BC for free

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2] 3 4

NewlyMrs
Laugh-Live-Love LIFE!

Member since 10/06

14432 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: BC for free

Posted by violet25

I'm not sure I understand your point about breast pumps. If you try breastfeeding, you always have the option to switch to formula later on. Anything that makes it easier on moms who would like to try to breastfeed -- or to continue once they return to work -- or which gives an incentive to BF over FF is a benefit in my mind both because of the benefit to babies as well as decreased cost (formula is expensive). Plus, those who couldnt afford a pump may have trouble affording formula so the government might have ended up footing some of the bill. I EBF and I have formula samples sitting in the back of my closet and received tons of formula check coupons in the mail. It's always available.



I can't say for all stated,...but I had a conversation with my Ped & she educated me about how here in NC, if a woman decides to BF & get the bump, they cannot later decide it didn't workout & switch to formula. So many lower-eco women never even attempt BFpumping, because they don't want to lose the formula in the future.

Posted 1/25/13 3:04 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

NewlyMrs
Laugh-Live-Love LIFE!

Member since 10/06

14432 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: BC for free

Posted by JenniferEver


Actually the 2% is or FICA and goes directly into social security. The cut forced social security to be funded by the general fund. Most people don't realize that social security is its own fund.

.



I do understand that there are separate funds for everything....but doesn't it all add up to one budget in the end?

Posted 1/25/13 3:06 PM
 

violet25
LIF Infant

Member since 8/12

101 total posts

Name:

Re: BC for free

Posted by NewlyMrs

Posted by violet25

I'm not sure I understand your point about breast pumps. If you try breastfeeding, you always have the option to switch to formula later on. Anything that makes it easier on moms who would like to try to breastfeed -- or to continue once they return to work -- or which gives an incentive to BF over FF is a benefit in my mind both because of the benefit to babies as well as decreased cost (formula is expensive). Plus, those who couldnt afford a pump may have trouble affording formula so the government might have ended up footing some of the bill. I EBF and I have formula samples sitting in the back of my closet and received tons of formula check coupons in the mail. It's always available.



I can't say for all stated,...but I had a conversation with my Ped & she educated me about how here in NC, if a woman decides to BF & get the bump, they cannot later decide it didn't workout & switch to formula. So many lower-eco women never even attempt BFpumping, because they don't want to lose the formula in the future.



That makes no sense to me. So if someone decides to breastfeed and has to or chooses to stop for whatever reason, the baby starves because they cant get formula? There must have been some kind of miscommunication because there is no way that could be true.

Posted 1/25/13 3:19 PM
 

NewlyMrs
Laugh-Live-Love LIFE!

Member since 10/06

14432 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: BC for free

Posted by violet25

That makes no sense to me. So if someone decides to breastfeed and has to or chooses to stop for whatever reason, the baby starves because they cant get formula? There must have been some kind of miscommunication because there is no way that could be true.




I didn't say it made sense...but I'm guessing from a funding standpoint, they arent going to hand out pumps. Which is why many women dont even consider BFing, because they don't want to lose the fomula down the road.

(I'm not sure if OBAMACARE changed this, but last year, this was the case).

Posted 1/25/13 3:41 PM
 

ElizaRags35
My 2 Girls

Member since 2/09

20494 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: BC for free

Posted by violet25

Posted by NewlyMrs

Posted by violet25

I'm not sure I understand your point about breast pumps. If you try breastfeeding, you always have the option to switch to formula later on. Anything that makes it easier on moms who would like to try to breastfeed -- or to continue once they return to work -- or which gives an incentive to BF over FF is a benefit in my mind both because of the benefit to babies as well as decreased cost (formula is expensive). Plus, those who couldnt afford a pump may have trouble affording formula so the government might have ended up footing some of the bill. I EBF and I have formula samples sitting in the back of my closet and received tons of formula check coupons in the mail. It's always available.



I can't say for all stated,...but I had a conversation with my Ped & she educated me about how here in NC, if a woman decides to BF & get the bump, they cannot later decide it didn't workout & switch to formula. So many lower-eco women never even attempt BFpumping, because they don't want to lose the formula in the future.



That makes no sense to me. So if someone decides to breastfeed and has to or chooses to stop for whatever reason, the baby starves because they cant get formula? There must have been some kind of miscommunication because there is no way that could be true.




Is it possible that it's a WIC thing and not a general insurance thing?

