as a parent, what do you do??? is there even a right answer?

Posted By Message

browneyedgirl
family is all that matters

Member since 6/06

6513 total posts

Name:
browneyes

as a parent, what do you do??? is there even a right answer?

DH and i have been discussing this for 2 days.

a baby was recently born in the area--it's a hermaphrodite. neither boy nor girl. they were doing tests on the baby to see what they could determine about it. i don't know the results of the tests or what they were even determining.

what the heck do you do as a parent? gender identity is beyond important in our society--especially as a kid. kids just want to belong and not be different.

do you:
*give the baby surgery to be the gender you were hoping for/expecting?
*give the baby surgery to be the gender that the "tests" determine it to be closer to?
*if you give the baby surgery, do you tell him/her? and when do you?
*leave gender unassigned until the baby is a child and let it determine it?
*leave gender unassigned until the baby is a child and determine FOR him/her?

and what if you make the WRONG gender decision and the child feels uncomfortable in his/her own skin--literally?!

what a heartbreaking decision to have to make as a parent. it just makes me think of all the difficulty that poor baby, and countless others, will have to face. what if they have surgery and it was the "wrong" gender? what if the parents never tell him/her and he always feels "wrong"?

this is really a theoretical question because i don't think any of us would really know what we would do in that situation. you just want your baby to have an easy and wonderful life and although he/she is "healthy", not having a gender isn't easily fixable the way some diseases/problems are. it can be a lifelong struggle.

i thought this would be an interesting conversation. me personally, i have absolutely NO idea what i would doChat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 2/9/10 8:21 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Bella311
Me and my Boys

Member since 1/10

1400 total posts

Name:

Re: as a parent, what do you do??? is there even a right answer?

I would:
*give the baby surgery to be the gender that the "tests" determine it to be closer to -
AND never tell the child. Sorry, maybe its just me but I think it would cause unnecessary self esteem issues.

Posted 2/9/10 8:59 PM
 

JennyPenny
?

Member since 1/08

12702 total posts

Name:
Jen

Re: as a parent, what do you do??? is there even a right answer?

Geez- I have no idea what I would do. Chat Icon

Posted 2/9/10 9:08 PM
 

Michmouse
LIF Adult

Member since 11/07

1260 total posts

Name:

Re: as a parent, what do you do??? is there even a right answer?

What a trying position to be in as a new parent. I would pray for guidance from God and the professionals about what to do.....I think when you are so close to a situation the emotional component can be to overwhelming to "go it alone"

I remember reading that a hermaphrodite is the result of a celllular mutation and that hormone levels can determine the sex....I would want that testing done immediately.

Chat Icon Chat Icon For this family!Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 2/9/10 9:14 PM
 

laurabora
LIF Adult

Member since 4/07

2712 total posts

Name:
Laura

Re: as a parent, what do you do??? is there even a right answer?

I want to say I'd wait for testing and have the gender assigned accordingly.

This reminds me so much of the book "Middlesex." The main character was a hermaphrodite and they just raised her as a girl, turned out "she" always felt more like a "he."

Such a tough decision for those parents.Chat Icon

Posted 2/9/10 9:20 PM
 

Domino
Always My Miracle

Member since 9/05

9924 total posts

Name:

Re: as a parent, what do you do??? is there even a right answer?

I would have the testing done and have the surgery done according to the results of the test. I would tell my child but am not sure at what age. i saw a special about this, on HBO I think, and it was heartwrenching and I'd always be terrified that I made the wrong choiceChat Icon

Posted 2/9/10 9:27 PM
 

Katie111806
Team Pink!

Member since 12/06

5349 total posts

Name:
Katie

Re: as a parent, what do you do??? is there even a right answer?

Wow, I have no idea. Chat Icon

Posted 2/9/10 9:29 PM
 

CrankyPants
I'm cranky

Member since 7/06

18178 total posts

Name:
Mama Cranky

Re: as a parent, what do you do??? is there even a right answer?

Posted by laurabora

I want to say I'd wait for testing and have the gender assigned accordingly.

This reminds me so much of the book "Middlesex." The main character was a hermaphrodite and they just raised her as a girl, turned out "she" always felt more like a "he."

Such a tough decision for those parents.Chat Icon



I read that book and in it they didn't know that she was a "he" when she was born.

In real life, I don't know what I would do. I've read that some adults who have gone through this say there is nothing wrong with them and they shouldn't be forced into a sex when then really are a blend of two sexes, that parents should allow the children to develop naturally and not try to assign a gender to them.

I don't know if that is what I would do, as an adult it seems easier to deal with than it would be for a 5 YO or 14 YO who just wants to fit in.

Posted 2/9/10 9:31 PM
 

A3CM
Avatar Title

Member since 9/08

3762 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: as a parent, what do you do??? is there even a right answer?

i would wait for the gender testing and give the surgery that would most represent who they are....

would i tell my child.. yes. because it will come out eventually.

Posted 2/9/10 9:32 PM
 

Blissful
Ultimate Expression of LOVE

Member since 6/08

4985 total posts

Name:
Maria

Re: as a parent, what do you do??? is there even a right answer?

What a tough decision... I don't know. I just want to send Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon For the family

Posted 2/9/10 9:34 PM
 

Nifheim
allo

Member since 1/09

5476 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: as a parent, what do you do??? is there even a right answer?

as a non-parent and a person who was interested in the subject. For me i think i would allow the child to grow up and make their own choice. I have seen too many docu's about sexual identity and how some people know who they are at a young age and some who do not discover truly how they feel until puberty. If the doctors after checking out hormone levels/etc really say there is a very high chance they are female or male then i might consider the operations that are necessary but be completely open to the child with what is/has happened. It really would have to be over 85% certainty that they are higher in that sex otherwise i would rather leave it to the adult to make that decision.

