ANY PARENTS RAISING..

Posted By Message

Failurebydsign
LIF Zygote

Member since 4/08

42 total posts

Name:
Dominique

ANY PARENTS RAISING..

children without religion?

im not necessarily meaning against religion or atheism..just wanting to know how freely i can speack or who can guide me more

Posted 4/5/08 6:15 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: ANY PARENTS RAISING..

I was raised without a religon. My parents felt it was shoved down their throats, so they chose not to baptize my sister and I. They wanted us to make the choice on our own.

We didn't really have that different of an upbringing at all, my sister is a Buddist now though. I really have no religon.

I told DH had no problem with him getting DS baptized, but it was his job, I know nothing about it, so he had to do it. Let's just say that DS is 11 months old and isn't baptized yetChat Icon

Posted 4/5/08 6:18 PM
 

jgm26
LIF Adolescent

Member since 7/06

583 total posts

Name:

Re: ANY PARENTS RAISING..

me!! And its a huge problem for my ILs b/c we have not baptized DD. Dh wants to do it to make his parents happy, but ... well, I could go on and on about how I feel. I'd be happy to talk about through PM, though! I'd actually love someone to talk to about itChat Icon

Posted 4/5/08 6:25 PM
 

Failurebydsign
LIF Zygote

Member since 4/08

42 total posts

Name:
Dominique

Re: ANY PARENTS RAISING..

Posted by KateDevine

I was raised without a religon. My parents felt it was shoved down their throats, so they chose not to baptize my sister and I. They wanted us to make the choice on our own.

We didn't really have that different of an upbringing at all, my sister is a Buddist now though. I really have no religon.

I told DH had no problem with him getting DS baptized, but it was his job, I know nothing about it, so he had to do it. Let's just say that DS is 11 months old and isn't baptized yetChat Icon



now that makes me feel a little better

i was raised catholic and DH was raised pretty religiously..not sure which one ( grew up in the bible belt)

we are now free thinkers and worry about what to do with our children since everyone other then us in both of our familys are still practicing

im not going to raise a kid with GOD in their life just because someone think i should..and i guess im wanting to talk to parents that already have kids and how they are handling it..because im not a parent yet but i want to prepare the best i can for this impt issue

Posted 4/5/08 6:26 PM
 

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: ANY PARENTS RAISING..

Posted by Failurebydsign

Posted by KateDevine

I was raised without a religon. My parents felt it was shoved down their throats, so they chose not to baptize my sister and I. They wanted us to make the choice on our own.

We didn't really have that different of an upbringing at all, my sister is a Buddist now though. I really have no religon.

I told DH had no problem with him getting DS baptized, but it was his job, I know nothing about it, so he had to do it. Let's just say that DS is 11 months old and isn't baptized yetChat Icon



now that makes me feel a little better

i was raised catholic and DH was raised pretty religiously..not sure which one ( grew up in the bible belt)

we are now free thinkers and worry about what to do with our children since everyone other then us in both of our familys are still practicing

im not going to raise a kid with GOD in their life just because someone think i should..and i guess im wanting to talk to parents that already have kids and how they are handling it..because im not a parent yet but i want to prepare the best i can for this impt issue



Here's the thing I think is important: my parents were open to what WE wanted to do. When my 7 year old sister wanted to go to church, my mom offered to take her, but she declined b/c she'd have to wake up early on a SundayChat Icon

And I believe in God, I just don't have an organized religion, I kind of hate when people assume I am atheist because I am not baptized, that isn't true.

Religion is really interesting from an educational point of view, I really enjoyed learning about it in school, and from a totally un influenced point of view!

Posted 4/5/08 6:29 PM
 

Failurebydsign
LIF Zygote

Member since 4/08

42 total posts

Name:
Dominique

Re: ANY PARENTS RAISING..

Posted by KateDevine

Posted by Failurebydsign

Posted by KateDevine

I was raised without a religon. My parents felt it was shoved down their throats, so they chose not to baptize my sister and I. They wanted us to make the choice on our own.

We didn't really have that different of an upbringing at all, my sister is a Buddist now though. I really have no religon.

