BFing past one year

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

OrganicMama
So in love with my little man!

Member since 6/08

5172 total posts

Name:
Mama

BFing past one year

When your DC turned 1, how many times were you nursing a day? Did your DC start wanting to nurse less because they are eating more?

Also, did anyone NOT introduce regular milk? DS has a dairy allergy, but even if he grows out of it I will not be introducing milk (ever). Almond and soy are out of the question too because of allergies. Would I just keep BFing or giving him pumped milk instead?

Posted 1/25/11 2:20 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

kerrycec03
Mom of 2 beautiful boys!!

Member since 6/06

13519 total posts

Name:
Kerry

Re: BFing past one year

I'm just curious why you will never introduce milk?

Posted 1/25/11 2:23 PM
 

wingsofsong
My 3 little loves <3<3<3

Member since 1/09

7395 total posts

Name:
Maureen

Re: BFing past one year

Kieran just turned 1 on Friday and we're still BFing! Since about 5 months or so, he had been nursing 4 times a day. About a month ago, we dropped one feeding (he was eating more foods, and he was very disinterested in that feeding). I am following his lead, and taking the "don't offer, don't refuse" approach with him. I always nurse him right when he wakes up, and then I wait for him to ask for it (by pulling my shirt down! Chat Icon). The past 2 days, he hasn't asked to nurse until bedtime. So I don't know if it will continue this way now with only 2 feedings a day, but it seems to be going that way.
Not sure about not introducing milk. We just gave him milk for the first time last night to see if he has outgrown the allergy. What is your reason for never wanting to introduce it? If you don't plan to, I would just ask your ped for a worthy substitute!

ETA: What about rice milk or hemp milk?

Message edited 2011-01-25 14:28:03.760000.

Posted 1/25/11 2:26 PM
 

wingsofsong
My 3 little loves <3<3<3

Member since 1/09

7395 total posts

Name:
Maureen

Re: BFing past one year

double post

Message edited 2011-01-25 14:27:33.270000.

Posted 1/25/11 2:27 PM
 

mommyIam

Member since 7/09

9209 total posts

Name:
Shana

Re: BFing past one year

I highly recommend trying goat milk. My nephew still has allergies like crazy and is doing great on goat milk. He hardly eats a thing. BF only till 6m and his crazy mom put his straight on goat milk.

I used to joke to DH, I think her kid must be a goat on the inside.

Look into it, its even better than cow milk in some regards.

Posted 1/25/11 3:01 PM
 

OrganicMama
So in love with my little man!

Member since 6/08

5172 total posts

Name:
Mama

Re: BFing past one year

Posted by kerrycec03

I'm just curious why you will never introduce milk?



No one in my family ever drank cow's milk growing up. I had to drink goat's milk because I was allergic to cow's milk and my mom's BM (she ate dairy products). Besides the fact that even touching it skeeves me out Chat Icon , I believe that cow's milk is meant for cows, not people. I was never a big dairy eater, and I don't plan on going back to dairy ever again. I kind of consider myself a vegan that eats meat.

Posted 1/25/11 3:01 PM
 

OrganicMama
So in love with my little man!

Member since 6/08

5172 total posts

Name:
Mama

Re: BFing past one year

Posted by mommyIam

I highly recommend trying goat milk. My nephew still has allergies like crazy and is doing great on goat milk. He hardly eats a thing. BF only till 6m and his crazy mom put his straight on goat milk.

I used to joke to DH, I think her kid must be a goat on the inside.

Look into it, its even better than cow milk in some regards.




Same thing with goats milk, I think it's only meant for goats Chat Icon But it is the closet thing to human milk, so it's not a bad substitute.

Posted 1/25/11 3:03 PM
 

Dulcinea
Weekend Warrior

Member since 3/08

2530 total posts

Name:
Dulcinea

Re: BFing past one year

Posted by OrganicMama

When your DC turned 1, how many times were you nursing a day? Did your DC start wanting to nurse less because they are eating more?

Also, did anyone NOT introduce regular milk? DS has a dairy allergy, but even if he grows out of it I will not be introducing milk (ever). Almond and soy are out of the question too because of allergies. Would I just keep BFing or giving him pumped milk instead?



After 1, DS nurses 1x a day after I get back from work, and periodically throughout the night because we cosleep.

He's definitely nursing less because the solid food and juice really fills him up.