Posted 1/25/13 3:52 PM
 

NewlyMrs
Laugh-Live-Love LIFE!

Member since 10/06

14432 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: BC for free

Yes....I'm referring to people getting assistance. Sorry, if I wasn't clear on that.

Posted 1/25/13 3:54 PM
 

JenniferEver
The Disney Lady

Member since 5/05

18163 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: BC for free

Posted by NewlyMrs

Posted by JenniferEver


Actually the 2% is or FICA and goes directly into social security. The cut forced social security to be funded by the general fund. Most people don't realize that social security is its own fund.

.



I do understand that there are separate funds for everything....but doesn't it all add up to one budget in the end?



Social security is separate from the general fund. Pretty much everything else - defense, education, federal employee salaries, etc all come from the general fund. Social Security is its own separate fund. That's why it's defecit neutral and also excet for the recent holiday, doesn't get into robbing peter to pay paul scenarios. That's my understanding

Posted 1/25/13 4:06 PM
 

JenniferEver
The Disney Lady

Member since 5/05

18163 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: BC for free

Posted by NewlyMrs

Posted by violet25

That makes no sense to me. So if someone decides to breastfeed and has to or chooses to stop for whatever reason, the baby starves because they cant get formula? There must have been some kind of miscommunication because there is no way that could be true.




I didn't say it made sense...but I'm guessing from a funding standpoint, they arent going to hand out pumps. Which is why many women dont even consider BFing, because they don't want to lose the fomula down the road.

(I'm not sure if OBAMACARE changed this, but last year, this was the case).



That stinks. I understand they don't want to pay for both, but if I were the mom on assitance, I'd take the forumal too. you never know how well BF will work out

Posted 1/25/13 4:06 PM
 

JenniferEver
The Disney Lady

Member since 5/05

18163 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: BC for free

Posted by Mill188

Posted by violet25

Posted by ElizaRags35

I get why it should be free... many people who should be on BCP are not because of the cost. By eliminating the copay, more people can go on it thus reducing the number of potential abortions or unwanted children as well as the number of women who may have to go on welfare to support unplanned children that they decide to keep. It has great benefits IMO.



I agree. I can see the argument for it having a copay like other medications, but if you look at the big picture and the policy implications, eliminating the copay will likely increase the number of people using birth control which reduces the number of potential abortions or unwanted children, both of which are way more expensive than birth control. Cost effective for the insurance companies (same with increased access to preventative care), and would likely keep people off of welfare. Its more about social engineering. Same with the free breastpumps and BF supplies.



But using this theory, my blood pressure medication should be covered 100% too because preventing a stroke is cheaper than taking care of a patient after a stroke.

Listen, I'm all for insurance being forced to cover birth control like it would cover any other medication. However, I don't think that certain medications should be free and others should have a co-pay. The money has to come from somewhere to pay for it, and we all know it's not coming from the big insurance companies, it's coming from all of our premiums.



Yeah, but I think the point it, whether or not you have issues from your high BP because you can't afford the medication doesn't have the systemic impact of an unwanted child

Posted 1/25/13 4:08 PM
 

NewlyMrs
Laugh-Live-Love LIFE!

Member since 10/06

14432 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: BC for free

Thanks Jennifer for clarifying Chat Icon

Yeah, sadly, I can't blame the Moms either.

Posted 1/25/13 4:08 PM
 

jlm2008
LIF Adult

Member since 1/10

5092 total posts

Name:

Re: BC for free

Posted by Mill188

Posted by Jugglemom

I really haven't been following this but I don't understand why it has to be free? Most medications have one ort of copay why is bp being singled out? I pay $10/ month for generic heart medication - yeah, it is only $10 but why is that any less important than bcp.

For tamiflu I paid $35. Both of these save lives. I understand it having to be covered but why is it free?



Chat Icon I agree 100%



I don't understand either, BCP is one thing the government should not have to pay for. Last time I checked nobody ever died from NOT having sex. It may feel like you will at times, but you really won't.

Posted 1/25/13 4:13 PM
 

Mill188
LIF Adult

Member since 3/09

3073 total posts

Name:

Re: BC for free

Posted by JenniferEver

Posted by Mill188

Posted by violet25

Posted by ElizaRags35

I get why it should be free... many people who should be on BCP are not because of the cost. By eliminating the copay, more people can go on it thus reducing the number of potential abortions or unwanted children as well as the number of women who may have to go on welfare to support unplanned children that they decide to keep. It has great benefits IMO.



