was my grandfather. he couldn't go a day without those drinks at 5. He depended on them to relax him and to cope with stress even though he never got drunk. Just to play devils advocate, if someone isnt getting drunk and it isn't negatively effecting their relationships or work, is it a problem? KWIM? And when I think "alcholic" I think of some sort of behavior or situation with a negative outcome.. but what if they cannot function without those drinks? Hmmm..good point. I think if they are nasty or moody or not doing what they need to do BEFORE the drinks--but are okay AFTER---yeah that is a problem. Self medicating--ya know? using liquor as an anti depressant (or something else) maybe? Message edited 2010-07-12 22:47:17.163000. |
|
Posted 7/12/10 10:46 PM
|
|
|
Re: can ... Posted by mamakap Posted by Sash I think if the person can't go a day without drinking, than that defines someone as an alcoholic. Its the dependency and the addictive behavior defines them as an alcoholic. There is such a thing as a functioning alcoholic, so just because someone can go to work and do daily routines doesn't necessarily rule alcoholism out. so even if the alcohol isnt interferring in activities of daily living or relationships or work, he/she can be an alcoholic? i tend to agree, dependency without interference Yes, functioning alcoholics. Unfortunatey, My cousin is one. For the most part he holds a job, has his own apartment and can pay some bills.I say sometimes, cause if he is in a jam, he has mommy to bail him out. But he can not live a day with a bottle of Old english. To me he is an alcoholic. My DH's uncle was the same way, Drank everyday since he was like 19. Sadly, he passed away a year ago. They think it had to do with him suffocating in his sleep cause he was drunk.
|
|
Posted 7/12/10 10:48 PM
|
|
|
Re: can ... I think it is both, the classic falling down drunk person who has destructive physical, mental, or behavioral issues caused by drinking AND someone who must have that drink(s) at the end of the day to "relax." |
|
Posted 7/12/10 10:48 PM
|
|
|
Re: can ... I also want to add, you don't have to be a alcoholic to be a bad drunk. |
|
Posted 7/12/10 10:50 PM
|
|
|
Re: can ... Posted by Sash I also want to add, you don't have to be a alcoholic to be a bad drunk. Someone, can rarely drink and be a horrible, mean drunk. However, a person can drink every day, be an alcoholic and always be in a good mood. agreed 100% |
|
Posted 7/12/10 10:53 PM
|
|
|
Re: can ... Posted by DiamondGirl Posted by prncsslehcar Absolutely. That was my grandfather. he couldn't go a day without those drinks at 5. He depended on them to relax him and to cope with stress even though he never got drunk. Just to play devils advocate, if someone isnt getting drunk and it isn't negatively effecting their relationships or work, is it a problem? KWIM? And when I think "alcholic" I think of some sort of behavior or situation with a negative outcome.. The difference is I don't think my grandfather could have functioned normally without those drinks or more like he thought he couldn't. So I think it's dependency. I know plenty of people who have a glass of wine or two everyday and there's no way I'd consider them alcoholics, but there are people like my grandfather who need it to self-medicate and that's an alcoholic to me. |
|
Posted 7/12/10 10:54 PM
|
|
|
Re: can ... Posted by prncsslehcar Posted by DiamondGirl Posted by prncsslehcar Absolutely. That was my grandfather. he couldn't go a day without those drinks at 5. He depended on them to relax him and to cope with stress even though he never got drunk. Just to play devils advocate, if someone isnt getting drunk and it isn't negatively effecting their relationships or work, is it a problem? KWIM? And when I think "alcholic" I think of some sort of behavior or situation with a negative outcome.. The difference is I don't think my grandfather could have functioned normally without those drinks or more like he thought he couldn't. So I think it's dependency. I know plenty of people who have a glass of wine or two everyday and there's no way I'd consider them alcoholics, but there are people like my grandfather who need it to self-medicate and that's an alcoholic to me. ITA many alcholics are self medicating. Instead of prescription pills some people use booze. |
|
Posted 7/12/10 10:57 PM
|
|
|
Re: can ... Posted by prncsslehcar Posted by DiamondGirl Posted by prncsslehcar Absolutely. That was my grandfather. he couldn't go a day without those drinks at 5. He depended on them to relax him and to cope with stress even though he never got drunk. Just to play devils advocate, if someone isnt getting drunk and it isn't negatively effecting their relationships or work, is it a problem? KWIM? And when I think "alcholic" I think of some sort of behavior or situation with a negative outcome.. The difference is I don't think my grandfather could have functioned normally without those drinks or more like he thought he couldn't. So I think it's dependency. I know plenty of people who have a glass of wine or two everyday and there's no way I'd consider them alcoholics, but there are people like my grandfather who need it to self-medicate and that's an alcoholic to me. i agree, i guess it really depends on the person and the circumstance.
|
|
Posted 7/12/10 10:58 PM
|
|
|
Re: can ...
|
|
Posted 7/12/10 11:04 PM
|
|
|
Re: can ... Posted by mamakap but what if they cannot function without those drinks? If they can't function without the drinks -- then that is a way that it is affecting their daily life. Then I would say that is someone who is definitely showing signs of being an alcoholic -- maybe they aren't fall down drunk kind...but it's something to show concern over. |
|
Posted 7/12/10 11:36 PM
|
|
|
Re: can ... Alcoholism is the dependence one can develop on alcohol. They need it to start/end the day, relax and can't function without it. So technically I guess you can drink every day and not be an alcoholic.....but they will be at risk for liver cirrhosis, alcoholic pancreatitis and other health issues. |
|
Posted 7/13/10 12:01 AM
|
|
|
Re: can ... yes I think they can have a glass of wine every day & not be an alcoholic but it is a slippery slope. |
|
Posted 7/13/10 6:22 AM
|
|
|
Re: can ... Posted by MrsPJB2007 Posted by mamakap but what if they cannot function without those drinks? If they can't function without the drinks -- then that is a way that it is affecting their daily life. Then I would say that is someone who is definitely showing signs of being an alcoholic -- maybe they aren't fall down drunk kind...but it's something to show concern over. I agree. I like to have a glass of wine or two every night, but I don't need it - some nights I choose ice cream instead But seriously, I can go several days if I want to, there is no pull to drink alcohol every night, so I don't believe it's a problem. If I had to have wine every night or feel like I was going to bug out, that's a problem.
|
|
Posted 7/13/10 8:20 AM
|
|
|
Re: can ... Posted by mamakap Posted by Sash I think if the person can't go a day without drinking, than that defines someone as an alcoholic. Its the dependency and the addictive behavior defines them as an alcoholic. There is such a thing as a functioning alcoholic, so just because someone can go to work and do daily routines doesn't necessarily rule alcoholism out. so even if the alcohol isnt interferring in activities of daily living or relationships or work, he/she can be an alcoholic? i tend to agree, dependency without interference I would call that a functioning alcoholic. |
|
Posted 7/13/10 8:28 AM
|
|
|
Re: can ... Yes, I believe if you NEED to drink every day - you are dependent on it - then you are an alcoholic. I know a functional alcohol. This person has a job, has a family, has a house, pays their bills on time. This person will only drink after they know everything is taken care of for the day (ie errands are done, dinner is made). Many people would never guess that this person has 6-12 beers a night as it is not "interfering" with their day. |
|
Posted 7/13/10 8:35 AM
|
|
| Pages: [1] 2 | |
















But seriously, I can go several days if I want to, there is no pull to drink alcohol every night, so I don't believe it's a problem. If I had to have wine every night or feel like I was going to bug out, that's a problem.