If you have the time, definitely keep on BFing him. Why bother with bottles?

And I'm also curious why you're not ever going to introduce milk.



Posted 1/25/11 3:04 PM
 

beachgirl
LIF Adult

Member since 7/05

7967 total posts

Name:
sara

Re: BFing past one year

Neither of my kids liked milk except for BM. I tried cows milk, rice, soy etc and it was a no go UNTIL DD turned 3 and discovered chocolate milk and she now drinks that on occasion. Its even a struggle for her to take milk in her cereal. She is now 5. DS is 18 months and no milk except for BM for him either. They seem to hate the taste. He is still BF once or twice in the evening, once during the night ( if he is not teething - if he is teething then its an all night feeding frenzy!) and then once in the morning when he wakes up.

Posted 1/25/11 3:07 PM
 

OrganicMama
So in love with my little man!

Member since 6/08

5172 total posts

Name:
Mama

Re: BFing past one year

Posted by Dulcinea

Posted by OrganicMama

When your DC turned 1, how many times were you nursing a day? Did your DC start wanting to nurse less because they are eating more?

Also, did anyone NOT introduce regular milk? DS has a dairy allergy, but even if he grows out of it I will not be introducing milk (ever). Almond and soy are out of the question too because of allergies. Would I just keep BFing or giving him pumped milk instead?



After 1, DS nurses 1x a day after I get back from work, and periodically throughout the night because we cosleep.

He's definitely nursing less because the solid food and juice really fills him up.

If you have the time, definitely keep on BFing him. Why bother with bottles?

And I'm also curious why you're not ever going to introduce milk.






Please no flames anyone. This is only MY OPINION.

Humans are the only animal on the planet to drink another species milk, and also to drink milk after we're weaned. It just seems unnatural to me. It's not a food that our body needs, and our bodies don't know how to process it properly. Cow's milk is also made for an animal that has 4 stomachs, instead of 1 like us.

A lot of health reasons too. Once a person is weaned it lacks the enzyme to break down milk. Your body doesn't absorb the calcium from milk properly.

Posted 1/25/11 3:19 PM
 

Denise
LIF Adolescent

Member since 12/09

572 total posts

Name:
Denise

Re: BFing past one year

Posted by OrganicMama

Posted by Dulcinea

Posted by OrganicMama

When your DC turned 1, how many times were you nursing a day? Did your DC start wanting to nurse less because they are eating more?

Also, did anyone NOT introduce regular milk? DS has a dairy allergy, but even if he grows out of it I will not be introducing milk (ever). Almond and soy are out of the question too because of allergies. Would I just keep BFing or giving him pumped milk instead?



After 1, DS nurses 1x a day after I get back from work, and periodically throughout the night because we cosleep.

He's definitely nursing less because the solid food and juice really fills him up.

If you have the time, definitely keep on BFing him. Why bother with bottles?

And I'm also curious why you're not ever going to introduce milk.






Please no flames anyone. This is only MY OPINION.

Humans are the only animal on the planet to drink another species milk, and also to drink milk after we're weaned. It just seems unnatural to me. It's not a food that our body needs, and our bodies don't know how to process it properly. Cow's milk is also made for an animal that has 4 stomachs, instead of 1 like us.

A lot of health reasons too. Once a person is weaned it lacks the enzyme to break down milk. Your body doesn't absorb the calcium from milk properly.


I used to work in the nutrition industry as a vitamin rep, and I have definitely heard this before. Since we lack the enzyme to break the milk down it can cause health problems. Most people I know who have eliminated dairy from their diet feel 100x better. When I was bfing I eliminated dairy bc DD exhibited a possible dairy allergy, and let me tell you..I felt great!!!! While I still enjoy an occassional slice of pizza, or milk in my coffee....I have found almond milk to be a great substitute for things like cereal, and coconut milk for ice cream (btw tastes soooo much better than reg ice cream)!!

Posted 1/25/11 3:29 PM
 

mommyIam

Member since 7/09

9209 total posts

Name:
Shana

Re: BFing past one year

Posted by OrganicMama
Please no flames anyone. This is only MY OPINION.

Humans are the only animal on the planet to drink another species milk, and also to drink milk after we're weaned. It just seems unnatural to me. It's not a food that our body needs, and our bodies don't know how to process it properly. Cow's milk is also made for an animal that has 4 stomachs, instead of 1 like us.