I agree. I can see the argument for it having a copay like other medications, but if you look at the big picture and the policy implications, eliminating the copay will likely increase the number of people using birth control which reduces the number of potential abortions or unwanted children, both of which are way more expensive than birth control. Cost effective for the insurance companies (same with increased access to preventative care), and would likely keep people off of welfare. Its more about social engineering. Same with the free breastpumps and BF supplies.



But using this theory, my blood pressure medication should be covered 100% too because preventing a stroke is cheaper than taking care of a patient after a stroke.

Listen, I'm all for insurance being forced to cover birth control like it would cover any other medication. However, I don't think that certain medications should be free and others should have a co-pay. The money has to come from somewhere to pay for it, and we all know it's not coming from the big insurance companies, it's coming from all of our premiums.



Yeah, but I think the point it, whether or not you have issues from your high BP because you can't afford the medication doesn't have the systemic impact of an unwanted child



You can't make that blanket statement. Let's pretend I'm a mom - I have a 2 year old. I have a stroke because I cannot afford the copay on my blood pressure medication. I end up in a nursing home, with little quality of life and no one to care for my child, no way to support my child, no home for my child to live in, etc....same costs as caring for an "unwanted" child.

I do not think BCP should be "free" unless all medication is "free." Why is your BCP more important than my health? See what I'm saying? We start a slippery slope by allowing some things and not others.

To someone on BCP, that is the most important thing to them. To someone with high blood pressure or diabetes, their medication is the most important thing to them. You cannot allow one and not the other.

Posted 1/25/13 4:14 PM
 

violet25
LIF Infant

Member since 8/12

101 total posts

Name:

Re: BC for free

Thank you for the clarification. Didnt realize you were talking about WIC.

As far as one med being more important than the other, I completely agree that BCP isnt more important than any other med and agree that if anything, the need for it is more in a persons control. But, if you look at the greater implications for society, I think you are going to see a bigger impact, a lower cost for society, and more far-reaching benefits/incentives associated with increased access to birth control v blood pressure or other meds that may justify treating it differently.

Posted 1/25/13 4:21 PM
 

ElizaRags35
My 2 Girls

Member since 2/09

20494 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: BC for free

Posted by jlm2008

Posted by Mill188

Posted by Jugglemom

I really haven't been following this but I don't understand why it has to be free? Most medications have one ort of copay why is bp being singled out? I pay $10/ month for generic heart medication - yeah, it is only $10 but why is that any less important than bcp.

For tamiflu I paid $35. Both of these save lives. I understand it having to be covered but why is it free?



Chat Icon I agree 100%



I don't understand either, BCP is one thing the government should not have to pay for. Last time I checked nobody ever died from NOT having sex. It may feel like you will at times, but you really won't.



The pill is not just used for birth control. There are other things it does besides prevent pregnancy.

Posted 1/25/13 4:23 PM
 

ap123
LIF Infant

Member since 10/10

268 total posts

Name:

Re: BC for free

Posted by ElizaRags35

Posted by jlm2008

Posted by Mill188

Posted by Jugglemom

I really haven't been following this but I don't understand why it has to be free? Most medications have one ort of copay why is bp being singled out? I pay $10/ month for generic heart medication - yeah, it is only $10 but why is that any less important than bcp.

For tamiflu I paid $35. Both of these save lives. I understand it having to be covered but why is it free?



Chat Icon I agree 100%



I don't understand either, BCP is one thing the government should not have to pay for. Last time I checked nobody ever died from NOT having sex. It may feel like you will at times, but you really won't.



The pill is not just used for birth control. There are other things it does besides prevent pregnancy.



So should all medicine be free? Why BC but not allergy medicine, or antibiotics?

Posted 1/25/13 4:38 PM
 

JenniferEver
The Disney Lady

Member since 5/05

18163 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: BC for free

Posted by violet25

Thank you for the clarification. Didnt realize you were talking about WIC.

As far as one med being more important than the other, I completely agree that BCP isnt more important than any other med and agree that if anything, the need for it is more in a persons control. But, if you look at the greater implications for society, I think you are going to see a bigger impact, a lower cost for society, and more far-reaching benefits/incentives associated with increased access to birth control v blood pressure or other meds that may justify treating it differently.



Agree.

