Re: Biggest Loser (SPOILERS!)
Posted 11/11/2009 10:36:06 AM by glinda-goodwitch


Posted by lbelle821

I need to play devils advocate here for a second but want to preface what I'm going to say with the fact that I agree that Shay has been very annoying the last few weeks and when I saw that she does have a family and a husband I somehow felt a little duped by her woe is me story and not having support...

BUT....

we have to remember that they've only been there for 8 or 9 weeks. Shay was close to 500 pounds. I'm not sure any of us can even begin to comprehend the mental torture this girl must have endured for her to get to be that heavy. It is a cycle that I have to imagine requires a divine amount of strength and conviction to break. We can't expect that she will have fought off all of her demons in 8 or 9 weeks. Not even a ranch can do that much work.

As far as her not trying, I don't think it should be overlooked that she is still a little less than 400 lbs. Do you know how hard it must be for her to jog or run or do any of the things that they have her do at the gym? She is carrying around 3 times as much weight than we should and her endurance and stamina is just naturally much lower. The other girls are at least 100-150 lbs lighter.

In the end I think Amanda should have been the one to go because I would have liked to see what more Shay was going to do ... even if it was just a week more. I'm not sure I could have standed her attitude for much longer than that. I was mad that they didn't show her transformation moment but I heard she looked great on Jay Leno.

Not sure who I'm rooting for at this point.



I agree. I mean honestly, how much can you run at almost 400 lbs. Plus, men are stronger than women, so the men at 400 lbs can lug their weight around easier than a woman could. I just don't see how they could send someone who was 370+ lbs home when Amanda clearly could have lost the rest of the weight on her own. And even if she didn't--she isn't morbidly obese. I think it was completely irresponsible for them to send her home. ESPECIALLY when it seemed like she was finally getting the big numbers she needed.
Print Post      Close Window