A lot of health reasons too. Once a person is weaned it lacks the enzyme to break down milk. Your body doesn't absorb the calcium from milk properly.



No flames at all! Totally understand your points. But just curious, no dairy at all either, right?
Are you giving meats? fishes? eggs? I think as long as you keep it varied and balanced I think you'll be fine giving your DS water to drink.

If anyone wants to flame, read this first:

http://milk.procon.org/view.answers.php?questionID=000817

To me its not proven science, its theory so I don't subscribe. And traditionally and culturally dairy is huge and important part of our diet.

Mediterranean diet is full of cheese, as well as leafy greens, and what's never mentioned is fish bones are great source of calcium. So eat up those sardines and anchovies whole! Tiny fish bones are soft when they are cooked, tons of omega, low on toxins, really healthy stuff!

Posted 1/25/11 3:34 PM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: BFing past one year

he nurses twice (am and pm) and the times I cannot manage to get him back to sleep during the night without it.

he loves it. it's definitely his preferred drink, though he is on cows milk and likes water too.

rock on with your bad self btw. they need things that cows milk HAS, but they can get it from other sources if you know what to feed them!

there are other countries where milk/dairy is not at all popluar. China comes to mind, but I am sure there are others.

Message edited 2011-01-25 15:36:24.720000.

Posted 1/25/11 3:35 PM
 

Rycois
Blessed with 2blue/2pink

Member since 12/05

13341 total posts

Name:
J

Re: BFing past one year

I didn't go much past a year (14 months with DS1 and nearly 15 months with DS2) but after the 12 month mark I packed up the pump and nursed probably a solid month-month and a half morning and night, and then just night. I also gave whatever pumped milk I had left.
I did introduce milk (regular for DS1 and soy for DS2) late in the 11th month so they would be ready for it after I stopped pumping.

Posted 1/25/11 3:35 PM
 

mommyIam

Member since 7/09

9209 total posts

Name:
Shana

Re: BFing past one year

Crissy, you got me thinking! I remember DH hates milk, eats only cheese. But not nearly enough for calcium. I'm always harassing him about what he eats, because he's a physician, and i think he eats like a caveman.

He told me something once about sardines having more calcium than milk. I hate sardines so I blew him off. So you sparked my curiosity, I went to check the nutritional info. WOW! Look bellow! I'm going to try sardines for dinner, they seem pretty amazing nutritionally speaking.

SARDINES
External Image


WHOLE MILK
External Image

Sardines lack nothing that Whole Milk has, nutritionally speaking. I wonder what other foods I can plug in that can give me such a close chart to milk. That's pretty amazing imo.

I used this site: http://nutritiondata.self.com/ sponsored by Self Magazine

Posted 1/25/11 3:57 PM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: BFing past one year

sardines, dark leafy greens are insane for calcium.

milk isn't necessary. it's just very easy.

how many kids do you know that eat sardines?!

Posted 1/25/11 4:04 PM
 

OrganicMama
So in love with my little man!

Member since 6/08

5172 total posts

Name:
Mama

Re: BFing past one year

Posted by mommyIam

Posted by OrganicMama
Please no flames anyone. This is only MY OPINION.

Humans are the only animal on the planet to drink another species milk, and also to drink milk after we're weaned. It just seems unnatural to me. It's not a food that our body needs, and our bodies don't know how to process it properly. Cow's milk is also made for an animal that has 4 stomachs, instead of 1 like us.

A lot of health reasons too. Once a person is weaned it lacks the enzyme to break down milk. Your body doesn't absorb the calcium from milk properly.



No flames at all! Totally understand your points. But just curious, no dairy at all either, right?
Are you giving meats? fishes? eggs? I think as long as you keep it varied and balanced I think you'll be fine giving your DS water to drink.





DS is allergic to dairy, soy, egg, almond and peanut at the moment. Hopefully he grows out of them by a year, and if he does I will reintroduce egg. I'm on an elimination diet right now because of the BFing (no dairy, egg, soy, tree nuts, peanuts, fish, shellfish) so I'm not sure when I'll be introducing any of those foods into his diet, I'll have to talk it over with his GI. But I plan on keeping both of us dairy & soy free after I quit BFing, even if he outgrows the allergies. If he goes to a birthday party and wants a piece of cake, of course I'll allow it, but it will have to be a special occasion. Same with the soy (unless it's in the form of miso or edamame - no soybean oil or soy protein).

