| Posted By |
Message |
| Pages:
[1] 2 |
MrsG72907
Mommy of 2 girls!
 Member since 5/10 2046 total posts
Name:
|
BF vs. Formula
Hello Ladies. I am crashing from pregnancy. I am 24 weeks and I am having a giant internal debate between BF and FF.
I really want to breast feed but I have several concerns including will I be able to? can I deal with the physical demands? will I be able to sleep/rest? How will I pump when I go back to work as a teacher? and more...But when I think about going straight for formula I think...Am I denying my child essentail health benefits and a diet made for them? Will I miss out on that special bond between mother and baby? Will my feeding choices now effect her later in life?....Ugh....As you can see I am totally confused.
If you don't mind, would you share your choice and experience. Thank you so much!!
|
Posted 7/27/11 7:51 PM
|
| |
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
|
LadyBug1209
Mommy to FOUR little men!
Member since 8/08 9655 total posts
Name:
|
Re: BF vs. Formula
This is a very personal decision so I'm not sure if the poll results should really sway you one way or the other. If your gut instinct says to give it a shot.. then I would!! If it doesn't work out, it doesn't work out, but at least you will have peace of mind!!
DS latched like a champ immediately after birth and throughout my entire stay in the hospital. This was before my milk came in so he was on colustrum (sp?). I got home on a Sunday and my milk came in on Monday (5th day after DS was born). Once it came in, I guess my nipples changed bc DS refused to latch. No matter what I did, he just refused. I really did not want to give up, so I started pumping. I exclusively pumped for the first 7 weeks. At that point, I really wanted to give it another shot. He latched at 7 weeks and we've been going strong ever since!!! I couldn't believe it.. it's never too late to latch, I learned that first hand!! DS is just about 8 momths now. I just recently introduced him to 1 formula bottle a day. My supply has really taken a hit since he is now on 3 meals a day. I am going to keep going for as long as I can!!!
BF and pumping is really difficult at times, but you just have to power through it and remember why you are doing it. The bonding experience alone is 110% worth it and you are doing a wonderful thing for your baby!
CONGRATULATIONS & GOOD LUCK in making your decision!!
|
Posted 7/27/11 8:02 PM
|
| |
|
|
|
Re: BF vs. Formula
I EBF my DS. Not going to lie, the beginning was tough. It took time to get the hang of it and I totally understand why people get frustrated and give up. It can also be very isolating because when people come over (I don't feel comfortable BF'ing in front of men) you have to go in the other room by yourself. It's a lot on you since DH can't do much in that arena.
All of that being said, I am very happy with my decision to EBF. The time I spend nursing DS is so special to me. He looks at me, smiles and coo's when he knows he is about to eat. When he's done eating and tired, he lays his head on my chest. At night, I nurse him laying down and he (I'm sure unknowingly) rubs my stomach as he eats and we fall back asleep. It's things like that I think I may have missed out on if I didn't BF. He has consistently gained weight and I feel proud that I was able to provide him with that nourishment. I have gotten the hang of it and can discreetly nurse in public.
As far as pumping and going back to work, I think it is possible. You'd have to figure out what worked best for you and your schedule. You may have to pump during a prep and your lunch. They have hands-free pumps though, so you could pump while grading papers or working on the computer essentially!
You have to make the best decision for YOU. Don't let other people's opinions on BFing or formula guide your decision because it's personal. Good luck!
|
Posted 7/27/11 8:17 PM
|
| |
|
|
|
Re: BF vs. Formula
Posted by Maria31
DS latched like a champ immediately after birth and throughout my entire stay in the hospital. This was before my milk came in so he was on colustrum (sp?). I got home on a Sunday and my milk came in on Monday (5th day after DS was born). Once it came in, I guess my nipples changed bc DS refused to latch. No matter what I did, he just refused. I really did not want to give up, so I started pumping. I exclusively pumped for the first 7 weeks. At that point, I really wanted to give it another shot. He latched at 7 weeks and we've been going strong ever since!!! I couldn't believe it.. it's never too late to latch, I learned that first hand!! DS is just about 8 momths now. I just recently introduced him to 1 formula bottle a day. My supply has really taken a hit since he is now on 3 meals a day. I am going to keep going for as long as I can!!!