I told DH had no problem with him getting DS baptized, but it was his job, I know nothing about it, so he had to do it. Let's just say that DS is 11 months old and isn't baptized yetChat Icon



now that makes me feel a little better

i was raised catholic and DH was raised pretty religiously..not sure which one ( grew up in the bible belt)

we are now free thinkers and worry about what to do with our children since everyone other then us in both of our familys are still practicing

im not going to raise a kid with GOD in their life just because someone think i should..and i guess im wanting to talk to parents that already have kids and how they are handling it..because im not a parent yet but i want to prepare the best i can for this impt issue



Here's the thing I think is important: my parents were open to what WE wanted to do. When my 7 year old sister wanted to go to church, my mom offered to take her, but she declined b/c she'd have to wake up early on a SundayChat Icon

And I believe in God, I just don't have an organized religion, I kind of hate when people assume I am atheist because I am not baptized, that isn't true.

Religion is really interesting from an educational point of view, I really enjoyed learning about it in school, and from a totally un influenced point of view!



people just freak out when they hear that you may not raise your children practicing a religion..like your making them work for the devil or something

Posted 4/5/08 6:33 PM
 

monkeybride
My Everything

Member since 5/05

20541 total posts

Name:

Re: ANY PARENTS RAISING..

We are. DH is atheist and I don't practice any religion so it is not something we practice in our home or choose to expose her to at this point either.
Of course my mother who is a devout Christian is less than thrilled and I'm sure DH's parents would prefer her to go through all the Catholic rituals but that's not happening.

Posted 4/5/08 6:35 PM
 

EmmaNick
*

Member since 12/06

16001 total posts

Name:
*

Re: ANY PARENTS RAISING..

I was raised Catholic but my children aren't baptized and we do not attend church and I'm fine with that decision. People kept asking if I would be getting DD baptized and I said no why would I since I myself don't go to church? The standard response was that it's tradition in some families, which confuses me since if the parents don't go to church and follow their own religion, what is the point? (rhetorical question).

Posted 4/5/08 6:42 PM
 

Failurebydsign
LIF Zygote

Member since 4/08

42 total posts

Name:
Dominique

Re: ANY PARENTS RAISING..

even though i just got a few responses its making me feel a little better that on a PUBLIC FORUM people are here to help and not tip toeing through anything

i really appreciate it

thanks ladies

Posted 4/5/08 6:47 PM
 

hbugal
Lesigh

Member since 2/07

15928 total posts

Name:

Re: ANY PARENTS RAISING..

I wasnt raised as any particular religion..

My great grandparents were Jewish but apparently when they came over here from Hungary they chose to become Christians...why???...that is a question we dont have any answers to...

I was basically raised Christian but without a specific religion..I believe in GOD and I believe in the Bible..but my mother raised us to have our own interpertation of things...

My eldest daughter was baptised Presbyterian, the twins Catholic, and DS is/or will be Jewish...the specifics of what religion they are doesnt matter to me as long as they are taught tolerance for other peoples beliefs...

In a sense I feel that I raise my children without religion. But I do try to teach them about religions in general so that they understand what others believe. I do, however, have raised them to believe in God and to have faith..Does that make sense???

I firmly believe that you can believe in God without having to choose what religion you are...

Posted 4/5/08 7:15 PM
 

Tah-wee-ZAH
Kisses

Member since 5/05

15952 total posts

Name:

Re: ANY PARENTS RAISING..

Posted by Failurebydsign

Posted by KateDevine

I was raised without a religon. My parents felt it was shoved down their throats, so they chose not to baptize my sister and I. They wanted us to make the choice on our own.

We didn't really have that different of an upbringing at all, my sister is a Buddist now though. I really have no religon.

I told DH had no problem with him getting DS baptized, but it was his job, I know nothing about it, so he had to do it. Let's just say that DS is 11 months old and isn't baptized yetChat Icon



now that makes me feel a little better

i was raised catholic and DH was raised pretty religiously..not sure which one ( grew up in the bible belt)

we are now free thinkers and worry about what to do with our children since everyone other then us in both of our familys are still practicing

im not going to raise a kid with GOD in their life just because someone think i should..and i guess im wanting to talk to parents that already have kids and how they are handling it..because im not a parent yet but i want to prepare the best i can for this impt issue



We are interfaith, non-practicing.

We chose not to have our children baptised or have a baby naming or a bris.

Even though we are of two different religions we are more alike in our values than most people whom we dated who were of our own religions. When we got engaged we wanted a spiritual home where we would both feel welcomed. DH's sister attends a Unitarian Fellowship in WI. I knew nothing about them but one weekend we decided to attend the UU Fellowship and we loved it.

