Re: ANY PARENTS RAISING..
Posted 4/5/2008 8:02:25 PM by jgm26

This is the same thign I pm'd you , but I thought I'd put it here too.


Ok- my background: parents catholic, didn't baptise me or my brother-would support us if we chose a religion, but we never did.

DH: raised catholic- hasn't been to church in 25 years. His parents are mega catholics. When you ask FIL why he started going to church again, he says b/c he's going to die soon and he wants to make sure he goes to heaven.


ILs have been harping on us since day one to have DD baptised. DH wants to do it JUST to make his parents happy. that is not good enough reason for me. We have had MANY arguments about this- the worst in our entire time as a couple.

I don't believe in fear-based religion. I don't believe in the original sin, or that homosexulaity is wrong, or that people shouldn't practice birth control. I believe abortion is a woman's choice, and that the church covering up molestion charges is repulsive. Obviously the Catholic church is not for me.
Maybe if I had been raised Catholic , I could see past these things , as many catholics seem to do. Maybe I could see past these things and get from catholicism what I believe to be the good things- sense of community, belief in a higher power, giving to the poor, etc. But I wasn't and I can't.
MIL sees it as a black and white issue- I have 'no' religion, so DD should be catholic. Just because I am not a part of any organized religion doesn't mean my daughters spirituality is up for grabs. If she wants to find out more about any kind of religion, I will support her in the future. But I wll not tell her she is This Relgion or That religion... and have her have to unlearn what she is taught( homosexuality is not wrong, premarital sex is not a sin, birth control is a GOOD thing, for christ sake!, etc) She can be taught, and I plan to teach her , to be an ethical person, or a spiritual person without being baptized.


whew. That felt good to type out.

My big problem is every couple of months, dh will pressure me to do it just to make his parents happy. That is completely the wrong reason. If you and Dh are on the same page, you don't owe an explanation to anyone. If others in your family raise their children in a particular relgion, your future kids will naturally have questions about why their cousins go to religion, or have a bat mitzvah or whatever... so that will be a good opportunity to start a dialogue about it.

good luck!

jessica
Print Post      Close Window