Article about poverty

Posted By Message

MorningCuppaCoffee
Tired!

Member since 12/07

16353 total posts

Name:
Allison

Article about poverty

I just saw this posted on Twitter by a social worker and thought it was really worthwhile to share. Especially for this area, where life for many is already hard enough given the cost of living for even 2 "middle class" people.

__________________________________

3 Things We Need to Stop Saying About Poverty

One in five American children are growing up in poverty. Problems, as a rule, do not get solved unless we talk about them. I would dearly love to see a national conversation about poverty, and I'd love it to be an intelligent and productive one. Unfortunately, there are a lot of worn-out conversation-enders that tend to come up in discussions about economic hardship. I could live a long and happy life without ever hearing these three again.

1. "People shouldn't have babies if they can't afford them."

I dislike this one for so many reasons.

I strongly feel that when you encounter a child in need, you should help. Arguing with the child about whether he or she has the right to exist is patently unhelpful. The child is here now, period. How he fares in the short term and how he's prepared to contribute to society as an adult depends on how well his needs are met today. Having an existential debate about a baby does nothing to further that cause.

Many people have babies fully expecting to be able to support them, by the way. But they lose their jobs, get sick, get divorced. They find out their home is suddenly worth a fraction of what they paid for it. Or they encounter some other variety of bad luck.

Finally, and perhaps most importantly, I would never presume to decide who should and shouldn't have children. I'm not nearly wise enough to be trusted with that kind of power; and I'm not sure I know anyone who is.

2. "I was poor and I... "

Many people cite their own hardscrabble youths to illustrate that low-income people don't really need help. "We were dirt poor but never asked for a handout. My mom made do with... "

I'm sure your mom was an amazing, hard-working person. And you are right to be proud of her. But that does not mean people who cannot get by are not working hard.

For example, in 1950 health care was five percent of GDP. Today it is more than 15 percent.

Minimum wage, relative to the cost of living, has been dropping precipitously since 1968. In other words, low-wage workers of today have paychecks that don't stretch as far as they used to. There's a common myth that people are forced into poverty because they squander their money on consumer goods. The fact is that it's harder to buy food, heat your home and put clothes on your children's backs than it used to be.

3. "Why don't they just... "

It's very common to hear some seemingly common-sense solution that will dramatically alter the effects of poverty -- if only people were resourceful enough to see it.

"Well, she should give up her car."

Many jobs that people on public assistance would qualify for are not within reach of public transportation.

"I save 30 percent on my groceries every week using coupons."

That means you have a newspaper subscription or a computer you can use regularly and a printer to print out coupons. It also probably means that you have access to a large supermarket. Many poor areas are served only by convenience stores. Driving to the store is an option if you've got a car and can afford the gas.

"The kids should get paper routes, or after-school jobs."

These kinds of earning opportunities are few and far between. Newspapers are hurting for customers. Subscribers who do get home delivery are rarely served by kids on bicycles. The youth unemployment rate for U.S. is above 16 percent. And many of those who do find work are stuck in low-quality jobs.

There's so much that we can and should talk about when it comes to poverty. But let's make sure we're talking sense.

Follow Joanne Goldblum on Twitter: www.twitter.com/jgoldblum

Posted 9/2/13 5:00 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Paramount
Sweet!

Member since 7/12

4289 total posts

Name:

Re: Article about poverty

Depending on circumstances, of course.

I have an opinion about the child thing. I believe that if you are living in a manner that you can barely pay for yourself, you struggle to pay a rent, you struggle to put food on the table, you struggle or cant afford BASIC necessity (food, clothing, shelter, and with exceptions medical) you don't have the means to support a child.

If you can BARELY take care of yourself, or worse, CANT take care of yourself then you have no place having children/ another child.

Posted 9/2/13 5:36 PM
 

MorningCuppaCoffee
Tired!

Member since 12/07

16353 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: Article about poverty

I do have mixed opinions about the child one too, especially now that I am a parent.

I can't even watch that show Teen Mom, because it upsets me way too much.

Posted 9/2/13 5:52 PM
 

EatingMyVeggies

Member since 1/12

6667 total posts

Name:

Article about poverty

I agree with a lot of these

I try not to judge for a variety of reasons. You even see it here - someone laid off, baby comes, buying new house or something of the sort. Someone lost X but is able to buy Y. You just never know someone's situation unless you're in it. Or how they are wrangling matters or what assistance they have from family or whatever.

Live and let live and all that. Im more concerned about corruption on grand scale govt and bank levels than a neighbor, kwim?

Posted 9/2/13 6:28 PM
 

MrsProfessor
hi

Member since 5/05

14279 total posts

Name:

Article about poverty

On the one hand I agree with #2 and #3. But while I do think we need to support kids who live in poverty, I feel that adults need to be more responsible about having babies if their financial situation is tenuous. I'm not talking about a woman in her late 30s trying to have her first kid and being worried because maybe her job or DHs job is iffy- I mean people who are already stretched with one or two kids who decide to have more. I feel like we even see it here- a woman who might express concerns about money and another kid, and everyone tells her to go for it, then ***** about people looking for help.

Posted 9/2/13 6:52 PM
 

MorningCuppaCoffee
Tired!

Member since 12/07

16353 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: Article about poverty

Posted by MrsProfessor

On the one hand I agree with #2 and #3. But while I do think we need to support kids who live in poverty, I feel that adults need to be more responsible about having babies if their financial situation is tenuous. I'm not talking about a woman in her late 30s trying to have her first kid and being worried because maybe her job or DHs job is iffy- I mean people who are already stretched with one or two kids who decide to have more. I feel like we even see it here- a woman who might express concerns about money and another kid, and everyone tells her to go for it, then ***** about people looking for help.




