Biggest Loser (SPOILERS!)

Posted By Message

glinda-goodwitch
:-)

Member since 7/06

9149 total posts

Name:
Beth

Biggest Loser (SPOILERS!)

So what do we think?

I think Daniel will be fine on his own, but I bet he won't be spending a lot of time with his friend (forget his name. The one on BL season 7). I think with their different lifestyles it will be hard for Daniel to see him eat the way he does, and that means they can't go out to eat together.

Shay...I think she finally had a breakthrough in weight loss and I don't think she should have gone home. I mean, Amanda barely loses 5 lbs a week. She says she wants to be there but come on...And it's not life or death for her to stay. It was for Shay. I just think it's sad she had to go so early and I really hope that she continues her weight loss at home.

Posted 11/11/09 8:38 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

TheLorax
LOVE

Member since 2/06

5581 total posts

Name:
Suzanne / SuzBride

Re: Biggest Loser (SPOILERS!)

I am not a huge Liz fan, but I was rooting for her since everyone else seemed to just assume that she would be the one below the red line. And she ended up being at the top!

I feel bad when anyone goes home at this point, but I think Daniel will do fine at home. I worry about Shay. She still has ALOT of weight to lose. Maybe she can come back next season like Daniel did?

I agree that they should have voted Amanda off. Shay is uber-annoying, but she needed it more. Amanda hasn't been pulling her weight either, although I would have felt a bit bad for Bob if Amanda went home cause he loves her SO much!Chat Icon

Posted 11/11/09 8:45 AM
 

kerrycec03
Mom of 2 beautiful boys!!

Member since 6/06

13519 total posts

Name:
Kerry

Re: Biggest Loser (SPOILERS!)

Ok, I'm happy with the two that went home. Daniel has been doing so poorly lately (1 good week out of the past 4 is NOT ok).

Shay, super annoying. I'm sorry but if she busted her butt all the other weeks like she did this week, THEN she wouldn't have gone home and would have lost well over 100lbs. If she can pull 17lbs in one week then there was no excuse all those other weeks. I'm so sick of woe is me. And she always said she didn't have any support. Well surprise, she has a sister, husband and tons of friends supporting her afterall. I'm sorry, yes she has a LOT to loose, but come on girl. You should have been outloosing the likes of Amanda, Abby, Tracy, Liz and all the other girls. Percentage she's lost the least!!!! (but I am concerned they didn't show an after shot of her)

Posted 11/11/09 8:54 AM
 

TheLorax
LOVE

Member since 2/06

5581 total posts

Name:
Suzanne / SuzBride

Re: Biggest Loser (SPOILERS!)

Posted by kerrycec03
(but I am concerned they didn't show an after shot of her)



I think she was on Jay Leno. I have it DVRed but still have to watch, so hopefully she has kept up the weight loss!

Posted 11/11/09 9:01 AM
 

IrishTracy
Believe!!

Member since 5/05

15167 total posts

Name:
Tracy

Re: Biggest Loser (SPOILERS!)

I thought for sure Amanda would be sent home. which would of been fine with me. I can't stand her. Shay was annoying as hell! It is a kick in the butt that she FINALLY lost a decent amount & it was not enough. It does prove that sleep is important. (they thought they were so great working out while the others sleptChat Icon )
Daniel will do great. I think his friend is just sad. It looked like Daniel was disgusted by him. Not sure that friendship will last.

Like Kerry said it is a bit odd that they didn't show Shays after video.

I think Jillian is going to be ticked that they sent Shay home.

Posted 11/11/09 9:03 AM
 

skinny
3 boys and a princess!

Member since 11/08

8178 total posts

Name:
Momma

Re: Biggest Loser (SPOILERS!)

Did u see that when they started the tennis ball challenge, everyone else but Shay was jogging, running, TRYING?
She was barely walking by the 3rd ball.
I think she really didn't push herself until it was too late.

Posted 11/11/09 10:15 AM
 

lbelle821
Arghhhhh

Member since 2/06

5285 total posts

Name:
Lisa

Re: Biggest Loser (SPOILERS!)