Posted 1/25/13 4:42 PM
 

Mill188
LIF Adult

Member since 3/09

3073 total posts

Name:

Re: BC for free

Posted by JenniferEver

Posted by violet25

Thank you for the clarification. Didnt realize you were talking about WIC.

As far as one med being more important than the other, I completely agree that BCP isnt more important than any other med and agree that if anything, the need for it is more in a persons control. But, if you look at the greater implications for society, I think you are going to see a bigger impact, a lower cost for society, and more far-reaching benefits/incentives associated with increased access to birth control v blood pressure or other meds that may justify treating it differently.



Agree.



I have to disagree with that. You cannot say giving someone access to free BC has a greater impact than covering diabetes or heart medicine or glaucoma or eplileptic medications or cancer medications, but I respect your opinion.

However, we're not talking about giving BCPs to welfare recipients or other people here. The original post was about people WITH health insurance having $0 copays on their BCPs. That's the difference. If I'm paying the same health insurance premiums as someone else - why is their medication covered and not mine?

Posted 1/25/13 4:50 PM
 

jlm2008
LIF Adult

Member since 1/10

5092 total posts

Name:

Re: BC for free

Posted by ElizaRags35

Posted by jlm2008

Posted by Mill188

Posted by Jugglemom

I really haven't been following this but I don't understand why it has to be free? Most medications have one ort of copay why is bp being singled out? I pay $10/ month for generic heart medication - yeah, it is only $10 but why is that any less important than bcp.

For tamiflu I paid $35. Both of these save lives. I understand it having to be covered but why is it free?



Chat Icon I agree 100%



I don't understand either, BCP is one thing the government should not have to pay for. Last time I checked nobody ever died from NOT having sex. It may feel like you will at times, but you really won't.



The pill is not just used for birth control. There are other things it does besides prevent pregnancy.



If it is used for some life saving purpose than fine. I do not know of too many of its other uses, besides, acne, cramps etc...But if it is prescribed to treat some medical condition, that is fine. But it is still my opinion that the government should not have to pay for birth control when it is being used to prevent pregnancy. That is just my opinion.

Posted 1/25/13 6:12 PM
 

jellybean78
:)

Member since 8/06

13103 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: BC for free

Posted by ElizaRags35

I get why it should be free... many people who should be on BCP are not because of the cost. By eliminating the copay, more people can go on it thus reducing the number of potential abortions or unwanted children as well as the number of women who may have to go on welfare to support unplanned children that they decide to keep. It has great benefits IMO. [/QUOTE

Chat Icon Agree. Now someone won't have to choose between using their last $30 to buy food or BC. I think it will pay for itself in a few years.

Posted 1/25/13 6:27 PM
 

gabbygirl855
Life is good!

Member since 11/09

1950 total posts

Name:

Re: BC for free

I don't think that BCP should be covered by the government. There are so many more other things that should be covered.

Posted 1/25/13 6:29 PM
 

DirtyBlonde
*****

Member since 11/07

7344 total posts

Name:

Re: BC for free

Posted by jlm2008

Posted by ElizaRags35

Posted by jlm2008

Posted by Mill188

Posted by Jugglemom

I really haven't been following this but I don't understand why it has to be free? Most medications have one ort of copay why is bp being singled out? I pay $10/ month for generic heart medication - yeah, it is only $10 but why is that any less important than bcp.

For tamiflu I paid $35. Both of these save lives. I understand it having to be covered but why is it free?



Chat Icon I agree 100%



I don't understand either, BCP is one thing the government should not have to pay for. Last time I checked nobody ever died from NOT having sex. It may feel like you will at times, but you really won't.



The pill is not just used for birth control. There are other things it does besides prevent pregnancy.



If it is used for some life saving purpose than fine. I do not know of too many of its other uses, besides, acne, cramps etc...But if it is prescribed to treat some medical condition, that is fine. But it is still my opinion that the government should not have to pay for birth control when it is being used to prevent pregnancy. That is just my opinion.



It is my opinion that free BC can prevent unwanted pregnancies for those who previously couldn't afford, especially for those women who may have to go on government assistance in order to raise that child.