They are the only faith that recognizes the validity of all religions. We wanted a place where our children would learn about the commonality of all of the world's religions. There are a lot of members are interfaith, some who wanted a more inclusive religious home, or some who were raised with very dogmatic religion. I would say most members come from Judeo-Christian backgrounds in our congregation but the minister has a lot of Buddhist leanings and we are a "welcoming congregation", meaning gay, lesbian, transgender individuals are welcomed in our community. About 1/3 of services are organized and implemented by the congregation... it's a much more democratic place than the religion I was born into.

I wanted to expose my kids to the commonality of all religions instead of the differences but to also have a religious background. I wanted them to see that we are much more alike than different so they grow up w/o stereotypes or misconstrued ideas. When they are adults they can decide what they want to do but they will have a background in every religion.

Just wanted to let you know about it as it "might" interest you given your situation. I am by no means trying to seek convertsChat Icon there's no such thing there and well, I haven't been attending regularly since DC's were bornChat Icon Just an FYI.

Posted 4/5/08 7:34 PM
 

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: ANY PARENTS RAISING..

Posted by Tah-wee-ZAH

Posted by Failurebydsign

Posted by KateDevine

I was raised without a religon. My parents felt it was shoved down their throats, so they chose not to baptize my sister and I. They wanted us to make the choice on our own.

We didn't really have that different of an upbringing at all, my sister is a Buddist now though. I really have no religon.

I told DH had no problem with him getting DS baptized, but it was his job, I know nothing about it, so he had to do it. Let's just say that DS is 11 months old and isn't baptized yetChat Icon



now that makes me feel a little better

i was raised catholic and DH was raised pretty religiously..not sure which one ( grew up in the bible belt)

we are now free thinkers and worry about what to do with our children since everyone other then us in both of our familys are still practicing

im not going to raise a kid with GOD in their life just because someone think i should..and i guess im wanting to talk to parents that already have kids and how they are handling it..because im not a parent yet but i want to prepare the best i can for this impt issue



We are interfaith, non-practicing.

We chose not to have our children baptised or have a baby naming or a bris.

Even though we are of two different religions we are more alike in our values than most people whom we dated who were of our own religions. When we got engaged we wanted a spiritual home where we would both feel welcomed. DH's sister attends a Unitarian Fellowship in WI. I knew nothing about them but one weekend we decided to attend the UU Fellowship and we loved it.

They are the only faith that recognizes the validity of all religions. We wanted a place where our children would learn about the commonality of all of the world's religions. There are a lot of members are interfaith, some who wanted a more inclusive religious home, or some who were raised with very dogmatic religion. I would say most members come from Judeo-Christian backgrounds in our congregation but the minister has a lot of Buddhist leanings and we are a "welcoming congregation", meaning gay, lesbian, transgender individuals are welcomed in our community. About 1/3 of services are organized and implemented by the congregation... it's a much more democratic place than the religion I was born into.

I wanted to expose my kids to the commonality of all religions instead of the differences but to also have a religious background. I wanted them to see that we are much more alike than different so they grow up w/o stereotypes or misconstrued ideas. When they are adults they can decide what they want to do but they will have a background in every religion.

Just wanted to let you know about it as it "might" interest you given your situation. I am by no means trying to seek convertsChat Icon there's no such thing there and well, I haven't been attending regularly since DC's were bornChat Icon Just an FYI.



My parents were married by a Unitarian minister

Posted 4/5/08 7:35 PM
 

NJmom
.

Member since 8/05

4987 total posts

Name:

Re: ANY PARENTS RAISING..

Posted by jgm26

me!! And its a huge problem for my ILs b/c we have not baptized DD. Dh wants to do it to make his parents happy, but ... well, I could go on and on about how I feel. I'd be happy to talk about through PM, though! I'd actually love someone to talk to about itChat Icon



Wow, you sound just like me! Although my DH has decided that he won't do something just to make his family happy. We have to do what's right for us and OUR family.

I was raised Lutheran, but I no longer affiliate myself with any organized religion. I consider myself to be spiritual and believe in God, but IMO religion and spirituality are not the same thing. I've considered looking into the Unitarian church though because from what I've read about it, it seems like it would fit with my beliefs and would provide my DC's with more structured teachings than I could give them myself.

Posted 4/5/08 7:45 PM
 

jgm26
LIF Adolescent

Member since 7/06

583 total posts

Name:

Re: ANY PARENTS RAISING..

This is the same thign I pm'd you , but I thought I'd put it here too.


Ok- my background: parents catholic, didn't baptise me or my brother-would support us if we chose a religion, but we never did.

