Attachment to stuff

Posted By Message

2boys4me
He's coming soon!

Member since 4/10

4260 total posts

Name:

Attachment to stuff

Do you get attached to stuff? For example, you won't get rid of something because it belonged to a relative or someone else who passed?

I'm asking for two reasons...
One. I watch hoarders, I don't know why it gives me anxiety but I watch it and it makes me so angry that their house is packed to the ceiling of garbage and the person is like I can't throw away this mug or stuffed animal or couch because it belonged to my dead mom, etc. on clean house the other day the girl was crying, crying over giving up her dog outfits because her dog that passes away wore them. Meanwhile, their house was soooooo gross and packed full of junk.

Two. Someone in our family is like this. Not a hoarder exactly but holds on to a lot of stuff that they can't use or look at or even really like just because it belonged to a dead relative. Some items even broken.

I just don't understand this. When I was 26 my dad died and my sister and got all his things and his home. Don't get me wrong, it was SO painful going through his stuff and packing it up for donation, garbage, and an estate sale and we each took some stuff....it was his stuff in the places he wanted it and I felt wrong going through his stuff and getting rid of it but I couldn't take it all. We rented a tiny house at the time and what was the point of storing all these things I couldn't use or like in my garage or attic for ever? I did end up taking some furniture and pieces that he really liked because at the time I couldn't part with selling stuff he really liked but as its approaching 2 years since he passed I'm starting to part with the things I kept that I don't like because once again, why store stuff? I have his memories and that's what is important and my sister and I made matching necklaces out of loose diamonds he had inherited so we have something to wear everyday to remind us of him.



My point is this...why do people do this lol? Do you have things in your home from a loved one who passed on that you don't use or like but keep out of guilt?

Posted 9/4/12 9:26 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

bpmom
Feeling Blessed

Member since 6/07

2963 total posts

Name:

Re: Attachment to stuff

I'm not a hoarder, but I do sometimes have trouble getting rid of stuff that is for my DCs.
For me and my family on my side, I attribute it to growing up poor.
I watched my parents sell almost all my siblings' toys and my stuffed animals, bikes, childhood playsets at a garage sale to get money to move away. I get sad when I think of my MIL who has held onto almost every childhood toy for her children (DH and siblings) and every piece of artwork they ever made/card they gave to her for her birthday/Mother's Day.
I feel lucky that I have a baby blanket and two dolls from when I was a baby that my mom saved for me -- I know I didn't lose things in a fire or in a tragedy, but I want to give my DCs what I don't have -- a box of their childhood "stuff" that they can take with them when they move on.

Message edited 2012-09-04 13:42:42.060000.

Posted 9/4/12 10:06 AM
 

SusiBee
. . . . .

Member since 3/09

8268 total posts

Name:
S

Re: Attachment to stuff

I keep some things of value that belonged to my great aunt, my grandmother and my mom, all of whom have passed. Most of my memories are in my heart and in my head, so I don't need to see things to remember them.

I am dealing with a hoarding situation now (just like the tv program !) and it is my nightmare. DH's stepdad is the hoarder and he is facing eviction because of it.
He finds value in everything, can't throw anything away because he needs it and will use it, never mind that it has been packed away or buried for years. He buys new stuff because he can't find it. (25 flashlights !) MIL died four years ago and her things are still everywhere. She was a hoarder too and a compulsive shopper. Every kitchen gadget imaginable, for a kitchen that has no storage and is only about 8x10.
He has good intentions of doing stuff, just doesn't follow thru. The washer and dryer were purchased 15 years ago but never hooked up. Sat in the living room for 15 years. All new cabinets and fixtures were bought for the bathroom, never installed. They were stored in the dining room. He got so far as to take the medicine cabinet out of the wall - 12 years ago.

When I first walked into the apartment, I had to walk sideways. Between my butt and my upper half, I kept knocking stuff over. Boxes were packed to the ceiling, newspapers and magazines were filed waist high. Clothes were hanging from every imaginable place, including a jury-rigged contraption consisting of a coffee table base, handtruck, crutches and rope.
The filth was what got to me - dirt, dust and mouse droppings, something growing on the walls.