DS couldn't latch in the hospital and I had to use a nipple shield. While it was another step to have to wean him off using it, it enabled me to BF whereas I otherwise might have given up.
|
Posted 7/27/11 8:22 PM
|
| |
|
MrsG72907
Mommy of 2 girls!
 Member since 5/10 2046 total posts
Name:
|
Re: BF vs. Formula
Thank you ladies
|
Posted 7/27/11 8:57 PM
|
| |
|
blustar214
So in love with my little girl
 Member since 1/10 2471 total posts
Name:
|
Re: BF vs. Formula
Let me preface my response by saying that my DD is only 4 weeks old. But so far, I"m EBF.
The first week and half was so incredibly hard, I wanted to give up and move on to formula. DD had latching problems and I had to use a nipple shield for about a week. Eventually she just latched and that has made BF much better.
I do like feeding her, and I"m looking forward to when she recognizes me and smiles, but it's still really hard, and I have no idea how long I will continue to EBF. What keeps me going now is that DD is doing really well, gaining weight, plenty of wet/dirty diapers, so I know she's getting enough. I also pump, usually once a day, so I'm building a freezer supply and also have some in the fridge for a bottle every now and again. It also doesn't hurt that BF is free!
If you're on the fence, I would suggest trying BF, for at least a month, and see how you feel about the whole thing.
Good luck!!
|
Posted 7/27/11 9:01 PM
|
| |
|
MommaBear
Very much in love!
 Member since 6/10 2864 total posts
Name: Angela
|
Re: BF vs. Formula
I EBF and I am a teacher...feel free to fm me about pumping at work.
|
Posted 7/27/11 9:03 PM
|
| |
|
mommyIam
 Member since 7/09 9209 total posts
Name: Shana
|
Re: BF vs. Formula
I was so motivated to BF, I threw out coupons and samples for formulas and even would say "how dare they". I was one those crazy women chanting breast is best and giving snarky looks to FF moms. Shame on me.
First time BF, was so stressful for me, I couldn't get DS to latch the nurse at the hospital was telling me my nipples are too flat I shouldn't even bother. I got no help from them. I cried, I squeezed (hand pumped) whatever was in there to my baby. Until finally a lactation consultant visited me, was helpful, but I still was in pain and feeling uncomfortable, but as soon as she left I was so lost again. I was in so much pain, found it so difficult. I struggled for almost 2 months when I decided I have to give up. It wasn't getting easier when other said it would by now. I was in pain and miserable. And to make it worse DS was just not happy at my breast by that time. he's latch on and cry. And I couldn't figure out what was wrong, my let down was normal, my flow good, I was pumping okay.
But I gotta tell you I hated pumping, I hated it sooo much, I don't know how women do it. I felt like a factory cow.
The sleep thing is hard, but if I learned to BF well enough, I would not have mind. I would have loved to be able to feed my baby and not worry about bottles etc.
I wish my LC told me about nipple shields, I wish I found the right help. I wish I had a little more energy and a little more support. Everyone around me essentially said "you don't have to BF" ... and it didn't help, because I wanted soooo much to. I cried over quitting for months and months.
I hope you have a better experience, but whatever you choose, I hope its the best choice for you.
|
Posted 7/27/11 9:08 PM
|
| |
|
NervousNell
Just another chapter in life..
 Member since 11/09 54921 total posts
Name: ..being a mommy and being a wife!
|
Re: BF vs. Formula
Never was BFing an option for me. Never in my life did I ever think I would do it. It wasn't, "oh maybe I'll try it." It wasn't "oh maybe I will change my mind when she is born." It was 100% a no go. I had no desire to- in any way, shape or form. It was 4000% not for me- it wasn't up for debate.
Having said that, my DD thrived on formula. She is 1 year old now and I can say she has been sick twice. Once with a stomach bug and 1 ear infection. And she is in daycare full time. She walked at 9 months old and was meeting developmental milestones early too.
When I look at my healthy, perfect DD, I have ZERO guilt about my decision!
If I ended up havign 4 more babies, I would formula feed every single one of them without a second thought.
Message edited 2011-07-28 08:51:30.117000. |
Posted 7/27/11 9:12 PM
|
| |
|
phoenix913
LIF Adult
 Member since 5/05 3034 total posts
Name: V
|
Re: BF vs. Formula
As someone else said, it's a very personal decision and you'll just have to do whatever you think will work best for you and your family.