DH: raised catholic- hasn't been to church in 25 years. His parents are mega catholics. When you ask FIL why he started going to church again, he says b/c he's going to die soon and he wants to make sure he goes to heaven.


ILs have been harping on us since day one to have DD baptised. DH wants to do it JUST to make his parents happy. that is not good enough reason for me. We have had MANY arguments about this- the worst in our entire time as a couple.

I don't believe in fear-based religion. I don't believe in the original sin, or that homosexulaity is wrong, or that people shouldn't practice birth control. I believe abortion is a woman's choice, and that the church covering up molestion charges is repulsive. Obviously the Catholic church is not for me.
Maybe if I had been raised Catholic , I could see past these things , as many catholics seem to do. Maybe I could see past these things and get from catholicism what I believe to be the good things- sense of community, belief in a higher power, giving to the poor, etc. But I wasn't and I can't.
MIL sees it as a black and white issue- I have 'no' religion, so DD should be catholic. Just because I am not a part of any organized religion doesn't mean my daughters spirituality is up for grabs. If she wants to find out more about any kind of religion, I will support her in the future. But I wll not tell her she is This Relgion or That religion... and have her have to unlearn what she is taught( homosexuality is not wrong, premarital sex is not a sin, birth control is a GOOD thing, for christ sake!, etc) She can be taught, and I plan to teach her , to be an ethical person, or a spiritual person without being baptized.


whew. That felt good to type out.

My big problem is every couple of months, dh will pressure me to do it just to make his parents happy. That is completely the wrong reason. If you and Dh are on the same page, you don't owe an explanation to anyone. If others in your family raise their children in a particular relgion, your future kids will naturally have questions about why their cousins go to religion, or have a bat mitzvah or whatever... so that will be a good opportunity to start a dialogue about it.

good luck!

jessica

Posted 4/5/08 8:02 PM
 

jgm26
LIF Adolescent

Member since 7/06

583 total posts

Name:

Re: ANY PARENTS RAISING..



I was raised without a religon. My parents felt it was shoved down their throats, so they chose not to baptize my sister and I. They wanted us to make the choice on our own.




And I believe in God, I just don't have an organized religion, I kind of hate when people assume I am atheist because I am not baptized, that isn't true.


I could have written this word for word, except I have a brother, and I believe in a god, not THE God, kwim?

Message edited 2008-04-05 20:05:40.093000.

Posted 4/5/08 8:05 PM
 

lipglossjunky73
My Everything!

Member since 11/05

35670 total posts

Name:
<3

Re: ANY PARENTS RAISING..

It depends what you mean by that - if you mean one particular organized religion, then yes - we are raising our son "without religion."

however, we will still practice all the traditions associated with our religions, if that makes sense. There will be a menora on Hannukah. A christmas tree will be up for christmas. Presents will be given for both holidays. We will go to my family for Passover for the seders, to my inlaws for Easter.

We won't go to church or synagogue, but Cailen will know the stories behind each tradition, and we will raise him with the understanding that there is a higher power watching over us, but how we choose to interact and worship this higher power is very individual, and no one can govern how he himself should do that....

If that all makes sense!!! Chat Icon

Posted 4/5/08 8:11 PM
 

MsMBV
:P

Member since 5/05

28602 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: ANY PARENTS RAISING..

Yes. We had a spiritual baptismal for DS, and took excerpts form egyptian, Native American, Gaelic and Buddhist traditions. DH celebrates the holidays, but only with his family as they are very devout catholics.

I will begin to take DS to different religious ceremonies and such once he begins to really understand when people speak and he is asking questions. I think it is important for him to make his own decision if he want to follow any belief.

I am lucky b/c my aunt is a Universalist Unitarian minister and is exposed to a myriad of religions in her church, so she has been a great source of information and guidance.

Posted 4/5/08 8:19 PM
 

dm24angel
Happiness

Member since 5/05

34581 total posts

Name:
Donna

Re: ANY PARENTS RAISING..

Ok, sticky situation and weird for us.

DH is much more relgious then I am.

That said Im MUCH more spiritual then he is.

I do not follow the catholic church. I have strong opinions about that for another day...BUT i had Noah baptised more for family then me. They wanted it and I felt "it couldnt hurt" him to be blessed and I saw no wrong in it.

so now I want to raise Noah believing in God ( as we do) but more spiritual and more lenient of others and more curious of all relgions till he is old enough to make his own decisions with some guidance from us.