Otherme, did you expect the thread to turn into this? Chat Icon

Posted 1/25/13 6:32 PM
 

caliz
LIF Zygote

Member since 8/07

45 total posts

Name:

Re: BC for free

Was just listening to NPR while cleaning up dinner and heard this story on free breast pumps. I think the point that when something becomes 'free' to the consumer - the cost actually gets passed along elsewhere- is important to keep in mind. The more things that health insurance covers - the more premiums will rise. I like the idea of someone who would never be able to afford the cost of a breast pump out of pocket being able to have one now. It makes breastfeeding a much more achievable thing for working women - so hard to do unless you have a pump. I'm less thrilled to hear some of the comments in the story from people who want a second pump b/c it's now free even though their other pump is perfectly adequate. Chat Icon

Free breast pumps and the cost of health care

I do hope that removing the co-pay from birth control will make it more accessible to lower income individuals and can help prevent unwanted pregnancies. But with the cost of most private healthcare - I'm not sure how many truly low-income individuals this will impact. Maybe I'm misunderstanding and this impacts more than just private insurance coverage. I guess in all things I'd like to see us spend money where it is most needed and not necessarily where individuals are capable of doing on their own. The goal of reducing unwanted pregnancies is certainly something I support though!

Posted 1/25/13 6:44 PM
 

MandJZ
Time for Baby #2!

Member since 8/10

4194 total posts

Name:
M

Re: BC for free

Posted by ap123

Posted by ElizaRags35

Posted by jlm2008

Posted by Mill188

Posted by Jugglemom

I really haven't been following this but I don't understand why it has to be free? Most medications have one ort of copay why is bp being singled out? I pay $10/ month for generic heart medication - yeah, it is only $10 but why is that any less important than bcp.

For tamiflu I paid $35. Both of these save lives. I understand it having to be covered but why is it free?



Chat Icon I agree 100%



I don't understand either, BCP is one thing the government should not have to pay for. Last time I checked nobody ever died from NOT having sex. It may feel like you will at times, but you really won't.



The pill is not just used for birth control. There are other things it does besides prevent pregnancy.



So should all medicine be free? Why BC but not allergy medicine, or antibiotics?



Yes. All medicine should be covered. As should all health insurance.

Posted 1/25/13 8:10 PM
 

ap123
LIF Infant

Member since 10/10

268 total posts

Name:

Re: BC for free

Posted by MandJZ

Posted by ap123

Posted by ElizaRags35

Posted by jlm2008

Posted by Mill188

Posted by Jugglemom

I really haven't been following this but I don't understand why it has to be free? Most medications have one ort of copay why is bp being singled out? I pay $10/ month for generic heart medication - yeah, it is only $10 but why is that any less important than bcp.

For tamiflu I paid $35. Both of these save lives. I understand it having to be covered but why is it free?



Chat Icon I agree 100%



I don't understand either, BCP is one thing the government should not have to pay for. Last time I checked nobody ever died from NOT having sex. It may feel like you will at times, but you really won't.



The pill is not just used for birth control. There are other things it does besides prevent pregnancy.



So should all medicine be free? Why BC but not allergy medicine, or antibiotics?



Yes. All medicine should be covered. As should all health insurance.



And let me guess, anyone earning over $200k should foot the majority of the bill for that, because they can afford it.

Posted 1/25/13 8:19 PM
 

JenniferEver
The Disney Lady

Member since 5/05

18163 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: BC for free

Ok, so in a perfect world all medication should be free, but in reality it shouldn't. If people don't pay for something they don't value it. So if all medications were free, people would fill scripts they don't need and won't take, causing waste. And people might not take the meds. If it's free and it sits in a drawer, you don't care, but if it you paid for it, you're more likely to take it so it won't go to waste.

I still think free BC is an incredible public policy decision. I really hope we see unwanted pregnancy decline. The only issue is education. One this site full of very educated women, many didn't know that BC would be free, even though it's been known for a while and well=published. I can only imagine that a huge percentage of the women this would help most have no idea

Posted 1/25/13 8:20 PM
 
Pages: 1 [2] 3 4
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
FREE credit reports - starting 9/1 - Got a high score you want to share? DjPiLL 8/28/05 9 Home
Is it ok if I have caffeine free diet coke? bean 8/22/05 8 Pregnancy
is any1 bored?? and can dl music for free??:-) Michi 8/15/05 0 Families Helping Families ™
Do you think that health insurance should be free? Tany 7/28/05 34 Families Helping Families ™
Wednesday Pepsi Picnic Area (Shea) - Anyone done the free tix? Leeners 7/20/05 1 Families Helping Families ™
Anyone know if there is a free website that you can make for older children? Scotty-CassidysMom 6/24/05 5 Parenting