Will growing up be hard? most definitely but i think even with gender assignment its difficult because if its done wrong guilt/resentment develops and that is something i would never want on my shoulders because it would be very hard to repair what i have taken away physically.

Posted 2/9/10 9:37 PM
 

hbugal
Lesigh

Member since 2/07

15928 total posts

Name:

Re: as a parent, what do you do??? is there even a right answer?

When my daughter was little I was very good friends with her Endo who was also the Geneticist at Winthrop. He actually still is. There was a baby born that was neither boy nor girl. (they use the term intersex now) I remember asking him "what do you do?" He told me that if the baby comes back genetically female there isnt a problem. They just make her female and that's it. It's not until the baby comes back male that the problem persists.

Essentially, from what I understand, it is hard to make the baby male. So, years ago, they made them female. There have been several cases, several famous cases in fact, where this obviously is not the answer...

In most cases the baby born isnt a true hermaphrodite but rather born with ambiguous gentalia. If the child is a true hermaphrodite it changes things dramatically. Because in this case the child isnt male or female but rather both.

In our society surgery was generally done at birth. But it is my current understanding that advocates for the intersex community stress waiting until the child is older and can make an informed decision.

As a parent I firmly believe that the whole equals much more than the sum of its parts....I'd wait to do the surgery unless it was medically necessary.

Message edited 2010-02-09 21:50:29.417000.

Posted 2/9/10 9:47 PM
 

SweetTooth
I'm a tired mommy!

Member since 12/05

20105 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: as a parent, what do you do??? is there even a right answer?

I would not do the surgery as a baby/child. I would "assign" the baby a gender - give him/her a name, dress him/her in gender appropriate clothing, but I would wait until the baby is a teenager adult, and then let him/her decide what gender he/she wants to be.
I've read/heard stories about this - that the baby is raised as a certain gender, and then as a teenager identifies more as the other gender.
It is a very tough decision, but one I think that a person should make for him/herself.

Posted 2/9/10 9:55 PM
 

Diana1215
Living on a prayer!!!

Member since 10/05

29450 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: as a parent, what do you do??? is there even a right answer?

Posted by Bella311

I would:
*give the baby surgery to be the gender that the "tests" determine it to be closer to -
AND never tell the child. Sorry, maybe its just me but I think it would cause unnecessary self esteem issues.



word for word, what you said. I think. Those poor parents, and poor baby! Chat Icon

Posted 2/9/10 9:57 PM
 

butterfly20
Party of 5 - 2015

Member since 4/06

7390 total posts

Name:

Re: as a parent, what do you do??? is there even a right answer?

this was a private practice episode..... they were going to make the kid the sex they wanted- even though the surgery said they were closer to the other sex.... i think by the end the dr changed the mothers mind but i cant remember if the dad was on board.

...... i would do the surgery and get them to the one that seems closer. honestly, there are tom boy girls, and girly guys . they aren't hermaphrodites and sometimes they decide to change sex when they grow up. When my kid is old enough to understand information that big i'd tell them

eta- no there is no "right" across the line answer. Each parent has to do what they feel is best for the baby.

Message edited 2010-02-09 22:08:02.893000.

Posted 2/9/10 10:06 PM
 

BigB
C & J are 10!

Member since 6/05

5914 total posts

Name:
Stacey

Re: as a parent, what do you do??? is there even a right answer?

Good Question! Genetic Tests come back quickly enough that I would wait until the tests were back before any surgery would take place.

And, I would tell the child when they were old enough or if and when they began to question who they were.

It is a tough place to be in. However, I do know (because I have had 2 friends who had gender reassignment surgery) it is much easier (surgically) to go female.

Posted 2/9/10 10:32 PM
 

FelAndJon
needs to update her avatar pic

Member since 6/05

10212 total posts

Name:
Felice (aka LuckyBride2004)

Re: as a parent, what do you do??? is there even a right answer?

I just don't know Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 2/10/10 8:18 AM
 

Sweets13
Bella Bambini

Member since 5/05

9300 total posts

Name:

Re: as a parent, what do you do??? is there even a right answer?

Posted by Diana1215

Posted by Bella311

I would:
*give the baby surgery to be the gender that the "tests" determine it to be closer to -
AND never tell the child. Sorry, maybe its just me but I think it would cause unnecessary self esteem issues.



word for word, what you said. I think. Those poor parents, and poor baby! Chat Icon



ME too...

Posted 2/10/10 8:48 AM
 

beachgirl13
Mommy to 3 boys!

Member since 5/05

4114 total posts

Name:

Re: as a parent, what do you do??? is there even a right answer?

I have no idea what I'd do. I feel for the parents.

Posted 2/10/10 9:27 AM
 

jes81276
summer fun!

Member since 3/06

4962 total posts

Name:
Jaime

Re: as a parent, what do you do??? is there even a right answer?

Posted by Bella311

I would:
*give the baby surgery to be the gender that the "tests" determine it to be closer to -
AND never tell the child. Sorry, maybe its just me but I think it would cause unnecessary self esteem issues.





as I was reading the post, this was my thought as well.

Posted 2/10/10 9:34 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
How does your DC sleep? (Please answer only if DC is over 3mos as before that I know the answer is different for most!) itsbabytime 5/22/08 22 Parenting
Why does every NON-Parent who watches Nanny 911 IrishTracy 7/16/05 2 Parenting
Health Question and Answer Session HarleyGirlFLA 6/30/05 3 Families Helping Families ™
SO vs. parent Redhead 6/29/05 27 Families Helping Families ™
Just tried the Answer OPK mrsmck 6/13/05 10 TTC
Answer OPKs MrsJ 6/9/05 0 TTC