Posted 4/5/08 9:33 PM
 

Failurebydsign
LIF Zygote

Member since 4/08

42 total posts

Name:
Dominique

Re: ANY PARENTS RAISING..

I agree with a lot of the things you all are saying and it is helpful because I don't know anyone that feels this way..Except the husband

IM not going to NEVER teach religion..IM just not going to raise my kids as being a part of one

I will teach them about everything religious from all different points of view and backgrounds

but I will teach them to find out FACTS and that not to believe something because someone else believes its true

we don't believe in god..Heaven or anything that really defines a religion and it just seems SO shunned upon

we are good people who have no skeletons in our closest like a lot of religious figures have

that's my biggest problem with religion and children

some people just seen them as naive prey to force beliefs on and it kills me

Posted 4/5/08 9:52 PM
 

ddunne2
LIF Adult

Member since 7/05

4189 total posts

Name:
Doreen

Re: ANY PARENTS RAISING..

I wish I could toss organized religion out the window in my house, but DH is religious and we are raising our kids Catholic just as both DH and I were. I simply go through the motions and make my grocery list in my head while I'm sitting in church.

I just don't have any strong belief or faith in what was taught to me my entire life. To me, religion was an invention to help people deal with all of the unexplainable things in life...natural disasters, death, etc. Personally, I'm ok with just accepting things as being unexplained and I don't necessarily believe their is a greater being with a master plan.

I envy those that have deep faith in religion as I've seen first hand that it can be a comfort to many. But, I'm a scientific minded person, so religion is hard for me.

Posted 4/5/08 10:16 PM
 

waytogo
Balancing act on a highwire

Member since 5/05

1292 total posts

Name:
a

Re: ANY PARENTS RAISING..

We are not raising him without religion per se, but we are letting him make his own choice.

DH is from a very catholic family and my family is half Muslim. So, there is no logical choice. We also live in a mixed community with a fair amount of people who are Jewish so whatever he wants or doesn't want is fine.

In the meantime he will be exposed to everything. Go to church with grandma, visit a mosque and a temple. As long as he knows someone is watching over him and he is a good person I will be happy.

I personally don't care what religion it is that teaches him this idea.

Posted 4/6/08 12:17 PM
 

heidla
Me and the guys

Member since 5/05

4024 total posts

Name:
Heidi

Re: ANY PARENTS RAISING..

No organized religion in this household. DH is Jewish, but has never practiced and I was raised without religion even in the Bible Belt!! We will educate him about his Jewish heritage and allow him to explore things for himself when the time comes. We will keep an open mind, but in general both DH and I are extremely anti-organized religion.

Posted 4/6/08 1:15 PM
 

johnsae
Sip.

Member since 3/06

18677 total posts

Name:

Re: ANY PARENTS RAISING..

We are. DH is Jewish (his mother is, so he is, but his Dad is Catholic), and he wasn't raised with religion. I went to church and consider myself a Christian and would like to raise DD to believe in God, but we are not Baptizing her or taking her to church.

Posted 4/6/08 1:46 PM
 

BaroqueMama
Chase is one!

Member since 5/05

27530 total posts

Name:
me

Re: ANY PARENTS RAISING..

We are raising our DD without a religion. Family and values and morals are important to us, not an organized group to identify with. We broke "tradition" in my family by not getting her baptized, and while some people are a little let down in the family, everyone seems to respect this.
My parents and my sister aren't Buddhist, persay, but they follow a lot of the teachings of the Dalai Lama (sp, I'm so sorry!), so we're all kind of doing our own spiritual thing in my family anyway.

Posted 4/6/08 8:09 PM
 

Leeners
:)

Member since 5/05

4898 total posts

Name:
Eileen

Re: ANY PARENTS RAISING..

Us. DH was raised Jewish and I was raised Catholic. Neither of us is practicing nor do we believe in institutional religion so DS will be raised in the traditions of both but the religious aspects of neither. What kind of guidance were you looking for - how to handle family reactions?

Posted 4/6/08 10:02 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Parents - what do you think of this? missus-hbradio 3/21/06 41 Families Helping Families ™
When did you tell your parents? Charly 3/19/06 17 Pregnancy
How did you tell your parents? bethsiar 3/10/06 23 Pregnancy
parents who breast feed? CJC25 3/8/06 19 Parenting
Interesting article in this month's Parents mag (april) re: cord blood banking debate CathyB 3/7/06 12 Pregnancy
Parents: Quick, I need your help!! Diva 3/7/06 2 Families Helping Families ™