I went straight to formula feeding. I just knew that breastfeeding was not for me. I'm not too worried about all the health benefits etc., but I did want to say that I definitely feel a special bond with my DS and don't feel like I missed anything by not BFing.
But that's just me. Since you seem interested in BFing it might be worth it to try and if it doesn't work out then just switch.
|
Posted 7/27/11 9:14 PM
|
| |
|
|
|
Re: BF vs. Formula
Ultimately it's a very personsal decision with NO right or wrong answer. You need to do what's best for you and your baby. Don't listen to other people; it will drive you crazy how opinionated some people are. There is nothing wrong with either choice. My biggest mistake was listening to others.
I am currently BF and have been doing so for 3 months. I wont lie, it's one of the hardest things I had to do and one of the most rewarding experiences as well. In the beginning it's rough. You feel like you feed the baby all day long. I felt like I had no other life but that. It was really rough too because it hurt. I was also very stressed because at first my supply wasnt the best. Even now there are days I hardly pump anything and it gets stressful. Thankfully I make just enough to feed her.
However, It is also one of the most rewarding experiences of my life. I know she is gaining weight and getting stronger because of me. Its the best feeling ever plus the bond and closeness you feel is amazing and well worth the few problems I had. Luckily she latched on like a champ. I only had a few minor supply issues.
Pumping while being a working mom is really tough. Especially because I work in a field that's so unpredictable that it's hard to take breaks to do it. Somehow though I manage and continued to BF while working. I pump every 4 hours at this point when Im away from the baby so it ends up being twice at work. It's tough sometimes to fit it in but I take one day at a time. I made small goals for myself and originally wanted to BF for 3 months. Well now I'm past that point and want to continue to 6 months. Set small goals for yourself and just see what happens!
Good luck with whatever you decide!
|
Posted 7/27/11 9:16 PM
|
| |
|
MrsG72907
Mommy of 2 girls!
 Member since 5/10 2046 total posts
Name:
|
Re: BF vs. Formula
I really appreciate your responses and being able to hear both sides!! Thank you for sharing your stories and experiences.
|
Posted 7/27/11 9:27 PM
|
| |
|
springsandra
Baby girl has a baby brother!
 Member since 11/09 7155 total posts
Name: Sandra
|
Re: BF vs. Formula
Sometimes you can try to do one thing but g-d has other plans.
I wanted to BF. I tried my hardest. I EBF and nothing came out. DD was starving and losing weight. I used the supplemental nutrition system (SNS) to keep DD latching (she was amazing at latching) and keep her on the breast as many hours of the day as possible. I had a LC and spent hours being coached by a friend who is a La Leche League leader. I took supplements. I had her nursing every 2 hours and in between I would pump with a rented hospital grade pump. I did this 24 hours a day for the first two weeks. I slept about 6 hours the entire first two weeks of her life. I was crying, she was crying, and she was still starving, losing weight. My milk never came in. I kept it up with the nursing, supplementing and pumping for the first 3 weeks, then I went to bottle with whatever I could pump (about 1/2 an ounce a day) plus formula and did that for 3 more weeks. The OB talked about putting me on reglan which is a GI drug that has an off-label side effect of sometimes producing milk in women. The nurse at the OB's office heard me crying, miserable, hysterical, feeling like a complete failure -- I honestly felt like I didn't deserve to be a mother because I couldn't feed my daughter -- and she told me to just stop and enjoy my newborn. I never once thought about enjoying my baby. I thought it was my duty to feed her. No one ever told me there are times when some women physically cannot do it. I wish someone had told me it happens that some women just don't produce milk. Maybe I wouldn't have felt so miserable. Maybe I could've been prepared.
I still want to cry when I think about how sad I was. Beyond sad. Destroyed.
My father told me to look at my little miracle of a baby (I rarely get my period and have a history of cysts) and just give her formula and cut the sh*t. He said he was FF, I was FF, and formula has been around a hundred years and is perfectly healthy. But what I was putting myself through was NOT healthy for me or DD.
I wish I had been smarter at the beginning. I just didn't know BF could be impossible. Hard, yes. Tiring, sure. Difficult, of course. But I didn't know it could be impossible. I honestly wish I hadn't tried as hard as I did. But I guess if I hadn't, I never would've known and always would've wondered if I could. At least I know for certain the answer.