I need to play devils advocate here for a second but want to preface what I'm going to say with the fact that I agree that Shay has been very annoying the last few weeks and when I saw that she does have a family and a husband I somehow felt a little duped by her woe is me story and not having support...

BUT....

we have to remember that they've only been there for 8 or 9 weeks. Shay was close to 500 pounds. I'm not sure any of us can even begin to comprehend the mental torture this girl must have endured for her to get to be that heavy. It is a cycle that I have to imagine requires a divine amount of strength and conviction to break. We can't expect that she will have fought off all of her demons in 8 or 9 weeks. Not even a ranch can do that much work.

As far as her not trying, I don't think it should be overlooked that she is still a little less than 400 lbs. Do you know how hard it must be for her to jog or run or do any of the things that they have her do at the gym? She is carrying around 3 times as much weight than we should and her endurance and stamina is just naturally much lower. The other girls are at least 100-150 lbs lighter.

In the end I think Amanda should have been the one to go because I would have liked to see what more Shay was going to do ... even if it was just a week more. I'm not sure I could have standed her attitude for much longer than that. I was mad that they didn't show her transformation moment but I heard she looked great on Jay Leno.

Not sure who I'm rooting for at this point.

Posted 11/11/09 10:28 AM
 

glinda-goodwitch
:-)

Member since 7/06

9149 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: Biggest Loser (SPOILERS!)

Posted by lbelle821

I need to play devils advocate here for a second but want to preface what I'm going to say with the fact that I agree that Shay has been very annoying the last few weeks and when I saw that she does have a family and a husband I somehow felt a little duped by her woe is me story and not having support...

BUT....

we have to remember that they've only been there for 8 or 9 weeks. Shay was close to 500 pounds. I'm not sure any of us can even begin to comprehend the mental torture this girl must have endured for her to get to be that heavy. It is a cycle that I have to imagine requires a divine amount of strength and conviction to break. We can't expect that she will have fought off all of her demons in 8 or 9 weeks. Not even a ranch can do that much work.

As far as her not trying, I don't think it should be overlooked that she is still a little less than 400 lbs. Do you know how hard it must be for her to jog or run or do any of the things that they have her do at the gym? She is carrying around 3 times as much weight than we should and her endurance and stamina is just naturally much lower. The other girls are at least 100-150 lbs lighter.

In the end I think Amanda should have been the one to go because I would have liked to see what more Shay was going to do ... even if it was just a week more. I'm not sure I could have standed her attitude for much longer than that. I was mad that they didn't show her transformation moment but I heard she looked great on Jay Leno.

Not sure who I'm rooting for at this point.



I agree. I mean honestly, how much can you run at almost 400 lbs. Plus, men are stronger than women, so the men at 400 lbs can lug their weight around easier than a woman could. I just don't see how they could send someone who was 370+ lbs home when Amanda clearly could have lost the rest of the weight on her own. And even if she didn't--she isn't morbidly obese. I think it was completely irresponsible for them to send her home. ESPECIALLY when it seemed like she was finally getting the big numbers she needed.

Posted 11/11/09 10:36 AM
 

AliceCullen
LIF Adult

Member since 6/08

1497 total posts

Name:

Re: Biggest Loser (SPOILERS!)

I agree with most of you. I didn't like Shay, but she would have benefitted a lot more from staying on the ranch. Amanda only had about 50 lbs to go and she could have done that on her own. I saw Shay on Leno and she looked great. She still has a long way to go, but she has definitely been keeping up with the weight loss since she returned home.

Posted 11/11/09 10:42 AM
 

kerrycec03
Mom of 2 beautiful boys!!

Member since 6/06

13519 total posts

Name:
Kerry

Re: Biggest Loser (SPOILERS!)

yea, I understand that her being 370+lbs is hard. I know its tough (I'm not that big but I am very plus sized).