Ha, and I think everyone's responses vary by the thread/day/mood/relationship with the poster. Chat Icon

Posted 9/2/13 7:44 PM
 

EatingMyVeggies

Member since 1/12

6667 total posts

Name:

Re: Article about poverty

Posted by MorningCuppaCoffee

Posted by MrsProfessor

On the one hand I agree with #2 and #3. But while I do think we need to support kids who live in poverty, I feel that adults need to be more responsible about having babies if their financial situation is tenuous. I'm not talking about a woman in her late 30s trying to have her first kid and being worried because maybe her job or DHs job is iffy- I mean people who are already stretched with one or two kids who decide to have more. I feel like we even see it here- a woman who might express concerns about money and another kid, and everyone tells her to go for it, then ***** about people looking for help.




Ha, and I think everyone's responses vary by the thread/day/mood/relationship with the poster. Chat Icon



Yes. I've never seen anyone said here NOT to have a baby due to finances. It's usually "you can always cut back" or "your situation may change" or "if everyone waited to have enough money for a child, no one would have any" or "kids need love the most". Which generally I agree with. For the most part.

But you're right.. Then many say the opposites when it comes to the general masses. So who knows.

Posted 9/2/13 7:56 PM
 

Paramount
Sweet!

Member since 7/12

4289 total posts

Name:

Re: Article about poverty

Posted by EatingMyVeggies

Yes. I've never seen anyone said here NOT to have a baby due to finances. It's usually "you can always cut back" or "your situation may change" or "if everyone waited to have enough money for a child, no one would have any" or "kids need love the most". Which generally I agree with. For the most part.

But you're right.. Then many say the opposites when it comes to the general masses. So who knows.



Interesting point. I see this a lot of this on the board as well.

I never answer these posts because I feel that if you can't afford a child why would you have one? For ME its something I JUST don't understand. I would NEVER tell someone don't. Its up to you. But I don't understand having financial difficulty and also wanting a child.

I also feel that most of the people on LIF are middle class for the most part. Some have more, some have less. But all of us have a roof, food. We might struggle to pay the bills and live paycheck to paycheck, but no one on this board is probably in poverty.

There a ton of things middle class people can do to "cut back" to afford something. Weather that something is a car, buying a house, or having a kid. I think we, on this board, have the means to cut back and maybe get a second job (or whatever it is) to have a child.

Being middle class we have options.

Its within our means to make the sacrifice.

But when you have little to nothing, on food stamps, no job, cant pay rent, etc etc etc you should not have kids. If I can't afford my OWN kids, I certainly can't afford yours.

Message edited 2013-09-02 20:52:37.097000.

Posted 9/2/13 8:51 PM
 

MorningCuppaCoffee
Tired!

Member since 12/07

16353 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: Article about poverty

I kind of feel that really poor people, especially GENERATIONS of poor people...........that's a WHOLE other dynamic/problem especially when it comes to having kids.

While the middle class thing is very interesting, and I can agree with you on many points, at the same time, in this area especially, it can be really financially devastating if one person in a 2-income household were to lose their job.

DH is self-employed and had a bad year a few years back. Luckily we had savings but we drained it within that year. It's extremely hard to build that back up and recover from that.

I also don't feel like the cost of RENT (forget about a mortgage/taxes) here on Long Island is very affordable for the average person.




Posted 9/3/13 5:35 AM
 

MarathonKnitter
HAPPY

Member since 2/07

17374 total posts

Name:
EMBRACING CHANGE

Re: Article about poverty

not sure if i agree whole-heartedly.

i can understand #1 because you don't know where every poor parent's life was when they found out they were expecting and/or if the child was planned. i was a kid when i got pregnant. i needed assistance... then again, i knew i couldn't afford more kids, so i didn't have any more... although i always dreamed of three kids.

#2
i think this is valid. i was not poor during the depression, i was poor when the dollar didn't go far... just like the article says. my experience is valid! i know what it's like. i know what it's like to think outside the box and realize that food stamps won't buy cleaning supplies... so you figure out how to use baking soda to clean and brush your teeth.

#3
again, i think it's valid.
over the weekend, i saw "a place at the table" a documentary about americans who don't have enough to eat. there were moments when i got angry at the people who i was suppose to empathize and sympathize with. this is the USA! yes, there are times you need help. I HAVE BEEN THERE. but there is always something that you can do for your self. why is it that the people who lived on ranches couldn't plant a small garden??

the point about the coupons is untrue. i've used coupons and never subscribed to a newspaper.

again, i understand that there are a lot of times and reasons people REALLY DO NEED HELP. i have been there. but if you really want to get out of it, there is always some extra small thing you can do to help yourself.

Posted 9/3/13 6:22 AM
 

mosh913
baby boy coming spring '11

Member since 5/05

3133 total posts

Name:

Re: Article about poverty

I'm surprised the article doesn't mention the cost of higher education especially since education can be a means to ending poverty.

Posted 9/3/13 6:36 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Family of 4 needs combined income of $68K to avoid poverty... EclecticEsq10810 4/9/11 0 Families Helping Families ™
Does anyone have a friend or friends who are always crying poverty... beautyq115 12/22/06 19 Families Helping Families ™
Article: Home Buyer Mistakes to Avoid HarleyGirlFLA 6/21/05 5 Home
Interesting Article on Home Ownsership karacg 6/13/05 1 Home
Daily News Article on Bad Vets baghag 5/29/05 2 Pets
This is a great article It so explains my MIL june262004 5/20/05 8 Families Helping Families ™