Formula is the best thing to have ever been invented IMHO. DD is doing AMAZING. Thank goodness!!!
|
Posted 7/27/11 9:41 PM
|
| |
|
NYchic
Girl & boy
 Member since 6/09 2357 total posts
Name:
|
Re: BF vs. Formula
Went straight to Formula and never once felt there was a bond missing between DD and me. I never regretted it - never thought twice about it. I knew breastfeeding was NOT for me. I got a ton of sleep - so did DD! She ate more at each feeding and was a very happy, full baby - slept a ton! All were happy here. Of course do what is best for you.
|
Posted 7/27/11 9:45 PM
|
| |
|
MrsDamonSalv7319
Somewhere in Westeros
 Member since 10/10 4495 total posts
Name:
|
Re: BF vs. Formula
I had all the same concerns as you...I had a c-section and DD latched and nursed in the recovery room. She had low blood sugar (I blame this on the 24 hours of labor I was in before my c-section, and they wouldn't let me eat or drink anything) so the NICU nurses wanted to give her formula b/c my milk wasnt in yet and they wanted to bring up her blood sugar. Well, she latched onto me just fine, but refused the bottle...as soon as my milk was in,her sugar level was fine.
BFing is so amazing IMO, knowing that you sustained this life for 9months, and are continuing to do so. At times (like 4am) it is hard to be the only one to feed her, but its so worth it to me.
Now, at 7 weeks, DD seems to have a milk protein allergy,so I have to cut all milk from my diet in order to continue to BF. I had to give her formula for 2days to allow the milk to clear our systems...it was heart breaking for me, but she didnt seem to mind the difference. She takes a bottle fine now,but I missed nursing her for the 2 days (plus I had to pump & dump which sucked). Im hoping Ill be able to stick to the diet and BF until at least 3 months...I know I will really miss it when I stop.
ALSO,a huge plus is not having to worry about bottles...sterilizing,preparing, heating...its a lot of extra work! Those 4am feedings are much easier when you only have to pick up the baby and pull down your shirt. Going out is easier too, b/c you dont have to worry about keeping the bottles cold or warm etc. You are always ready.
Its a personal decision, but IMO I would at least try to BF, and if it works for you, do it for as long as you want/can.
|
Posted 7/27/11 10:30 PM
|
| |
|
munchkinbugs
My little loves!
Member since 1/06 8093 total posts
Name: Lisa
|
Re: BF vs. Formula
I BD'd both DCs.
My advice to you, is if you want to do it, TRY it. Give it a few weeks. The first few are the toughest, not gonna lie. It's an adjustment. If it's not for you, at least you tried. If you get the hang of it quickly, worry about pumping when the time comes. If you can't do it, you stop. With BFing you just need to take one step at a time.
|
Posted 7/27/11 10:37 PM
|
| |
|
CrankyPants
I'm cranky
 Member since 7/06 18178 total posts
Name: Mama Cranky
|
Re: BF vs. Formula
I didn't BF my first 2, I knew I wasn't going to, I never felt the call of the breast, ever. My kids did great on formula.
However, DS has had tons of ear infections, we went through a really bad stretch with him.
For this reason, I am thinking of giving it a go with this next child. I've read that doing so may decrease the risk of ear infections and for that reason I may give it a try-just for the chance of avoiding painful ear infections in this next child. I'd give almost anything not to go through that stage again, even breast feeding when I really have no desire to.
We'll see if it works out.
|
Posted 7/27/11 10:45 PM
|
| |
|
Kelly9904
Mommy to 2 amazing little boys
Member since 5/05 9306 total posts
Name: Kelly
|
Re: BF vs. Formula
I can understand the debate you are going through but know its one only you can answer.
With DS #1, I tried, failed and he went to FF. He was FF from day 1 and I think I just never really gave BF a real try...I used to say DS was FF and I supplemented for the first month with BM. I think part of the reason I didnt try harder was because I didnt want to have to pump when I returned to work.