See, my rational is this. In 1 week of weight watchers I can loose 10lbs (without working out or anything). Someone half my size may only loose 5lbs. For Shay to be loosing the same numbers (not percentages) as the other girls isn't right. Previous weeks she would loose only 7lbs (same as the other girls who are in fact over 150lbs lighter). I personally didn't really see her work for it until last night. Before I only saw her as "going through the motions". I think she felt that since she "needed" to be there, she was almost invisiable from elimination so I don't think she tried as hard. Sorry, she should have been busting from day one. How could women who couldn't work out (Tracy, Abby) ended up loosing more in 1 week than Shay did.

Posted 11/11/09 10:45 AM
 

curliegirl
He's here!!!!

Member since 3/06

10128 total posts

Name:
Gina

Re: Biggest Loser (SPOILERS!)

I honestly think it is unfair to say that Shay should have rightfully stayed....no one deserves it any more than anyone else....and remember, this is also a game! They smartly picked off Shay because it's getting down to the wire and they needed to get rid of a threat also.

And Shay SHOULD have been losing double digits EVERY week without much effort, based on what I have seen this show do for other people over the seasons.

Posted 11/12/09 5:06 PM
 

mrswask
Pookie Love

Member since 5/05

20229 total posts

Name:
Michal

Re: Biggest Loser (SPOILERS!)

Posted by kerrycec03

Ok, I'm happy with the two that went home. Daniel has been doing so poorly lately (1 good week out of the past 4 is NOT ok).

Shay, super annoying. I'm sorry but if she busted her butt all the other weeks like she did this week, THEN she wouldn't have gone home and would have lost well over 100lbs. If she can pull 17lbs in one week then there was no excuse all those other weeks. I'm so sick of woe is me. And she always said she didn't have any support. Well surprise, she has a sister, husband and tons of friends supporting her afterall. I'm sorry, yes she has a LOT to loose, but come on girl. You should have been outloosing the likes of Amanda, Abby, Tracy, Liz and all the other girls. Percentage she's lost the least!!!! (but I am concerned they didn't show an after shot of her)




I agree with everything you wrote! Weight-wise, does Shay need to be more than Amanda does - of course she does! But, ultimately, it's a game with a very nice reward at the end and being that there's only 2-3 weeks left until they go to finalists - it's time to start getting rid of threats! Shay is obviously a HUGE threat because she still has so much more to lose! If I was there, I would have voted her off too!

Posted 11/12/09 7:58 PM
 

SummerMom
Now a mom of 2!

Member since 6/07

4970 total posts

Name:

Re: Biggest Loser (SPOILERS!)

Here's the link to Shay and Daniel on Jay Leno:

Video

Posted 11/12/09 11:05 PM
 

DeniseMarie
<3

Member since 8/07

10682 total posts

Name:

Re: Biggest Loser (SPOILERS!)

Posted by TheLorax

Posted by kerrycec03
(but I am concerned they didn't show an after shot of her)



I think she was on Jay Leno. I have it DVRed but still have to watch, so hopefully she has kept up the weight loss!



ya she was on Jay Leno. She lost a lot more and looks good.

Posted 11/13/09 9:06 AM
 

annoyedTTCer
LIF Adult

Member since 4/09

3272 total posts

Name:

Re: Biggest Loser (SPOILERS!)

Do they really send the contestants home or do they keep them at the ranch but off camera and away from the rest of the contestants?

If they sent them home wouldn't it leak out who was sent home when?

Posted 11/13/09 10:06 AM
 

chicky724
LIF Infant

Member since 8/09

80 total posts

Name:
Kristen

Re: Biggest Loser (SPOILERS!)

Posted by annoyedTTCer

Do they really send the contestants home or do they keep them at the ranch but off camera and away from the rest of the contestants?

If they sent them home wouldn't it leak out who was sent home when?




That would make sense.. but I’m pretty sure they send them home right away. Because when you see them coming home to their families they’re always the same weight they were when they left the ranch.

Posted 11/13/09 11:05 AM
 

kimbalina
Bring on the glitter and bows!