It's a mental illness, there's a lot going on inside the old man's head that we don't know about. I've arranged for an evaluation for him to get into a geriatric mental health program that also gives us access to social services.

I've also done a major cleanout of "stuff", filling three 1-800-GotJunk trucks. Lots of arguing back and forth, me yelling and trying to not lose my patience, DH and his step-dad almost coming to blows a couple of times. I've been to court twice already, a third date is later this week. I still don't know if the old man gets to stay in his apartment, everything depends upon the court. If they say yes, then I get a restoration cleaning company in to do a thorough cleaning and deodorizing, then the apartment can be repaired and painted. Ground rules will have to be established, including routine cleaning services and unannounced inspections to make sure he doesn't revert to old ways.

DH and I fight about the old man, but there is no one else to deal with this issue. It's been going on since January.

I keep reminding myself that it is a mental illness and pray that everything works out in the end, that the old man gets to stay in his apartment.

Posted 9/4/12 10:19 AM
 

Domino
Always My Miracle

Member since 9/05

9924 total posts

Name:

Re: Attachment to stuff

Me? No. DH? Yes. And we are both irked by each other. This hideous acrylic bank that MIL gave "us" of a chesire cat broke recently. I came home and there was DH gluing it back together. I asked him to please throw it out. He refuses. "But my mom gave it to us." But it sits in a corner of our bedroom unused all because MIL gave it to us. Chat Icon (she is alive BTW)

I throw out things all the time. DH picks through the garbage: "You're throwing THIS out?"

I have the if I havent seen it, touched it, or used it in a year, it goes in the trash. DH keeps things because "you'll never know when you'll need something like that."

I think it is important to remember people who have passed though. I have a gold heart necklace that was my Aunt's. I have a Cartier Silver Salt and Pepper shaker set that was given to us from my Great Aunt and Uncle. I have a ring from my Grandmother. A violin from my Grandfather. But they are all thing I cherish and love.

Posted 9/4/12 11:09 AM
 

computergirl
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

3118 total posts

Name:

Re: Attachment to stuff

I definitely do not get attached to stuff. I am completely the opposite of a hoarder.

Haven't worn it in a while? OUT
Kids haven't played with it in a while? OUT
Am I tired of dusting this? OUT

I do have a sense of sentimentality about some things-- I have boxes in my attic of my kids' baby clothes and other mementos of their babyhood. I save some of their art projects and trophies and stuff for sentimental reasons. I have a small collection of cookbooks that my grandma passed down to me. Things like that. I just don't like the concept of having a lot of STUFF in general.

Posted 9/4/12 11:38 AM
 

WenRC
Happiness is...

Member since 4/11

1253 total posts

Name:
Wendy

Attachment to stuff

I have a few trinkets that my grandmother gave me yrs before she passed. A couple of items I use, like my rosary and bible. But other things; like hair clips or bracelets remind me of her so much I will never throw them out.
Besides, that the only thing I can't let go of are my clothes.. I have bins of clothing that are too small and I hold out hope that one day I will fit into them again.

Posted 9/4/12 1:40 PM
 

glinda-goodwitch
:-)

Member since 7/06

9149 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: Attachment to stuff

Yes and no. I love heirlooms and things that remind me of family. But only if they are in good condition, and if I have a place for them. I hate disorder and disorganization. Many gifts I will keep for a bit, but if I never use them or plan on using them, I will donate. I'm definitely a sentimental person, but I know where to draw the line.

Posted 9/4/12 2:06 PM
 

cateyemm
Twins!

Member since 7/10

8027 total posts

Name:

Re: Attachment to stuff

hoarding is a mental illness and will soon be included in the DSM. if they are holding onto things that are broken or have no real value (i.e. old newspapers, broken trinkets) this may signify hoarding versus simply being a packrat. you may want to look into the reasons behind the hoarding or seek professional help for them.

eta i have a lot of old jewelry of both my grandmother's that i wont throw away but its not considered hoarding.