DS #2 I was determined to give it my all to BF and I did. It was an emotional rollercoaster. I never wanted to EBF so I did supplement with FF from day 1. The first month was HARD. I think having an older DC is what made it hard. I felt like it was hard to balance DS#1's needs with constant demand based bf. But I stuck it out and it got easier. However I decided on my own accord, to wean at 3 months. By 4 months DS will be 100% FF. He is now about 95% ( I have pumped milk still to go through) I am proud I got that far, but I like bottle feeding. I think its better for my personality. I like knowing how much my kids eat and I like having help with the feedings.
FF in no way was detrimental to DS#1. He is an amazing child, didnt have a cold until 9 months, hit all milestones with no issues and at 3.5yo is one of the smartest kids I know (and I dont just say that because he is my son ) He walked at 10 months, talked in 2-3 word sentences at 8 months old, and now at 3.5yo he has taught HIMSELF how to write most letters, the sounds of all letters, and is learning to read.
So I have no worries about FF my children. But you have to do what is best for you. This time it was very important to me to BF...I wanted to know I could do it and this is my last child so it wa snow or never.
GL
ETA: I just wanted to add one thing. Everyone talks about the bond of breastfeeding. I FF DS #1 and felt instantly bonded to him. I felt relaxed and would ENJOY every moment of holding him while feeding.
In the beginning with DS #2 (in the hospital) I was relaxed and felt bonded with DS - I mostly FF in the hospital as DS was too lazy to latch. When I got home he latched well, no issues there, but the demands of being home and the constant desire for him to nurse and his slow nature of eating, he woudl nurse for about 1 hour at at time (even now it takes awhile for him to finsih a bottle) I was stressed, didnt enjoy my new baby and felt disconnected to him. For me once I relaxed about BF and said, I will do it for 1 more week things got better...then when I got to that 1 week markers I said Okay I can do this for 2 more weeks etc....and things got better. But I feel that BF actually made it harder to bond and feel connected to my baby because I was so focused on the HOW to feed that I was missing the relaxing quiet moments with him.
Message edited 2011-07-27 22:55:55.847000. |
Posted 7/27/11 10:48 PM
|
| |
|
FlowerWife
Positive Vibrations...
 Member since 1/08 8423 total posts
Name:
|
Re: BF vs. Formula
i planned to BF and pump. but when my baby was born at 33w and was in the NICU for a month I could only pump and BF when i was there i never had enough breast milk so the NICU always supplemented her with formula. i had so many complications during her birth that i couldn't pump consistently right away .my supply was heavily effected and my milk never fully came in correctly. so now that shes home I BF but I also follow with a 3-4oz bottle. most of the time the bottle is formula because i dont have enough milk to pump for every feeding and BF. but i am doing the best i can.
my only advice is have a plan but also have an open mind. we never know how things will end up!
Message edited 2011-07-27 22:54:39.500000. |
Posted 7/27/11 10:53 PM
|
| |
|
imyself
 Member since 10/06 2938 total posts
Name: me
|
Re: BF vs. Formula
I knew I wanted to bf and was hoping I woudl be able to. I was a lucky and was able to nurse both my kids. My ds self weaned at 14 months and dd is still nursing at 22 months. My sister nursed all 3 of her kids and she is a teacher. She would just pump at work and keep the milk in the fridge.
|
Posted 7/27/11 11:33 PM
|
| |
|
Mags1227
Just a mommy ...
Member since 10/10 2665 total posts
Name: M
|
Re: BF vs. Formula
Posted by MrsG72907
Am I denying my child essential health benefits and a diet made for them? NO! formula comes as close as possible Will I miss out on that special bond between mother and baby? NO! DS and I have a very close bond Will my feeding choices now effect her later in life? Not sure. So far so good with us!
i tried BF against my personal preference because of the pressure everyone was putting on me. it did not work out. i never had a milk supply, it hurt so much i cried every time i had to do it, and DS was never satisfied. everyone told me to keep at it so i pumped but never got more than 1-2 oz per breast. that didn't even cover one feeding! i finally called it quits and gave DS formula. EVERYONE on DH's side blamed me for being a bad mother for not trying long enough for this and that. I cried for weeks about it!
ds thrives on formula (he's 11m) he hit his milestones early, has started walking at 10m, has no problem transitioning to sippy cups and table food. He's ahead of his cousins in just about anything. The cousins who were EBF because that's what is best for your child. The comments about me being a bad mother have stopped.