Posted 1/25/11 4:48 PM
 

OrganicMama
So in love with my little man!

Member since 6/08

5172 total posts

Name:
Mama

Re: BFing past one year

Posted by Ophelia

sardines, dark leafy greens are insane for calcium.

milk isn't necessary. it's just very easy.

how many kids do you know that eat sardines?!



I don't plan on feeding him sardines, because I can't even imagine myself buying them, let alone have DS eat them Chat Icon

But he will be drinking carrot juice and/or fruit smoothies with kale for calcium.

Posted 1/25/11 4:53 PM
 

KangaMom
...

Member since 1/06

4593 total posts

Name:

Re: BFing past one year

I always nurse on cue so no clue how many times a day - night right now Chat Icon Our last DC nursed for well over 2 years.

I couldn't agree more with you about about cow's milk. I think it quite weird to drink and never drank as a child nor give to our kids. We do eat cheese though. Our older DC occasionally drinks soy milk.

Enjoy Nursing as long as you desire Chat Icon

Posted 1/25/11 4:54 PM
 

headoverheels
s'il vous plaît

Member since 6/07

42079 total posts

Name:
LB

Re: BFing past one year

Posted by OrganicMama

Posted by Dulcinea

Posted by OrganicMama

When your DC turned 1, how many times were you nursing a day? Did your DC start wanting to nurse less because they are eating more?

Also, did anyone NOT introduce regular milk? DS has a dairy allergy, but even if he grows out of it I will not be introducing milk (ever). Almond and soy are out of the question too because of allergies. Would I just keep BFing or giving him pumped milk instead?



After 1, DS nurses 1x a day after I get back from work, and periodically throughout the night because we cosleep.

He's definitely nursing less because the solid food and juice really fills him up.

If you have the time, definitely keep on BFing him. Why bother with bottles?

And I'm also curious why you're not ever going to introduce milk.






Please no flames anyone. This is only MY OPINION.

Humans are the only animal on the planet to drink another species milk, and also to drink milk after we're weaned. It just seems unnatural to me. It's not a food that our body needs, and our bodies don't know how to process it properly. Cow's milk is also made for an animal that has 4 stomachs, instead of 1 like us.

A lot of health reasons too. Once a person is weaned it lacks the enzyme to break down milk. Your body doesn't absorb the calcium from milk properly.



I really appreciate you posting this - I do still give my kids milk because they like it, but I have stopped drinking it myself (going on about 2 weeks now) and I really do feel SO much better and healthier.

Posted 1/25/11 5:02 PM
 

Dulcinea
Weekend Warrior

Member since 3/08

2530 total posts

Name:
Dulcinea

Re: BFing past one year

Posted by Ophelia

he nurses twice (am and pm) and the times I cannot manage to get him back to sleep during the night without it.

he loves it. it's definitely his preferred drink, though he is on cows milk and likes water too.

rock on with your bad self btw. they need things that cows milk HAS, but they can get it from other sources if you know what to feed them!

there are other countries where milk/dairy is not at all popluar. China comes to mind, but I am sure there are others.



Interesting where this thread is going...I didn't realize you can get so much calcium from sardines, almonds and sesame!

That's true about milk/diary not being popular in other countries. In Asia, we get calcium from such things as leafy greens and soy beans 'cus we're lactose intolerant so can't drink milk. And cheese and yogurt aren't common food items.

Posted 1/25/11 5:29 PM
 

MamaB17
Back for baby #3

Member since 5/09

4065 total posts

Name:
N

Re: BFing past one year

I couldn't agree with you more on this. My mom is always saying this too. DD has a milk protein allergy as well. Honestly, since I cut dairy out b/c I am BF, I feel great. I lost a ton of weight (baby weight & then some). I also don't get all congested anymore like I use to, and my eczema hasn't flared up either! I really don't miss it either, sometimes I miss cheese (really good stinky real cheese but that is it). Luna & Larry makes a Cherry coconut ice cream that I could eat by the truck load. Love it Chat Icon I add some dairy, soy, free chocolate chips, and it is pure heaven.
I don't know what I would switch dd to. Reg milk she can't have and like you I rather her not have. Soy we don't think she is allergic to, but I have as many issues with that as cows milk. Rice milk is too binding (constipation issues). Coconut milk I guess if I am going to give something. I plan to just keep BF until she weans.
I am thinking by a year she will only prob be nursing two or three times a day. Unless she is teething. Are you planning to just give water during the day & w/ meals? I was thinking of doing fruit smoothies w/ kale and such.