Message edited 2012-09-04 15:32:24.873000.

Posted 9/4/12 3:31 PM
 

LSP2005
Bunny kisses are so cute!

Member since 5/05

19461 total posts

Name:
L

Re: Attachment to stuff

I think attachment to things is a very complex issue. For some people the things represent the people, the memory and unfortunately they cannot dis-associate the memory from the item. For those that horde trash I think it is a lot of depression and other disorders.

As for me, I keep some things and give away, donate and trash other things. There are some things I have that frankly I don't think I would keep but I have them because someone passed away and gave them to me. It would upset other people in my family if I did not keep it, so I have it. Of course, they themselves don't want the items but they want them in the family.

Posted 9/4/12 4:01 PM
 

drpepper318
MIR MIR MIR!

Member since 6/07

8274 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Attachment to stuff

I think it's been found to be a genetic tendency, I think they may have (not sure) found the marker for it. It's definitely a mental illness.

I have worked very hard to break the cycle... I throw out & donate a ton of stuff & force myself not to think about it. I won't buy something or bring it into my house if I think I'm going to have trouble parting with it. My space is pretty neat but not 100% clutter free. I try to keep on top of it. I don't want "stuff" to be the focus of my life.

My mother is a SERIOUS hoarder. Like to the point that there is almost no empty space in her house, just piles of stuff everywhere. Entire rooms that you can't even walk into. Not even room to sit anywhere. It's bad. I've tried to help her but she won't admit she has a problem, she doesn't want to change. She hasn't had anyone over in years. She could easily be on the show Hoarders. I had to get out when I was 18, could not live like that.

So I definitely am anti-junk in my home!!!!! DH has a tendency to keep crap he doesn't use, so I have to keep on top of him about it too.

Posted 9/4/12 6:33 PM
 

MorningCuppaCoffee
Tired!

Member since 12/07

16353 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: Attachment to stuff

We collect stuff, sure and every so often I get fed up and go and do a huge clean and put it out on the curb. DH and I did this with our basement recently and now we have hardly anything down there.

I always say too, that you never realize how much crap you have until you have to move or reorganize because you can't find something.

When I get the itch to go on a clothing shopping spree, I often go through my closets and drawers and realize that no, I really do NOT need to go on another shopping spree. When I do need something, I am trying to get rid of 5-10 items in exchange.

But people who hoard.......yes, that's a very serious mental illness.

I did one of my internships in graduate school at a legal services clinic that helped out the elderly and disabled.

Most of the cases referred to them were hoarders........many who LLs were looking for any reason to evict because not only were they putting themselves and other tenants at risk, but many of them were paying almost nothing in rent, and the LL knew they could turn around and charge 1000's for that apartment if they could boot them out.

I also notice this sometimes with my clientele. Primarily I work with people who have brain injury, and studies have shown that people who hoard have tended to go through some kind of physical/emotional trauma.

It's tough too because it's a very slow process to clean someone out, you need to involve mental health professionals and resources in this area are super, super limited.

I have also seen that show and they make it look like they clean out the person's home overnight.

In reality, it can take months.

Posted 9/4/12 6:42 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Spinoff to attachment parenting: Those of you who co-sleep... OOSMommy 4/20/10 6 Parenting
Does anyone suscribe to any of the "attachment parenting" theories/beliefs? If so, come on in! maybeamommy 4/20/10 33 Parenting
Q about bassinet/carriage vs. using car seat attachment Sunday 3/27/10 10 Parenting
Looking for a water purification attachment for the kitchen faucet... Candy Girl 12/6/08 2 Home
My kid is into attachment parenting and I am not... Janice 9/5/08 4 Parenting
How to post a picture w/out resizing & not as an attachment... MrsMerlot 7/25/06 3 Families Helping Families ™