Do what you feel is the right thing not just for your baby but for YOU as well. If mommy is unhappy, baby will sense it and will be unhappy as well!
|
Posted 7/28/11 8:42 AM
|
| |
|
CaMacho
Sisters :)
 Member since 7/06 15112 total posts
Name: Jess
|
Re: BF vs. Formula
If you want to BF, try it. It might be easier than you ever thought it would be. We hear a lot of horror stories about a lot of things pregnancy/parenting related on here and in real life but you won't know how your experience might be if you don't try.
I wanted to BF, knew all the things that could go wrong, the pain I could feel, etc but it didn't stop me from trying. I ended up having ZERO issues, loving it more than I ever thought I would and BFed longer than I thought I would too.
|
Posted 7/28/11 8:56 AM
|
| |
|
PotofLuck06
Our Baby Boy Is Here!!!
 Member since 11/06 13241 total posts
Name: Betsy
|
Re: BF vs. Formula
I wanted to BF, but had some issues at the start: -My DD blood sugar was extremely low after birth and since she wasn't latching onto me well at the hospital, she lost weight and her blood sugar continued to drop, so they had to introduce formula to her on her 2nd night in the hospital. As soon as she got that nipple from the bottle, I was doomed!
-I met with a LC who introduced me to the idea of pumping at the hopsital to help stimulate my nipples since DD couldn't latch. It sorta worked, but not really. The nurses told me what I had was considered flat nipples and the reason my DD was having trouble latching
-Upon arriving home, I was upset she couldn't latch and was afraid of her sugar levels going low again, so she got a bottle of formula at every feeding after attempting BF
-My friend suggested nipple shields and we used those for a while, but they either fell off during a feed or DD wouldn't latch onto them to feed.
-So after about 2-3 weeks, I was crying everyday and finally had to make a decision about BF and FF. I decided to pump as much as I could as often as I could and feed that to DD and if a bottle was short, then she would get FF.
DD is now 3.5 months old and and I stopped pumping at 2 months when my BM supply had significantly decreased and she is now exclusively FF. She's healthy, she's happy and she's growing a mile a minute.
Am I disappointed? - Yes, but I tried my best and I can still say DD got BM, just not as much and for as long as I hoped for, but she's happy and I couldn't ask for anything more!
Message edited 2011-07-28 09:11:24.907000. |
Posted 7/28/11 9:09 AM
|
| |
|
maybeamommy
Blessed beyond belief
 Member since 10/07 17048 total posts
Name:
|
Re: BF vs. Formula
Posted by CaMacho
If you want to BF, try it. It might be easier than you ever thought it would be. We hear a lot of horror stories about a lot of things pregnancy/parenting related on here and in real life but you won't know how your experience might be if you don't try.
I wanted to BF, knew all the things that could go wrong, the pain I could feel, etc but it didn't stop me from trying. I ended up having ZERO issues, loving it more than I ever thought I would and BFed longer than I thought I would too.
Same exact situation for us, except I knew I wanted to TRY and I figured if it didn't work then oh well! But once Loey was born, I felt this strong desire to make it work and the first time he latched I just got this amazing feeling and I felt like it was so beautiful and natural. I wanted to continue with all of my might and it was hard for the first two weeks (thought of quitting many times) but after that it was a breeze and I EBF for about 12-13 months.
|
Posted 7/28/11 9:12 AM
|
| |
|
TessMike214
Gabriella Aubrey born 3/26!
 Member since 5/10 2440 total posts
Name: Tess
|
Re: BF vs. Formula
you sound like me. when I was pregnant, I was having an internal debate myself with bf vs. formula, as well as outside influences...I don't know when it happen, I believe it was during labor, I just knew that I was going to BF...my ds was a NICU baby for 7 days (he left healthy )...I pretty much had no choice but to supplement...I loved BF'ing my newborn baby, especially since the nurses and doctor were saying that the breast feeding was helping him get stronger everyday in the nicu...I felt that it was something only I was able to provide while the nurse staff took care of my baby...I only ended up BFing for 1 month, although I do wish that I could have done it for a few more months..I didn't educate myself on BFing when I was pregnant! I'm basically saying that you will decide for yourself when the time is right what you are going to do, and make sure that you read a book on breastfeeding and formula feeding
|
Posted 7/28/11 9:16 AM
|
| |
|
| Pages:
[1] 2 |