Posted 1/25/11 5:59 PM
 

thiadora
Happy Little Girl

Member since 5/05

3830 total posts

Name:
Thia (Cynthia)

Re: BFing past one year

I am (was) an extended BFer. It was always my intent to BF until my DS was 2 (we ended up going to 3). My mom BFed my sister and me until 2 because the literature she read from LLL and other sources at the time recommended that. To me it was normal to BF that long.

During the first year, I always offered BFing or EBM before solids were given. My DS was still BFing about 8x's a day when we reached 1. He generally decreased throughout the 2nd year, but still stayed to about 4x's a day by the time he reached his second b'day. I also continued pumping until I had enough of a stash so that he would have 1 cup of EBM at daycare until his second b'day. I am including the EBM he received in the count.

After 1, as long as the baby/toddler BFs or receives EBM 3-4 times a day, there is no need for cow's milk.

Here is an article from kellymom that I found useful at the time: link

Posted 1/25/11 6:10 PM
 

OrganicMama
So in love with my little man!

Member since 6/08

5172 total posts

Name:
Mama

Re: BFing past one year

Posted by MrsB0118

I couldn't agree with you more on this. My mom is always saying this too. DD has a milk protein allergy as well. Honestly, since I cut dairy out b/c I am BF, I feel great. I lost a ton of weight (baby weight & then some). I also don't get all congested anymore like I use to, and my eczema hasn't flared up either! I really don't miss it either, sometimes I miss cheese (really good stinky real cheese but that is it). Luna & Larry makes a Cherry coconut ice cream that I could eat by the truck load. Love it Chat Icon I add some dairy, soy, free chocolate chips, and it is pure heaven.
I don't know what I would switch dd to. Reg milk she can't have and like you I rather her not have. Soy we don't think she is allergic to, but I have as many issues with that as cows milk. Rice milk is too binding (constipation issues). Coconut milk I guess if I am going to give something. I plan to just keep BF until she weans.
I am thinking by a year she will only prob be nursing two or three times a day. Unless she is teething. Are you planning to just give water during the day & w/ meals? I was thinking of doing fruit smoothies w/ kale and such.



I will probably do 1 smoothie a day (with kale or spinach) and carrot juice once a day. Everything else will be water or BM. I'm still BFing 6-7x a day including 1 or 2 night feedings, and I'm doing baby-led weaning so DS really isn't eating much, only what he can physically feed himself. I can't see him dropping any nursing sessions until at least a year, so he will probably continue 4x a day or so after his bday.

ETA: I use coconut milk and water for the smoothie, so he will be getting that also.

Message edited 2011-01-25 19:19:27.453000.

Posted 1/25/11 7:17 PM
 

Bella311
Me and my Boys

Member since 1/10

1400 total posts

Name:

Re: BFing past one year

Well I EBF'd past one year but just up until 15 months DS self-weaned, wanted no part of BFing anymore (I think due in part to me being pregnant and the milk changing) anyway, he is allergic to dairy and I think soy (haven't gotten him tested yet)

He does NOT drink anything other than water. At first I was pretty disturbed by this, thinking he needs milk but as I investigated more, he really doesn't if you can include good sources of calcium & protein in their diet. I've been making lots of things with Kale, brocollii, beans (the ones you soak overnight not canned) and of course sardines are fantastic haven't tried them with DS yet, but I love them. It was a hard adjustment at first, in our culture, dairy is EVERYwhere, but once start getting creative in the kitchen you shouldn't be worried.

Posted 1/25/11 9:32 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Extended BF MOms.. talk to me about the benefits of bfing past 1 year Cookiegobbler 4/20/08 6 Parenting
BFing 8 months to 1 year...how often? NJmom 12/5/08 7 Parenting
11-Year-Old Girl Pitches Perfect Baseball Game DebG 5/24/05 4 Sports
Present for 1 year old? Bxgell2 5/20/05 2 Families Helping Families ™
Passport Info for the upcomming Year.. justme1 5/16/05 0 Travel & Vacations
1st Year Birthday Party Entertainment CampisiMom 5/13/05 4 Families Helping Families ™