Member since 6/08

15158 total posts

Name:
Kim

Re: Biggest Loser (SPOILERS!)

Posted by annoyedTTCer

Do they really send the contestants home or do they keep them at the ranch but off camera and away from the rest of the contestants?

If they sent them home wouldn't it leak out who was sent home when?




I met Ali Vincent Tuesday at a book signing and she said that when you are up for elimination, you pack ur bags before you go to the voting part. You say Good bye and there is a van waiting for you to leave in right from the vote off! They have your bags, and ship anything else home.
If they can not get you a flight right away, you have a night in a hotel away from campus and return home the next day.

Posted 11/13/09 12:27 PM
 

Kierasmom
I love my kids

Member since 5/05

2885 total posts

Name:
Jenn

Re: Biggest Loser (SPOILERS!)

I love the show but my complaint has always been that I don't like that people get voted off. It should be based on who lost the least amount of weight (by percentage). I am all for the challenges and the immunity but I don't like the voting. Every person on that show needs to lose weight. So picking and choosing who stays just doesn't seem right. Plus it would motivate everyone even more. Look at the numbers people put up this week because of the automatic elimination. Granted that wouldn't happen every week but at the same time it would keep people motivated.

Posted 11/13/09 11:47 PM
 

glinda-goodwitch
:-)

Member since 7/06

9149 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: Biggest Loser (SPOILERS!)

Posted by Kierasmom

I love the show but my complaint has always been that I don't like that people get voted off. It should be based on who lost the least amount of weight (by percentage). I am all for the challenges and the immunity but I don't like the voting. Every person on that show needs to lose weight. So picking and choosing who stays just doesn't seem right. Plus it would motivate everyone even more. Look at the numbers people put up this week because of the automatic elimination. Granted that wouldn't happen every week but at the same time it would keep people motivated.



I see what you're saying. But then no one could have a bad day. There's no forgiveness if just the lowest percentage gets voted off. And we all have bad days.

Posted 11/14/09 8:38 AM
 

mrswask
Pookie Love

Member since 5/05

20229 total posts

Name:
Michal

Re: Biggest Loser (SPOILERS!)

Posted by Kierasmom

I love the show but my complaint has always been that I don't like that people get voted off. It should be based on who lost the least amount of weight (by percentage). I am all for the challenges and the immunity but I don't like the voting. Every person on that show needs to lose weight. So picking and choosing who stays just doesn't seem right. Plus it would motivate everyone even more. Look at the numbers people put up this week because of the automatic elimination. Granted that wouldn't happen every week but at the same time it would keep people motivated.




See - I think that instantly puts women at a disadvantage. It's harder for women to lose weight, esp the bigger numbers that men can typically put up on a weekly basis. Also, what about when it's the TOM for a woman? Water retention, bloating, etc? Not her fault, but biology and something that men do NOT have to deal with. I am all for the little twist they threw in this week with the red line - it was definitely motivating for all of the contestants. But I would definitely not be happy if it was just always lowest percentage of weight loss. Also, from the producers point of view, it's a show and they want ratings. If the show was conducted in that manner, there would be no need for game play, alliances, backstabbing and all the things that producers want to see to keep their ratings high.

Posted 11/14/09 11:54 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Okay so what did everyone think of Biggest Loser last night? SPOILERS!! glinda-goodwitch 10/21/09 12 Celebrities & Entertainment
Is there a Biggest Loser thread for this week? SPOILERS! glinda-goodwitch 10/14/09 12 Celebrities & Entertainment
No Biggest Loser Thread??? Spoilers! mrswask 3/31/09 13 Celebrities & Entertainment
anyone watch Biggest Loser last night??? ...Possible Spoilers.. MetsGirl07 9/24/08 0 Celebrities & Entertainment
Biggest Loser--probably Spoilers eventually! NewYawkah 4/8/08 2 Families Helping Families ™
Biggest Loser --SPOILERS-- lilacwine 3/26/08 21 Families Helping Families ™